Overview page

Table showing the aRT in number of function evaluations divided by the best aRT measured during BBOB-2009

Last dimension | Dimension = 2 | Next dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 2-D
1e0
1
1e-1
32
1e-2
224
1e-3
1567
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.1 (2)5.1 (3)4.3 (1.0)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.2 (1)2.1 (0.7)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.0 (2)7.8 (6)12 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.2 (2)6.7 (4)7.7 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.0 (2)3.1 (1)2.4 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.9 (1)1073 (1786)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.5 (3)2.7 (0.8)3.8 (1)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.6 (3)2.1 (0.5)3.1 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.3 (0.8)1.6 (0.6)3.1 (0.3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2.6 (2)3.1 (2)3.1 (0.6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.8 (1)2.2 (1)2.0 (0.2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.1 (2)3.2 (0.7)3.3 (0.9)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)1.6 (1)1.5 (0.4)6.1 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.1 (2)2.6 (0.6)3.4 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.3 (2)2.4 (0.4)2.8 (0.9)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.6 (3)4.0 (0.9)20750/10

Δ HVref
f2, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
38
1e-2
200
1e-3
780
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (3)3.6 (4)7.7 (8)8.8 (4)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (6)3.5 (4)2.5 (2)66 (193)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)3.9 (7)16 (23)32 (26)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (11)4.3 (5)10 (11)17 (10)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (8)4.7 (5)4.6 (3)4.2 (2)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)1.8 (1)1.3 (0.7)599 (449)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (3)4.7 (5)3.2 (1)2.1 (1)6/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)3.0 (5)2.2 (1)2.0 (1)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (6)2.9 (4)1.9 (1)2.7 (3)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (6)4.8 (5)5.0 (6)5.9 (2)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (2)2.5 (3)2.9 (3)2.8 (1)4/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)4.9 (7)31 (42)33 (40)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.7 (3)1.4 (0.8)1.4 (0.8)4.3 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (1)3.7 (4)2.9 (1)2.8 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (5)3.8 (4)2.8 (1)2.5 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (35)10 (12)5.7 (2)8.5 (8)0/10

Δ HVref
f3, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
62
1e-2
317
1e-3
2690
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)16 (36)8.9 (13)4.0 (3)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (12)3.3 (6)2.5 (2)669 (762)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 31 (76)61 (150)41 (87)18 (23)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)30 (72)19 (34)8.3 (9)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 28 (68)7.7 (16)4.8 (6)2.1 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)1.7 (2)272 (631)669 (948)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)3.4 (6)3.0 (3)4.0 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (11)3.3 (5)76 (164)53 (56)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)1.8 (2)1.7 (1)6.3 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (17)7.1 (15)4.7 (7)2.2 (1)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (11)3.3 (6)2.8 (3)1.5 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (43)5.2 (10)24 (48)10 (8)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.1 (5)1.7 (2)3.4 (6)6.1 (6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (16)2.7 (5)3.3 (4)4.0 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (15)3.3 (6)3.9 (5)3.5 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (51)7.5 (11)4.3 (5)20610/10

Δ HVref
f4, 2-D
1e0
10
1e-1
52
1e-2
209
1e-3
892
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)6.8 (15)8.0 (12)7.4 (5)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)2.7 (4)2.7 (3)27 (57)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (10)14 (33)26 (52)29 (34)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.7 (14)8.3 (19)15 (28)15 (13)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (11)5.6 (11)4.9 (6)3.9 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (3)2.0 (2)1.6 (1)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.44 (0.8)3.3 (6)3.0 (2)2.6 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.54 (0.9)1.9 (3)2.3 (2)3.6 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.94 (2)1.9 (2)2.3 (1)2.6 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (5)5.5 (12)4.9 (7)5.0 (3)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.68 (1)3.5 (7)2.7 (3)2.3 (1)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.92 (1)3.4 (5)5.7 (6)17 (14)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (3)1.2 (2)1.4 (2)5.9 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (6)3.2 (5)2.9 (2)3.9 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)3.0 (4)2.7 (2)3.4 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)5.4 (11)5.9 (4)11 (15)0/10

Δ HVref
f5, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
49
1e-2
603
1e-3
4709
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.5)3.1 (3)4.5 (4)4.3 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)2.2 (2)1.4 (0.7)171 (584)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)3.2 (4)8.7 (11)13 (13)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (1)3.6 (5)7.3 (9)6.9 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (0.9)3.0 (3)2.4 (2)2.1 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)1.7 (1)775 (581)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)2.8 (3)5.1 (9)11 (14)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.5)1.9 (2)41 (90)32 (64)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)2.0 (2)39 (84)8.8 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (3)3.0 (3)2.5 (3)3.3 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)2.1 (2)1.9 (1)2.5 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)3.8 (3)3.0 (2)43 (66)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.2 (2)1.8 (1)4.6 (9)6.9 (7)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)2.6 (3)2.9 (4)6.2 (13)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (0.8)2.9 (3)2.6 (3)6.2 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (0.9)4.2 (6)2.6 (2)20740/10

Δ HVref
f6, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
38
1e-2
221
1e-3
2306
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)6.7 (12)8.4 (11)3.6 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)3.3 (5)2.5 (2)348 (195)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (2)9.1 (17)23 (40)14 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)7.8 (15)16 (23)6.9 (6)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)4.0 (6)4.5 (4)1.8 (1.0)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)2.6 (3)389 (905)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (8)4.4 (7)3.2 (2)3.0 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.1 (11)3.6 (5)3.3 (3)25 (45)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)2.5 (3)2.2 (2)3.2 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)5.8 (10)5.7 (8)2.2 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.87 (1)2.6 (4)3.0 (3)1.3 (0.7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.0 (18)4.0 (6)4.4 (3)4.3 (4)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.1 (4)1.8 (2)2.4 (2)5.3 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)3.9 (6)3.5 (3)3.2 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)3.3 (4)3.4 (3)2.8 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (5)7.0 (14)5.8 (5)20710/10

Δ HVref
f7, 2-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
102
1e-2
1953
1e-3
10949
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)5.8 (7)3.4 (3)44 (50)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (2)2.9 (3)45 (103)165 (178)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)8.7 (10)7.5 (7)8.7 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)14 (22)5.1 (4)23 (30)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)5.4 (6)13 (26)165 (452)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (5)1.3 (1)922 (819)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (3)3.8 (4)1.8 (2)3.1 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)3.1 (2)1.5 (2)8.4 (21)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (3)1.9 (2)1.6 (2)8.2 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (3)3.5 (3)1.8 (1)4.1 (6)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)4.0 (6)14 (30)4.5 (6)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)3.9 (4)1.7 (1)5.7 (5)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.7 (4)1.3 (0.9)0.93 (0.9)8.5 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)3.1 (3)1.2 (0.9)2.3 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)2.7 (3)1.6 (2)2.3 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)6.3 (7)4.8 (7)20720/10

Δ HVref
f8, 2-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
146
1e-2
747
1e-3
3019
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)6.0 (8)5.6 (4)4.9 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)1.8 (2)1.8 (1)597 (894)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (7)7.6 (14)17 (22)20 (18)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)9.5 (17)10 (13)10 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)2.8 (3)2.9 (2)19 (34)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)1.4 (1.0)179 (134)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)2.8 (3)2.0 (2)4.1 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (4)1.9 (2)1.8 (2)7.5 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)1.4 (2)1.7 (2)3.2 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.51 (0.6)3.9 (6)3.6 (3)2.2 (0.9)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (4)2.5 (3)1.8 (1)1.4 (1)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (3)2.3 (2)2.2 (2)4.7 (4)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.5 (2)0.77 (0.7)1.6 (2)9.0 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (6)2.1 (2)1.7 (0.9)3.1 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)2.3 (2)2.1 (2)3.5 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)4.8 (5)3.2 (2)20700/10

Δ HVref
f9, 2-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
42
1e-2
161
1e-3
963
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (24)10 (16)14 (14)8.7 (4)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)4.2 (5)3.8 (2)55 (157)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (7)8.0 (8)46 (52)38 (28)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (5)10 (13)28 (30)19 (10)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 5.9 (12)7.2 (8)7.5 (6)4.2 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (6)2.5 (2)313 (932)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (5)5.5 (5)4.4 (2)2.7 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (6)4.2 (5)3.7 (2)3.6 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (7)3.6 (4)2.7 (2)2.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)5.1 (5)11 (10)5.4 (2)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (7)3.4 (3)5.4 (4)2.6 (1.0)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (3)5.5 (6)11 (13)27 (50)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.9 (4)2.0 (1)1.7 (1)4.8 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)4.1 (4)4.2 (2)4.1 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (8)4.6 (5)4.1 (3)3.8 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (20)11 (12)8.6 (4)10 (11)0/10

Δ HVref
f10, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
187
1e-2
726
1e-3
6110
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)2.4 (3)4.2 (3)1.8 (0.5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)1.1 (1.0)70 (138)295 (344)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)2.5 (3)9.4 (8)7.7 (4)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (3)2.7 (3)6.3 (5)3.9 (1)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)1.9 (2)2.6 (1)0.86 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (9)120 (268)276 (413)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)1.7 (1)2.7 (3)2.2 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)1.7 (2)5.0 (10)17 (25)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (3)1.0 (1)119 (276)23 (17)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (5)1.7 (2)2.9 (2)0.99 (0.3)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)0.92 (1.0)42 (91)5.2 (11)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)1.8 (2)3.4 (4)3.0 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.0 (5)12 (27)15 (21)3.9 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (8)1.4 (2)1.6 (0.9)1.3 (1.0)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)1.5 (1)1.5 (0.5)1.2 (0.6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)3.2 (4)2.6 (2)20660/10

