Overview page

Table showing the ERT in number of evaluations

Last dimension | Dimension = 20 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 334 (60)612 (68)862 (77)1133 (90)1410 (96)1965 (114)2514 (122)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 293 (54)534 (54)780 (36)1016 (58)1279 (66)1786 (68)2270 (64)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 344 (36)644 (56)941 (64)1238 (66)1532 (54)2103 (88)2680 (64)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 318 (68)536 (84)773 (66)1018 (48)1281 (62)1788 (102)2291 (150)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 313 (50)533 (45)795 (56)1046 (60)1286 (58)1773 (90)2247 (82)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 313 (44)532 (89)733 (99)947 (124)1176 (130)1617 (150)2049 (182)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 359 (36)598 (66)859 (97)1131 (105)1392 (112)1933 (122)2448 (95)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 294 (54)515 (114)717 (121)949 (170)1181 (166)1605 (184)2059 (250)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)65 (0)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 285 (64)530 (71)754 (75)991 (80)1208 (62)1684 (124)2129 (132)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 80 (4)97 (5)106 (9)111 (9)112 (9)112 (9)112 (9)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 107 (8)245 (8)369 (32)485 (6)626 (10)866 (12)1119 (32)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 594 (84)1544 (32)2397 (52)3225 (61)4023 (48)5646 (46)7257 (33)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 106 (39)294 (70)468 (54)672 (48)853 (77)1228 (58)1581 (69)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 184 (169)1167 (140)1881 (196)2858 (212)3698 (251)5388 (226)7011 (278)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f2, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8426 (1266)1.0e4 (1626)1.1e4 (1324)1.1e4 (1185)1.2e4 (886)1.3e4 (879)1.3e4 (913)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (5176)2.8e4 (6762)4.1e4 (1e4)5.0e4 (1e4)5.9e4 (2e4)7.8e4 (1e4)1.1e5 (3e4)14/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7.8e4 (3e4)1.5e5 (5e4)2.0e5 (7e4)2.5e5 (7e4)3.1e5 (8e4)4.0e5 (9e4)5.0e5 (9e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.4e4 (1e4)8.8e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (2e4)1.5e5 (3e4)1.9e5 (4e4)2.5e5 (4e4)3.2e5 (5e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 6.0e4 (2e4)8.6e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (3e4)1.4e5 (3e4)1.7e5 (3e4)2.3e5 (4e4)2.9e5 (4e4)14/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 6.1e4 (2e4)9.6e4 (3e4)1.4e5 (4e4)1.8e5 (6e4)2.1e5 (7e4)2.8e5 (6e4)3.6e5 (6e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5775 (558)6577 (788)7097 (696)7618 (358)7907 (352)8383 (362)8807 (360)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5935 (721)6724 (420)7222 (400)7547 (438)7852 (452)8370 (464)8929 (456)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3676 (734)4518 (1158)5044 (1254)5472 (1303)5760 (1370)6296 (1435)6789 (1446)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4999 (1113)6296 (1144)7232 (924)7800 (1008)8129 (819)8562 (546)8898 (704)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2390 (280)2661 (224)2904 (222)3137 (240)3371 (264)3836 (297)4319 (304)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 219 (30)★4245 (31)★4269 (30)★4311 (50)★4329 (40)★4391 (52)★4451 (54)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 723 (75)861 (42)1002 (42)1149 (43)1250 (74)1523 (44)1746 (45)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4787 (59)5574 (39)6355 (44)7164 (74)7961 (48)9565 (46)1.1e4 (50)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1021 (114)1220 (76)1403 (98)1614 (100)1774 (113)2138 (82)2453 (136)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4543 (654)5377 (659)6201 (594)7169 (616)7888 (557)9418 (458)1.1e4 (418)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f3, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.6e6 (3e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.5e7 (8e6)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.1e6 (3e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e7 (1e7)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.3e6 (4e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.2e6 (3e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 669 (102)★41186 (174)★41515 (434)★41540 (430)★41564 (440)★41606 (430)★41669 (438)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1725 (127)5.5e4 (1e5)3.0e5 (4e5)3.1e5 (3e5)3.1e5 (4e5)3.1e5 (4e5)3.1e5 (6e5)6/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2042 (599)1.3e4 (7792)1.8e4 (8176)1.9e4 (7915)1.9e4 (7532)2.0e4 (6918)2.1e4 (7208)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f4, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 885 (128)★42155 (423)★42388 (532)★42499 (452)★42591 (372)★42854 (366)★43610 (409)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2638 (630)1.3e6 (1e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6269 (8223)2.5e5 (4e5)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f5, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 216 (46)258 (48)261 (48)263 (48)263 (48)263 (48)263 (48)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 96 (10)115 (10)121 (10)121 (10)121 (10)121 (10)121 (10)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 177 (48)194 (56)197 (60)197 (60)197 (60)197 (60)197 (60)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 172 (28)188 (31)191 (31)193 (43)193 (43)193 (43)193 (43)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 155 (36)174 (25)177 (24)177 (24)177 (24)177 (24)177 (24)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 169 (32)187 (38)187 (38)187 (38)187 (38)187 (38)187 (38)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 160 (60)179 (59)181 (60)181 (60)181 (60)181 (60)181 (60)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 223 (46)244 (52)246 (52)248 (52)248 (52)248 (52)248 (52)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 204 (74)244 (69)256 (69)256 (69)256 (69)256 (69)256 (69)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 97 (21)115 (21)121 (32)121 (32)121 (32)121 (32)121 (32)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 246 (61)295 (42)307 (38)307 (38)307 (38)307 (38)307 (38)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 60 (1)60 (1)60 (1)60 (1)60 (1)60 (1)60 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)32 (3)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 98 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 98 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)100 (8)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f6, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2181 (603)3088 (552)3992 (490)4905 (769)5819 (771)7754 (712)9607 (782)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2862 (1606)5297 (1890)8178 (2184)1.1e4 (2268)1.3e4 (2824)1.9e4 (3182)2.4e4 (2846)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 6.7e4 (6e4)1.7e5 (6e4)2.7e5 (7e4)3.8e5 (1e5)4.9e5 (1e5)6.9e5 (1e5)9.4e5 (9e4)10/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4454 (3094)1.7e4 (7623)3.2e4 (9703)4.7e4 (7970)6.2e4 (1e4)9.4e4 (1e4)1.3e5 (2e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3.1e4 (3e4)1.1e5 (5e4)1.9e5 (8e4)2.6e5 (8e4)5.6e5 (5e5)7.0e6 (9e6)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1956 (368)3210 (730)4853 (1538)6944 (2843)9638 (3050)1.4e4 (3596)1.9e4 (4602)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3320 (1810)5519 (2709)7512 (2936)9319 (2586)1.2e4 (2418)1.6e4 (3412)2.1e4 (3853)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2530 (496)3676 (582)4721 (666)5873 (855)7015 (910)9197 (1234)1.2e4 (1487)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2857 (1086)4846 (2415)7712 (2947)1.1e4 (3140)1.9e4 (4440)2.9e4 (6781)3.8e4 (1e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3018 (1092)6072 (2205)8776 (3244)1.1e4 (2667)1.3e4 (2552)1.9e4 (3192)2.5e4 (2678)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2199 (532)3252 (757)4348 (930)5613 (1316)6833 (1774)9286 (2392)1.2e4 (2566)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.0e4 (1e4)3.7e4 (6e4)6.4e4 (8e4)1.0e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)3.3e5 (3e5)6.5e5 (7e5)4/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.7e4 (2168)2.7e4 (4e4)4.6e4 (7e4)7.6e4 (1e5)1.0e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)2.9e5 (3e5)6/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.7e4 (4e4)1.3e5 (1e5)3.2e5 (3e5)4.6e5 (3e5)3.0e6 (3e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.1e4 (1e4)5.8e4 (6e4)1.6e5 (2e5)2.6e5 (3e5)3.4e5 (3e5)1.4e6 (2e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f7, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1991 (1909)2.3e5 (2e5)4.4e6 (4e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7.2e5 (6e5)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8.5e5 (1e6)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 6.5e6 (7e6)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4.4e4 (1e5)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3545 (3922)3.1e6 (3e6)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (2e4)6.9e6 (7e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5450 (8552)4.5e6 (5e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.8e6 (3e6)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.8e6 (4e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.3e6 (1e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f8, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 6815 (1152)1.5e4 (7866)1.6e4 (7822)1.7e4 (7773)1.8e4 (7751)1.8e4 (7752)1.9e4 (7762)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1347 (388)2430 (262)2673 (252)2796 (231)2865 (220)2952 (242)3026 (210)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7821 (2950)8.8e4 (2862)9.0e4 (2918)9.2e4 (3055)9.2e4 (2920)9.3e4 (2868)9.3e4 (2832)14/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5143 (2126)8.1e4 (2902)8.2e4 (2983)8.3e4 (2974)8.4e4 (3031)8.5e4 (3014)8.5e4 (2980)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8781 (2572)3.8e5 (8e5)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (5e5)3.8e5 (5e5)3.8e5 (5e5)3.8e5 (1e6)11/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5918 (682)1.1e4 (806)1.3e4 (1010)1.3e4 (1018)1.4e4 (1034)1.5e4 (1076)1.6e4 (1194)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5992 (1579)1.3e4 (9002)1.4e4 (8937)1.5e4 (9150)1.5e4 (9250)1.6e4 (9342)1.7e4 (9202)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 7727 (1956)1.9e4 (1e4)2.1e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (1e4)2.3e4 (1e4)2.4e4 (1e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6054 (1405)1.2e4 (1818)1.3e4 (1890)1.4e4 (1874)1.4e4 (1900)1.5e4 (1986)1.6e4 (2030)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1279 (262)2532 (1534)2755 (1534)2865 (1534)2928 (1534)2994 (1544)3043 (1534)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (5982)6.6e4 (7e4)7.5e4 (7e4)8.6e4 (7e4)9.9e4 (7e4)1.3e5 (7e4)1.5e5 (7e4)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 9.2e4 (1e5)3.0e5 (3e5)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.2e4 (4216)5.2e4 (1e5)7.3e4 (1e5)9.6e4 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)2.0e5 (1e5)2.5e5 (2e5)3/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7896 (5112)6.4e4 (1e5)1.0e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.6e5 (1e5)2.7e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (5e5)5/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6299 (6778)9.0e4 (1e5)1.1e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)3.1e5 (2e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4870 (330)1.8e5 (2e5)2.0e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.2e5 (1e5)2.8e5 (2e5)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f9, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 6745 (1112)1.3e4 (1266)1.4e4 (1112)1.5e4 (1151)1.6e4 (1210)1.6e4 (1111)1.7e4 (1084)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1349 (514)3005 (1912)3243 (1901)3361 (1922)3420 (1912)3502 (1912)3579 (1912)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7862 (1900)1.7e4 (1950)1.9e4 (1964)2.0e4 (1822)2.1e4 (2036)2.2e4 (2142)2.2e4 (2147)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5569 (1394)8.1e4 (2061)8.3e4 (1676)8.4e4 (1871)8.4e4 (1989)8.5e4 (2084)8.5e4 (2203)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 7271 (1596)8.7e4 (1942)8.9e4 (1972)9.0e4 (1881)9.0e4 (1894)9.1e4 (1819)9.2e4 (1823)14/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5819 (1654)1.6e5 (5e5)1.7e5 (5e5)1.7e5 (5e5)1.7e5 (5e5)1.7e5 (5e5)1.7e5 (5e5)13/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 6529 (1080)1.7e4 (8945)1.8e4 (8964)1.9e4 (8895)1.9e4 (8892)2.0e4 (8774)2.0e4 (8818)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8705 (1636)1.7e4 (4520)2.0e4 (4146)2.1e4 (4179)2.1e4 (4138)2.2e4 (4134)2.3e4 (4164)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6711 (1838)1.5e4 (9518)1.7e4 (9782)1.8e4 (9852)1.8e4 (9893)1.9e4 (9972)1.9e4 (9957)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1367 (294)2249 (598)2448 (672)2565 (588)2637 (588)2693 (588)2743 (578)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4.2e4 (2342)8.4e4 (7661)1.2e5 (1e4)4.6e6 (4e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.1e4 (5944)7.8e4 (1e5)9.3e4 (1e5)1.2e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)2.4e5 (2e5)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.5e4 (4358)1.0e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)1.9e5 (2e5)3.2e5 (2e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.8e4 (1e4)1.2e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (1e5)3.3e5 (3e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.0e4 (8684)1.1e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (1e5)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f10, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9213 (871)1.1e4 (1056)1.2e4 (852)1.2e4 (600)1.2e4 (612)1.3e4 (622)1.4e4 (640)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.6e4 (4316)2.6e4 (8127)3.8e4 (1e4)4.8e4 (1e4)6.6e4 (2e4)3.3e5 (3e5)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7.2e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (3e4)1.9e5 (5e4)2.4e5 (6e4)3.0e5 (6e4)4.1e5 (1e5)5.2e5 (9e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4.1e4 (1e4)6.9e4 (2e4)1.0e5 (4e4)1.3e5 (4e4)1.7e5 (4e4)2.2e5 (6e4)2.8e5 (6e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4.7e4 (1e4)7.5e4 (2e4)1.0e5 (2e4)1.3e5 (3e4)1.6e5 (3e4)2.3e5 (2e4)2.8e5 (2e4)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 7.0e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (3e4)1.4e5 (3e4)1.8e5 (4e4)2.2e5 (5e4)2.9e5 (5e4)3.6e5 (6e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e5 (2e5)2.6e6 (2e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e6 (1e6)1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.5e4 (8586)4.0e4 (8412)4.2e4 (5650)4.3e4 (5426)4.4e4 (5448)4.5e4 (5580)4.5e4 (5690)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 5013 (924)★46359 (1050)★47286 (1060)★47733 (1228)★48641 (1155)★29910 (4085)4.5e5 (6e5)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f11, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4494 (228)5005 (262)5433 (240)5790 (158)6154 (170)6791 (118)7413 (170)★415/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 576 (200)964 (168)1501 (346)2236 (766)3716 (2248)3.5e4 (4e4)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (9495)5.2e4 (2e4)8.2e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (3e4)1.5e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.6e5 (3e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8543 (3108)2.4e4 (7344)4.2e4 (1e4)5.9e4 (1e4)7.6e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (2e4)1.5e5 (2e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (5622)3.2e4 (8182)5.4e4 (1e4)7.4e4 (1e4)9.3e4 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e4)1.7e5 (1e4)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.6e5 (1e5)5.0e5 (2e5)7.6e5 (2e5)9.8e5 (5e5)2.9e6 (2e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e6 (3e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e4 (7907)4.1e4 (6818)4.7e4 (6705)5.2e4 (6196)5.5e4 (7451)5.9e4 (4490)6.0e4 (4072)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 687 (294)1025 (410)1321 (494)1643 (598)2322 (1197)9910 (2e4)7.0e6 (5e6)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f12, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3113 (2752)7223 (5078)1.1e4 (4025)1.3e4 (4148)1.5e4 (4162)1.9e4 (4328)2.1e4 (4698)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 590 (630)1423 (1113)2183 (1460)2578 (1334)2943 (1386)5829 (4610)1.6e4 (2e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2130 (162)7999 (7520)1.4e4 (1e4)1.8e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (1e4)3.0e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (1e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2759 (1592)6039 (5004)9255 (7094)1.1e4 (5826)1.3e4 (5892)1.8e4 (6244)2.1e4 (6526)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3878 (1986)9992 (8024)1.5e4 (1e4)1.8e4 (1e4)2.1e4 (1e4)2.8e4 (1e4)3.2e4 (1e4)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2807 (1758)6037 (4032)8910 (4124)1.1e4 (4544)1.2e4 (4392)1.6e4 (4685)1.8e4 (4586)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2886 (1835)6284 (4754)9455 (5719)1.1e4 (6514)1.3e4 (6743)1.6e4 (7078)1.8e4 (7436)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2871 (1902)7247 (7396)1.4e4 (1e4)2.0e4 (1e4)2.6e4 (1e4)3.8e4 (1e4)4.7e4 (2e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4204 (4332)9369 (6845)1.4e4 (6919)1.6e4 (7074)1.8e4 (7172)2.2e4 (7246)2.5e4 (6998)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 418 (231)1053 (1092)1744 (1344)2133 (1197)2536 (1208)6119 (3056)3.0e4 (4e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1777 (171)1.3e5 (2e5)7.7e5 (7e5)3.1e6 (3e6)4.5e6 (4e6)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.8e5 (2e5)4.0e5 (5e5)8.0e5 (1e6)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (2e5)5.6e5 (4e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)5.5e5 (7e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7.9e4 (1e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f13, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2199 (1484)6872 (7246)1.3e4 (1e4)2.0e4 (1e4)2.7e4 (2e4)5.0e4 (4e4)1.7e5 (2e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1290 (1838)4458 (3760)1.9e4 (3e4)5.7e4 (3e4)8.0e4 (7e4)8.9e5 (9e5)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 6.1e4 (4e4)3.0e5 (5e5)8.3e5 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)4.2e6 (5e6)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2986 (4232)1.5e4 (2e4)8.9e4 (1e5)1.9e5 (2e5)7.0e5 (8e5)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (5e5)2.8e6 (4e6)4.0e6 (5e6)6.5e6 (7e6)1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e5)2.8e6 (6e6)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3198 (3394)9504 (9370)2.8e4 (2e4)1.0e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)4.4e5 (5e5)1.2e6 (1e6)5/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1803 (720)2.1e4 (2e4)3.8e4 (2e4)7.6e4 (6e4)1.8e5 (1e5)3.1e6 (5e6)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6850 (7052)2.6e4 (3e4)8.7e4 (1e5)2.8e5 (2e5)9.7e5 (9e5)1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1404 (1628)1.1e4 (1e4)2.5e4 (2e4)3.2e4 (3e4)3.4e4 (3e4)9.2e5 (1e6)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2845 (3415)1.5e4 (3e4)8.6e4 (8e4)2.8e5 (3e5)8.7e5 (6e5)4.5e6 (4e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 3.7e4 (3e4)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.3e5 (3e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.7e4 (1e5)5.6e5 (7e5)8.1e5 (1e6)2.8e6 (2e6)2.8e6 (4e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.0e5 (3e5)8.0e5 (1e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (2e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.0e5 (5e5)8.1e5 (6e5)2.8e6 (4e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f14, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 299 (98)686 (97)1088 (113)1798 (168)3014 (274)6432 (322)1.1e4 (625)★415/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 103 (21)184 (42)276 (42)477 (52)799 (74)4973 (1302)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 210 (54)510 (76)793 (109)1338 (181)2994 (555)3.7e4 (9710)5.6e5 (1e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 234 (44)520 (56)829 (69)1183 (70)2475 (404)2.5e4 (6334)3.6e5 (9e4)2/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 275 (122)607 (120)915 (139)1500 (169)2996 (362)2.6e4 (5470)4.7e5 (5e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 279 (110)574 (114)887 (157)1394 (166)3058 (360)4.4e4 (2e4)1.1e6 (9e5)0/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 272 (108)636 (140)928 (180)1453 (345)3463 (877)1.2e5 (5e4)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 287 (105)720 (119)1089 (187)1901 (201)4884 (828)4.3e5 (5e5)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 299 (74)693 (130)1030 (138)1611 (148)3666 (732)2.6e4 (4142)4.4e4 (5410)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 108 (21)195 (42)295 (63)468 (84)766 (84)2150 (326)★31e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 266 (106)654 (116)1002 (170)1752 (214)6175 (1156)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 125 (80)1829 (1173)3872 (2366)2.5e4 (2e4)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 119 (63)356 (82)656 (106)1254 (214)5853 (3202)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 181 (166)1489 (130)2697 (258)5042 (654)1.4e4 (2816)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 56 (18)372 (156)678 (104)1577 (375)1.1e4 (3854)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 56 (18)929 (212)2194 (324)4482 (682)1.8e4 (3758)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 5.8e6 (7e6)4e50/15