Δ HVref
f11, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
30
1e-2
200
1e-3
1038
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 8.5 (20)6.1 (14)4.0 (8)3.1 (4)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.5 (13)2.4 (5)1.4 (2)22 (48)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)1.9 (3)10 (21)10 (21)9/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (8)3.6 (7)5.7 (12)5.6 (10)9/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)3.6 (8)2.6 (4)1.9 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.3 (2)0.82 (0.7)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (28)3.7 (8)2.0 (2)1.6 (0.5)9/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (36)2.7 (6)2.0 (3)2.5 (4)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (7)2.2 (4)0.99 (1)1.4 (0.4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (25)3.0 (6)3.0 (5)1.6 (2)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)3.7 (8)1.5 (2)1.7 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)3.8 (7)2.5 (3)2.5 (3)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.7 (3)2.4 (4)1.7 (2)2.8 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (7)2.0 (3)1.9 (2)1.7 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)3.4 (7)2.0 (3)1.7 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (35)5.1 (11)2.9 (4)1.7 (0.7)0/10

Δ HVref
f12, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
53
1e-2
256
1e-3
986
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)6.4 (13)7.9 (11)7.0 (8)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)3.1 (4)2.4 (2)88 (204)3/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.82 (1)18 (41)35 (72)34 (45)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)13 (27)17 (31)15 (18)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)4.4 (7)4.6 (6)3.5 (4)3/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.78 (1)1.3 (2)88 (196)305 (507)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (2)421 (946)337 (977)92 (153)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.62 (0.8)422 (1890)522 (1759)141 (203)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)2.3 (3)1.5 (1)2.3 (2)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.72 (0.9)3.4 (6)4.3 (6)3.7 (4)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)2.1 (3)2.0 (3)2.4 (3)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (2)45 (98)57 (123)49 (73)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.90 (2)43 (96)35 (39)18 (41)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (2)44 (97)35 (98)13 (18)2/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (1)44 (97)35 (59)12 (23)2/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)8.9 (14)6.5 (7)5.5 (8)1/10

Δ HVref
f13, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
37
1e-2
315
1e-3
756
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)6.3 (14)3.0 (7)4.1 (8)9/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (7)2.5 (5)1.6 (3)30 (67)7/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)12 (25)9.3 (22)20 (45)8/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (2)6.7 (15)6.8 (14)9.1 (19)9/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)4.1 (7)2.6 (5)2.5 (5)8/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)2.3 (5)71 (159)66 (132)1/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)3.9 (8)3.4 (8)35 (86)5/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)2.9 (4)159 (318)67 (199)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (8)2.4 (4)29 (73)66 (132)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (4)3.0 (6)3.1 (7)3.5 (7)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.3 (14)2.4 (4)1.5 (3)3.8 (8)8/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)6.6 (14)16 (48)7.2 (13)3/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (4)1.2 (2)10 (54)9.4 (13)5/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)4.1 (9)7.7 (17)7.1 (13)4/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (12)3.7 (7)8.1 (18)7.1 (13)4/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (16)3.7 (8)2.3 (5)1.4 (2)2/10

Δ HVref
f14, 2-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
110
1e-2
566
1e-3
3600
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.68 (1)5.2 (9)6.7 (4)3.9 (2)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (7)2.0 (3)1.8 (1)38 (70)1/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (15)5.6 (8)19 (18)22 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 7.5 (18)3.8 (5)11 (10)9.4 (5)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (2)2.4 (3)3.3 (2)2.0 (1)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)0.93 (0.9)152 (177)223 (542)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)1.9 (3)50 (104)38 (84)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.99 (2)1.9 (2)96 (177)225 (167)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (6)1.8 (2)4.1 (3)8.1 (15)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.81 (1)2.5 (3)4.4 (4)3.7 (2)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (4)1.9 (3)2.2 (2)2.7 (1)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (17)4.1 (5)146 (266)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (5)1.3 (1)15 (20)2e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (6)2.3 (3)13 (46)24 (25)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (3)2.1 (2)14 (30)26 (19)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)4.6 (5)7.4 (6)20680/10

Δ HVref
f15, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
24
1e-2
497
1e-3
2385
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (8)5.6 (7)3.9 (4)3.2 (2)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)6.0 (7)1.1 (1.0)37 (42)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)5.9 (7)7.6 (9)13 (13)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)8.3 (12)6.9 (8)6.2 (5)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)5.5 (8)2.0 (2)1.5 (1.0)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (6)3.1 (4)173 (201)336 (461)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (1)6.2 (8)46 (203)11 (23)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)6.5 (8)46 (202)24 (105)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (6)5.2 (9)0.78 (0.8)1.6 (2)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)5.5 (5)2.5 (3)1.9 (1)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (5)4.6 (6)1.3 (1)1.1 (0.8)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (3)6.0 (8)26 (66)36 (102)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.2 (8)2.8 (3)5.7 (12)6.3 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (5)6.1 (8)5.9 (11)3.2 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (15)6.2 (7)5.7 (11)2.2 (5)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)12 (15)2.8 (3)8.2 (10)0/10

Δ HVref
f16, 2-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
181
1e-2
1690
1e-3
6995
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (17)6.4 (13)3.9 (5)2.4 (2)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (7)124 (277)14 (30)43 (50)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 31 (77)3.5 (7)14 (27)11 (11)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 31 (76)9.3 (21)7.9 (12)5.4 (6)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 17 (41)2.4 (3)1.6 (2)4.1 (8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (12)124 (277)119 (119)257 (200)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)2.8 (5)15 (31)18 (24)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (23)1.9 (3)7.1 (16)21 (22)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.6 (13)124 (277)126 (89)127 (136)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 42 (104)4.4 (10)2.0 (2)4.4 (8)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 19 (47)2.8 (6)14 (30)45 (36)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (32)2.7 (4)20 (22)13 (11)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.4 (8)0.69 (0.8)2.0 (3)5.2 (11)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (23)1.5 (2)1.4 (2)4.8 (8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (13)2.0 (3)4.0 (8)5.8 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)3.0 (5)1.5 (2)2.8 (3)0/10

Δ HVref
f17, 2-D
1e0
13
1e-1
200
1e-2
509
1e-3
1980
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)1.9 (3)6.8 (8)6.6 (4)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (1)1.3 (2)46 (101)152 (152)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)3.9 (4)20 (26)29 (25)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)2.6 (4)11 (12)14 (10)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)2.3 (3)3.9 (3)14 (26)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (8)0.72 (0.9)394 (491)909 (1187)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)1.7 (2)2.7 (2)6.5 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)1.1 (1.0)2.7 (3)7.8 (9)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)0.80 (0.9)34 (83)93 (85)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)1.5 (2)4.3 (4)3.0 (1)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (3)1.2 (1)2.3 (2)26 (51)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.3 (6)30 (72)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (3)0.60 (0.7)1.8 (2)9.1 (13)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (2)1.7 (2)2.6 (2)5.7 (9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (1)1.4 (2)2.1 (2)3.9 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.93 (1)2.6 (2)4.1 (8)20600/10

Δ HVref
f18, 2-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
45
1e-2
474
1e-3
1086
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)8.2 (19)2.3 (4)4.4 (6)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (14)3.9 (8)47 (106)21 (46)1/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)12 (29)11 (26)19 (36)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (7)19 (46)6.5 (14)10 (16)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)3.8 (8)1.4 (3)2.2 (3)3/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (5)2.1 (4)47 (106)276 (276)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (8)2.6 (5)2.2 (4)50 (138)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)7.5 (17)20 (49)80 (138)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)1.7 (3)0.48 (0.6)21 (46)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (6)2.8 (5)1.7 (3)2.2 (3)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.6 (10)2.9 (6)0.94 (2)2.4 (4)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (8)3.0 (7)5.9 (12)18 (14)1/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)4.4 (8)0.95 (2)8.6 (19)3/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (5)3.4 (6)1.1 (1)8.7 (19)2/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (8)6.5 (15)3.1 (7)8.8 (23)3/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (26)5.8 (12)1.8 (3)2.9 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f19, 2-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
211
1e-2
926
1e-3
2276
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.83 (1)1.2 (2)2.0 (1)3.3 (2)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (1)1.3 (1)0.88 (0.4)59 (110)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)0.98 (2)3.2 (3)12 (7)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)1.3 (2)3.1 (2)5.9 (3)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)1.0 (1)1.3 (0.6)1.7 (0.8)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)407 (948)864 (972)352 (352)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (16)1.1 (1)1.6 (1.0)2.9 (3)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (11)0.65 (0.6)25 (54)11 (23)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.90 (1)106 (237)97 (162)71 (110)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)1.0 (1)1.3 (1)2.5 (2)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.93 (1)0.85 (0.9)25 (54)23 (44)7/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)1.2 (1)18 (20)36 (33)1/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.7 (3)12 (24)10 (11)12 (14)2/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (8)1.1 (1)0.90 (0.4)7.0 (5)2/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (7)1.2 (1)1.6 (2)1.4 (1)2/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (16)1.6 (3)1.9 (2)8.8 (8)0/10

Δ HVref
f20, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
147
1e-2
391
1e-3
2044
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.8 (16)4.4 (9)8.7 (11)5.0 (5)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)1.3 (2)1.9 (2)66 (123)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)17 (40)34 (64)24 (30)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (4)8.0 (17)17 (29)11 (12)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)2.7 (5)4.2 (5)2.5 (3)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (9)0.88 (1)58 (128)391 (978)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.1 (18)152 (342)59 (129)15 (31)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (9)152 (341)130 (256)39 (76)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (6)0.90 (1)1.3 (1)1.5 (1)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (22)1.9 (4)4.8 (7)2.5 (2)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)1.4 (3)2.2 (3)1.3 (1)4/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)17 (37)17 (40)11 (15)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (8)16 (35)7.1 (15)9.2 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.3 (19)16 (36)8.0 (15)6.2 (6)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)17 (36)7.8 (14)5.0 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)3.8 (6)4.6 (4)9.4 (14)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 2-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
72
1e-2
237
1e-3
878
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (5)6.8 (10)13 (22)11 (13)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (6)4.7 (8)96 (424)153 (228)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (17)6.4 (11)51 (91)61 (87)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (13)13 (24)27 (49)25 (33)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)7.5 (14)8.6 (13)29 (60)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (14)1.9 (3)212 (633)532 (456)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (13)6.7 (12)7.3 (12)32 (65)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.4 (12)5.2 (8)41 (96)183 (180)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)2.1 (3)4.7 (9)11 (25)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.8 (9)5.2 (7)6.8 (11)5.4 (5)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (8)2.8 (4)3.8 (4)3.2 (3)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.9 (19)4.8 (5)8.6 (15)24 (18)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.6 (9)2.1 (3)2.4 (4)16 (20)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (8)2.3 (3)5.3 (9)14 (31)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (8)3.3 (5)6.6 (11)14 (24)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (17)5.2 (6)7.3 (11)6.5 (10)0/10

Δ HVref
f22, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
68
1e-2
620
1e-3
3965
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)3.9 (5)6.8 (6)4.0 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)2.5 (3)1.7 (1)202 (706)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)5.5 (8)18 (19)21 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)5.9 (10)12 (12)10 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)4.4 (3)3.5 (2)2.1 (0.8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)2.3 (2)323 (645)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.4 (3)8.0 (10)21 (30)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)3.5 (3)114 (323)81 (66)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)2.3 (2)3.3 (3)8.0 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (7)3.5 (4)5.0 (3)11 (15)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.90 (1)2.3 (2)4.2 (5)8.4 (13)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)4.8 (5)42 (55)46 (55)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.9 (6)2.6 (3)4.7 (6)21 (23)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)3.0 (3)5.1 (5)21 (20)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)3.9 (4)6.3 (7)22 (29)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)6.2 (7)10 (9)20730/10

Δ HVref
f23, 2-D
1e0
1
1e-1
19
1e-2
183
1e-3
1196
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)1.8 (1)5.9 (7)4.3 (3)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (1)2.1 (3)1.9 (2)112 (209)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)2.3 (3)16 (29)16 (18)5/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (1)2.0 (2)11 (16)8.4 (8)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)1.6 (2)3.7 (4)2.4 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)2.1 (2)123 (274)669 (502)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)2.4 (4)471 (1368)119 (177)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (1)2.4 (4)472 (550)203 (464)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (0.8)1.4 (0.8)1.4 (2)2.5 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (0.8)2.5 (4)3.8 (5)2.8 (2)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)1.7 (2)1.9 (2)1.7 (2)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)2.9 (4)117 (170)78 (59)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (0.8)1.6 (2)49 (83)30 (29)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)3.0 (4)49 (165)14 (19)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)2.7 (4)49 (166)14 (22)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (1)2.5 (3)9.1 (12)17 (30)0/10

Δ HVref
f24, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
343
1e-2
3334
1e-3
19378
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)2.8 (4)2.3 (2)7.9 (16)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (9)0.94 (1)26 (60)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)6.8 (13)8.0 (9)5.7 (4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)3.7 (6)4.1 (3)2.8 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)2.0 (2)1.2 (0.7)24 (26)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (5)0.48 (0.3)540 (405)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (4)1.7 (2)7.0 (10)9.0 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (4)1.2 (1)6.4 (14)11 (31)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)0.78 (0.7)25 (34)94 (155)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.6 (20)2.0 (3)1.4 (0.7)4.2 (15)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.4 (11)1.4 (2)18 (45)20 (25)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)1.9 (2)16 (26)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (2)0.57 (0.5)1.2 (0.9)2.4 (2)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (12)0.96 (1.0)1.1 (1.0)2.2 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (4)1.2 (2)1.8 (2)3.2 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)2.3 (2)6.2 (8)20660/10

Δ HVref
f25, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
166
1e-2
975
1e-3
4432
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)1.4 (2)3.2 (3)3.0 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)1.3 (2)1.3 (0.8)181 (259)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)2.7 (5)9.4 (15)11 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)2.2 (3)6.2 (8)6.1 (5)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.8 (2)1.9 (2)7.0 (13)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)0.86 (0.8)89 (103)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)1.2 (1)1.4 (0.9)2.4 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)0.82 (0.6)2.1 (3)9.1 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)0.75 (1)55 (152)417 (519)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)1.2 (2)1.7 (2)1.3 (0.5)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)0.77 (0.9)1.2 (1.0)12 (22)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)1.8 (3)187 (226)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (2)0.75 (0.7)1.0 (1)2.3 (2)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (1)1.1 (1)1.1 (0.9)1.4 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (3)0.99 (0.9)1.2 (0.7)1.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (5)2.5 (3)2.7 (1)20720/10

Δ HVref
f26, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
213
1e-2
805
1e-3
1889
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (6)4.5 (9)4.3 (6)17 (31)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (5)1.1 (2)1.2 (1)71 (186)1/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (4)8.7 (20)14 (25)28 (35)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (8)10 (22)9.3 (17)13 (15)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (20)3.2 (7)2.4 (4)14 (55)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (7)0.69 (1)62 (124)424 (1059)1/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (14)1.8 (3)1.2 (2)3.7 (6)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (18)2.1 (4)43 (128)56 (53)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (5)0.61 (1.0)63 (124)49 (85)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (5)3.6 (8)2.4 (3)2.5 (2)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (3)1.2 (2)1.3 (1)13 (27)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (8)1.5 (2)11 (25)6.8 (13)1/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (7)2.1 (5)4.1 (8)9.3 (15)1/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.5 (17)1.4 (2)3.8 (7)4.4 (8)1/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.7 (15)1.2 (2)0.90 (1)3.7 (7)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (5)1.9 (3)2.1 (3)3.0 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 2-D
1e0
22
1e-1
293
1e-2
874
1e-3
4818
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (14)4.2 (10)3.9 (6)2.1 (1)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (12)77 (172)58 (172)97 (166)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (6)4.5 (10)16 (34)9.3 (11)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 8.7 (21)3.5 (8)7.8 (14)4.5 (4)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)1.9 (4)2.0 (2)5.6 (11)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.78 (1)0.53 (0.5)535 (744)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (9)1.5 (2)6.0 (11)3.3 (4)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (3)0.83 (1)4.3 (9)11 (21)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (6)0.63 (0.9)26 (58)11 (21)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (3)1.7 (3)1.6 (2)1.0 (0.6)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (9)0.96 (2)27 (58)5.4 (11)7/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (2)0.72 (1)27 (36)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (3)1.3 (3)12 (18)7.6 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)0.85 (1)1.5 (1)1.2 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)1.1 (2)1.9 (3)1.3 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.37 (0.4)1.8 (2)2.7 (2)4.2 (7)0/10

Δ HVref
f28, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
26
1e-2
269
1e-3
1200
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)3.7 (7)4.2 (8)4.4 (7)9/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)2.7 (3)1.6 (2)0.96 (1)2/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)3.4 (7)11 (24)16 (29)6/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)2.4 (3)6.5 (13)9.0 (14)9/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)2.3 (4)2.9 (5)2.1 (3)8/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (1)1.4 (2)0.74 (0.8)111 (208)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.1 (5)84 (188)43 (83)5/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)2.7 (4)187 (372)124 (125)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)1.2 (2)0.79 (0.9)73 (88)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.93 (0.9)2.4 (4)2.4 (4)2.4 (3)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.73 (0.8)2.1 (2)1.4 (2)10 (25)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)3.8 (5)20 (58)19 (35)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.87 (1)2.7 (4)10 (22)6.3 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)3.2 (5)9.3 (19)5.6 (18)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (7)2.2 (4)9.4 (38)5.6 (14)2/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)6.9 (11)3.4 (4)2.4 (3)0/10