Δ fopt
f15, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.4e6 (5e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.5e7 (3e7)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4.5e6 (4e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.3e6 (6e6)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.3e6 (3e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.5e6 (4e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f16, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2220 (930)7.0e4 (8e4)4.3e6 (4e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (5e5)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 390 (94)8.1e5 (8e5)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (5e5)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e5)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2616 (900)7.2e5 (8e5)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2346 (1088)2.7e5 (3e5)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3618 (6142)1.4e6 (2e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 9821 (2e4)1.1e6 (1e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 3.7e4 (5e4)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 7.3e4 (2e5)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.6e4 (1070)2.8e6 (3e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3.0e5 (5e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.8e5 (2e5)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f17, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 161 (98)1043 (332)4097 (6592)5.3e4 (6e4)1.1e6 (3e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (1e5)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 167 (132)1.5e7 (2e7)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 110 (44)3.7e5 (8e5)1.5e6 (2e6)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 179 (64)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 131 (70)6.5e6 (9e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 178 (88)2436 (3545)4.2e4 (4e4)6.9e5 (5e5)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 165 (104)1941 (325)1.2e4 (1e4)4.3e4 (7e4)1.8e6 (2e6)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 190 (96)7983 (4712)4.8e4 (4e4)1.6e6 (1e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (4e4)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 120 (58)1976 (271)2.3e4 (2e4)9.2e4 (2e5)4.5e6 (6e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 85 (58)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 96 (123)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 85 (100)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 65 (97)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 93 (90)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1.6e4 (2e4)4e50/15

Δ fopt
f18, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 779 (160)7747 (7552)1.3e5 (1e5)4.5e6 (4e6)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e5)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1800 (234)2.8e5 (5e5)7.0e6 (6e6)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.5e6 (1e6)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.0e5 (1e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1086 (579)2.0e4 (3e4)1.1e6 (1e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 585 (166)8337 (2e4)8.4e4 (1e5)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 614 (186)5.4e4 (7e4)2.5e6 (3e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 695 (186)9080 (1e4)2.2e5 (3e5)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.9e5 (2e5)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.5e5 (9e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.8e6 (4e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f19, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 146 (44)6.0e4 (2e4)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (2e5)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 145 (46)5.1e5 (1e6)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 158 (37)5.0e5 (1e6)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 129 (32)2.8e6 (3e6)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 120 (52)8.9e5 (1e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 185 (68)1.4e5 (2e5)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 160 (102)1.4e5 (2e5)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 181 (92)4.6e4 (7e4)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6.1e4 (7e4)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 140 (36)2.9e5 (5e5)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 103 (88)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1131 (106)★22e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3780 (230)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1325 (172)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3914 (281)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)4e50/15

Δ fopt
f20, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 380 (69)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 117 (10)6.6e5 (7e5)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 314 (66)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 350 (85)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 296 (78)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 311 (58)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 324 (68)7.0e6 (7e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 391 (87)1.5e7 (1e7)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 342 (98)3.4e6 (3e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 117 (10)4.5e5 (1e6)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 345 (91)1.4e6 (1e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 134 (41)4.2e4 (5e4)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 146 (2)536 (22)★22e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 625 (2)3400 (3)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 172 (42)1.5e4 (122)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 564 (176)3905 (1166)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f21, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1680 (2338)3.5e4 (4e4)9.5e4 (1e5)9.5e4 (1e5)9.6e4 (1e5)9.6e4 (1e5)9.6e4 (1e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 906 (1670)5265 (5678)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)5.8e4 (6e4)4/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e5)4.0e6 (5e6)6.5e6 (7e6)6.5e6 (6e6)6.5e6 (7e6)6.5e6 (8e6)6.5e6 (7e6)2/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e5)6.5e6 (7e6)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (5e5)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (4e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (2e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (4e6)4/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (5e5)6.5e6 (9e6)6.5e6 (7e6)6.5e6 (9e6)6.5e6 (7e6)6.5e6 (9e6)6.5e6 (9e6)2/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1288 (3064)2.9e4 (4e4)4.4e4 (5e4)4.4e4 (5e4)4.5e4 (5e4)4.5e4 (5e4)4.6e4 (5e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4312 (7083)3.8e4 (5e4)5.5e4 (8e4)5.5e4 (8e4)5.5e4 (8e4)5.6e4 (8e4)5.6e4 (8e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1843 (3568)2.1e4 (3e4)7.9e4 (1e5)8.0e4 (1e5)8.0e4 (1e5)8.0e4 (1e5)8.1e4 (1e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 836 (999)7038 (9163)1.4e4 (1e4)1.4e4 (1e4)1.4e4 (1e4)1.4e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (4e4)2/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2713 (2250)3.9e4 (2e4)5.5e4 (4e4)5.5e4 (4e4)5.5e4 (4e4)5.6e4 (4e4)5.6e4 (4e4)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 7810 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 7.3e4 (1e5)5.5e5 (6e5)8.0e5 (8e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (1e6)3/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.4e4 (1e5)5.5e5 (5e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (7e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (8e5)3/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)5.5e5 (7e5)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (1e6)3/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)5.5e5 (7e5)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (1e6)8.0e5 (6e5)8.0e5 (9e5)8.0e5 (1e6)3/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f22, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4818 (8988)2.1e5 (5e5)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (3e6)6/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2228 (3078)2.0e4 (3e4)1.4e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)4.4e6 (6e6)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8.8e5 (2e6)6.5e6 (1e7)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (1e6)1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.5e6 (2e6)1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8.8e5 (1e6)4.0e6 (5e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4530 (8483)1.9e5 (5e5)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (1e6)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)7/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6627 (1e4)2.3e5 (4e5)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (3e6)4/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8844 (8386)2.2e5 (4e5)2.4e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (2e6)5/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1122 (821)1.8e4 (2e4)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.0e6 (1e6)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6595 (8239)1.4e5 (8e4)2.4e6 (4e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (3e6)5/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.8e4 (3e4)1.4e5 (2e5)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.8e5 (2e5)1.3e6 (1e6)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.8e5 (3e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.3e5 (4e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.3e5 (3e5)1.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Δ fopt
f23, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 11 (12)4.4e4 (3e4)3.5e5 (3e5)1.5e7 (2e7)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 162 (220)9.0e5 (1e6)1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7.5 (10)2.5e5 (5e5)1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 13 (8)1135 (2088)2.3e5 (2e5)1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 6.7 (8)6.7e5 (1e6)1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.5 (3)5.0e5 (1e6)1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 14 (17)1.5e4 (2e4)2.0e6 (2e6)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 16 (18)5.6e4 (7e4)7.6e5 (9e5)1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 16 (20)1.6e4 (1e4)1.9e6 (2e6)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 89 (158)2.3e5 (2e5)1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 14 (14)4.4e4 (5e4)1.4e6 (1e6)1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 10 (8)2.0e4 (3e4)2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6.1 (8)3.0e5 (4e5)2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6.1 (8)7.6e4 (2e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.8 (7)2.3e5 (5e5)2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.8 (7)1.8e5 (2e5)2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6.1 (10)4e50/15

Δ fopt
f24, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (2e7)1e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e7 (1e7)1e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (1e7)1e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 4e50/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 40 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 810 (68)1301 (71)1827 (128)2317 (129)2790 (156)3806 (158)4806 (193)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 667 (64)1088 (68)1507 (84)1923 (74)2354 (92)3194 (66)4030 (64)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 751 (76)1219 (68)1677 (58)2159 (66)2607 (100)3561 (68)4491 (74)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 658 (56)1109 (90)1539 (74)1962 (88)2372 (72)3217 (90)4051 (92)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 634 (88)1086 (77)1554 (88)1984 (87)2448 (73)3286 (155)4124 (112)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 622 (157)971 (117)1311 (120)1649 (141)1980 (118)2691 (189)3402 (207)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 775 (84)1256 (73)1737 (88)2208 (64)2664 (110)3599 (106)4561 (126)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 606 (110)945 (118)1349 (123)1686 (156)2064 (145)2800 (190)3529 (210)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)125 (0)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 720 (73)1156 (78)1591 (98)2036 (120)2473 (160)3336 (172)4228 (196)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 175 (12)202 (8)218 (19)226 (16)229 (12)229 (12)229 (12)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 328 (18)525 (6)806 (8)1085 (17)1271 (6)1827 (12)2316 (18)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1872 (71)3644 (54)5290 (38)6912 (34)8525 (36)1.2e4 (39)1.5e4 (58)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 314 (54)733 (50)1146 (60)1508 (106)1874 (43)2617 (50)3437 (78)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1494 (330)3225 (367)5374 (480)7717 (410)9835 (390)1.4e4 (718)1.8e4 (730)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f2, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.2e4 (2210)3.7e4 (3484)4.2e4 (2598)4.4e4 (2706)4.7e4 (1350)5.0e4 (1124)5.1e4 (1413)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.1e4 (1e4)8.3e4 (1e4)1.2e5 (2e4)1.5e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (4e4)2.6e5 (5e4)3.2e5 (6e4)8/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (4e4)2.8e5 (6e4)4.0e5 (7e4)5.0e5 (8e4)6.1e5 (1e5)8.2e5 (1e5)1.0e6 (1e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (2e4)1.6e5 (4e4)2.2e5 (5e4)2.6e5 (5e4)3.3e5 (7e4)4.5e5 (7e4)5.8e5 (8e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (4e4)2.7e5 (5e4)3.4e5 (5e4)4.2e5 (8e4)5.8e5 (1e5)7.3e5 (1e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.6e5 (4e4)2.4e5 (6e4)3.1e5 (6e4)3.9e5 (7e4)4.8e5 (7e4)6.7e5 (8e4)8.4e5 (8e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1432)1.4e4 (1170)1.6e4 (1185)1.7e4 (1136)1.8e4 (966)1.9e4 (1108)1.9e4 (1210)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (922)1.4e4 (1132)1.5e4 (940)1.6e4 (974)1.6e4 (874)1.7e4 (957)1.8e4 (938)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (2219)1.3e4 (3134)1.5e4 (3784)1.6e4 (3850)1.7e4 (4342)1.9e4 (4374)2.0e4 (4505)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (2009)2.2e4 (2911)2.5e4 (2890)2.8e4 (3260)3.0e4 (2747)3.2e4 (4141)3.4e4 (3546)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5862 (402)6496 (450)7056 (512)7523 (496)7977 (429)8898 (456)9781 (466)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 467 (40)★4518 (79)★4592 (46)★4656 (64)★4709 (47)★4805 (99)★4973 (91)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1559 (72)1801 (76)2034 (6)2325 (12)2565 (82)3078 (10)3542 (13)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 9805 (78)1.2e4 (65)1.3e4 (94)1.5e4 (24)1.6e4 (25)1.9e4 (73)2.3e4 (265)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2232 (114)2618 (110)2997 (153)3417 (120)3782 (118)4528 (115)5174 (110)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.2e4 (873)1.4e4 (1032)1.6e4 (838)1.8e4 (1080)2.0e4 (684)2.4e4 (834)2.7e4 (988)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f3, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1684 (196)★42599 (329)★42887 (494)★42923 (534)★42980 (494)★43078 (354)★43182 (394)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5639 (557)6.1e5 (8e5)5.6e6 (7e6)5.6e6 (8e6)5.6e6 (6e6)5.6e6 (7e6)5.6e6 (7e6)1/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7153 (684)3.9e4 (2e4)4.5e4 (1179)4.6e4 (1159)4.7e4 (1286)5.0e4 (1964)5.2e4 (1378)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f4, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2652 (524)★44671 (935)★45067 (1080)★45285 (1063)★45433 (1168)★46010 (1131)★47535 (1039)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.1e5 (2e5)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.5e4 (2e4)1.2e6 (8e5)5.6e6 (6e6)5.6e6 (6e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.7e6 (1e7)5.7e6 (6e6)1/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f5, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 494 (52)541 (86)557 (59)558 (59)558 (59)558 (59)558 (59)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 199 (20)226 (41)240 (62)240 (62)240 (62)243 (62)243 (62)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 343 (104)374 (104)377 (94)377 (94)377 (94)377 (94)377 (94)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 316 (56)346 (60)352 (63)356 (63)356 (63)356 (63)356 (63)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 349 (45)368 (54)370 (54)370 (54)370 (54)370 (54)370 (54)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 347 (79)375 (76)380 (80)380 (80)380 (80)380 (80)380 (80)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 366 (72)403 (98)408 (90)408 (90)408 (90)408 (90)408 (90)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 388 (56)430 (67)441 (38)443 (39)443 (39)443 (39)443 (39)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 407 (68)441 (70)445 (70)445 (70)445 (70)445 (70)445 (70)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 212 (20)243 (20)248 (41)248 (41)248 (41)248 (41)248 (41)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 526 (68)602 (84)624 (98)627 (98)627 (98)627 (98)627 (98)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 120 (1)120 (1)120 (1)120 (1)120 (1)120 (1)120 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)62 (4)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 194 (11)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 194 (11)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)198 (10)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f6, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 5869 (1166)8289 (1184)1.1e4 (1430)1.3e4 (1009)1.6e4 (1389)2.1e4 (1600)2.5e4 (1780)★215/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.0e4 (2829)1.7e4 (3526)2.6e4 (3034)3.3e4 (5064)4.1e4 (4469)5.4e4 (4120)7.0e4 (6437)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8.5e5 (3e5)1.9e6 (1e6)5.8e6 (5e6)3.0e7 (3e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.3e4 (3e4)1.1e5 (4e4)1.8e5 (4e4)2.4e5 (5e4)3.1e5 (6e4)4.5e5 (5e4)5.9e5 (7e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 6.0e6 (7e6)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (4147)2.6e4 (3752)3.7e4 (3470)4.7e4 (5534)6.0e4 (7405)8.3e4 (9691)1.0e5 (6820)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 9638 (2676)1.6e4 (4506)2.3e4 (7196)3.0e4 (9098)3.7e4 (9615)5.1e4 (1e4)6.8e4 (2e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6806 (1224)9775 (1680)1.3e4 (2271)1.6e4 (3166)2.0e4 (3692)2.6e4 (4854)3.3e4 (4918)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (4398)2.3e4 (1e4)3.9e4 (3e4)7.0e4 (7e4)9.3e4 (2e5)1.2e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (3998)1.9e4 (4920)2.7e4 (4530)3.5e4 (4244)4.4e4 (4838)6.0e4 (7749)7.6e4 (9963)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5882 (1180)8542 (1314)1.1e4 (1710)1.4e4 (1598)1.7e4 (1488)2.3e4 (2384)2.8e4 (2792)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8.2e4 (2e5)1.1e5 (2e5)1.6e5 (2e5)2.3e5 (2e5)3.5e5 (3e5)7.7e5 (1e6)3.0e6 (2e6)0/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.1e4 (3e4)8.1e4 (6e4)1.2e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (1e5)2.6e5 (2e5)4.2e5 (4e5)9.0e5 (5e5)4/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3.9e4 (4e4)1.1e5 (9e4)2.2e5 (2e5)4.4e5 (3e5)8.4e5 (9e5)2.8e6 (3e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.5e4 (4e4)1.2e5 (9e4)2.4e5 (3e5)3.7e5 (3e5)5.5e5 (6e5)1.9e6 (2e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f7, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 7.5e4 (9e4)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3.0e7 (3e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (9e4)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5.1e5 (6e5)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f8, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4.2e4 (4428)7.5e4 (4e4)7.9e4 (4e4)8.0e4 (4e4)8.1e4 (4e4)8.3e4 (4e4)8.4e4 (4e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 6529 (1824)1.0e4 (7852)1.1e4 (8016)1.1e4 (7811)1.1e4 (7811)1.1e4 (7811)1.2e4 (7790)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.6e4 (3794)5.6e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)12/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.9e4 (3371)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (2e6)8/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.1e4 (6574)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)3.9e5 (1e6)3.9e5 (1e6)13/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.9e4 (1337)3.9e4 (1367)4.2e4 (1366)4.4e4 (1320)4.4e4 (1404)4.6e4 (1366)4.8e4 (1053)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e4 (3462)5.1e4 (3e4)5.3e4 (3e4)5.5e4 (3e4)5.6e4 (3e4)5.8e4 (3e4)5.9e4 (3e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.8e4 (3690)5.7e4 (3e4)6.0e4 (3e4)6.1e4 (3e4)6.2e4 (3e4)6.4e4 (3e4)6.6e4 (3e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.5e4 (8120)4.1e4 (3e4)4.3e4 (3e4)4.5e4 (3e4)4.6e4 (3e4)4.7e4 (3e4)4.9e4 (3e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6628 (758)9689 (5351)1.0e4 (5310)1.0e4 (5330)1.0e4 (5330)1.1e4 (5351)1.1e4 (5392)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5.4e4 (1678)8.5e4 (1428)9.5e4 (1308)1.1e5 (1556)1.2e5 (2347)1.5e5 (3245)1.8e5 (3072)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 9.9e4 (7e4)1.9e5 (3e5)2.3e5 (2e5)3.0e5 (2e5)3.5e5 (2e5)4.6e5 (2e5)3.0e6 (3e6)1/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.7e4 (2e4)2.2e5 (2e5)2.6e5 (3e5)3.0e5 (4e5)3.8e5 (2e5)5.2e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (2e5)9/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.4e4 (7e4)2.5e5 (3e5)2.6e5 (3e5)3.1e5 (3e5)4.0e5 (3e5)8.0e5 (5e5)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.6e4 (4e4)3.5e5 (3e5)3.6e5 (3e5)3.8e5 (3e5)4.0e5 (2e5)4.8e5 (3e5)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f9, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4.1e4 (3034)6.6e4 (3e4)7.0e4 (3e4)7.1e4 (3e4)7.2e4 (3e4)7.4e4 (3e4)7.5e4 (3e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 6532 (1742)8295 (2337)8738 (2276)8992 (2276)9118 (2296)9284 (2316)9437 (2358)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.8e4 (4104)5.6e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)5.7e5 (1e6)12/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.8e4 (2250)3.7e4 (6886)4.0e4 (6222)4.1e4 (6558)4.2e4 (6842)4.4e4 (7055)4.5e4 (7241)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4.7e4 (1e4)3.7e5 (1e6)3.7e5 (1e6)3.7e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)3.8e5 (1e6)13/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.0e4 (3316)3.5e5 (1e6)3.5e5 (1e6)3.5e5 (1e6)3.5e5 (1e6)3.5e5 (1e6)3.6e5 (1e6)13/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.2e4 (2802)5.0e4 (3e4)5.3e4 (3e4)5.4e4 (3e4)5.5e4 (3e4)5.6e4 (3e4)5.7e4 (3e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.7e4 (2622)7.1e4 (2852)7.6e4 (2862)7.7e4 (2708)7.8e4 (2709)8.0e4 (2579)8.1e4 (2596)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.2e4 (2926)7.2e4 (5e4)7.5e4 (5e4)7.6e4 (5e4)7.7e4 (5e4)7.9e4 (5e4)8.0e4 (5e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6311 (861)8292 (1722)8669 (1742)8918 (1804)9022 (1824)9186 (1599)9301 (1620)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.8e5 (6514)2.8e5 (8569)2.5e6 (3e6)2.9e7 (4e7)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.2e5 (1e4)2.4e5 (3e5)2.8e5 (2e5)3.4e5 (2e5)4.2e5 (2e5)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (1e4)2.2e5 (2e5)2.7e5 (2e5)3.4e5 (2e5)4.3e5 (2e5)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.2e5 (4e4)2.6e5 (2e5)3.1e5 (2e5)5.2e5 (5e5)3.0e6 (4e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (4e4)2.6e5 (5e5)3.1e5 (3e5)4.0e5 (3e5)1.9e6 (3e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f10, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.2e4 (2815)3.7e4 (3156)4.1e4 (2682)4.4e4 (2570)4.7e4 (2466)4.9e4 (1584)5.1e4 (1104)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.3e4 (1e4)8.9e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (2e4)1.5e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (5e4)5.0e5 (5e5)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.8e5 (3e4)2.8e5 (8e4)3.9e5 (9e4)4.9e5 (1e5)6.0e5 (1e5)8.0e5 (2e5)1.0e6 (2e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (2e4)1.7e5 (3e4)2.4e5 (4e4)2.9e5 (4e4)3.5e5 (5e4)4.6e5 (7e4)5.6e5 (8e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (2e4)2.1e5 (4e4)2.9e5 (6e4)3.7e5 (8e4)4.4e5 (8e4)5.9e5 (9e4)7.3e5 (1e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (2e4)2.3e5 (5e4)3.1e5 (8e4)4.0e5 (1e5)4.7e5 (1e5)6.3e5 (1e5)7.6e5 (1e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 9.7e5 (5e5)7.0e6 (6e6)2.9e7 (4e7)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.8e6 (8e6)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (2e4)1.7e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (1e4)2.1e5 (1e4)2.2e5 (1e4)2.2e5 (1e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (1496)★42.1e4 (2501)★42.4e4 (2972)2.7e4 (4080)2.9e4 (4900)9.0e4 (7e4)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f11, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (704)1.5e4 (468)1.6e4 (550)1.7e4 (520)1.8e4 (398)1.9e4 (474)2.0e4 (401)★415/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1686 (308)2241 (636)3252 (1025)4681 (1312)8456 (3731)5.9e4 (6e4)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.6e4 (2e4)1.0e5 (3e4)1.5e5 (3e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.6e5 (2e4)3.6e5 (4e4)4.7e5 (4e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (4020)4.4e4 (9946)7.3e4 (1e4)1.0e5 (1e4)1.4e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.6e5 (2e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.7e4 (1e4)7.0e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (2e4)1.5e5 (3e4)1.9e5 (3e4)2.7e5 (3e4)3.6e5 (4e4)14/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.9e5 (2e5)9.2e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e5)1.6e6 (2e5)2.3e6 (1e6)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e6 (2e6)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e7 (3e7)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 7.7e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (2e4)1.3e5 (2e4)1.6e5 (2e4)1.8e5 (2e4)2.1e5 (2e4)1.0e6 (1e6)8/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1743 (390)2325 (656)2918 (718)3864 (882)4881 (1517)★22.1e4 (2e4)1.5e7 (1e7)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f12, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 7292 (5912)1.3e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (1e4)2.3e4 (1e4)2.8e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (1e4)3.9e4 (1e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 866 (697)1872 (1886)2954 (2152)3629 (2194)4408 (2255)7519 (3464)3.1e4 (4e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5727 (8336)1.4e4 (2e4)2.4e4 (2e4)3.1e4 (2e4)3.9e4 (2e4)5.4e4 (2e4)6.4e4 (2e4)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6045 (4340)1.2e4 (9900)1.8e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (1e4)2.6e4 (9514)3.7e4 (9878)4.4e4 (1e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5244 (3598)1.4e4 (1e4)2.4e4 (2e4)3.0e4 (2e4)3.7e4 (2e4)5.2e4 (2e4)6.2e4 (2e4)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3844 (327)1.0e4 (6841)1.5e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (9142)2.2e4 (9197)2.9e4 (9570)3.3e4 (1e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 6637 (5503)1.3e4 (1e4)1.6e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (1e4)2.8e4 (1e4)3.1e4 (1e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 7828 (7020)1.8e4 (1e4)2.7e4 (2e4)3.4e4 (2e4)4.1e4 (2e4)5.7e4 (2e4)6.6e4 (2e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 5286 (4532)1.3e4 (8356)1.8e4 (7374)2.1e4 (7625)2.4e4 (8270)3.0e4 (9626)3.4e4 (9987)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 811 (390)1675 (1742)2689 (2173)3386 (2030)4209 (2070)1.1e4 (4510)3.8e4 (7e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.8e5 (3e5)5.0e5 (7e5)1.3e6 (2e6)4.5e6 (6e6)1.3e7 (1e7)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.7e5 (4e5)2.6e6 (4e6)2.6e6 (3e6)5.6e6 (8e6)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.8e5 (5e5)6.3e5 (1e6)2.6e6 (5e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.5e5 (2e5)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.7e5 (5e5)2.6e6 (4e6)5.6e6 (6e6)5.6e6 (4e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f13, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4204 (354)2.1e4 (2e4)5.5e4 (7e4)1.1e5 (1e5)2.2e5 (2e5)1.9e6 (2e6)9.3e6 (1e7)1/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2853 (3424)8214 (8365)4.9e4 (5e4)9.0e4 (1e5)2.3e5 (3e5)2.2e6 (3e6)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5397 (7112)3.0e4 (4e4)1.4e5 (1e5)3.3e5 (3e5)2.0e6 (2e6)1.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5219 (6825)2.5e4 (2e4)9.6e4 (1e5)3.4e5 (6e5)9.5e5 (8e5)9.7e6 (1e7)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.0e5 (1e6)8.0e6 (1e7)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (390)1.8e6 (3e6)5.5e6 (1e7)2.8e7 (4e7)2.8e7 (3e7)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3400 (446)1.7e4 (2e4)9.4e4 (1e5)3.1e5 (4e5)9.4e5 (7e5)4.1e6 (4e6)2.9e7 (3e7)0/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6040 (6910)1.9e4 (2e4)6.8e4 (7e4)1.7e5 (2e5)3.6e5 (3e5)6.3e6 (7e6)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 5734 (6780)4.2e4 (4e4)1.6e5 (2e5)3.7e5 (4e5)1.9e6 (2e6)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (3e7)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2741 (3280)1.2e4 (1e4)3.2e4 (3e4)5.6e4 (1e5)9.3e4 (1e5)5.3e6 (4e6)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6027 (7272)2.1e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (1e5)3.2e5 (5e5)7.7e5 (8e5)9.0e6 (1e7)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 7.6e4 (6e4)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6.5e4 (2e5)8.0e5 (2e6)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.3e4 (4923)8.2e5 (1e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (2e6)2.6e6 (3e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.7e5 (4e5)1.6e6 (2e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f14, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 796 (146)1537 (170)2383 (261)4169 (278)8049 (482)2.0e4 (894)3.8e4 (920)★415/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 281 (62)469 (62)688 (62)1125 (82)2014 (164)1.8e4 (2440)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 543 (113)1067 (108)1605 (132)2667 (237)5864 (668)7.0e4 (1e4)1.2e6 (2e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 535 (119)1005 (120)1533 (122)2356 (174)5039 (439)4.8e4 (5082)7.2e5 (2e5)1/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 589 (114)1154 (181)1752 (222)2978 (295)6368 (654)6.1e4 (1e4)1.0e6 (1e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 636 (144)1205 (208)1754 (270)2864 (290)6167 (775)8.0e4 (1e4)1.8e6 (1e6)0/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 603 (149)1209 (254)1771 (270)3226 (398)8633 (1214)5.0e5 (2e5)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 755 (164)1456 (290)2278 (311)4199 (347)1.2e4 (1782)5.7e5 (2e5)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 662 (146)1302 (214)1866 (407)3282 (700)8139 (2346)7.7e4 (1e4)8.2e5 (1e6)1/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 275 (62)448 (82)661 (102)1104 (82)1904 (102)5832 (512)★42e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 793 (184)1455 (170)2147 (196)3929 (415)1.6e4 (2288)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 774 (1040)5485 (1621)1.0e4 (3002)6.2e4 (3e4)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 445 (146)983 (184)1827 (248)3721 (449)1.7e4 (6757)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 967 (368)4297 (708)7460 (752)1.3e4 (1358)3.6e4 (6421)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 280 (204)1067 (178)2023 (234)4548 (544)2.6e4 (9454)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 282 (218)3184 (394)6254 (950)1.3e4 (1309)4.8e4 (1e4)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f15, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f16, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 5110 (2314)2.3e6 (2e6)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (2e4)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1976 (323)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (1e6)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 7.3e5 (1e6)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2476 (1226)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 9801 (2936)1.3e7 (1e7)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (2e4)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (2207)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8.0e5 (2e6)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 5.6e6 (8e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.6e6 (2e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f17, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 450 (128)2238 (452)1.9e4 (2e4)4.7e5 (5e5)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.3e6 (2e6)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 342 (114)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 299 (93)1.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 269 (138)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 333 (180)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 336 (117)1.3e5 (4e5)6.4e6 (6e6)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 435 (248)2602 (952)3.3e4 (4e4)4.7e5 (3e5)2.9e7 (4e7)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 370 (161)1.4e5 (2e5)2.8e7 (3e7)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.6e5 (3e5)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 362 (127)4174 (778)8.2e4 (7e4)3.1e6 (3e6)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.1e4 (2e4)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 178 (200)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 374 (490)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 278 (426)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 824 (1244)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3.5e6 (7e6)8e50/15