Δ HVref
f29, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
149
1e-2
754
1e-3
2848
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)3.5 (6)4.6 (4)7.1 (4)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (9)1.0 (1.0)1.5 (1)1.6 (0.9)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (10)2.4 (4)17 (25)29 (27)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (7)3.2 (6)8.2 (10)13 (9)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (5)1.8 (3)2.8 (4)3.5 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)1.00 (1.0)0.64 (0.4)633 (509)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)2.3 (4)3.0 (4)30 (39)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (13)4.4 (8)32 (69)85 (72)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (4)2.7 (6)1.5 (2)20 (36)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)2.1 (3)3.6 (4)4.4 (4)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (8)1.4 (2)1.6 (1)2.4 (1)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (5)17 (35)14 (14)64 (71)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.6 (8)4.0 (9)4.6 (9)64 (77)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (6)2.1 (3)4.9 (9)32 (39)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)1.1 (2)5.5 (10)33 (46)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (6)2.9 (3)3.5 (2)20690/10

Δ HVref
f30, 2-D
1e0
10
1e-1
67
1e-2
224
1e-3
1596
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)14 (33)12 (24)5.4 (6)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (10)4.7 (10)3.0 (5)84 (126)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 26 (64)41 (101)59 (133)25 (40)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (8)28 (69)30 (66)11 (16)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 12 (31)7.7 (17)6.0 (9)2.5 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)1.5 (2)100 (224)502 (439)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (10)4.4 (9)7.8 (16)4.8 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.8 (12)4.6 (10)101 (225)16 (34)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.1 (12)2.5 (5)1.9 (3)1.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.3 (10)6.5 (14)6.6 (12)2.8 (3)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (5)3.0 (6)3.5 (5)1.9 (2)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (17)8.3 (17)50 (61)31 (54)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.98 (2)3.4 (7)11 (23)5.7 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (16)3.4 (6)7.5 (15)3.6 (6)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.79 (2)2.7 (5)10 (21)4.3 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.8 (19)4.7 (10)5.2 (6)4.0 (4)0/10

Δ HVref
f31, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
173
1e-2
1349
1e-3
7267
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)3.5 (4)4.2 (4)14 (14)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)1.7 (2)65 (112)248 (275)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (6)4.5 (8)14 (17)12 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)4.8 (6)9.4 (11)8.9 (9)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)1.6 (2)2.1 (1)42 (96)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)0.94 (0.9)223 (111)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)2.1 (2)3.3 (5)6.2 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)1.7 (2)1.9 (3)5.0 (16)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)0.92 (1)67 (77)131 (121)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)1.3 (2)15 (34)16 (34)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (4)1.1 (1)2.3 (3)23 (41)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)2.4 (3)8.3 (20)26 (29)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (4)0.82 (0.9)1.8 (2)2.9 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)2.1 (3)1.8 (2)1.9 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.9 (2)2.1 (2)2.2 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)3.6 (4)2.6 (3)20660/10

Δ HVref
f32, 2-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
176
1e-2
1116
1e-3
4723
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (6)5.0 (7)4.6 (3)3.9 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (4)2.4 (2)1.4 (0.7)382 (392)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (18)13 (26)15 (18)18 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 11 (27)10 (17)11 (10)8.0 (5)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (7)3.9 (5)2.7 (1)2.2 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (8)1.7 (2)1613 (2375)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (9)2.4 (3)1.7 (1)2.1 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)1.9 (2)1.3 (1)5.9 (8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)1.4 (1)7.1 (13)29 (39)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.5 (7)3.0 (4)2.8 (2)1.4 (0.5)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (6)2.2 (3)1.3 (0.7)6.5 (26)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)3.3 (3)19 (31)41 (32)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.2 (4)0.98 (0.7)0.97 (0.8)5.8 (6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)2.0 (2)1.3 (0.9)2.1 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)1.9 (2)1.4 (1)2.1 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (10)4.6 (4)3.3 (3)20770/10

Δ HVref
f33, 2-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
294
1e-2
822
1e-3
1842
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (5)3.0 (6)30 (127)30 (57)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)0.88 (2)105 (122)73 (81)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)7.9 (18)20 (40)34 (76)5/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)2.4 (5)11 (22)23 (43)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)2.4 (5)62 (122)47 (137)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (7)0.33 (0.4)104 (122)109 (190)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (8)1.5 (3)13 (31)6.9 (15)5/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (6)0.82 (1)68 (122)62 (54)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (8)0.49 (0.8)105 (183)48 (110)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)2.2 (5)2.2 (4)2.1 (2)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (2)1.4 (2)0.99 (2)14 (32)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.6 (13)1.4 (2)4.4 (9)5.5 (14)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.9 (5)2.1 (5)1.1 (2)7.6 (17)2/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (9)0.92 (1)1.8 (3)2.5 (4)2/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)1.1 (2)1.3 (2)2.4 (4)2/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)2.1 (3)2.1 (3)1.3 (2)0/10

Δ HVref
f34, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
168
1e-2
494
1e-3
1885
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)1.3 (1)2.8 (1)3.3 (1)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)0.91 (0.6)1.3 (0.9)46 (80)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (8)1.1 (1)4.7 (3)11 (8)5/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.78 (1)1.7 (2)3.5 (2)6.0 (2)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)0.84 (1)1.8 (1.0)1.8 (0.5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)1.2 (1.0)271 (405)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)0.89 (1)5.2 (9)19 (57)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (5)1.0 (1)12 (27)75 (163)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)0.78 (0.9)67 (150)58 (88)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)1.3 (1)2.5 (3)1.9 (0.9)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (4)0.83 (0.8)175 (304)48 (53)4/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.0 (6)14 (31)10 (18)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (3)0.92 (1)18 (51)27 (26)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (6)0.82 (1)1.8 (2)4.2 (9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)1.1 (1)1.8 (1)3.3 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (7)2.0 (2)2.5 (1)20700/10

Δ HVref
f35, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
89
1e-2
789
1e-3
4587
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 16 (39)5.2 (8)4.8 (4)3.4 (2)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)2.0 (2)1.4 (0.8)103 (109)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)8.7 (19)12 (12)16 (11)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 10 (25)7.2 (13)8.0 (8)7.5 (4)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)3.3 (6)2.6 (2)13 (33)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)1.3 (1)592 (444)393 (665)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)2.9 (4)4.2 (6)14 (18)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)2.4 (3)8.7 (15)103 (88)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.9 (11)1.7 (3)2.9 (4)46 (88)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)2.1 (2)3.5 (3)4.1 (4)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)1.8 (2)2.3 (2)5.4 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (42)3.0 (4)5.2 (8)13 (22)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.7 (13)1.2 (1)7.2 (10)20 (21)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (48)2.8 (4)4.3 (7)12 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)3.0 (4)4.3 (7)12 (12)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (73)4.6 (6)5.0 (7)20640/10

Δ HVref
f36, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
25
1e-2
1137
1e-3
6309
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)14 (26)2.7 (3)3.0 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)6.6 (9)0.82 (0.5)127 (143)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)32 (74)6.5 (11)12 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)20 (42)4.5 (6)7.6 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (14)14 (24)1.5 (1)1.6 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)3.2 (4)264 (396)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)9.3 (17)7.2 (15)11 (12)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)6.0 (7)0.96 (0.8)19 (16)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1)5.0 (8)1.1 (1)6.2 (27)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)8.1 (14)1.6 (2)2.0 (2)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (5)10 (19)1.0 (1)2.7 (3)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)11 (20)2.2 (3)30 (42)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (4)3.9 (4)1.8 (2)9.3 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)7.8 (11)1.2 (0.8)14 (10)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (16)7.6 (12)1.6 (2)9.0 (10)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (1)10 (17)2.0 (2)20700/10

Δ HVref
f37, 2-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
384
1e-2
2779
1e-3
21596
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (11)3.0 (3)2.9 (2)2.0 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)1.1 (1)49 (126)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)6.1 (9)10 (8)5.3 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)5.0 (6)4.9 (3)2.4 (0.8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)2.0 (3)1.5 (0.7)37 (65)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)131 (391)648 (954)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (3)1.7 (2)2.1 (1)4.5 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)1.1 (1)14 (30)43 (31)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (3)0.89 (0.7)9.1 (10)14 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)2.6 (3)3.4 (5)2.2 (2)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)1.2 (1)2.1 (3)4.4 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)2.6 (4)7.5 (7)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.3 (4)0.73 (0.7)2.8 (3)9.1 (12)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.3 (1)1.4 (0.7)9.2 (16)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (5)1.2 (1)1.3 (0.7)2e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)2.3 (2)20750/10

Δ HVref
f38, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
180
1e-2
1395
1e-3
6364
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)1.4 (2)2.4 (2)11 (16)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (0.8)0.91 (1)37 (72)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)1.9 (3)5.8 (6)13 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)2.3 (3)4.0 (3)7.6 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)1.3 (2)1.7 (0.9)33 (71)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (10)0.85 (0.9)1291 (2294)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)1.6 (1)1.9 (2)7.1 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)0.99 (0.7)1.1 (0.8)11 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (1)0.90 (0.7)12 (21)43 (27)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (3)1.5 (1)1.7 (1)1.1 (0.2)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.5)0.84 (0.4)1.0 (0.3)2.1 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.7 (2)14 (16)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (2)0.49 (0.2)1.8 (2)10 (12)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)0.85 (0.8)1.0 (0.3)6.4 (11)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.2 (1)1.2 (0.5)2.5 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (0.9)1.6 (1)3.4 (2)20750/10

Δ HVref
f39, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
239
1e-2
1103
1e-3
3676
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.88 (1)3.1 (5)5.3 (6)6.5 (5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (7)1.1 (1)21 (46)128 (163)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (10)6.4 (14)16 (20)32 (23)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)6.4 (13)10 (11)14 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (3)2.6 (4)23 (47)16 (41)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.4 (11)94 (210)78 (91)218 (299)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)1.3 (1)1.8 (2)8.5 (14)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (4)1.3 (2)28 (57)42 (44)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (5)0.94 (1)0.96 (1)15 (41)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (4)2.7 (5)2.7 (2)2.7 (2)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)1.4 (2)1.5 (1)2.8 (3)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (5)2.1 (3)5.7 (12)50 (45)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (10)2.0 (4)3.7 (6)10 (22)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (5)1.2 (2)3.0 (5)8.1 (7)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)1.5 (2)2.9 (4)10 (8)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)1.9 (2)3.7 (9)20720/10

Δ HVref
f40, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
300
1e-2
1003
1e-3
7955
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)1.7 (2)4.9 (2)2.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)75 (167)134 (100)227 (509)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (8)2.9 (4)11 (6)10 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (5)1.8 (2)7.1 (5)5.4 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)1.3 (0.9)2.4 (0.8)7.4 (13)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (4)167 (334)798 (2193)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (8)1.4 (1)9.3 (16)6.4 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (6)0.89 (0.7)29 (63)16 (27)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (4)0.82 (0.7)2.6 (5)11 (19)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (7)1.3 (1.0)2.9 (1)1.4 (2)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (5)0.86 (0.8)1.5 (0.5)0.47 (0.2)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.3 (8)2.9 (5)49 (52)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (16)2.2 (4)16 (15)11 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (8)1.0 (0.6)4.3 (7)1.8 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (3)0.91 (0.8)10 (15)2.1 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)2.2 (2)4.9 (6)20710/10

Δ HVref
f41, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
33
1e-2
292
1e-3
2801
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (1)5.2 (8)7.9 (5)3.8 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)3.8 (3)2.5 (1)286 (357)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)6.8 (11)17 (18)16 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)4.9 (7)12 (11)7.9 (4)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)5.9 (7)5.1 (3)2.1 (0.7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (9)2.5 (2)458 (857)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (6)5.2 (5)3.5 (2)3.6 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)4.4 (5)2.7 (1)2.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (7)2.3 (3)1.9 (0.8)2.1 (1.0)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (3)4.5 (5)4.8 (4)2.1 (0.6)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)2.9 (2)3.4 (2)1.4 (0.7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (3)5.9 (6)4.9 (3)15 (24)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (2)1.7 (1)2.0 (2)7.4 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)5.5 (5)3.1 (2)3.6 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)4.3 (4)3.1 (2)2.8 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (5)10 (11)6.5 (4)20760/10

Δ HVref
f42, 2-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
69
1e-2
1277
1e-3
9996
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)11 (23)4.0 (4)81 (95)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)3.5 (4)68 (79)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (11)21 (48)7.7 (11)16 (18)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)17 (37)6.1 (6)25 (31)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (11)4.2 (6)2.2 (2)2e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (14)1.9 (2)157 (157)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.94 (2)4.0 (6)1.6 (1)11 (16)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)3.2 (5)1.7 (2)8.9 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (3)2.2 (4)21 (42)9.3 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)5.8 (11)2.1 (2)11 (30)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (7)4.0 (8)1.4 (0.9)9.4 (14)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.74 (1)5.1 (9)1.9 (2)4.0 (3)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (3)1.7 (2)1.7 (2)18 (12)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.54 (0.8)3.4 (5)1.4 (0.9)2.6 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.4 (13)3.0 (4)1.6 (1)2.5 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (16)7.4 (12)3.2 (2)20640/10

Δ HVref
f43, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
161
1e-2
867
1e-3
5539
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)2.5 (2)4.5 (3)2.9 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)2.1 (2)27 (58)145 (172)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (3)3.9 (5)8.6 (6)11 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (4)3.3 (5)6.5 (6)5.6 (2)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)2.2 (2)2.5 (1)5.5 (19)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 9.3 (17)1.0 (0.8)2077 (1672)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)1.8 (1)2.2 (1)2.8 (1)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)1.6 (1)1.4 (0.6)2.5 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (5)1.0 (0.9)0.91 (0.5)4.7 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (5)1.8 (1)2.6 (2)1.2 (0.2)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)0.91 (0.6)1.7 (0.7)0.62 (0.2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)2.1 (1)2.4 (1)2.2 (0.9)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.0 (8)0.81 (0.5)1.2 (0.7)5.9 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)1.7 (1)1.4 (0.5)1.4 (0.5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)1.4 (1)1.5 (0.6)1.4 (0.6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)3.1 (2)2.8 (3)20800/10

Δ HVref
f44, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
26
1e-2
431
1e-3
1848
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (23)34 (78)7.4 (12)4.9 (5)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 16 (28)7.9 (12)1.5 (2)28 (81)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (20)87 (184)33 (59)26 (33)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 65 (160)60 (129)16 (27)11 (13)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 15 (28)15 (30)3.8 (5)14 (28)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (15)3.4 (7)52 (233)974 (1190)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (32)8.7 (16)1.7 (2)2.7 (4)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.9 (18)6.1 (11)1.9 (3)15 (32)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (14)5.5 (11)1.1 (2)4.5 (9)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (29)18 (35)4.1 (6)2.7 (2)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.2 (18)12 (26)2.2 (3)1.5 (1)4/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (36)12 (17)2.8 (3)15 (9)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.5 (9)3.2 (5)1.0 (2)4.7 (12)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (24)7.2 (11)1.7 (2)3.0 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.9 (12)10 (13)2.0 (2)3.0 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (19)17 (28)3.4 (2)20650/10

Δ HVref
f45, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
232
1e-2
1131
1e-3
8714
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (8)1.3 (2)2.7 (2)1.5 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (10)0.80 (0.4)45 (89)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)1.5 (1)6.6 (6)6.2 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)1.1 (0.9)4.0 (3)3.1 (1)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)1.5 (1)22 (45)24 (69)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)97 (216)1592 (1989)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.93 (0.8)1.1 (0.9)1.6 (0.9)2.0 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)1.2 (0.8)21 (45)6.2 (8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (4)0.93 (0.8)35 (107)5.1 (8)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (4)1.3 (0.9)2.0 (1)0.73 (0.2)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (3)0.79 (0.7)1.0 (0.6)0.37 (0.2)4/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (1)0.92 (0.8)5.6 (18)2.2 (1)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.9 (7)0.89 (1)5.4 (9)3.2 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)1.2 (0.8)1.2 (0.7)1.7 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)1.1 (0.8)3.2 (5)2.3 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)2.0 (2)3.3 (5)20730/10

Δ HVref
f46, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
684
1e-2
4108
1e-3
17611
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (15)2.5 (3)3.2 (1)13 (14)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (5)1.0 (0.7)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (14)4.5 (7)11 (7)11 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)4.2 (5)5.9 (3)5.0 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)1.4 (2)1.6 (0.5)2e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (4)74 (220)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)1.4 (1)2.1 (2)11 (11)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (4)0.94 (0.6)3.6 (4)13 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (5)15 (36)126 (266)2e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (6)1.7 (2)1.5 (0.3)8.2 (20)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.5 (11)1.1 (1)16 (26)104 (122)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (9)2.5 (3)6.3 (6)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.1 (5)0.62 (0.7)2.1 (2)2e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.1 (10)1.2 (1)1.5 (1)2e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (8)0.98 (0.6)2.0 (2)3.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (3)1.7 (1)20700/10

Δ HVref
f47, 2-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
370
1e-2
3988
1e-3
15233
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 26 (63)4.7 (7)3.3 (2)33 (33)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (13)1.6 (2)201 (188)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 19 (46)15 (33)10 (10)13 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 29 (72)10 (19)5.5 (3)8.3 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 10 (25)2.8 (4)23 (88)2e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (9)61 (135)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (12)2.2 (2)2.0 (2)12 (13)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (16)1.3 (1)1.6 (2)13 (28)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.3 (20)1.1 (1)17 (29)17 (24)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.9 (13)2.9 (4)1.4 (0.7)1.6 (1)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)1.7 (2)2.2 (3)4.4 (7)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (10)3.0 (4)3.5 (3)2e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)0.95 (0.8)1.2 (0.9)2e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)1.5 (1)2.1 (2)13 (9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (13)1.6 (2)1.6 (1)2.8 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.5 (20)2.6 (2)20660/10

Δ HVref
f48, 2-D
1e0
17
1e-1
319
1e-2
1440
1e-3
6136
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)6.8 (16)5.2 (7)25 (25)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.72 (1)1.1 (2)60 (104)294 (261)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (10)11 (26)22 (43)16 (16)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 12 (30)6.9 (16)10 (21)15 (36)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.62 (0.8)3.0 (7)17 (36)50 (130)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.86 (2)70 (157)209 (243)293 (318)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)1.7 (4)1.4 (1)17 (25)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (6)70 (158)36 (104)24 (49)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (4)70 (157)37 (104)34 (41)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (8)2.8 (6)1.9 (2)1.1 (0.5)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (4)1.3 (2)1.0 (0.9)9.1 (16)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)1.7 (4)6.4 (11)4.3 (5)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.4 (8)7.3 (16)2.4 (4)4.2 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)1.0 (2)2.1 (3)3.0 (6)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.68 (1)0.98 (2)1.3 (1)5.7 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)2.0 (3)1.9 (2)20660/10