Δ fopt
f18, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1476 (482)1.4e4 (2e4)1.5e6 (2e6)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.5e6 (1e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.9e5 (1e6)2.8e7 (3e7)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (4e6)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.8e7 (3e7)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3656 (4645)2.8e6 (3e6)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1254 (250)3.6e4 (8e4)3.3e6 (3e6)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2006 (690)2.2e6 (1e6)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1392 (504)5.1e4 (7e4)1.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f19, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 408 (113)2.2e5 (5e5)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3.7e6 (4e6)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 331 (48)1.3e7 (1e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 312 (54)1.8e6 (2e6)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 249 (45)2.4e6 (3e6)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 247 (43)1.3e7 (2e7)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 349 (79)7.6e5 (1e6)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 432 (150)1.0e6 (1e6)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 294 (62)2.8e5 (6e5)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (1e6)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 452 (92)1.3e6 (1e6)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2536 (6124)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)5676 (542)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1.3e4 (514)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)6544 (954)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1.3e4 (888)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)8e50/15

Δ fopt
f20, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 878 (110)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 251 (0)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 627 (76)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 698 (54)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 519 (68)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 565 (78)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 571 (110)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 833 (106)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 633 (128)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 243 (20)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 739 (93)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1658 (3440)3.2e4 (4e4)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 300 (4)1141 (6)★44e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1729 (3)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 385 (200)1513 (279)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1449 (327)1.8e4 (4e4)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f21, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8299 (1e4)1.1e5 (1e5)2.6e5 (3e5)2.6e5 (3e5)2.6e5 (3e5)2.6e5 (3e5)2.6e5 (3e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 806 (1374)2.5e4 (4e4)3.4e4 (4e4)3.4e4 (4e4)3.5e4 (4e4)3.5e4 (4e4)1.4e6 (2e6)1/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.0e5 (1e6)1.3e7 (1e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.8e6 (3e6)1.3e7 (2e7)2.8e7 (3e7)2.8e7 (2e7)2.8e7 (3e7)2.8e7 (3e7)2.8e7 (4e7)1/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (2e6)3.0e6 (5e6)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (1e7)1.3e7 (1e7)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (6e6)2/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (1e6)3.0e6 (4e6)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (1e7)1.3e7 (1e7)2/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5706 (9813)8.5e4 (1e5)2.0e5 (3e5)2.0e5 (3e5)2.1e5 (3e5)2.1e5 (3e5)2.1e5 (3e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2378 (4490)7.2e4 (1e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2925 (3709)6.0e4 (6e4)1.9e5 (2e5)1.9e5 (2e5)1.9e5 (2e5)1.9e5 (2e5)1.9e5 (2e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1115 (800)2.4e4 (1e4)5.9e4 (1e5)5.9e4 (1e5)5.9e4 (1e5)5.9e4 (1e5)1.9e6 (1e6)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4617 (8027)7.9e4 (1e5)4.1e5 (5e5)4.1e5 (5e5)4.1e5 (5e5)4.1e5 (5e5)4.1e5 (5e5)14/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.5e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (1e5)5.7e5 (5e5)5.7e5 (6e5)5.8e5 (7e5)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (9e5)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)3/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.0e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (1e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (1e6)1.6e6 (1e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)3/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6.2e4 (2e5)1.1e6 (1e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (3e6)3/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6.3e4 (2e5)1.1e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (2e6)3/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f22, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e4 (2e4)7.7e5 (1e6)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (4e7)1/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2114 (3449)4.3e5 (1e6)2.6e6 (3e6)2.6e6 (3e6)2.6e6 (2e6)2.6e6 (3e6)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (4e6)1.3e7 (1e7)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.3e6 (1e6)5.5e6 (9e6)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.5e6 (1e7)1.3e7 (3e7)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4.0e6 (4e6)8.0e6 (1e7)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3025 (3261)9.9e5 (2e6)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (2e7)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (3e7)3.0e7 (3e7)1/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (2e4)5.6e5 (1e6)2.9e7 (2e7)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (2e7)2.9e7 (4e7)2.9e7 (3e7)1/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.2e4 (4e4)8.6e5 (1e6)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (5e7)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (3e7)2.9e7 (2e7)1/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4519 (1662)3.6e5 (1e6)2.5e6 (4e6)2.5e6 (3e6)2.5e6 (2e6)2.5e6 (2e6)9.0e6 (1e7)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (2e4)8.8e5 (1e6)2.8e7 (3e7)2.8e7 (3e7)2.8e7 (4e7)2.8e7 (4e7)2.8e7 (3e7)1/15
BSrr Tanabe 3.1e4 (4e4)6.9e4 (1e5)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.7e5 (4e5)2.6e6 (3e6)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.7e5 (6e5)2.6e6 (3e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.6e5 (8e5)2.6e6 (4e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.6e5 (6e5)2.6e6 (4e6)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Δ fopt
f23, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 59 (80)8.7e4 (8e4)4.9e5 (5e5)1.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2569 (4942)2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 53 (42)1825 (3414)2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 36 (36)950 (218)1.7e6 (2e6)2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 23 (29)3.1e5 (1e6)2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 44 (39)1.3e6 (2e6)2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 67 (74)1.5e4 (1e4)1.3e7 (2e7)2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 20 (28)5.5e4 (6e4)9.4e5 (1e6)2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 45 (44)1.4e4 (1e4)1.5e7 (1e7)2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 382 (512)2.6e6 (3e6)2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 44 (42)1.1e5 (1e5)8.8e6 (8e6)2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 16 (15)5.9e5 (5e5)4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8.8 (6)1.1e6 (2e6)4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8.8 (6)1.5e5 (2e5)4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 10 (8)1.6e6 (2e6)4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 10 (8)2.1e5 (2e5)4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8.7 (7)8e50/15