Δ HVref
f49, 2-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
454
1e-2
1525
1e-3
20183
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.5 (7)3.8 (3)5.5 (3)7.6 (15)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (6)1.3 (1)88 (164)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)6.2 (7)18 (15)8.4 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (3)4.3 (6)12 (8)6.5 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)1.5 (2)17 (34)23 (42)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)50 (111)1181 (656)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (4)2.5 (3)18 (35)4.3 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (13)1.3 (1)17 (34)5.9 (6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (3)52 (117)73 (90)11 (31)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (7)2.0 (1)2.9 (1)0.41 (0.1)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (7)1.7 (2)2.7 (4)6.2 (8)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (4)1.4 (1)3.1 (2)4.5 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.4 (3)6.3 (12)4.7 (7)2.1 (2)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (5)1.2 (0.8)2.1 (2)0.96 (0.9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (8)1.2 (0.7)5.4 (8)1.7 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (6)2.3 (2)4.2 (4)20770/10

Δ HVref
f50, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
322
1e-2
1692
1e-3
7560
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)2.2 (2)4.2 (3)14 (40)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (7)0.95 (0.5)80 (148)2e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)2.8 (4)10 (7)13 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (6)3.0 (4)6.6 (4)8.7 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (6)1.5 (1)15 (30)41 (40)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)0.71 (0.7)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)1.2 (0.8)1.7 (0.9)2.8 (2)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (9)0.93 (0.6)1.5 (1)11 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)0.70 (0.5)2.3 (1)2.8 (1)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)1.3 (0.9)2.4 (0.9)2.3 (2)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (1)0.67 (0.3)1.3 (0.5)1.9 (1)8/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)1.1 (0.9)1.7 (0.9)8.0 (13)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.7 (5)0.55 (0.5)1.2 (0.9)5.6 (11)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (12)1.1 (0.8)1.4 (0.6)2.7 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)1.0 (0.7)1.3 (0.9)1.7 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.87 (1)2.2 (1)3.9 (3)20770/10

Δ HVref
f51, 2-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
55
1e-2
738
1e-3
3757
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (3)2.8 (4)4.6 (6)3.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.9 (3)1.2 (1)81 (160)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)3.0 (5)7.4 (10)12 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.9 (3)5.0 (6)6.8 (4)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)2.3 (3)2.6 (3)24 (54)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (7)1.7 (2)272 (813)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)2.6 (4)1.3 (1)1.9 (2)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (0.9)2.0 (2)0.91 (0.6)7.4 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (4)1.6 (2)36 (74)486 (599)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.90 (1)2.6 (4)2.1 (2)1.4 (0.5)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (1)2.4 (3)1.3 (1)4.9 (11)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.3 (5)6.0 (10)49 (50)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (2)1.2 (1)0.78 (0.8)3.3 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)2.2 (3)1.2 (1)1.1 (0.9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)2.8 (4)1.3 (1)1.3 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)3.6 (5)2.1 (3)5.5 (10)0/10

Δ HVref
f52, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
376
1e-2
1157
1e-3
9626
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)2.1 (2)3.6 (2)1.6 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)60 (134)174 (303)187 (229)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)2.3 (3)10 (11)6.3 (4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)1.7 (2)7.0 (6)3.2 (2)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.2 (1)21 (45)10 (11)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)798 (931)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)2.1 (3)10 (19)5.6 (13)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)13 (31)44 (87)10 (17)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)2.8 (6)2.8 (4)1.2 (1)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)1.5 (2)2.3 (1)1.1 (1)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)0.60 (0.5)1.4 (0.8)1.2 (1.0)8/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)6.9 (14)9.5 (13)4.1 (3)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.8 (5)36 (81)27 (22)9.3 (14)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)0.86 (0.9)1.4 (1)1.0 (0.8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)0.92 (0.9)3.2 (5)1.9 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)1.4 (1)3.0 (5)20640/10

Δ HVref
f53, 2-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
230
1e-2
529
1e-3
661
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)3.7 (9)7.2 (18)13 (30)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)1.5 (4)95 (189)76 (151)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)9.1 (23)35 (88)59 (142)8/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)5.5 (14)14 (36)24 (56)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)2.8 (7)3.3 (8)76 (151)3/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.5 (12)97 (218)95 (189)130 (454)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)1.6 (4)1.8 (4)6.3 (14)8/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (12)0.66 (2)27 (68)41 (101)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.2 (12)0.68 (2)69 (155)76 (227)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.1 (9)2.4 (6)2.7 (6)3.9 (8)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)1.3 (3)5.8 (14)5.7 (13)8/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)1.4 (3)2.5 (6)8.4 (15)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (4)1.9 (5)10 (19)7.9 (15)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (7)1.5 (4)5.5 (33)8.3 (15)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)0.97 (2)1.6 (4)8.3 (15)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)1.6 (4)1.4 (2)2.0 (2)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
240
1e-2
817
1e-3
2789
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (8)1.6 (2)3.3 (3)3.7 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (3)0.83 (1)164 (245)287 (251)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (11)1.3 (2)5.3 (7)14 (11)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.6 (2)4.7 (5)7.4 (4)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)1.1 (1)2.2 (1.0)10 (19)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (6)209 (417)572 (1040)646 (1004)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)1.5 (3)3.6 (5)5.3 (6)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (4)0.62 (0.4)1.1 (0.9)5.4 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (4)93 (209)180 (122)53 (72)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (4)0.85 (1)30 (64)10 (19)9/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (4)0.57 (0.5)106 (122)31 (36)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)9.3 (22)29 (32)30 (27)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (1)13 (34)27 (31)10 (13)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)10 (43)4.0 (7)3.1 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)8.1 (18)4.5 (8)2.5 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)2.6 (4)2.6 (3)20710/10

Δ HVref
f55, 2-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
340
1e-2
1693
1e-3
4427
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.50 (0.4)2.2 (3)2.7 (3)8.1 (12)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.9)67 (148)119 (325)407 (745)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)2.7 (4)5.6 (6)15 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)2.0 (3)5.7 (7)12 (15)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)1.1 (1)31 (60)107 (260)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)707 (1324)2e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.62 (0.5)1.9 (2)15 (31)34 (59)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)0.95 (0.7)7.5 (17)24 (25)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.97 (2)0.89 (0.6)29 (54)19 (36)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.95 (1)1.3 (1)1.5 (1)6.4 (12)8/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)1.0 (1)22 (47)31 (45)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)1.3 (1)5.5 (6)6.1 (4)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (2)24 (44)8.0 (21)10 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)0.82 (0.7)0.73 (0.4)3.0 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (1)1.1 (1)1.4 (1)3.2 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)1.7 (2)2.8 (2)20700/10

Previous dimension | Dimension = 3 | Next dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 3-D
1e0
1
1e-1
42
1e-2
416
1e-3
2270
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (0.8)7.6 (7)9.3 (4)6.6 (0.8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)3.5 (2)2.5 (0.5)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (0.2)6.7 (6)29 (14)34 (7)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (2)8.0 (6)16 (6)15 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (0.2)6.0 (3)4.9 (1)3.5 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (1)2.9 (1)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (0.5)5.8 (4)3.1 (0.7)6.3 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)5.2 (3)2.4 (0.6)6.1 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (1)3.9 (3)2.2 (0.7)5.8 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (0.5)6.4 (4)7.7 (3)3.6 (0.5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (2)4.2 (2)3.7 (0.9)2.7 (0.4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)9.0 (8)4.0 (0.8)5.7 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.2 (0.5)2.6 (1)2.1 (0.5)59 (105)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (0.5)6.0 (5)2.9 (0.8)7.1 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (3)6.1 (4)2.9 (0.5)5.4 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)10 (9)4.5 (1.0)30860/10

Δ HVref
f2, 3-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
73
1e-2
343
1e-3
1417
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)6.4 (9)13 (10)10 (3)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)3.4 (3)3.2 (1)214 (212)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)10 (20)46 (55)56 (22)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)14 (28)26 (24)24 (8)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)6.4 (6)7.0 (3)4.7 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)1.7 (1)376 (438)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)4.3 (5)3.0 (0.9)2.0 (0.7)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)3.4 (3)21 (46)25 (54)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)2.0 (3)2.2 (2)4.0 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (4)5.1 (6)8.9 (6)5.4 (1)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)4.3 (6)4.5 (2)2.7 (0.9)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (14)10 (14)52 (46)65 (48)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.50 (0.6)1.7 (0.8)1.6 (1)4.7 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)4.1 (4)3.2 (0.9)3.4 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.6 (10)4.7 (4)3.1 (1)2.6 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)10 (10)5.8 (2)30670/10