Δ fopt
f24, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 8e50/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 80 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1441 (172)2319 (156)3202 (212)4127 (152)4994 (230)6804 (220)8607 (242)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)256 (40)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1138 (76)1823 (68)2476 (82)3139 (86)3835 (154)5212 (121)6591 (92)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1149 (63)1828 (104)2541 (100)3232 (114)3912 (91)5268 (127)6659 (132)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1171 (125)1821 (161)2498 (136)3176 (196)3849 (166)5299 (240)6678 (212)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1133 (106)1740 (88)2426 (131)3109 (114)3813 (172)5204 (104)6606 (156)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 944 (63)1541 (93)2121 (102)2747 (119)3354 (179)4620 (192)5835 (270)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1423 (85)2310 (114)3175 (145)4033 (148)4889 (196)6615 (215)8328 (274)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 980 (94)1579 (104)2161 (138)2788 (129)3430 (134)4794 (164)6137 (222)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)245 (0)256 (40)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1307 (136)2133 (130)2957 (126)3793 (127)4631 (137)6254 (98)7951 (178)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 351 (20)400 (4)445 (39)465 (17)468 (17)470 (16)470 (16)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 642 (20)1036 (10)1607 (12)2154 (14)2537 (12)3639 (32)4611 (14)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3740 (40)7274 (42)1.1e4 (35)1.4e4 (31)1.7e4 (36)2.3e4 (36)3.0e4 (115)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 635 (62)1498 (20)2363 (23)2951 (66)3795 (16)5235 (44)6930 (124)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3472 (449)7268 (369)1.2e4 (902)1.7e4 (732)2.2e4 (654)3.2e4 (765)4.1e4 (728)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f2, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (8932)1.3e5 (8714)1.5e5 (9816)1.6e5 (6062)1.7e5 (9248)1.9e5 (8600)2.1e5 (3862)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (2e4)2.7e5 (5e4)3.5e5 (6e4)4.2e5 (6e4)5.6e5 (6e4)7.0e5 (8e4)11/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3.1e5 (5e4)5.1e5 (9e4)7.2e5 (1e5)8.9e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (3e5)1.5e6 (3e5)1.9e6 (4e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.9e5 (3e4)2.9e5 (3e4)3.9e5 (5e4)4.8e5 (5e4)5.6e5 (5e4)7.3e5 (5e4)9.2e5 (8e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3.1e5 (4e4)4.6e5 (6e4)6.0e5 (1e5)7.4e5 (1e5)9.1e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (1e5)1.5e6 (2e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.2e5 (4e4)4.8e5 (6e4)6.3e5 (9e4)7.8e5 (1e5)9.3e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (2e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.9e4 (3242)3.3e4 (3332)3.6e4 (2412)3.8e4 (1612)4.0e4 (1409)4.3e4 (1739)4.5e4 (1786)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e4 (1688)3.0e4 (2152)3.2e4 (1972)3.3e4 (1592)3.5e4 (1528)3.7e4 (1619)3.9e4 (1612)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.8e4 (7592)3.7e4 (9182)4.3e4 (1e4)4.8e4 (1e4)5.3e4 (1e4)5.9e4 (1e4)6.4e4 (1e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4.7e4 (3402)6.1e4 (3564)7.2e4 (3321)8.1e4 (4293)9.0e4 (6075)1.1e5 (5710)1.2e5 (5832)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (1024)1.5e4 (1149)1.6e4 (1206)1.7e4 (1209)1.8e4 (1172)2.0e4 (1090)2.2e4 (1034)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 986 (82)★41061 (82)★41185 (85)★41271 (88)★41422 (122)★41689 (120)★41940 (122)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3146 (12)3547 (154)4053 (10)4628 (17)5019 (143)6136 (18)7066 (10)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.9e4 (32)2.3e4 (31)2.6e4 (131)2.9e4 (34)3.2e4 (30)3.9e4 (82)4.6e4 (702)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4563 (225)5189 (234)6048 (148)6932 (230)7506 (16)9190 (165)1.1e4 (88)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.6e4 (1272)3.1e4 (1674)3.7e4 (892)4.1e4 (1450)4.6e4 (1609)5.4e4 (1900)6.1e4 (1090)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f3, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 3436 (170)★45197 (360)★46257 (1041)★46296 (1014)★46423 (1053)★46563 (1054)★46803 (1081)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.2e4 (1074)3.2e6 (4e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.6e4 (1035)9.3e4 (2892)9.8e4 (1568)1.0e5 (1838)1.0e5 (1737)1.1e5 (3544)1.1e5 (3264)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f4, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 4987 (703)★49211 (1123)★41.1e4 (1402)★41.2e4 (1328)★41.2e4 (1127)★41.3e4 (1441)★41.6e4 (1199)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.1e5 (8e5)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8.7e4 (1241)1.1e7 (2e7)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f5, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 849 (60)982 (78)1016 (96)1025 (93)1025 (93)1025 (93)1025 (93)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 412 (40)472 (40)493 (81)493 (81)493 (81)493 (81)493 (81)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 631 (112)683 (140)695 (148)699 (154)699 (154)699 (154)699 (154)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 535 (88)592 (62)613 (80)613 (80)613 (80)613 (80)613 (80)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 612 (108)669 (126)674 (116)674 (116)674 (116)674 (116)674 (116)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 600 (68)673 (98)676 (98)680 (98)680 (98)680 (98)680 (98)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 704 (90)758 (88)774 (88)777 (88)777 (88)777 (88)777 (88)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 747 (89)844 (111)862 (111)862 (111)862 (111)863 (104)863 (104)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 661 (66)770 (90)789 (96)796 (103)796 (103)798 (103)798 (103)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 396 (40)461 (40)477 (40)483 (81)483 (81)483 (81)483 (81)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 972 (64)1202 (111)1288 (113)1291 (113)1291 (113)1291 (113)1291 (113)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 240 (1)240 (1)240 (1)240 (1)240 (1)240 (1)240 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)122 (4)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 393 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 393 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)401 (12)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f6, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1567)2.0e4 (2014)2.6e4 (2822)3.3e4 (2763)4.0e4 (3184)5.3e4 (4124)6.8e4 (4393)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3.1e4 (6804)5.0e4 (8829)7.1e4 (7533)9.1e4 (9842)1.1e5 (1e4)1.5e5 (1e4)1.9e5 (2e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 6.8e6 (5e6)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.1e5 (9e4)4.9e5 (2e5)7.6e5 (2e5)1.0e6 (2e5)1.3e6 (3e5)1.8e6 (3e5)2.3e6 (3e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.2e4 (8087)8.3e4 (9342)1.1e5 (1e4)1.4e5 (9536)1.8e5 (9889)2.4e5 (1e4)3.1e5 (1e4)14/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.3e4 (5991)5.7e4 (1e4)8.6e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (3e4)1.6e5 (3e4)4.6e5 (2e5)6.0e5 (2e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (2379)2.4e4 (2964)3.2e4 (3245)4.0e4 (4808)4.8e4 (6322)6.4e4 (6810)7.9e4 (8659)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (3e5)9.0e5 (9e5)2.3e6 (2e6)6.1e6 (6e6)5.6e7 (7e7)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3.3e4 (1e4)5.7e4 (1e4)8.4e4 (1e4)1.1e5 (2e4)1.4e5 (2e4)1.8e5 (1e4)2.3e5 (2e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1859)1.9e4 (1642)2.6e4 (2960)3.2e4 (5080)4.0e4 (6566)5.5e4 (1e4)7.0e4 (1e4)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.0e4 (1e4)5.4e4 (3e4)1.2e5 (7e4)2.0e5 (1e5)3.0e5 (2e5)5.6e5 (5e5)9.3e5 (5e5)7/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.8e4 (1e4)6.4e4 (5e4)1.2e5 (1e5)2.0e5 (2e5)3.1e5 (2e5)4.6e5 (3e5)7.6e5 (6e5)9/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.1e4 (5e4)1.2e5 (1e5)2.8e5 (2e5)6.5e5 (7e5)1.1e6 (1e6)2.6e6 (2e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.2e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (8e4)2.4e5 (2e5)4.5e5 (5e5)7.5e5 (1e6)1.6e6 (2e6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f7, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2.8e7 (3e7)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 7.7e6 (7e6)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5.7e7 (7e7)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f8, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (8275)2.4e5 (9060)2.5e5 (8788)2.5e5 (8917)2.5e5 (8904)2.6e5 (8899)2.6e5 (8868)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e4 (8464)3.5e4 (1e4)3.6e4 (1e4)3.7e4 (1e4)3.7e4 (1e4)3.8e4 (1e4)3.8e4 (1e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (3e4)8.0e5 (3e6)8.0e5 (3e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.2e5 (2e6)13/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 9.5e4 (3e4)1.1e6 (2e6)1.1e6 (2e6)1.1e6 (2e6)1.1e6 (2e6)1.1e6 (2e6)1.1e6 (2e6)12/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.9e5 (4e4)8.8e5 (2e6)8.9e5 (2e6)8.9e5 (2e6)9.0e5 (2e6)9.0e5 (2e6)9.0e5 (2e6)13/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (6960)2.1e6 (4e6)2.1e6 (4e6)2.1e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (3e6)2.2e6 (5e6)2.2e6 (2e6)10/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8.8e4 (2986)1.2e5 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e4)1.3e5 (1e4)1.4e5 (1e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (6614)1.6e5 (5328)1.6e5 (5713)1.7e5 (5630)1.7e5 (5438)1.7e5 (5346)1.8e5 (5445)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 7.7e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.2e4 (6156)3.5e4 (2e4)3.7e4 (2e4)3.7e4 (2e4)3.7e4 (2e4)3.8e4 (2e4)3.8e4 (2e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (6188)2.0e5 (2e5)2.1e5 (2e5)2.2e5 (2e5)2.4e5 (2e5)2.6e5 (2e5)2.9e5 (2e5)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3.4e5 (2e5)4.4e5 (5e5)5.6e5 (4e5)7.1e5 (5e5)9.7e5 (9e5)2.9e6 (3e6)1.2e7 (1e7)0/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.0e5 (1e5)4.5e5 (5e5)5.8e5 (5e5)7.5e5 (5e5)8.5e5 (7e5)1.6e6 (9e5)5.9e6 (7e6)1/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.6e5 (1e5)7.3e5 (8e5)8.1e5 (8e5)1.0e6 (1e6)1.3e6 (1e6)2.8e6 (4e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.9e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e6)1.2e6 (1e6)1.3e6 (1e6)1.3e6 (1e6)1.9e6 (1e6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f9, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (5752)2.2e5 (6906)2.3e5 (6784)2.4e5 (6590)2.4e5 (6762)2.4e5 (6594)2.4e5 (6667)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.6e4 (6116)3.4e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (1e4)3.6e4 (1e4)3.6e4 (1e4)3.6e4 (1e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (3e4)7.9e5 (2e6)8.0e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)8.1e5 (2e6)13/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (4655)4.2e5 (7694)4.2e5 (7068)4.3e5 (7370)4.3e5 (7665)4.3e5 (7740)4.4e5 (8192)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.1e5 (7e4)3.8e6 (6e6)3.8e6 (4e6)3.8e6 (6e6)3.8e6 (8e6)3.8e6 (5e6)3.8e6 (3e6)8/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (4624)2.1e6 (3e6)2.1e6 (3e6)2.2e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (2e6)2.2e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (2e6)10/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (1e4)2.0e5 (1e5)2.0e5 (1e5)2.0e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (1e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e5 (5976)2.4e5 (8541)2.5e5 (7718)2.5e5 (7422)2.5e5 (7772)2.6e5 (7920)2.6e5 (8359)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (2e4)1.7e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (1e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.2e4 (5103)2.9e4 (8181)3.0e4 (8302)3.1e4 (8181)3.1e4 (8181)3.2e4 (8181)3.2e4 (8181)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6.1e5 (3e4)2.2e6 (2e6)1.7e7 (2e7)2.7e7 (5e7)5.7e7 (8e7)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5.7e5 (4e5)1.1e6 (9e5)1.2e6 (1e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.9e6 (9e6)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.6e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (7e5)1.8e6 (2e6)2.8e6 (2e6)1.2e7 (2e7)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8.3e5 (6e5)5.5e6 (4e6)5.5e6 (7e6)5.6e6 (6e6)5.6e6 (8e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.8e5 (2e5)8.6e5 (1e6)9.3e5 (8e5)1.2e6 (8e5)1.8e6 (1e6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f10, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (9261)1.3e5 (9731)1.5e5 (9012)1.6e5 (9669)1.7e5 (7967)1.9e5 (7679)2.1e5 (6704)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (3e4)2.7e5 (5e4)3.4e5 (6e4)4.4e5 (8e4)6.0e5 (1e5)5.8e7 (9e7)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.8e5 (5e4)4.6e5 (1e5)6.7e5 (1e5)8.4e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (2e5)1.4e6 (2e5)1.8e6 (2e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.0e5 (3e4)3.1e5 (4e4)4.1e5 (5e4)5.1e5 (5e4)6.2e5 (8e4)8.2e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (9e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.8e5 (4e4)4.4e5 (8e4)6.2e5 (1e5)7.5e5 (1e5)8.9e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (2e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.9e5 (4e4)4.3e5 (5e4)5.7e5 (8e4)7.0e5 (9e4)8.4e5 (9e4)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (2e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8.8e5 (6e5)1.5e6 (9e5)2.3e6 (1e6)3.1e6 (2e6)4.0e6 (3e6)1.1e7 (1e7)2.8e7 (4e7)2/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.9e6 (2e6)5.4e6 (6e6)1.3e7 (1e7)2.7e7 (4e7)2.8e7 (3e7)5.8e7 (6e7)5.8e7 (5e7)0/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.0e5 (2e5)5.5e5 (2e5)6.7e5 (2e5)7.4e5 (2e5)8.0e5 (2e5)8.9e5 (1e5)9.3e5 (1e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4.6e4 (3969)★46.0e4 (3686)★47.1e4 (4455)8.0e4 (3604)9.1e4 (6278)1.8e5 (1e5)2.8e7 (4e7)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f11, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 6.0e4 (2293)6.4e4 (1974)6.7e4 (1735)7.0e4 (1472)7.2e4 (1402)7.5e4 (1198)7.9e4 (1193)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4290 (486)6536 (1174)8664 (1944)1.0e4 (2876)2.6e4 (2e4)2.7e5 (2e5)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (3e4)2.3e5 (5e4)3.4e5 (5e4)4.5e5 (6e4)5.7e5 (9e4)8.0e5 (1e5)1.0e6 (1e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.3e4 (4119)7.5e4 (8511)1.4e5 (2e4)2.2e5 (2e4)2.9e5 (4e4)4.5e5 (4e4)5.8e5 (4e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.3e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.9e5 (4e4)3.7e5 (4e4)5.2e5 (4e4)6.8e5 (4e4)14/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (2e5)2.0e6 (2e5)2.7e6 (2e5)3.4e6 (3e5)1.5e7 (1e7)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5.7e6 (5e6)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (3e4)2.1e5 (6e4)2.7e5 (7e4)3.4e5 (7e4)3.9e5 (7e4)5.0e5 (6e4)7.6e6 (7e6)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4257 (1053)6325 (1498)8210 (2430)9879 (1863)1.3e4 (2187)★26.6e4 (5e4)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f12, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e4 (1e4)3.9e4 (2e4)6.1e4 (3e4)1.1e5 (6e4)1.3e5 (6e4)1.7e5 (4e4)2.1e5 (6e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1789 (1336)4554 (3159)6774 (2997)1.1e4 (6764)1.4e4 (8019)5.1e4 (3e4)1.1e6 (1e6)4/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1e4)1.1e5 (2e4)9.2e5 (2e6)8.8e6 (1e7)2.6e7 (5e7)5.6e7 (4e7)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (9366)3.2e4 (2e4)6.3e4 (5e4)9.8e4 (7e4)1.2e5 (6e4)1.7e5 (8e4)2.0e5 (7e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (1e4)5.8e4 (5e4)1.1e5 (9e4)2.1e5 (1e5)2.5e5 (9e4)3.1e5 (1e5)3.4e5 (1e5)13/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (6258)2.8e4 (8456)8.8e5 (2e6)8.0e6 (1e7)2.6e7 (4e7)5.6e7 (9e7)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (8820)2.4e4 (1e4)4.2e4 (2e4)6.5e4 (3e4)8.2e4 (3e4)1.1e5 (4e4)1.3e5 (4e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 9833 (9510)2.7e4 (2e4)1.2e6 (2e6)6.4e6 (1e7)1.8e7 (2e7)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (1e4)2.6e4 (2e4)4.5e4 (3e4)6.2e4 (3e4)7.0e4 (3e4)1.0e5 (3e4)1.2e5 (3e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1363 (202)3420 (1984)5861 (2187)7854 (3118)1.5e4 (6764)6.1e4 (6e4)1.5e6 (2e6)2/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8.2e5 (8e5)7.3e6 (8e6)2.8e7 (3e7)5.7e7 (8e7)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 5e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.2e6 (1e6)1.1e7 (1e7)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.3e6 (5e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3.0e5 (6e5)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7.4e5 (6e5)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f13, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 5729 (542)4.5e4 (6e4)7.5e5 (8e5)3.2e6 (4e6)5.8e7 (7e7)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2205 (243)2.3e4 (2e4)1.6e5 (1e5)2.0e6 (2e6)6.2e6 (5e6)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (1e4)1.1e6 (2e6)2.5e6 (3e6)2.7e7 (3e7)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.0e4 (1e4)8.3e4 (1e5)1.3e6 (1e6)7.9e6 (7e6)2.8e7 (4e7)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (3e6)2.6e7 (4e7)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4235 (576)1.1e7 (1e7)5.6e7 (8e7)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 6654 (9278)4.7e4 (5e4)4.7e5 (6e5)6.2e6 (5e6)2.7e7 (3e7)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 7315 (2610)5.0e4 (5e4)3.1e5 (3e5)2.6e6 (3e6)1.1e7 (1e7)6.0e7 (5e7)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4482 (641)9.9e4 (9e4)7.7e5 (9e5)4.7e6 (4e6)5.9e7 (8e7)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2243 (122)2.1e4 (2e4)7.0e4 (5e4)1.1e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (2e5)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6632 (686)5.8e4 (8e4)6.9e5 (8e5)7.7e6 (1e7)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 5.6e4 (5e4)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.3e5 (4e5)1.6e6 (2e6)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.6e4 (4103)2.3e6 (3e6)1.1e7 (7e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.1e5 (4e5)1.1e7 (2e7)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.2e5 (4e5)5.2e6 (6e6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f14, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1270 (141)2704 (189)4169 (255)7337 (544)1.6e4 (792)5.8e4 (3083)1.3e5 (4345)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 504 (81)893 (81)1314 (162)2065 (202)4025 (243)3.8e4 (6278)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 876 (120)1912 (168)2840 (184)4582 (286)9338 (614)1.0e5 (1e4)1.8e6 (1e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 810 (81)1693 (127)2474 (152)3784 (272)7584 (554)7.2e4 (4800)9.8e5 (1e5)6/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 915 (102)1998 (220)2887 (260)4839 (375)1.1e4 (724)9.5e4 (9826)1.8e6 (3e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 902 (221)1937 (272)2821 (265)4480 (301)9491 (450)1.0e5 (1e4)1.8e6 (4e5)0/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 932 (216)2027 (328)2956 (382)4846 (286)1.2e4 (970)3.6e5 (2e5)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1245 (217)2616 (343)4042 (298)7161 (508)1.6e4 (1691)3.3e5 (1e5)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 973 (181)2060 (218)3041 (324)5183 (567)1.2e4 (1178)1.3e5 (3e4)2.3e6 (3e6)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 488 (81)904 (162)1298 (162)2092 (243)4003 (324)1.5e4 (770)★44e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1168 (176)2467 (218)3806 (176)6403 (564)1.6e4 (2472)6.2e6 (9e6)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 495 (160)7769 (2940)1.4e4 (3934)4.1e4 (1e4)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 865 (304)2011 (272)3799 (474)6594 (808)2.3e4 (9256)3.8e6 (5e6)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1384 (919)1.0e4 (1316)1.9e4 (2170)2.9e4 (2414)7.0e4 (1e4)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 386 (214)2081 (254)3988 (524)7909 (1080)2.8e4 (1e4)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 386 (214)7209 (812)1.5e4 (1809)2.9e4 (2440)8.0e4 (3e4)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f15, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f16, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8320 (1651)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.6e6 (6e6)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7190 (2e4)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3.5e6 (4e6)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4.6e6 (6e6)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (4e4)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (1252)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e4 (7e4)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.6e4 (6e4)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.1e7 (1e7)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.2e6 (4e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f17, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1080 (234)6114 (1000)8.7e5 (1e6)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 6.4e6 (8e6)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 745 (166)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 672 (272)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 784 (275)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 671 (131)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 862 (278)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1139 (242)1.6e4 (3e4)9.7e5 (1e6)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 866 (382)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (1e6)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 957 (276)1.0e4 (2231)3.6e6 (4e6)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.6e4 (4e4)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1500 (962)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3326 (3302)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 5.9e4 (1300)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6.1e4 (4416)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f18, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3353 (691)1.8e5 (3e5)5.9e7 (1e8)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.6e7 (5e7)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5.1e6 (4e6)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3670 (973)3.3e5 (4e5)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.9e5 (7e5)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3378 (854)1.3e6 (2e6)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f19, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1070 (285)8.5e6 (1e7)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.9e7 (3e7)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 679 (326)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 561 (98)8.1e6 (1e7)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 576 (130)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 525 (90)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 656 (204)1.6e7 (2e7)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 959 (218)5.9e6 (8e6)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 614 (121)2.8e7 (3e7)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 5.8e7 (7e7)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1092 (322)5.8e7 (5e7)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2860 (1140)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)2.7e4 (4914)★28e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)5.0e4 (2893)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3.3e4 (5636)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)5.1e4 (6699)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)2e60/15

Δ fopt
f20, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1869 (144)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 547 (40)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1077 (92)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1201 (85)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1098 (78)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1022 (144)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1030 (151)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1787 (179)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1015 (136)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 564 (81)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1635 (190)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 776 (290)5.9e4 (2e4)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 596 (4)2552 (86)★48e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4664 (81)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 677 (83)3721 (732)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3160 (648)7.4e4 (1e5)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f21, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3958 (7793)2.3e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (1e6)4.7e5 (1e6)4.7e5 (1e6)4.7e5 (1e6)4.7e5 (1e6)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1396 (1864)3.2e4 (3e4)1.2e5 (3e5)1.2e5 (3e5)1.2e5 (3e5)1.2e5 (3e5)1.2e7 (2e7)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (2e6)2.6e7 (4e7)2.6e7 (3e7)2.6e7 (4e7)2.6e7 (4e7)2.6e7 (3e7)2.6e7 (2e7)2/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (2e6)2.6e7 (2e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (9e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (5e7)1/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (2e6)5.6e7 (7e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (7e7)5.6e7 (5e7)5.6e7 (5e7)5.6e7 (6e7)1/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (2e6)2.6e7 (4e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (5e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.6e7 (5e7)1/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3601 (6098)1.7e5 (3e5)4.2e5 (1e6)4.2e5 (1e6)4.2e5 (1e6)4.2e5 (1e6)4.2e5 (1e6)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6743 (1e4)3.5e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (5e5)6.1e5 (5e5)14/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4451 (5910)1.1e5 (1e5)2.4e5 (4e5)2.4e5 (4e5)2.4e5 (4e5)2.4e5 (4e5)2.4e5 (4e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2255 (2350)4.4e4 (8e4)9.6e4 (1e5)9.7e4 (1e5)9.7e4 (1e5)9.8e4 (1e5)5.8e7 (6e7)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 9451 (1e4)2.7e5 (2e5)4.5e5 (4e5)4.5e5 (4e5)4.5e5 (4e5)4.5e5 (4e5)4.6e5 (4e5)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.4e4 (6e4)3.5e5 (5e5)5.4e5 (8e5)5.5e5 (6e5)5.7e5 (1e6)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5.8e4 (686)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (6e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6.2e4 (1612)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 5.8e4 (536)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (6e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.9e4 (1902)3.2e6 (5e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (6e6)3.2e6 (3e6)3/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f22, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 6.2e4 (4e4)2.6e6 (5e6)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2622 (1500)1.6e6 (2e6)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.7e6 (3e6)1.6e7 (2e7)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.7e6 (6e6)1.6e7 (2e7)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4.6e6 (6e6)5.6e7 (5e7)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.5e6 (6e6)8.0e6 (1e7)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e4 (4e4)2.0e6 (2e6)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 9071 (1e4)2.4e6 (4e6)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (4e4)3.2e6 (6e6)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4972 (3687)1.6e6 (3e6)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.6e4 (7e4)2.2e6 (2e6)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 7.6e4 (2e5)2.3e5 (4e5)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5.3e5 (8e5)1.1e7 (9e6)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.4e5 (1e6)1.1e7 (2e7)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.0e5 (4e5)1.1e7 (1e7)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.0e5 (8e5)1.1e7 (9e6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Δ fopt
f23, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 114 (145)7.1e4 (2e4)7.8e5 (9e5)4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2086 (3119)4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 65 (56)6.2e5 (2e6)4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 38 (38)1891 (838)5.7e7 (7e7)4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 28 (23)6.2e5 (2e6)4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 32 (28)1.5e6 (4e6)4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 99 (89)1.1e4 (7827)2.8e7 (4e7)4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 107 (84)7.1e4 (6e4)2.2e6 (3e6)4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 61 (80)1.3e4 (9358)4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 482 (608)5.9e7 (6e7)4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 87 (82)8.0e4 (5e4)6.3e6 (7e6)4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 7.6 (6)8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3.5 (4)3.2e6 (3e6)8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.5 (4)2.2e6 (3e6)8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 5.4 (6)1.1e7 (1e7)8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.4 (6)8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 7.5 (8)2e60/15

Δ fopt
f24, 80-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8e50/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 8e50/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 2e60/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 160 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2697 (119)4364 (174)5961 (142)7631 (122)9224 (136)1.2e4 (174)1.6e4 (181)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)614 (80)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1946 (114)3071 (145)4220 (170)5384 (172)6513 (156)8877 (174)1.1e4 (166)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1865 (60)2950 (85)4006 (106)5081 (116)6113 (104)8256 (140)1.0e4 (220)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1886 (104)3053 (150)4294 (143)5391 (208)6627 (190)8961 (263)1.1e4 (332)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1774 (83)2960 (145)4082 (169)5199 (202)6318 (212)8732 (304)1.1e4 (270)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1728 (151)2797 (188)3895 (276)5018 (316)6099 (320)8290 (424)1.1e4 (376)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2676 (184)4265 (165)5860 (144)7504 (186)9114 (176)1.2e4 (251)1.5e4 (264)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1739 (114)2807 (148)3891 (217)5041 (260)6172 (218)8508 (332)1.1e4 (504)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)485 (0)614 (80)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2577 (94)4157 (92)5703 (115)7280 (124)8820 (171)1.2e4 (184)1.5e4 (299)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 705 (22)795 (6)910 (33)946 (15)950 (14)952 (13)952 (13)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1291 (34)2067 (12)3207 (18)4288 (38)5068 (17)7292 (28)9212 (43)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7497 (44)1.5e4 (53)2.1e4 (32)2.7e4 (57)3.4e4 (49)4.7e4 (48)6.0e4 (57)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1229 (82)2996 (22)4726 (41)5888 (82)7588 (32)1.0e4 (61)1.4e4 (34)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7311 (543)1.5e4 (530)2.5e4 (748)3.7e4 (670)4.6e4 (635)6.7e4 (947)8.6e4 (953)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f2, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (2e4)4.4e5 (2e4)5.1e5 (3e4)5.6e5 (3e4)6.1e5 (2e4)6.8e5 (2e4)7.5e5 (2e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (2e4)4.0e5 (4e4)5.8e5 (1e5)7.4e5 (1e5)9.2e5 (2e5)1.3e6 (3e5)1.6e6 (3e5)13/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.3e5 (6e4)8.6e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (2e5)1.9e6 (3e5)2.7e6 (4e5)3.5e6 (6e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.5e5 (4e4)5.3e5 (6e4)7.1e5 (1e5)8.8e5 (9e4)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (1e5)1.8e6 (2e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.5e5 (4e4)8.6e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (1e5)1.7e6 (1e5)2.3e6 (1e5)2.9e6 (2e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.9e5 (6e4)8.3e5 (6e4)1.1e6 (8e4)1.3e6 (1e5)1.6e6 (1e5)2.1e6 (1e5)2.6e6 (2e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 6.5e4 (3892)7.6e4 (4768)8.5e4 (7766)9.1e4 (5302)9.5e4 (5306)1.0e5 (4003)1.1e5 (3069)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.1e4 (3957)6.8e4 (5418)7.2e4 (5070)7.5e4 (4648)7.8e4 (5097)8.2e4 (4919)8.5e4 (4896)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.9e4 (2e4)9.9e4 (3e4)1.2e5 (4e4)1.4e5 (4e4)1.5e5 (4e4)1.8e5 (4e4)1.9e5 (4e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (7970)1.5e5 (8211)1.9e5 (8292)2.1e5 (8936)2.5e5 (9418)2.9e5 (1e4)3.3e5 (9338)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.3e4 (2248)3.7e4 (2511)3.9e4 (2768)4.2e4 (2973)4.4e4 (3150)4.7e4 (3098)5.0e4 (3089)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 1953 (80)★42181 (80)★42428 (98)★42677 (164)★42911 (163)★43410 (159)★43983 (310)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6276 (18)7045 (297)8092 (18)9237 (44)1.0e4 (286)1.2e4 (297)1.4e4 (15)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.9e4 (65)4.6e4 (80)5.2e4 (63)5.8e4 (64)6.4e4 (68)7.7e4 (218)9.3e4 (1480)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8999 (450)1.0e4 (158)1.2e4 (28)1.4e4 (449)1.5e4 (24)1.8e4 (436)2.1e4 (307)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.5e4 (2553)6.6e4 (1450)7.6e4 (2392)8.6e4 (1893)9.7e4 (1276)1.2e5 (1432)1.3e5 (1426)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f3, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 6955 (342)★41.1e4 (748)★41.4e4 (1146)★41.4e4 (1146)★41.4e4 (1066)★41.4e4 (988)★41.5e4 (992)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.5e4 (1328)2.2e7 (2e7)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.4e4 (1046)1.9e5 (6218)2.0e5 (3516)2.1e5 (4503)2.2e5 (4800)2.3e5 (5634)2.4e5 (7970)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f4, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 9706 (677)★41.9e4 (1632)★42.2e4 (2218)★42.3e4 (2375)★42.4e4 (1833)★42.6e4 (2298)★43.4e4 (2320)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.4e4 (3171)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.9e5 (2435)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f5, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1648 (145)2019 (148)2157 (245)2171 (245)2172 (245)2172 (245)2172 (245)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 764 (80)861 (80)925 (80)925 (80)925 (80)925 (80)925 (80)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1181 (139)1310 (159)1348 (150)1353 (151)1354 (151)1354 (151)1354 (151)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 977 (152)1071 (165)1108 (180)1113 (180)1116 (180)1116 (180)1116 (180)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1090 (118)1196 (132)1236 (168)1240 (168)1240 (168)1240 (168)1240 (168)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1146 (61)1310 (122)1349 (96)1352 (96)1358 (88)1358 (88)1358 (88)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1178 (290)1332 (286)1373 (314)1383 (338)1383 (338)1383 (338)1383 (338)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1323 (118)1515 (146)1556 (152)1574 (152)1577 (152)1577 (152)1577 (152)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1217 (198)1420 (169)1499 (198)1521 (170)1521 (170)1521 (170)1521 (170)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 764 (161)861 (80)904 (161)914 (161)914 (161)914 (161)914 (161)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1810 (180)2321 (161)2500 (161)2525 (198)2531 (240)2531 (240)2531 (240)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 480 (1)480 (1)480 (1)480 (1)480 (1)480 (1)480 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)241 (6)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 787 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 787 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)802 (12)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f6, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.7e4 (4006)5.4e4 (4020)7.3e4 (5908)9.2e4 (6891)1.1e5 (7602)1.5e5 (8448)1.9e5 (9650)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8.2e4 (2e4)1.4e5 (2e4)1.9e5 (3e4)2.4e5 (3e4)2.9e5 (3e4)3.9e5 (2e4)5.0e5 (2e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4.5e5 (5e5)9.4e5 (1e6)1.5e6 (1e6)2.1e6 (2e6)2.6e6 (2e6)3.9e6 (2e6)5.3e6 (3e6)12/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (1e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.7e5 (1e4)3.4e5 (2e4)4.2e5 (2e4)5.7e5 (2e4)7.2e5 (2e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 9.1e4 (1e4)1.7e5 (4e4)2.6e5 (5e4)3.8e5 (8e4)5.2e5 (8e4)8.2e5 (2e5)1.2e6 (3e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.7e4 (5129)6.8e4 (6028)9.0e4 (8336)1.1e5 (1e4)1.4e5 (1e4)1.8e5 (2e4)2.4e5 (2e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e6 (3e6)1.2e8 (1e8)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8.2e4 (2e4)1.5e5 (3e4)2.2e5 (2e4)2.9e5 (3e4)3.6e5 (4e4)5.0e5 (5e4)6.5e5 (4e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.4e4 (4151)5.0e4 (7396)6.8e4 (1e4)8.6e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (3e4)1.5e5 (4e4)2.0e5 (5e4)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4.5e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (1e5)2.8e5 (4e5)4.6e5 (6e5)7.3e5 (8e5)1.4e6 (1e6)2.0e6 (2e6)9/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6.8e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (4e4)2.4e5 (9e4)3.7e5 (2e5)5.2e5 (3e5)8.4e5 (6e5)1.3e6 (9e5)12/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8.6e4 (5e4)2.4e5 (1e5)5.0e5 (5e5)9.1e5 (9e5)1.4e6 (1e6)4.3e6 (5e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.2e5 (4e4)2.9e5 (2e5)5.5e5 (3e5)9.5e5 (9e5)1.3e6 (8e5)3.1e6 (3e6)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f7, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f8, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 7.3e5 (2e4)9.4e5 (2e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 7.8e4 (3e4)9.6e4 (5e4)1.2e5 (6e4)1.2e5 (6e4)1.2e5 (6e4)1.3e5 (6e4)1.3e5 (6e4)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (1e5)4.9e5 (1e5)1.7e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)13/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.4e5 (9e4)4.3e5 (1e5)4.4e5 (1e5)4.5e5 (1e5)4.6e5 (1e5)4.7e5 (1e5)4.7e5 (1e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.6e5 (3e5)7.0e5 (4e5)1.3e6 (4e5)1.3e6 (4e5)1.3e6 (4e5)1.3e6 (4e5)1.3e6 (4e5)14/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.5e5 (8e4)4.6e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)4.8e5 (2e5)4.8e5 (2e5)4.8e5 (2e5)4.9e5 (2e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (7e4)3.1e5 (8e4)3.7e5 (2e5)3.7e5 (2e5)3.8e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.2e5 (9056)5.5e5 (8676)6.0e5 (1e4)6.1e5 (1e4)6.2e5 (1e4)6.2e5 (1e4)6.3e5 (1e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e4)3.1e5 (9e4)3.3e5 (1e5)3.4e5 (1e5)3.4e5 (9e4)3.5e5 (9e4)3.5e5 (9e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8.5e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (3e4)1.2e5 (7e4)1.2e5 (7e4)1.3e5 (7e4)1.3e5 (7e4)1.3e5 (7e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.1e5 (1e4)4.1e5 (2e4)5.3e5 (3e5)5.4e5 (3e5)5.5e5 (3e5)5.8e5 (3e5)6.1e5 (3e5)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.2e6 (1e6)3.0e6 (3e6)3.2e6 (3e6)4.1e6 (5e6)5.4e6 (6e6)1.2e7 (1e7)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.0e5 (3e5)1.0e6 (8e5)1.3e6 (9e5)1.5e6 (1e6)1.7e6 (1e6)3.6e6 (2e6)5.9e6 (5e6)0/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.2e5 (3e5)9.9e5 (8e5)1.7e6 (2e6)2.0e6 (2e6)2.5e6 (2e6)2.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.8e5 (3e5)1.2e6 (1e6)3.3e6 (3e6)3.6e6 (2e6)4.5e6 (5e6)7.8e6 (7e6)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f9, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 7.4e5 (2e4)1.0e6 (3e4)1.4e6 (5e5)1.4e6 (5e5)1.4e6 (5e5)1.4e6 (5e5)1.4e6 (5e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 7.2e4 (3e4)8.5e4 (3e4)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (1e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.1e5 (1e5)5.4e5 (1e5)2.5e6 (4e6)2.5e6 (4e6)2.5e6 (4e6)2.5e6 (4e6)2.6e6 (4e6)12/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.9e5 (1e4)5.3e5 (8e4)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)13/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8.9e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (3e5)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)3.2e6 (4e6)12/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (1e5)4.8e5 (2e5)1.7e6 (6e6)1.7e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (4e6)13/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (8e4)4.9e5 (8e4)7.1e5 (6e5)7.2e5 (6e5)7.2e5 (6e5)7.3e5 (6e5)7.3e5 (6e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.9e5 (2e4)7.8e5 (9e4)1.0e6 (5e5)1.0e6 (5e5)1.0e6 (5e5)1.0e6 (5e5)1.0e6 (5e5)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (1e5)4.6e5 (1e5)6.4e5 (4e5)6.4e5 (4e5)6.5e5 (4e5)6.6e5 (4e5)6.6e5 (4e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 7.9e4 (2e4)9.4e4 (3e4)1.0e5 (4e4)1.1e5 (4e4)1.1e5 (4e4)1.1e5 (4e4)1.1e5 (4e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (1e5)1.1e8 (1e8)1.1e8 (2e8)1.1e8 (9e7)1.1e8 (2e8)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3.1e6 (2e6)7.7e6 (1e7)7.8e6 (1e7)1.2e7 (1e7)2.4e7 (2e7)2.4e7 (3e7)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.7e6 (1e7)2.4e7 (2e7)2.4e7 (2e7)2.4e7 (3e7)2.4e7 (3e7)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 7.6e6 (8e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.7e6 (6e6)1.2e7 (1e7)1.2e7 (9e6)2.4e7 (3e7)2.4e7 (3e7)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f10, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (3e4)4.4e5 (2e4)5.0e5 (1e4)5.6e5 (2e4)6.0e5 (2e4)6.8e5 (2e4)7.5e5 (2e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (3e4)3.9e5 (4e4)5.6e5 (1e5)7.2e5 (1e5)9.1e5 (9e4)1.3e6 (1e5)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.1e5 (6e4)8.6e5 (1e5)1.2e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (2e5)1.9e6 (3e5)2.6e6 (3e5)3.4e6 (5e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (3e4)5.6e5 (5e4)7.6e5 (1e5)9.5e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (1e5)1.9e6 (2e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.3e5 (7e4)8.1e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (2e5)1.7e6 (2e5)2.3e6 (3e5)3.0e6 (3e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.8e5 (1e5)8.4e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (2e5)1.6e6 (2e5)2.1e6 (3e5)2.7e6 (3e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e6 (7e5)3.1e6 (2e6)4.8e6 (2e6)7.4e6 (6e6)1.7e7 (2e7)5.6e7 (6e7)5.7e7 (6e7)2/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.3e6 (1e6)5.5e6 (4e6)1.1e7 (8e6)2.8e7 (3e7)1.2e8 (1e8)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (3e5)1.6e6 (4e5)2.1e6 (5e5)2.5e6 (4e5)2.9e6 (4e5)3.4e6 (4e5)3.7e6 (3e5)9/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (9258)★41.6e5 (7406)1.9e5 (7970)2.1e5 (7245)2.4e5 (1e4)3.9e5 (2e5)1.1e8 (2e8)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.4e7 (2e7)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f11, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e5 (8948)2.9e5 (7270)3.0e5 (5068)3.1e5 (4381)3.2e5 (4306)3.4e5 (3360)3.5e5 (2900)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (2576)1.7e4 (2978)2.4e4 (6440)3.5e4 (1e4)1.1e5 (7e4)2.0e6 (2e6)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (5e4)4.6e5 (5e4)6.6e5 (4e4)9.0e5 (6e4)1.1e6 (8e4)1.5e6 (1e5)2.0e6 (1e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7.7e4 (8372)1.9e5 (3e4)3.5e5 (2e4)5.1e5 (3e4)6.8e5 (4e4)1.0e6 (6e4)1.3e6 (8e4)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (5e4)3.4e5 (8e4)5.4e5 (8e4)7.4e5 (1e5)9.4e5 (1e5)1.3e6 (1e5)1.7e6 (3e5)9/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 6.8e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (1e5)1.8e6 (2e5)2.2e6 (2e5)2.9e6 (2e5)3.6e6 (2e5)10/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.7e7 (3e7)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e5 (7e4)4.9e5 (2e5)7.0e5 (3e5)8.9e5 (4e5)1.1e6 (4e5)1.8e6 (1e6)1.1e8 (2e8)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (3381)1.7e4 (3944)2.3e4 (5152)2.7e4 (7245)4.1e4 (2e4)★24.1e5 (4e5)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f12, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2.9e4 (2e4)8.1e4 (4e4)2.1e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (9e4)4.2e5 (2e5)6.6e5 (1e5)8.8e5 (2e5)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 4446 (2334)1.3e4 (5394)1.9e4 (6923)4.9e4 (5e4)7.2e4 (5e4)1.2e6 (1e6)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.2e4 (2e4)7.7e4 (2e4)1.8e6 (2e6)8.1e6 (7e6)1.2e8 (1e8)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.5e4 (2e4)7.7e4 (4e4)1.9e5 (1e5)3.2e5 (2e5)4.4e5 (2e5)6.9e5 (3e5)1.4e6 (7e5)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.4e4 (2e4)1.1e5 (1e5)2.9e5 (2e5)4.8e5 (2e5)5.8e5 (2e5)7.6e5 (3e5)3.8e6 (6e6)3/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (2e4)1.1e6 (3e6)9.9e6 (8e6)3.2e7 (4e7)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.4e4 (9760)6.4e4 (6e4)1.3e5 (5e4)1.7e5 (7e4)7.9e5 (1e5)2.2e7 (4e7)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.1e4 (2e4)4.7e5 (2e4)1.0e7 (1e7)1.2e8 (1e8)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e4 (2e4)7.1e4 (3e4)1.4e5 (8e4)2.0e5 (1e5)2.9e5 (2e5)4.2e5 (3e5)5.9e5 (2e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3555 (1771)1.1e4 (5876)2.2e4 (5957)3.8e4 (3e4)7.5e4 (6e4)1.0e6 (1e6)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.5e6 (4e6)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 9e40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.0e7 (8e6)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.4e6 (2e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6.5e6 (7e6)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f13, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9761 (363)6.0e4 (5e4)6.2e6 (7e6)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3920 (242)4.1e4 (4e4)2.5e6 (3e6)5.7e7 (6e7)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7388 (521)7.3e6 (1e7)3.5e7 (4e7)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6418 (271)1.8e5 (2e5)9.7e6 (2e7)1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 7512 (1008)1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 6910 (418)3.2e7 (3e7)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 7253 (674)2.4e5 (2e5)7.8e6 (8e6)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 9448 (398)1.1e5 (1e5)4.0e6 (4e6)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 7454 (680)1.9e5 (2e5)8.8e6 (8e6)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3952 (322)4.0e4 (6e4)1.9e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (3e5)4.6e6 (5e6)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8788 (306)8.7e4 (2e5)6.5e6 (6e6)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 8.2e4 (2e4)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.4e4 (1778)3.2e6 (4e6)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8.2e4 (5613)2.0e6 (2e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.4e4 (2828)1.0e7 (9e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6.9e4 (1e4)2.2e7 (2e7)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f14, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2407 (314)5163 (325)7698 (374)1.3e4 (478)3.0e4 (1098)1.6e5 (8918)4.7e5 (1e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 914 (161)1913 (322)2793 (402)4231 (402)7730 (483)7.9e4 (8292)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1418 (176)3507 (190)5133 (157)7982 (212)1.5e4 (838)1.4e5 (6266)3.2e6 (3e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1302 (116)3100 (252)4439 (230)6595 (337)1.3e4 (620)1.1e5 (6970)1.6e6 (1e5)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1280 (112)3440 (344)5069 (325)8172 (476)1.7e4 (910)1.5e5 (8968)3.5e6 (5e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1338 (79)3267 (132)4819 (185)7442 (404)1.6e4 (718)1.6e5 (1e4)2.5e6 (1e5)0/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1357 (196)3491 (300)5131 (306)8160 (352)1.8e4 (1246)3.5e5 (1e5)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2238 (278)4940 (322)7537 (366)1.3e4 (488)2.6e4 (1618)3.6e5 (1e5)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1457 (183)3607 (338)5261 (373)8789 (529)1.9e4 (2123)2.0e5 (5e4)3.6e6 (5e6)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 957 (161)2063 (402)2771 (402)4274 (402)8063 (564)3.5e4 (886)★48e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2264 (216)4854 (373)7247 (459)1.2e4 (604)2.4e4 (2202)1.5e6 (5e5)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 760 (109)1.2e4 (5232)2.1e4 (5186)5.0e4 (8527)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1008 (643)4208 (461)7522 (724)1.4e4 (974)4.2e4 (2e4)1.1e7 (1e7)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1087 (874)2.0e4 (3096)4.2e4 (2422)6.7e4 (2910)1.4e5 (3e4)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 463 (117)4530 (1224)8559 (937)1.5e4 (1348)4.7e4 (2e4)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 463 (117)1.5e4 (2071)3.6e4 (2811)6.8e4 (3999)1.5e5 (2e4)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f15, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f16, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4.6e4 (7e4)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 9.7e4 (2e5)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.2e7 (7e7)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.2e7 (3e7)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (1e6)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (4896)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.9e6 (2e6)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.9e5 (4e5)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f17, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3126 (500)8.2e4 (9e4)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (4e6)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1509 (217)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3759 (3960)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (4e6)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1922 (510)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2810 (393)1.5e5 (2e5)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2524 (692)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.0e7 (2e7)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3055 (620)6.4e5 (8e5)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.8e5 (3e5)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.2e5 (4412)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 9.0e4 (2e4)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.5e5 (8e5)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.3e5 (1e4)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f18, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9040 (1326)1.2e8 (1e8)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 9293 (1922)1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 9359 (2686)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f19, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4096 (2078)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1426 (246)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1251 (260)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1359 (208)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1330 (222)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4989 (2600)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3558 (1449)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3987 (2680)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4198 (2332)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.0e4 (4e4)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)7.4e4 (8035)★32e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1.5e5 (2e4)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)9.9e4 (1e4)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)1.4e5 (2e4)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)3e60/15