Δ HVref
f3, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
78
1e-2
392
1e-3
2435
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)6.1 (11)12 (12)6.5 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (15)4.0 (6)2.9 (2)289 (339)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (11)13 (27)51 (78)37 (25)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (6)6.8 (12)25 (31)15 (9)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (4)7.5 (11)6.0 (5)3.6 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (22)2.1 (2)1149 (765)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (19)4.9 (7)8.1 (14)6.6 (11)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (4)3.0 (4)87 (192)33 (63)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)2.9 (3)2.5 (2)4.1 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)4.1 (5)7.1 (5)3.2 (0.7)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.1 (16)2.4 (2)3.6 (1)1.9 (0.8)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (5)5.5 (5)62 (99)115 (167)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.9 (9)1.6 (1.0)2.1 (3)7.8 (12)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.73 (0.8)2.7 (3)5.8 (9)5.2 (8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (14)4.2 (5)4.1 (4)4.2 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.67 (0.8)6.9 (8)7.2 (4)30800/10

Δ HVref
f4, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
91
1e-2
346
1e-3
2072
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)6.3 (7)12 (8)6.8 (1)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)2.7 (3)3.0 (0.9)339 (362)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.95 (1)6.0 (10)40 (33)38 (13)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)7.7 (13)25 (20)16 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (1)4.1 (3)6.6 (3)3.1 (0.5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (4)1.4 (1.0)579 (1084)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.82 (1)3.2 (3)3.4 (0.9)19 (38)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (6)2.6 (2)2.4 (0.6)7.5 (9)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)2.6 (3)2.2 (0.9)3.2 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.4 (12)3.7 (3)8.8 (4)3.7 (0.5)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)2.6 (2)4.3 (1)2.5 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.53 (0.6)3.7 (4)16 (24)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.82 (1)1.2 (0.8)1.5 (1)8.3 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.68 (1)3.9 (2)3.4 (0.7)6.3 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)3.3 (2)3.2 (0.7)4.3 (12)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)6.5 (6)10 (9)30860/10

Δ HVref
f5, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
81
1e-2
697
1e-3
9434
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)9.4 (12)13 (12)3.7 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.7 (20)3.7 (3)2.6 (2)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (11)28 (58)61 (83)34 (41)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)19 (35)28 (30)11 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)4.6 (6)5.4 (3)2.0 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (1)1.9 (1)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)5.5 (6)48 (111)33 (53)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.5 (3)50 (109)18 (27)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)2.7 (3)2.7 (2)39 (35)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (3)7.4 (12)6.9 (4)2.7 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)3.8 (6)4.5 (5)2.5 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)5.7 (4)9.3 (8)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.9 (5)43 (93)8.6 (15)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (19)4.3 (4)11 (30)9.3 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)5.3 (4)7.4 (11)6.9 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)7.7 (7)5.4 (4)30820/10

Δ HVref
f6, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
48
1e-2
383
1e-3
2902
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)11 (16)13 (9)5.6 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (11)3.9 (3)2.9 (1)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)12 (21)41 (43)30 (13)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)15 (24)23 (21)13 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (11)7.3 (9)6.0 (3)2.6 (0.7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (14)2.3 (2)3134 (1175)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)5.9 (6)3.3 (0.8)5.5 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)5.2 (5)3.0 (1)35 (52)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)3.5 (3)2.2 (0.8)13 (20)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)6.2 (6)8.3 (6)2.9 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)3.0 (2)3.7 (1)1.8 (0.5)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)7.1 (7)4.8 (2)12 (12)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.4 (7)2.5 (1)2.7 (2)99 (184)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)6.0 (6)3.5 (1)6.9 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)6.0 (5)3.1 (1)3.7 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (14)12 (11)5.3 (2)30800/10

Δ HVref
f7, 3-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
349
1e-2
21556
1e-3
2.1e5
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.94 (1)6.6 (8)22 (49)13 (13)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)1.7 (1)125 (73)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)15 (20)9.3 (8)14 (19)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)14 (20)11 (11)13 (14)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (10)3.7 (4)14 (18)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)0.94 (0.8)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)2.0 (2)6.1 (8)6.7 (14)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (9)2.6 (3)6.7 (9)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (4)16 (38)1.9 (3)2.4 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (5)4.6 (5)1.9 (4)6.1 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)2.5 (2)4.3 (10)2.1 (4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (10)3.1 (3)1.6 (3)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.7 (5)1.5 (2)13 (5)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)1.8 (2)1.4 (0.8)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (7)2.1 (2)1.4 (2)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (3)3.7 (3)1.3 (2)30760/10

Δ HVref
f8, 3-D
1e0
10
1e-1
549
1e-2
14045
1e-3
1.7e5
#succ
2/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (4)5.6 (5)4.1 (6)7.3 (10)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (6)1.8 (1)50 (112)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)15 (17)14 (12)5.3 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)10 (12)4.9 (5)1.3 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)3.3 (2)6.0 (11)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.98 (2)0.87 (0.6)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)2.0 (2)8.2 (11)7.4 (12)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.61 (0.9)1.6 (1)24 (27)7.6 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)1.2 (0.7)3.9 (7)3.5 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (3)3.5 (4)1.5 (2)1.2 (1.0)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.88 (1)1.7 (1)1.8 (3)1.6 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)1.9 (2)2.7 (3)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.86 (1)0.82 (0.6)2.6 (3)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.6 (1)1.9 (1)1.7 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)1.7 (1)2.5 (3)1.7 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.93 (2)2.8 (2)30810/10

Δ HVref
f9, 3-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
68
1e-2
290
1e-3
1918
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (11)12 (15)16 (11)7.7 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (8)4.6 (3)3.6 (1)19 (40)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (6)28 (43)67 (55)45 (16)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (10)14 (18)40 (27)19 (6)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (9)6.1 (6)7.9 (5)3.3 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (5)2.0 (1)260 (776)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (14)5.9 (4)4.1 (1)2.3 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)3.8 (2)2.8 (0.9)2.6 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.5 (5)3.8 (3)2.4 (1.0)2.4 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)5.0 (5)10 (7)4.0 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)2.8 (2)5.2 (1)1.8 (0.6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)6.9 (6)12 (14)40 (71)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.2 (5)1.7 (0.6)1.5 (0.7)9.2 (23)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)5.2 (4)3.8 (2)4.4 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.8 (10)5.0 (3)4.0 (1)2.9 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (4)11 (8)7.6 (5)30720/10

Δ HVref
f10, 3-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
348
1e-2
2284
1e-3
6628
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)2.9 (2)3.4 (1)8.2 (23)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (6)1.3 (1)34 (66)408 (204)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)4.9 (5)15 (7)20 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.96 (1)4.5 (4)7.2 (2)7.9 (3)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)2.3 (1)1.8 (0.9)21 (23)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (3)96 (216)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)1.8 (1)3.3 (4)25 (43)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1.0)1.2 (0.5)90 (197)51 (46)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (1)0.92 (0.7)25 (53)74 (140)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)1.3 (1)1.9 (0.5)6.4 (11)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.96 (1)1.1 (1)16 (34)20 (45)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (0.9)1.9 (1)10 (23)20 (13)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.5 (2)0.63 (0.6)12 (13)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)1.4 (0.4)4.7 (10)6.8 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (2)1.4 (1.0)4.6 (6)4.9 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)2.5 (2)3.0 (3)30620/10

Δ HVref
f11, 3-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
50
1e-2
320
1e-3
3248
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (9)13 (31)9.1 (19)3.4 (5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)3.7 (7)2.0 (3)24 (69)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 17 (41)39 (95)37 (85)14 (28)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (10)18 (42)17 (39)6.8 (12)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.6 (15)10 (23)4.4 (8)2.0 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (7)2.1 (4)235 (469)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (11)4.0 (7)2.1 (2)1.6 (2)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)2.9 (6)2.0 (3)1.8 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)1.5 (2)2.0 (3)2.9 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.5 (10)8.4 (19)4.7 (9)1.8 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.2 (11)5.3 (11)2.5 (4)1.4 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)4.9 (10)3.1 (5)2.4 (3)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.9 (6)1.2 (1)2.2 (3)2.9 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.1 (11)3.2 (6)2.3 (3)2.1 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)4.1 (8)2.7 (4)1.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (40)8.2 (18)3.9 (5)2.0 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f12, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
32
1e-2
238
1e-3
1581
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.97 (1)2.5 (4)5.6 (9)4.0 (5)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)2.9 (3)2.1 (3)82 (380)4/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)2.5 (3)18 (26)19 (27)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (1)3.2 (5)9.0 (15)8.6 (12)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (17)3.5 (5)3.4 (5)2.1 (2)5/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.9)1.2 (2)141 (316)190 (190)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)3.3 (4)142 (317)25 (53)4/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (5)3.0 (4)142 (317)50 (95)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)2.9 (4)1.8 (2)2.5 (3)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (8)2.6 (3)3.6 (6)2.2 (2)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)2.4 (2)1.9 (3)1.8 (2)6/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)1.6 (2)48 (91)15 (24)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.2 (2)1.6 (2)15 (32)8.6 (24)3/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (1)1.9 (3)16 (34)4.7 (9)4/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)3.4 (4)16 (34)4.4 (7)4/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (5)4.6 (7)5.4 (6)2.5 (3)1/10