Δ fopt
f20, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4211 (238)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1226 (80)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2070 (118)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2085 (180)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2007 (180)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1850 (119)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1876 (118)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3793 (354)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1988 (199)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1226 (80)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3858 (206)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 9712 (2e4)2.1e5 (2e5)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1197 (8)7033 (164)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 8703 (163)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1342 (325)8692 (1810)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6931 (1772)1.5e5 (3e5)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f21, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (1e4)1.2e6 (3e6)3.5e6 (4e6)3.5e6 (8e6)3.5e6 (4e6)3.5e6 (4e6)3.5e6 (6e6)12/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3877 (4268)1.1e6 (3e6)2.2e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (4e6)2.2e6 (4e6)1.2e8 (8e7)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (4e6)2.2e7 (4e7)3.2e7 (2e7)3.2e7 (5e7)3.2e7 (4e7)3.2e7 (4e7)3.2e7 (5e7)3/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.3e6 (6e6)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (4e6)5.2e7 (6e7)1.1e8 (1e8)1.1e8 (1e8)1.1e8 (2e8)1.1e8 (1e8)1.1e8 (1e8)1/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (4e6)1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1e4)4.4e5 (5e5)1.7e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (3e6)14/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8017 (914)1.6e6 (4e6)3.9e6 (5e6)3.9e6 (4e6)4.0e6 (5e6)4.0e6 (6e6)4.0e6 (8e6)11/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1e4)1.0e6 (2e6)3.9e6 (5e6)3.9e6 (6e6)3.9e6 (8e6)3.9e6 (4e6)3.9e6 (6e6)11/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 4038 (6442)4.9e5 (6e5)9.8e5 (3e6)9.8e5 (3e6)9.9e5 (3e6)9.9e5 (3e6)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8201 (1093)7.6e5 (8e5)3.0e6 (4e6)3.0e6 (4e6)3.0e6 (4e6)3.0e6 (4e6)3.0e6 (4e6)13/15
BSrr Tanabe 4.1e4 (8e4)1.1e6 (1e6)2.3e6 (2e6)2.3e6 (2e6)2.3e6 (2e6)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.2e5 (792)1.8e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (4e6)2.4e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (2e6)2.4e6 (4e6)6/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.2e5 (6083)1.9e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (4e6)2.4e6 (3e6)2.4e6 (3e6)2.5e6 (2e6)2.5e6 (4e6)6/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.2e5 (758)1.4e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (3e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (3e6)1.8e6 (3e6)1.8e6 (2e6)7/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.2e5 (3781)1.4e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (4e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (3e6)7/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f22, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8.3e4 (2e5)7.7e6 (2e7)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (7166)5.9e6 (8e6)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.3e6 (8e6)2.2e7 (2e7)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4.0e6 (4e6)5.2e7 (6e7)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (4e6)1.1e8 (1e8)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 5.3e6 (8e6)3.2e7 (2e7)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (2e5)6.7e6 (1e7)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.0e4 (1e5)7.6e6 (1e7)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (2e4)7.0e6 (2e7)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3.2e4 (2e4)5.7e6 (7e6)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.6e4 (4e4)5.4e6 (8e6)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 6.7e4 (8e4)4.7e5 (5e5)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5.8e5 (8e5)3.2e6 (4e6)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.9e5 (8e5)3.2e6 (4e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 5.8e5 (8e5)3.2e6 (5e6)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 5.8e5 (8e5)3.2e6 (4e6)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Δ fopt
f23, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 57 (0)1.0e5 (3e4)7.2e5 (7e5)8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1 (0)5172 (1e4)8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1 (0)1622 (212)8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)2.0e6 (4e6)8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)2.9e6 (4e6)8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)8922 (5218)8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 22 (0)1.1e5 (4e4)2.7e6 (3e6)8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.3 (10)7862 (3524)8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)1.0e5 (6e4)4.0e6 (3e6)8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 1 (0)2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)2.2e7 (2e7)2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)3e60/15

Δ fopt
f24, 160-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8e60/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8e60/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 8e60/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 3e60/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 320 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 5254 (164)8399 (200)1.1e4 (238)1.5e4 (338)1.8e4 (334)2.4e4 (359)3.0e4 (334)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1372 (160)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3690 (214)5859 (220)8055 (188)1.0e4 (296)1.2e4 (300)1.7e4 (312)2.1e4 (266)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3261 (119)5157 (226)7043 (209)8938 (198)1.1e4 (194)1.5e4 (248)1.8e4 (272)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3410 (113)5433 (151)7698 (176)9768 (155)1.2e4 (212)1.6e4 (128)2.0e4 (159)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3386 (172)5350 (102)7340 (182)9244 (175)1.1e4 (184)1.5e4 (247)2.0e4 (240)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3263 (250)5303 (232)7265 (381)9289 (358)1.1e4 (389)1.5e4 (342)1.9e4 (314)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5207 (185)8250 (199)1.1e4 (260)1.4e4 (256)1.7e4 (322)2.3e4 (432)2.9e4 (380)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3212 (261)5179 (350)7201 (380)9236 (462)1.1e4 (502)1.6e4 (469)2.0e4 (516)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1286 (0)1414 (160)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3130 (76)4998 (223)6931 (246)8796 (272)1.1e4 (259)1.5e4 (366)1.9e4 (410)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 1412 (26)1587 (11)1840 (63)1903 (17)1909 (14)1911 (13)1911 (13)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2590 (34)4126 (20)6398 (28)8585 (39)1.0e4 (30)1.5e4 (50)1.8e4 (35)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.5e4 (78)2.9e4 (94)4.2e4 (92)5.5e4 (95)6.8e4 (114)9.3e4 (102)1.2e5 (384)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2474 (156)5991 (27)9453 (76)1.2e4 (158)1.5e4 (48)2.1e4 (116)2.8e4 (56)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.5e4 (912)3.0e4 (948)4.9e4 (1144)7.4e4 (876)9.2e4 (1050)1.4e5 (1101)1.7e5 (830)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f2, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (6e4)1.4e6 (7e4)1.6e6 (5e4)1.8e6 (6e4)1.9e6 (6e4)2.2e6 (6e4)2.5e6 (6e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.2e5 (3e4)8.2e5 (5e4)1.2e6 (1e5)1.6e6 (2e5)1.9e6 (2e5)2.6e6 (4e5)3.4e6 (6e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 9.9e5 (9e4)1.6e6 (1e5)2.4e6 (2e5)3.0e6 (4e5)3.8e6 (4e5)5.5e6 (7e5)7.4e6 (7e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7.3e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (1e5)1.4e6 (1e5)1.8e6 (1e5)2.1e6 (2e5)2.8e6 (3e5)3.6e6 (3e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (8e4)1.6e6 (1e5)2.2e6 (2e5)2.7e6 (2e5)3.3e6 (3e5)4.4e6 (4e5)5.5e6 (5e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (5e4)1.5e6 (7e4)2.0e6 (1e5)2.5e6 (1e5)2.9e6 (1e5)3.8e6 (1e5)4.9e6 (3e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e5 (7796)1.8e5 (1e4)2.1e5 (1e4)2.2e5 (1e4)2.3e5 (1e4)2.5e5 (1e4)2.6e5 (2e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (9644)1.5e5 (8432)1.6e5 (1e4)1.7e5 (1e4)1.8e5 (9800)1.9e5 (1e4)1.9e5 (1e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e5 (3e4)2.4e5 (6e4)3.0e5 (6e4)3.4e5 (6e4)4.0e5 (4e4)4.8e5 (6e4)5.5e5 (7e4)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.7e5 (8025)3.8e5 (1e4)4.8e5 (9951)5.7e5 (9309)6.4e5 (2e4)7.8e5 (2e4)9.0e5 (3e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (4346)1.5e5 (7380)1.6e5 (8960)1.6e5 (8293)1.7e5 (7772)1.7e5 (7419)1.8e5 (7366)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 3886 (182)★44308 (167)★44963 (177)★45442 (318)★45930 (174)★46867 (326)★49135 (966)★412/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.3e4 (30)1.4e4 (558)1.6e4 (26)1.9e4 (28)2.0e4 (502)2.5e4 (38)2.8e4 (326)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.8e4 (87)9.1e4 (588)1.0e5 (75)1.2e5 (78)1.3e5 (82)1.5e5 (940)1.9e5 (3894)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.8e4 (889)2.1e4 (42)2.4e4 (47)2.7e4 (613)3.0e4 (36)3.6e4 (862)4.3e4 (334)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.1e5 (2284)1.3e5 (1900)1.5e5 (956)1.7e5 (3166)2.0e5 (1934)2.4e5 (1905)2.7e5 (1632)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f3, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.4e4 (424)★42.1e4 (644)★43.1e4 (2e4)★43.1e4 (2e4)★43.2e4 (2e4)★43.2e4 (2e4)★43.3e4 (2e4)★415/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.2e4 (3039)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7.0e4 (2014)3.9e5 (9142)4.2e5 (4782)4.3e5 (6223)4.5e5 (6914)4.8e5 (7994)5.1e5 (7840)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f4, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.9e4 (702)★43.7e4 (2130)★44.5e4 (2253)★44.7e4 (2233)★44.8e4 (2569)★45.6e4 (3031)★41.1e6 (1e6)★40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6.9e4 (3859)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.8e5 (2678)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f5, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3076 (266)4008 (350)4632 (377)4775 (420)4775 (420)4775 (420)4775 (420)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1693 (321)1907 (321)1971 (321)2099 (482)2099 (482)2099 (482)2099 (482)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2382 (239)2812 (440)2913 (482)2929 (520)2934 (520)2934 (522)2934 (522)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1897 (258)2176 (352)2251 (324)2276 (332)2279 (322)2279 (322)2279 (322)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2127 (220)2458 (266)2543 (244)2562 (243)2567 (243)2567 (243)2567 (243)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2109 (240)2433 (262)2529 (233)2552 (238)2553 (238)2553 (238)2553 (238)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2244 (281)2637 (416)2728 (408)2757 (368)2765 (398)2765 (398)2765 (398)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2549 (305)2921 (281)3032 (278)3046 (296)3049 (296)3049 (296)3049 (296)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2213 (192)2724 (328)2877 (273)2931 (276)2933 (276)2933 (276)2933 (276)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1714 (321)2014 (321)2056 (321)2078 (482)2099 (482)2099 (482)2099 (482)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2204 (206)2613 (268)2756 (238)2821 (244)2821 (244)2822 (244)2822 (244)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 957 (1)960 (1)960 (1)960 (1)960 (1)960 (1)960 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)481 (9)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1567 (24)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1567 (24)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)1601 (19)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f6, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9.9e4 (6424)1.5e5 (8907)★42.0e5 (1e4)★42.4e5 (9664)★43.0e5 (1e4)★44.0e5 (1e4)5.1e5 (2e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.8e5 (5e4)3.1e5 (5e4)4.4e5 (7e4)5.7e5 (8e4)7.1e5 (1e5)9.8e5 (1e5)1.3e6 (1e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.8e5 (3e4)4.8e5 (8e4)6.7e5 (1e5)8.5e5 (1e5)1.1e6 (1e5)1.5e6 (1e5)1.9e6 (2e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.0e5 (2e4)4.7e5 (2e4)6.3e5 (2e4)7.9e5 (2e4)9.6e5 (3e4)1.3e6 (3e4)1.6e6 (4e4)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.2e5 (2e4)4.0e5 (5e4)6.7e5 (9e4)1.0e6 (3e5)1.4e6 (3e5)2.8e6 (8e5)6.4e6 (3e6)13/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (1e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2.7e5 (2e4)3.4e5 (2e4)4.1e5 (3e4)5.7e5 (5e4)7.3e5 (6e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.3e8 (3e8)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.0e5 (3e4)3.3e5 (4e4)4.7e5 (4e4)6.1e5 (4e4)7.6e5 (5e4)1.0e6 (4e4)1.3e6 (5e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.5e6 (2e5)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.1e5 (2e4)2.4e5 (4e4)4.5e5 (1e5)7.4e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (3e5)1.8e6 (5e5)2.9e6 (2e6)12/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.0e5 (3e4)3.6e5 (9e4)5.9e5 (2e5)8.6e5 (3e5)1.2e6 (4e5)1.8e6 (6e5)2.9e6 (2e6)10/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.1e5 (4e4)5.6e5 (2e5)1.2e6 (4e5)2.3e6 (2e6)4.5e6 (5e6)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.1e5 (9e4)9.0e5 (3e5)1.7e6 (7e5)2.5e6 (2e6)5.1e6 (3e6)4.7e7 (5e7)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f7, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f8, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2.9e6 (5e5)4.0e6 (1e6)4.8e6 (3e6)4.8e6 (3e6)4.8e6 (3e6)4.8e6 (3e6)4.8e6 (3e6)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3.3e5 (1e5)4.2e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)4.7e5 (2e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 9.8e5 (5e5)1.3e6 (7e5)3.7e6 (8e6)3.7e6 (8e6)3.7e6 (8e6)3.7e6 (8e6)3.7e6 (8e6)13/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.6e6 (7e5)2.1e6 (9e5)6.1e6 (8e6)6.1e6 (1e7)6.1e6 (9e6)6.2e6 (8e6)6.2e6 (8e6)12/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.5e6 (1e6)3.3e6 (2e6)3.4e6 (2e6)3.5e6 (2e6)3.5e6 (2e6)3.5e6 (2e6)3.5e6 (2e6)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (4e5)1.5e6 (6e5)7.3e6 (8e6)7.3e6 (8e6)7.4e6 (9e6)7.4e6 (8e6)7.4e6 (8e6)11/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 7.5e5 (3e5)9.1e5 (4e5)1.1e6 (4e5)1.1e6 (4e5)1.2e6 (4e5)1.2e6 (4e5)1.2e6 (4e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e6 (2e5)2.0e6 (7e4)2.6e6 (1e6)2.6e6 (1e6)2.6e6 (1e6)2.7e6 (1e6)2.7e6 (1e6)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.9e5 (3e5)7.9e5 (4e5)1.2e6 (8e5)1.2e6 (8e5)1.2e6 (8e5)1.2e6 (8e5)1.2e6 (8e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (1e5)3.0e5 (1e5)3.3e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (2e5)3.3e5 (2e5)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.4e6 (2e5)1.5e6 (1e5)2.6e6 (2e6)2.6e6 (2e6)2.6e6 (2e6)2.7e6 (2e6)2.7e6 (2e6)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5.1e6 (4e6)7.3e6 (5e6)7.3e6 (6e6)9.0e6 (8e6)1.2e7 (9e6)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.5e6 (2e6)2.7e6 (2e6)3.9e6 (2e6)6.2e6 (5e6)1.1e7 (1e7)2.4e7 (3e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 9.8e5 (6e5)1.4e6 (5e5)3.7e6 (5e6)4.1e6 (2e6)6.0e6 (7e6)4.7e7 (7e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.0e6 (8e5)1.5e6 (7e5)6.9e6 (9e6)8.8e6 (9e6)1.1e7 (1e7)1.2e7 (1e7)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f9, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e6 (8e5)4.0e6 (9e5)5.3e6 (3e6)5.3e6 (3e6)5.4e6 (3e6)5.4e6 (3e6)5.4e6 (3e6)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.6e5 (1e5)3.2e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (2e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (4e5)1.4e6 (6e5)5.4e6 (9e6)5.5e6 (9e6)5.5e6 (8e6)5.5e6 (9e6)5.5e6 (8e6)12/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (6e5)2.5e6 (1e6)1.1e7 (9e6)1.1e7 (1e7)1.1e7 (2e7)1.1e7 (2e7)1.1e7 (2e7)10/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.6e6 (1e6)3.3e6 (2e6)7.4e6 (9e6)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (9e6)7.5e6 (1e7)7.5e6 (9e6)12/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (4e5)1.6e6 (5e5)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)8/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (4e5)1.3e6 (5e5)1.5e6 (6e5)1.5e6 (5e5)1.5e6 (6e5)1.5e6 (6e5)1.5e6 (6e5)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (6e5)2.8e6 (6e5)3.1e6 (6e5)3.1e6 (6e5)3.1e6 (6e5)3.1e6 (6e5)3.1e6 (6e5)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (4e5)1.5e6 (7e5)1.5e6 (7e5)1.5e6 (7e5)1.5e6 (7e5)1.5e6 (7e5)1.5e6 (7e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (1e5)3.1e5 (1e5)4.8e5 (4e5)4.9e5 (4e5)4.9e5 (4e5)4.9e5 (4e5)4.9e5 (4e5)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5.9e6 (2e6)6.7e6 (2e6)1.2e7 (9e6)1.3e7 (2e7)1.3e7 (1e7)1.3e7 (1e7)1.4e7 (2e7)11/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.8e7 (6e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f10, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (6e4)1.4e6 (5e4)1.6e6 (5e4)1.8e6 (5e4)1.9e6 (4e4)2.2e6 (5e4)2.5e6 (4e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.3e5 (5e4)8.3e5 (8e4)1.1e6 (1e5)1.5e6 (1e5)1.8e6 (2e5)2.7e6 (4e5)1.1e8 (2e8)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 9.7e5 (9e4)1.6e6 (1e5)2.3e6 (3e5)3.0e6 (4e5)3.7e6 (4e5)5.5e6 (7e5)7.4e6 (1e6)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7.3e5 (7e4)1.1e6 (8e4)1.5e6 (1e5)1.8e6 (1e5)2.2e6 (2e5)2.9e6 (3e5)3.7e6 (4e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (8e4)1.6e6 (2e5)2.1e6 (3e5)2.7e6 (3e5)3.2e6 (3e5)4.4e6 (3e5)5.5e6 (5e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (1e5)1.6e6 (8e4)2.1e6 (1e5)2.5e6 (1e5)3.1e6 (1e5)4.1e6 (3e5)5.1e6 (5e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5.2e6 (5e6)1.4e7 (1e7)5.6e7 (5e7)2.4e8 (1e8)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.0e7 (3e7)4.4e7 (4e7)1.2e8 (1e8)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (6e5)4.0e6 (1e6)5.9e6 (1e6)7.7e6 (2e6)9.4e6 (2e6)1.2e7 (2e6)2.2e7 (2e7)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.8e5 (1e4)★43.9e5 (1e4)4.9e5 (1e4)5.8e5 (1e4)6.5e5 (1e4)8.7e5 (3e4)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f11, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e6 (3e4)1.3e6 (2e4)1.4e6 (2e4)1.4e6 (2e4)1.5e6 (1e4)1.5e6 (1e4)1.6e6 (8929)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e4 (4334)3.9e4 (3692)7.0e4 (2e4)1.6e5 (1e5)3.9e5 (3e5)6.5e6 (7e6)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.0e5 (5e4)8.9e5 (9e4)1.3e6 (1e5)1.6e6 (1e5)2.0e6 (1e5)2.8e6 (2e5)3.5e6 (2e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2.3e5 (3e4)6.1e5 (6e4)9.5e5 (7e4)1.3e6 (6e4)1.7e6 (5e4)2.4e6 (9e4)3.2e6 (1e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.6e5 (1e5)5.8e5 (8e4)8.8e5 (1e5)1.3e6 (1e5)1.6e6 (2e5)2.3e6 (3e5)5.5e6 (8e6)3/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.5e5 (3e4)4.0e5 (2e4)5.3e5 (2e4)6.7e5 (4e4)8.1e5 (5e4)1.1e6 (5e4)2.5e6 (7e4)8/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.2e5 (2e5)9.4e5 (3e5)1.4e6 (5e5)1.9e6 (6e5)2.6e6 (1e6)4.0e6 (2e6)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e4 (3210)3.8e4 (5136)5.1e4 (6099)★26.9e4 (1e4)★21.3e5 (5e4)★21.5e6 (1e6)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f12, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (2e4)2.8e5 (1e5)9.6e5 (2e5)1.3e6 (4e5)1.9e6 (3e5)2.6e6 (4e5)4.8e6 (3e6)10/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8669 (5296)2.9e4 (4976)4.3e4 (9951)8.2e4 (3e4)1.3e5 (8e4)1.4e7 (2e7)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 5.5e4 (3e4)6.2e5 (9e4)4.9e7 (7e7)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6.2e4 (4e4)2.1e5 (1e5)7.8e5 (4e5)1.3e6 (5e5)1.7e6 (6e5)2.4e6 (5e5)3.8e6 (1e6)12/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4.6e4 (3e4)2.7e5 (1e5)8.4e5 (4e5)1.1e6 (4e5)1.5e6 (5e5)2.0e6 (5e5)2.1e7 (2e7)2/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4.3e4 (3e4)1.3e6 (6e4)4.8e7 (5e7)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5.0e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (4e4)2.8e5 (1e5)3.5e5 (1e5)2.9e6 (8e6)2.2e8 (3e8)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8.3e4 (5e4)3.6e6 (8e6)1.0e8 (1e8)2.2e8 (2e8)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.9e4 (4e4)2.0e5 (1e5)3.6e5 (9e4)6.4e5 (3e5)9.1e5 (5e5)1.3e6 (6e5)1.6e6 (6e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 7941 (2408)2.7e4 (7222)4.1e4 (9470)8.8e4 (5e4)1.8e5 (2e5)2.0e7 (3e7)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4.6e7 (5e7)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 2e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.1e7 (3e7)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.5e7 (4e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.1e7 (2e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f13, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (454)6.6e4 (5e4)3.1e7 (4e7)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 7235 (642)2.0e4 (2e4)9.7e6 (2e7)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (718)2.0e7 (2e7)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (480)2.6e6 (8e6)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (522)4.4e7 (6e7)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (462)1.8e7 (2e7)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (548)1.0e5 (1e5)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (348)4.9e4 (4e4)3.2e7 (4e7)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (638)1.6e5 (2e5)1.1e8 (1e8)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6914 (963)1.9e4 (2408)2.2e5 (3e5)★24.2e5 (5e5)6.8e7 (5e7)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (686)1.8e5 (2e5)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.0e5 (3e4)2.3e6 (2e6)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.8e4 (2332)1.7e6 (2e6)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.0e5 (1e4)3.4e5 (4e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.4e4 (2867)1.3e7 (1e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (1e4)2.1e7 (3e7)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f14, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 4373 (315)9950 (562)1.4e4 (586)2.3e4 (656)5.1e4 (1522)3.8e5 (9189)1.6e6 (4e4)15/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1885 (321)4410 (642)6080 (642)8476 (802)1.5e4 (1124)1.5e5 (8186)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1889 (218)6027 (518)9081 (471)1.4e4 (592)2.5e4 (1084)2.3e5 (2e4)6.0e6 (4e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1736 (245)5243 (336)7780 (386)1.1e4 (411)2.1e4 (448)1.6e5 (5708)2.4e6 (1e5)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1765 (188)5806 (224)9023 (340)1.4e4 (340)2.7e4 (975)2.5e5 (1e4)6.0e6 (5e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1927 (284)5756 (381)8454 (384)1.3e4 (579)2.5e4 (866)2.5e5 (1e4)3.9e6 (2e5)0/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1872 (108)6010 (331)9025 (486)1.4e4 (732)3.0e4 (1637)5.8e5 (1e5)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3908 (244)9216 (450)1.4e4 (392)2.2e4 (829)4.5e4 (1308)5.1e5 (1e5)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1994 (214)5924 (259)8833 (354)1.4e4 (544)2.9e4 (1750)2.7e5 (4e4)3.1e6 (5e5)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1907 (321)4325 (482)5930 (963)8412 (802)1.5e4 (802)8.0e4 (1124)★42e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1970 (266)5729 (486)8421 (450)1.4e4 (420)3.2e4 (1372)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1360 (130)1.9e4 (6886)3.6e4 (4836)7.8e4 (7854)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 917 (232)9871 (2927)1.7e4 (3195)2.7e4 (3200)7.3e4 (1e4)1.5e7 (1e7)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 917 (232)4.0e4 (3774)9.1e4 (5920)1.5e5 (7146)2.7e5 (3e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 641 (140)6885 (1162)1.5e4 (1318)2.9e4 (2599)8.0e4 (1e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 641 (140)2.9e4 (3032)7.5e4 (3832)1.5e5 (5242)3.2e5 (4e4)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f15, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f16, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 6.0e5 (8e5)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.1e8 (2e8)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.0e5 (5e5)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f17, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9230 (910)2.2e8 (2e8)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3.2e7 (3e7)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.1e6 (8e6)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (1e7)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e7 (3e7)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 7699 (5084)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8586 (1483)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.3e4 (3e4)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6.0e5 (1e6)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.5e5 (1e4)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.8e5 (3e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 8.7e5 (2e6)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.6e5 (1e5)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f18, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e4 (3364)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.7e4 (5112)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f19, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e5 (1e5)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2623 (458)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2295 (174)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2674 (606)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2738 (632)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.6e4 (8900)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.2e5 (1e5)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (6860)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.6e4 (9182)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.3e4 (1e4)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)2.0e5 (3e4)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3.8e5 (4e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)2.1e5 (1e4)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3.1e5 (3e4)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)6e60/15

Δ fopt
f20, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 9586 (817)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2527 (160)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3903 (196)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3658 (254)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3574 (207)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3829 (261)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3814 (325)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 8717 (818)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3803 (188)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2549 (0)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3711 (250)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3.5e4 (3e4)1.6e6 (2e6)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2400 (10)1.9e4 (20)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.9e4 (8)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2766 (322)2.5e5 (3448)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.7e4 (3212)9.1e5 (2e6)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f21, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1.4e4 (1834)2.7e6 (5e6)8.3e6 (1e7)8.3e6 (9e6)8.3e6 (8e6)8.3e6 (1e7)8.3e6 (8e6)13/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3747 (1124)3.9e5 (8e5)2.7e6 (5e6)2.7e6 (5e6)2.7e6 (5e6)2.7e6 (5e6)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4.0e6 (8e6)2.2e8 (2e8)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4.0e6 (8e6)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.8e6 (8e6)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 8.0e6 (1e7)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 5239 (802)2.7e6 (4e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.7e6 (7e6)5.7e6 (7e6)14/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.3e4 (6e4)2.7e6 (3e6)6.9e6 (9e6)6.9e6 (1e7)6.9e6 (9e6)7.0e6 (1e7)7.0e6 (9e6)12/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e4 (2e4)6.6e5 (1e6)5.8e6 (8e6)5.8e6 (1e7)5.8e6 (8e6)5.8e6 (1e7)5.8e6 (8e6)13/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 7065 (1e4)9.8e5 (5e5)3.0e6 (5e6)3.0e6 (5e6)3.0e6 (5e6)3.0e6 (5e6)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.2e4 (2e4)2.0e6 (5e6)8.9e6 (9e6)8.9e6 (1e7)8.9e6 (1e7)8.9e6 (9e6)8.9e6 (2e7)11/15
BSrr Tanabe 1723 (450)★29.7e5 (1e6)9.9e5 (1e6)1.0e6 (1e6)1.1e6 (1e6)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4800 (1634)2.8e6 (4e6)2.8e6 (3e6)2.8e6 (4e6)2.8e6 (6e6)2.8e6 (5e6)2.8e6 (4e6)8/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.5e4 (6548)2.8e6 (4e6)2.9e6 (6e6)2.9e6 (3e6)2.9e6 (5e6)2.9e6 (4e6)3.0e6 (4e6)8/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4289 (908)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (2e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (3e6)1.6e6 (5e6)10/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 9626 (4623)1.6e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (2e6)1.7e6 (3e6)1.7e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (3e6)1.8e6 (3e6)10/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f22, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 7.3e5 (4e5)1.8e7 (2e7)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (2e5)1.5e7 (2e7)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (2e7)4.4e7 (6e7)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.1e7 (1e7)6.4e7 (6e7)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (2e7)4.4e7 (5e7)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.4e7 (2e7)3.2e7 (5e7)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.9e6 (5e6)1.5e7 (2e7)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.4e6 (8e6)1.8e7 (3e7)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.6e5 (7e5)1.4e7 (2e7)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.7e5 (5e5)1.4e7 (2e7)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e6 (3e6)1.4e7 (2e7)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.1e5 (2e5)7.0e5 (6e5)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.1e6 (3e6)6.4e6 (1e7)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.2e6 (4e6)6.5e6 (1e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1.6e6 (2e6)6.4e6 (6e6)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.6e6 (3e6)6.4e6 (7e6)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Δ fopt
f23, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)1.5e5 (2e4)1.8e5 (2e4)2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1 (0)2234 (326)2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1 (0)1933 (236)2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)1875 (304)2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)1946 (305)2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)6608 (2900)2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)1.3e5 (2e4)2.0e5 (2e4)2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)7508 (4578)2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)6932 (3254)2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1 (0)3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)2.1e7 (3e7)3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)2.9e6 (6e6)3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)2.1e7 (2e7)3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)2.1e7 (2e7)3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)6e60/15

Δ fopt
f24, 320-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 6e60/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 640 | First dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)3250 (0)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 6897 (242)1.1e4 (265)1.5e4 (324)1.9e4 (378)2.3e4 (432)3.1e4 (372)3.9e4 (444)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6231 (138)9830 (164)1.3e4 (275)1.7e4 (432)2.1e4 (564)2.8e4 (498)3.5e4 (584)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 6376 (218)1.0e4 (336)1.4e4 (378)1.8e4 (460)2.1e4 (469)2.9e4 (540)3.7e4 (566)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 6221 (184)1.0e4 (240)1.4e4 (286)1.7e4 (323)2.1e4 (288)2.9e4 (292)3.6e4 (408)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 6213 (405)1.0e4 (314)1.4e4 (390)1.8e4 (486)2.1e4 (411)2.9e4 (468)3.7e4 (614)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (348)1.6e4 (352)2.2e4 (310)2.8e4 (370)3.4e4 (424)4.6e4 (503)5.7e4 (577)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 6132 (299)9849 (309)1.4e4 (520)1.8e4 (642)2.1e4 (548)2.9e4 (654)3.7e4 (731)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)2566 (0)3207 (0)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 6003 (221)9692 (218)1.3e4 (460)1.7e4 (402)2.1e4 (448)2.8e4 (586)3.6e4 (610)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 2810 (44)3177 (12)3690 (80)3815 (22)3823 (24)3826 (20)3830 (18)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 5177 (65)8252 (22)1.3e4 (34)1.7e4 (54)2.0e4 (29)2.9e4 (90)3.7e4 (74)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.0e4 (81)5.8e4 (127)8.4e4 (106)1.1e5 (94)1.4e5 (106)1.9e5 (112)2.4e5 (1229)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4883 (124)1.2e4 (58)1.9e4 (72)2.4e4 (190)3.0e4 (44)4.2e4 (197)5.6e4 (67)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.0e4 (1743)6.0e4 (1432)9.9e4 (1728)1.5e5 (1100)1.8e5 (404)2.7e5 (1861)3.5e5 (1762)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f2, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (6e4)1.7e6 (9e4)2.3e6 (8e4)3.0e6 (2e5)3.7e6 (2e5)5.2e6 (4e5)6.6e6 (6e5)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.2e6 (2e5)4.0e6 (4e5)6.1e6 (6e5)8.0e6 (9e5)9.9e6 (1e6)1.4e7 (1e6)1.9e7 (2e6)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.8e6 (1e5)2.8e6 (9e4)3.8e6 (2e5)4.8e6 (3e5)5.8e6 (4e5)7.6e6 (4e5)9.6e6 (5e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (9e4)3.0e6 (9e4)4.0e6 (2e5)5.0e6 (3e5)6.1e6 (2e5)8.2e6 (5e5)1.0e7 (8e5)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.2e6 (1e5)3.1e6 (1e5)3.9e6 (1e5)4.9e6 (2e5)5.9e6 (2e5)7.8e6 (2e5)9.8e6 (2e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.6e5 (2e4)4.2e5 (2e4)4.7e5 (2e4)5.1e5 (2e4)5.4e5 (3e4)5.8e5 (4e4)6.1e5 (4e4)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.2e5 (1e4)3.5e5 (8810)3.7e5 (2e4)3.9e5 (1e4)4.0e5 (1e4)4.1e5 (1e4)4.3e5 (1e4)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e5 (1e5)3.4e5 (2e5)4.2e5 (3e5)5.0e5 (4e5)5.7e5 (5e5)6.9e5 (6e5)7.9e5 (7e5)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6.2e5 (2e4)8.8e5 (2e4)1.1e6 (3e4)1.4e6 (2e4)1.6e6 (3e4)2.0e6 (5e4)2.3e6 (8e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3.8e5 (2e4)4.4e5 (2e4)4.8e5 (2e4)4.9e5 (2e4)5.1e5 (2e4)5.2e5 (2e4)5.3e5 (2e4)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 7904 (310)★48708 (329)★49577 (626)★41.1e4 (340)★41.2e4 (350)★41.4e4 (336)★42.1e4 (132)★40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.5e4 (28)2.8e4 (1090)3.2e4 (38)3.7e4 (50)4.0e4 (50)4.9e4 (44)5.8e4 (1318)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.6e5 (142)1.8e5 (1104)2.1e5 (146)2.3e5 (126)2.6e5 (126)3.1e5 (3814)3.8e5 (7898)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3.6e4 (1234)4.2e4 (34)4.9e4 (69)5.5e4 (1207)6.0e4 (40)7.2e4 (1776)8.6e4 (55)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.2e5 (1948)2.7e5 (2576)3.1e5 (1927)3.5e5 (5108)3.9e5 (3160)4.7e5 (2653)5.5e5 (2628)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f3, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.7e4 (648)★44.1e4 (1587)★45.2e4 (3198)★46.2e4 (3e4)★46.3e4 (3e4)★46.4e4 (3e4)★47.4e4 (3e4)★414/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.1e5 (5222)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (3486)7.8e5 (2e4)8.5e5 (1e4)9.5e5 (3e5)9.9e5 (3e5)1.1e6 (2e5)1.1e6 (2e5)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f4, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 3.8e4 (1185)★47.5e4 (4518)★48.8e4 (6067)★49.4e4 (4854)★41.1e5 (5e4)★41.4e5 (6e4)★47e5★40/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.4e5 (5523)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 7.8e5 (7030)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f5, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3848 (0)4489 (0)4532 (0)4617 (320)4660 (320)4660 (320)4660 (320)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 4960 (620)6085 (993)6484 (1312)6563 (1376)6583 (1403)6587 (1411)6587 (1411)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3770 (320)4559 (566)4780 (682)4866 (686)4885 (680)4886 (690)4886 (690)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4164 (532)5108 (642)5351 (683)5406 (689)5417 (689)5417 (689)5417 (689)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 4108 (254)4950 (553)5226 (594)5276 (592)5285 (608)5293 (594)5293 (594)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4478 (320)5495 (502)5735 (516)5795 (546)5801 (543)5806 (543)5806 (543)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 4819 (272)5726 (411)5948 (428)6043 (448)6060 (448)6073 (448)6073 (448)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4596 (311)5775 (484)6103 (437)6190 (442)6212 (426)6213 (426)6213 (426)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3848 (0)4489 (0)4489 (0)4574 (320)4660 (320)4660 (320)4660 (320)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4707 (372)5936 (599)6265 (721)6365 (686)6392 (715)6392 (715)6392 (715)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 1912 (2)1920 (1)1920 (1)1920 (1)1920 (1)1920 (1)1920 (1)15/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)15/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)962 (12)15/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 3133 (29)3195 (23)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)15/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3133 (29)3195 (23)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)3198 (22)15/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f6, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3.9e5 (6e4)7.0e5 (1e5)1.0e6 (1e5)1.3e6 (2e5)1.6e6 (2e5)2.2e6 (2e5)3.3e6 (1e6)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (4e4)5.8e5 (5e4)7.9e5 (7e4)1.0e6 (9e4)1.2e6 (8e4)1.7e6 (8e4)2.1e6 (1e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 6.5e5 (2e4)1.0e6 (3e4)1.4e6 (3e4)1.7e6 (3e4)2.1e6 (4e4)2.9e6 (5e4)3.6e6 (7e4)12/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4.8e5 (3e4)8.7e5 (6e4)1.4e6 (1e5)2.1e6 (2e5)3.5e6 (6e5)2.6e7 (2e7)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.7e5 (2e4)5.5e5 (3e4)7.3e5 (4e4)9.3e5 (6e4)1.2e6 (8e4)1.6e6 (1e5)2.2e6 (2e5)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3.8e5 (4e4)6.3e5 (6e4)9.0e5 (7e4)1.2e6 (7e4)1.4e6 (7e4)1.9e6 (6e4)2.4e6 (8e4)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 3.4e5 (7e4)7.1e5 (2e5)1.3e6 (5e5)2.0e6 (7e5)2.9e6 (1e6)5.2e6 (3e6)1.1e7 (1e7)6/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6.5e5 (9e4)1.2e6 (2e5)2.1e6 (7e5)3.2e6 (1e6)4.3e6 (2e6)8.4e6 (9e6)4.7e7 (3e7)1/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6.2e5 (2e5)1.5e6 (4e5)2.9e6 (7e5)5.3e6 (1e6)3.1e7 (4e7)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.2e6 (2e5)2.3e6 (4e5)3.8e6 (4e5)5.8e6 (9e5)3.2e7 (3e7)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f7, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 7e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f8, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8.1e5 (6e5)1.1e6 (9e5)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)1.4e6 (2e6)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.2e6 (1e6)3.0e6 (2e6)2.5e7 (3e7)2.5e7 (3e7)2.5e7 (3e7)2.5e7 (7e7)2.5e7 (3e7)9/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 5.9e6 (2e6)9.2e6 (4e6)1.4e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)1.5e7 (2e7)13/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 7.8e6 (6e6)1.1e7 (7e6)3.3e7 (3e7)3.3e7 (3e7)3.3e7 (3e7)3.3e7 (4e7)3.3e7 (4e7)9/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.9e6 (2e6)4.1e6 (2e6)4.2e6 (3e6)4.2e6 (3e6)4.2e6 (3e6)4.2e6 (3e6)4.3e6 (3e6)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e6 (6e5)2.1e6 (7e5)3.4e6 (2e6)3.4e6 (2e6)3.4e6 (2e6)3.4e6 (2e6)3.5e6 (2e6)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.8e6 (2e6)7.7e6 (2e6)9.1e6 (6e6)9.2e6 (6e6)9.2e6 (6e6)9.2e6 (6e6)9.3e6 (6e6)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.8e6 (6e5)2.3e6 (8e5)2.4e6 (1e6)2.4e6 (1e6)2.4e6 (1e6)2.5e6 (1e6)2.5e6 (1e6)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 8.1e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (4e5)1.5e6 (1e6)1.5e6 (1e6)1.5e6 (1e6)1.5e6 (1e6)1.5e6 (1e6)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 5.6e6 (1e6)6.4e6 (8e5)8.7e6 (3e6)8.7e6 (3e6)8.8e6 (3e6)8.8e6 (3e6)8.8e6 (3e6)15/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1.0e7 (7e6)3.1e7 (3e7)3.1e7 (4e7)3.1e7 (3e7)9.5e7 (1e8)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 7.9e6 (7e6)1.4e7 (1e7)2.2e7 (2e7)2.3e7 (2e7)4.6e7 (8e7)9.6e7 (9e7)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.4e6 (1e6)3.6e6 (1e6)6.6e6 (7e6)6.7e6 (5e6)7.4e6 (7e6)1.8e7 (2e7)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.4e6 (2e6)5.9e6 (4e6)2.3e7 (2e7)3.1e7 (3e7)9.6e7 (9e7)9.6e7 (8e7)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f9, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 6.9e5 (3e5)9.2e5 (5e5)1.2e6 (1e6)1.2e6 (1e6)1.2e6 (1e6)1.3e6 (1e6)1.3e6 (1e6)15/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.7e6 (2e6)3.9e6 (2e6)1.2e7 (2e7)1.2e7 (2e7)1.2e7 (2e7)1.2e7 (2e7)1.2e7 (2e7)12/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7.7e6 (4e6)1.1e7 (6e6)2.7e7 (3e7)2.7e7 (2e7)2.7e7 (3e7)2.7e7 (4e7)2.7e7 (3e7)10/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 5.9e6 (4e6)8.8e6 (5e6)3.7e7 (4e7)3.7e7 (4e7)3.7e7 (3e7)3.7e7 (4e7)3.7e7 (6e7)8/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.9e6 (1e6)4.2e6 (2e6)1.6e7 (2e7)1.6e7 (3e7)1.6e7 (2e7)1.6e7 (3e7)1.6e7 (2e7)11/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.3e6 (1e6)4.4e6 (2e6)6.2e6 (3e6)6.3e6 (3e6)6.3e6 (3e6)6.3e6 (3e6)6.4e6 (3e6)15/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 6.8e6 (2e6)9.3e6 (3e6)1.3e7 (6e6)1.3e7 (6e6)1.3e7 (6e6)1.3e7 (6e6)1.3e7 (6e6)15/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e6 (9e5)3.6e6 (1e6)5.6e6 (4e6)5.6e6 (4e6)5.6e6 (4e6)5.7e6 (4e6)5.7e6 (4e6)15/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 7.0e5 (3e5)9.5e5 (4e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.2e6 (7e5)1.3e6 (7e5)15/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4.3e7 (5e7)1.1e8 (8e7)1.5e8 (2e8)1.5e8 (2e8)2.3e8 (2e8)2.3e8 (3e8)4.6e8 (4e8)1/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f10, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e6 (5e4)1.7e6 (1e5)2.3e6 (1e5)3.0e6 (1e5)3.6e6 (2e5)5.1e6 (5e5)2.1e8 (2e8)0/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (2e5)4.0e6 (3e5)6.0e6 (6e5)8.0e6 (6e5)9.9e6 (7e5)1.4e7 (8e5)1.9e7 (1e6)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.8e6 (1e5)2.8e6 (1e5)3.8e6 (2e5)4.7e6 (2e5)5.7e6 (2e5)7.6e6 (3e5)9.6e6 (5e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.0e6 (1e5)3.0e6 (2e5)3.9e6 (2e5)5.0e6 (2e5)6.0e6 (2e5)8.2e6 (3e5)1.0e7 (1e6)15/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.2e6 (2e5)3.2e6 (2e5)4.1e6 (2e5)5.1e6 (2e5)6.0e6 (3e5)7.9e6 (3e5)9.8e6 (3e5)15/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.0e7 (5e6)1.1e8 (1e8)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.9e6 (2e6)9.3e6 (3e6)1.8e7 (1e7)2.8e7 (3e7)5.9e7 (7e7)2.4e8 (1e8)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 6.1e5 (3e4)★48.8e5 (2e4)1.1e6 (3e4)1.4e6 (4e4)1.6e6 (3e4)2.0e6 (6e4)4.5e8 (4e8)0/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f11, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5.4e4 (8654)9.6e4 (2e4)2.0e5 (1e5)3.6e5 (1e5)9.1e5 (4e5)1.4e7 (2e7)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.0e6 (9e4)1.7e6 (1e5)2.4e6 (2e5)3.2e6 (2e5)3.8e6 (1e5)5.3e6 (2e5)6.7e6 (3e5)15/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 7.7e5 (6e4)1.6e6 (6e4)2.4e6 (1e5)3.2e6 (1e5)4.0e6 (1e5)5.7e6 (2e5)7.3e6 (2e5)15/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 4.6e5 (2e5)9.1e5 (4e5)1.3e6 (5e5)1.6e6 (7e5)2.0e6 (9e5)2.7e6 (1e6)1.1e7 (2e7)2/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3.4e5 (3e4)5.3e5 (3e4)6.9e5 (6e4)8.8e5 (9e4)1.1e6 (7e4)1.4e6 (1e5)6.7e6 (2e7)2/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (2e6)3.9e6 (3e6)6.9e6 (6e6)1.0e7 (6e6)1.4e7 (1e7)4.7e7 (5e7)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 5.4e4 (1e4)8.0e4 (1e4)1.1e5 (2e4)★41.4e5 (2e4)★42.0e5 (1e5)★41.5e6 (1e6)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f12, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (9936)5.8e4 (1e4)9.5e4 (4e4)1.7e5 (6e4)2.5e5 (9e4)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (3e4)3.0e5 (5e4)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.4e5 (1e5)6.2e5 (3e5)5.9e6 (4e6)1.3e7 (4e6)1.6e7 (6e6)2.3e7 (6e6)2.8e7 (2e7)9/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.3e5 (5e4)1.0e6 (8e5)2.6e6 (1e6)3.5e6 (1e6)4.0e6 (1e6)5.2e6 (1e6)7.0e7 (1e8)1/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1.1e5 (3e4)3.7e5 (2e5)2.2e8 (2e8)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 9.0e4 (2e4)2.3e5 (1e5)6.0e5 (1e5)8.2e5 (2e5)3.4e6 (3e5)4.5e8 (5e8)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.8e5 (6e4)3.7e7 (6e7)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.5e5 (8e4)4.5e5 (4e5)9.5e5 (3e5)1.8e6 (8e5)2.6e6 (1e6)4.1e6 (3e6)5.1e6 (3e6)13/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.9e4 (1e4)5.8e4 (1e4)8.9e4 (2e4)1.8e5 (6e4)2.3e5 (4e4)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.3e8 (2e8)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 5e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 9.0e7 (1e8)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f13, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1923)2.6e4 (4166)7.7e7 (8e7)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2.3e4 (315)2.3e6 (8e4)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.9e4 (670)3.4e4 (2414)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (284)8.0e6 (2e7)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (394)3.6e4 (2196)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (760)5.7e4 (5585)4.5e8 (5e8)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3.0e4 (248)4.7e4 (1646)1.4e8 (1e8)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (620)5.6e4 (7e4)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (1282)2.8e4 (3526)7.0e5 (7e5)1.5e6 (3e6)1.5e8 (1e8)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.1e4 (754)7.0e4 (6e4)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.5e5 (2e4)1.0e6 (7e5)6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6.2e4 (5170)1.1e5 (1e4)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 4.4e5 (2e4)7.6e5 (4e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.7e4 (3892)4.4e6 (6e6)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.7e5 (2e4)1.3e7 (2e7)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f14, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3720 (641)9959 (1923)1.4e4 (2564)1.9e4 (2244)3.0e4 (2244)2.6e5 (2e4)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 2786 (146)1.1e4 (340)1.7e4 (575)2.5e4 (820)4.3e4 (925)3.5e5 (2e4)1.2e7 (4e5)0/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 2478 (230)9209 (317)1.4e4 (419)2.1e4 (689)3.6e4 (977)2.5e5 (8754)3.6e6 (2e5)14/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2564 (199)9860 (366)1.6e4 (290)2.4e4 (650)4.3e4 (883)3.7e5 (1e4)9.6e6 (3e5)0/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2699 (170)1.0e4 (416)1.5e4 (461)2.2e4 (721)4.2e4 (1244)3.9e5 (1e4)8.6e6 (2e5)2/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2638 (230)1.0e4 (544)1.6e4 (470)2.4e4 (516)4.7e4 (1028)8.9e5 (2e5)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 7156 (366)1.8e4 (546)2.7e4 (910)4.1e4 (1064)7.8e4 (1569)7.7e5 (1e5)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2738 (416)1.0e4 (672)1.6e4 (656)2.5e4 (690)5.2e4 (2798)4.8e5 (2e5)8.9e6 (5e6)0/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3592 (320)1.0e4 (962)1.4e4 (1923)1.9e4 (1602)3.0e4 (1923)1.7e5 (5128)★43e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2733 (194)1.0e4 (582)1.5e4 (670)2.3e4 (724)5.2e4 (1082)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 2416 (60)2.2e4 (1e4)6.7e4 (1e4)1.2e5 (2e4)7.8e5 (4e5)6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1033 (102)1.5e4 (2348)2.9e4 (2548)5.5e4 (3008)1.2e5 (1e4)3.2e7 (3e7)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1033 (102)7.1e4 (7300)1.9e5 (6112)3.1e5 (2e4)5.5e5 (4e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 935 (54)1.3e4 (1372)3.3e4 (2657)6.3e4 (4406)1.5e5 (1e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 935 (54)5.1e4 (6228)1.6e5 (1e4)3.0e5 (2e4)6.4e5 (6e4)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f15, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f16, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e8 (2e8)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 7e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f17, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 4.7e8 (5e8)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e8 (4e8)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.9e4 (3306)★23e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.8e7 (4e7)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.2e7 (3e7)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6.0e4 (2e4)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1.9e5 (8e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 7.3e5 (6e5)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1.4e6 (3e6)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f18, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.1e6 (2e6)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f19, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.3e4 (5127)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6428 (3083)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (1e4)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (1e4)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (7273)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 5.6e5 (1e5)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1.8e4 (7367)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1.7e4 (5234)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1.9e4 (3e4)7e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)3.5e5 (2e4)★46e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)9.2e5 (8e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)4.3e5 (2e4)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)1 (0)6.4e5 (4e4)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1 (0)1e70/15

Δ fopt
f20, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 5130 (0)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 7614 (347)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 6950 (409)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 7058 (352)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 7292 (359)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 7367 (512)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.0e4 (1374)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 7408 (354)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 5130 (0)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 7251 (452)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6.3e4 (5e4)6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4800 (12)★46.0e4 (30)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 3.5e4 (12)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6652 (1319)4.8e4 (5793)★46e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 3.8e4 (3178)2.5e5 (4e4)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f21, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 8720 (6090)1.8e7 (2e7)4.4e7 (4e7)4.4e7 (7e7)4.4e7 (6e7)4.4e7 (4e7)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 8.0e6 (2e7)4.5e8 (6e8)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1.2e7 (2e7)4.5e8 (4e8)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (2863)4.5e8 (4e8)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.3e6 (2078)4.5e8 (3e8)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 4.8e4 (4e4)3.0e7 (4e7)1.4e8 (1e8)1.4e8 (2e8)1.4e8 (3e8)1.4e8 (1e8)1.4e8 (1e8)3/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.4e4 (3138)2.7e7 (7e7)2.2e8 (3e8)2.2e8 (2e8)2.2e8 (2e8)2.2e8 (2e8)2.2e8 (3e8)2/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 4.0e4 (4e4)1.9e7 (2e7)6.4e7 (9e7)6.4e7 (6e7)6.4e7 (1e8)6.4e7 (8e7)6.4e7 (6e7)6/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1.1e4 (2e4)1.3e7 (2e7)4.0e7 (6e7)4.0e7 (5e7)4.0e7 (4e7)7.9e7 (9e7)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 4.9e4 (8e4)1.4e7 (2e7)7.5e7 (6e7)7.5e7 (1e8)7.5e7 (1e8)7.5e7 (6e7)7.5e7 (7e7)5/15
BSrr Tanabe 4252 (2313)2.2e6 (1e6)2.9e6 (2e6)3.0e6 (4e6)4.6e6 (6e6)6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 4.7e5 (4553)7.3e6 (1e7)7.3e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (1e7)7/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 5.1e5 (5e4)7.4e6 (1e7)7.5e6 (1e7)7.5e6 (1e7)7.5e6 (2e7)7.6e6 (1e7)7.7e6 (1e7)7/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 4.7e5 (5762)7.3e6 (8e6)7.3e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (8e6)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (1e7)7.4e6 (6e6)7/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 4.8e5 (3e4)7.4e6 (1e7)7.5e6 (6e6)7.5e6 (1e7)7.6e6 (1e7)7.7e6 (8e6)7.8e6 (1e7)7/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f22, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 2.4e6 (3e5)3.7e7 (5e7)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1.6e7 (3e7)8.8e7 (2e8)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3.7e7 (3e7)8.8e7 (1e8)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1.2e7 (2e7)6.4e7 (6e7)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 2.1e7 (3e7)6.4e7 (7e7)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3.9e6 (1e7)3.8e7 (6e7)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.6e6 (9e5)3.7e7 (6e7)3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 2.8e6 (3e6)3.7e7 (4e7)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 2.5e6 (1e6)3.7e7 (5e7)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 2.9e6 (2e6)3.7e7 (3e7)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 2.3e5 (3e5)1.0e6 (1e6)6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 2.3e6 (3e6)1.3e7 (1e7)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 2.4e6 (3e6)1.3e7 (2e7)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 2.3e6 (3e6)1.3e7 (2e7)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 2.3e6 (5e6)1.3e7 (3e7)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Δ fopt
f23, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 1 (0)1488 (78)3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 1 (0)1522 (120)3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)1328 (100)3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 1 (0)1437 (88)3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)5060 (1992)3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)2.1e5 (4e4)2.9e5 (4e4)★43e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)4354 (1320)3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 1 (0)6.0e7 (8e7)3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 1 (0)4760 (1545)3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 1 (0)5884 (2194)7e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1.3e4 (3142)6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 1 (0)4.1e4 (6354)6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 1 (0)1.2e4 (1977)6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 1 (0)3.3e4 (6573)6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1 (0)1e70/15

Δ fopt
f24, 640-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-7
 
#succ
 
LBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA14 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
LMCMA17 Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R10ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
R2ES Varelas largescale 3e70/15
V2D-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
VkD-CMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
m2DLBFGS Varelas largescale 3e70/15
sepCMA Varelas largescale 3e70/15
BSrr Tanabe 6e50/15
HJ-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
HJ-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-5 Tanabe 6e60/15
MTSLS1-9 Tanabe 6e60/15
RANDOMSEARCH Brockhoff.zip 1e70/15

Expected runtime (ERT) to reach given targets, measured in number of f-evaluations, in different dimensions. For each function, the ERT  and, in braces as dispersion measure, the half difference between 10 and 90%-tile of (bootstrapped) runtimes is shown for the different target ∆f-values as shown in the top row. #succ is the number of trials that reached the last target fopt+ 10−8. The median number of conducted function evaluations is additionally given in italics, if the target in the last column was never reached. The best entry is marked by a star when the largest p-value of pairwise rank-sum tests with the other algorithms either obeys 0.01 < p ≤ 0.05 or 10−k−1 < p ≤ 10−k when the star is followed by the number k, with Bonferroni correction by the number of functions (24). Best results are printed in bold.