Δ HVref
f13, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
17
1e-2
163
1e-3
621
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)5.0 (8)3.8 (5)7.1 (9)8/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (5)4.0 (5)1.5 (1)1.4 (1)2/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (2)6.2 (8)6.8 (10)23 (37)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (1)2.7 (4)5.3 (9)13 (20)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)3.6 (5)2.3 (4)2.8 (3)8/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (4)2.0 (2)0.99 (0.7)122 (242)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (0.9)4.0 (5)2.2 (2)1.7 (1)6/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)6.3 (9)29 (69)85 (188)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (3)3.0 (5)2.7 (5)56 (124)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (6)6.0 (10)3.9 (6)4.2 (5)10/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.7 (11)5.2 (8)2.2 (4)2.3 (2)7/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (3)3.8 (5)5.8 (10)7.6 (14)1/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.6 (4)2.6 (3)0.77 (0.6)1.4 (2)1/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)5.8 (10)2.5 (2)1.7 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)3.6 (5)2.1 (3)1.5 (1)3/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (7)14 (20)5.3 (6)4.4 (3)0/10

Δ HVref
f14, 3-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
139
1e-2
1774
1e-3
10133
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)11 (14)7.1 (3)3.2 (1)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)3.0 (2)1.1 (0.5)30 (37)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)16 (26)36 (28)24 (17)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (16)17 (25)16 (9)8.1 (2)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (4)5.5 (6)2.8 (1.0)1.5 (0.8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (10)1.7 (2)170 (254)267 (681)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)4.1 (3)54 (86)141 (118)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (8)3.2 (2)66 (211)267 (222)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (5)2.2 (2)75 (169)55 (84)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (16)5.6 (7)3.7 (1)14 (24)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.3 (12)4.5 (5)12 (24)11 (24)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (6)17 (18)155 (153)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (8)3.3 (6)14 (21)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (12)4.3 (3)7.4 (9)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)3.5 (2)8.5 (9)27 (36)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (34)7.3 (4)30780/10

Δ HVref
f15, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
42
1e-2
352
1e-3
1838
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (1)14 (16)15 (11)9.1 (4)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (15)5.9 (6)2.9 (2)165 (286)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)13 (18)58 (57)53 (33)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (6)11 (12)31 (30)21 (12)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)9.0 (14)7.0 (5)3.9 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)3.2 (3)570 (853)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)7.7 (8)4.4 (3)10 (11)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)7.0 (7)3.3 (2)6.6 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (7)3.9 (5)3.0 (3)16 (25)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.6 (10)6.7 (8)8.5 (7)4.3 (2)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)2.5 (2)3.4 (3)4.1 (4)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)325 (359)776 (984)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.97 (1)3.7 (5)8.5 (14)72 (82)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)7.0 (7)4.2 (3)32 (44)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)6.4 (7)3.4 (2)5.4 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)17 (16)11 (8)16 (21)0/10

Δ HVref
f16, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
670
1e-2
5703
1e-3
2.0e5
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (7)3.9 (8)2.9 (2)2.4 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (13)0.65 (0.9)36 (66)14 (18)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (17)13 (31)14 (15)2.0 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (21)7.2 (16)6.2 (6)0.51 (0.2)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (6)1.8 (3)1.3 (1.0)6.2 (8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 16 (37)0.54 (0.8)123 (197)14 (17)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (27)0.76 (1.0)28 (40)15 (7)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)2.6 (6)13 (19)6.5 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)50 (112)123 (118)14 (23)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)2.1 (4)14 (27)6.2 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (8)0.90 (1)31 (75)6.2 (10)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (21)18 (23)48 (54)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.1 (12)0.47 (0.8)8.7 (15)1.5 (1)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.2 (20)0.78 (1)3.9 (4)1.5 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (20)0.92 (1)5.1 (6)1.4 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (39)1.5 (2)1.5 (2)30880/10

Δ HVref
f17, 3-D
1e0
22
1e-1
1125
1e-2
25640
1e-3
1.7e5
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)3.6 (4)2.4 (4)3.0 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)0.84 (0.9)47 (56)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)12 (18)10 (13)8.3 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.79 (1)6.8 (9)3.3 (3)1.7 (1)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.78 (2)1.7 (2)5.4 (15)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (3)30 (67)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)0.84 (0.9)5.4 (9)7.6 (8)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)0.60 (0.6)6.7 (6)7.5 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.56 (0.8)30 (67)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)1.7 (2)1.7 (3)7.7 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)0.88 (0.9)18 (20)3e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.74 (1)14 (36)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (2)0.63 (0.9)2.9 (3)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (4)0.82 (1)1.4 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)0.70 (0.8)1.4 (2)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (7)1.5 (1)1.2 (1)30860/10

Δ HVref
f18, 3-D
1e0
14
1e-1
78
1e-2
636
1e-3
2621
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.7 (14)6.6 (16)3.8 (6)4.8 (4)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (7)2.6 (6)0.91 (1.0)0.88 (0.5)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (3)24 (59)18 (40)23 (26)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 13 (32)18 (44)10 (20)10 (9)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (17)5.4 (12)2.2 (3)2.2 (2)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (5)1.1 (2)0.52 (0.4)1030 (1374)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.9 (17)2.9 (6)1.2 (1)2.6 (4)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (6)1.5 (3)0.91 (1.0)2.8 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (12)2.0 (4)1.3 (2)0.84 (0.7)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.35 (0.7)1.8 (4)1.8 (3)2.1 (1)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (25)2.4 (5)2.9 (6)14 (30)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.4 (13)3.3 (7)3.1 (2)14 (22)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (4)1.3 (1)0.76 (0.8)2.3 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.1 (13)2.2 (4)1.1 (1.0)1.7 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)1.9 (4)0.96 (0.8)1.9 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (18)3.2 (7)2.0 (2)3.6 (4)0/10

Δ HVref
f19, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
222
1e-2
5928
1e-3
29477
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)1.8 (1)1.0 (0.6)0.57 (0.2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (5)2.4 (3)13 (25)41 (31)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)1.6 (2)2.9 (2)2.9 (0.8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)1.3 (1)2.0 (1)1.3 (0.3)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)1.8 (2)0.52 (0.3)7.1 (18)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (5)151 (676)202 (89)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)1.2 (0.9)9.0 (19)24 (18)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (1)1.0 (1)13 (38)7.2 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (1)8.0 (18)51 (76)24 (18)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)0.84 (0.5)0.53 (0.3)2.8 (5)6/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)0.69 (0.6)13 (38)15 (13)3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.95 (1)2.8 (4)22 (28)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (4)0.86 (0.6)7.7 (19)4.1 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)1.3 (0.9)1.8 (3)1.7 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)1.7 (2)1.6 (4)0.72 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.9)2.7 (1)0.89 (0.9)30480/10

Δ HVref
f20, 3-D
1e0
19
1e-1
102
1e-2
389
1e-3
2887
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 27 (67)19 (40)18 (25)6.4 (7)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 12 (28)5.3 (10)3.7 (4)243 (234)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 56 (139)99 (237)107 (182)44 (47)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 25 (62)51 (121)46 (74)16 (17)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)10 (22)7.9 (11)3.1 (3)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)2.0 (3)1157 (2314)243 (208)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (31)8.3 (16)5.8 (9)17 (31)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (21)11 (24)139 (501)54 (55)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.1 (10)2.1 (3)2.5 (3)15 (29)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 25 (63)10 (22)9.1 (12)3.0 (4)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.0 (19)4.2 (7)4.0 (4)2.7 (4)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.0 (19)12 (26)22 (39)8.7 (7)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (6)2.2 (3)4.2 (6)11 (24)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.9 (21)6.0 (12)7.3 (13)7.4 (8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)5.7 (11)7.5 (13)7.2 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (7)8.6 (14)7.8 (7)10 (11)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 3-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
78
1e-2
536
1e-3
3164
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)9.0 (17)11 (15)5.2 (5)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (18)4.5 (7)2.0 (2)64 (142)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (7)27 (60)49 (89)34 (37)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.96 (1)16 (31)23 (37)13 (14)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)6.3 (10)4.2 (5)2.8 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (7)2.0 (2)141 (280)221 (356)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)4.6 (7)4.3 (7)25 (95)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)242 (601)64 (141)27 (50)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (3)1.7 (2)63 (140)42 (95)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)6.1 (10)5.2 (6)3.2 (4)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.0 (1)4.0 (6)2.2 (2)1.6 (2)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (8)6.0 (9)17 (85)12 (14)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (3)1.5 (2)7.0 (14)9.4 (11)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (7)3.9 (6)3.4 (6)4.7 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)4.1 (5)3.3 (5)4.1 (10)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)7.9 (9)4.2 (5)4.4 (2)0/10

Δ HVref
f22, 3-D
1e0
1
1e-1
94
1e-2
677
1e-3
9994
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 44 (108)12 (22)14 (11)3.1 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)3.4 (6)2.9 (2)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 23 (55)46 (107)69 (83)20 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 22 (52)30 (68)32 (31)7.3 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 21 (49)7.1 (12)6.2 (4)3.6 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 32 (78)2.1 (2)3989 (4321)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (0.8)4.4 (5)7.8 (9)27 (19)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (60)4.2 (6)58 (122)72 (68)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (31)2.9 (3)16 (30)9.3 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 18 (42)7.1 (12)11 (11)3.4 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (36)4.0 (6)6.3 (9)4.0 (4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (16)30 (43)121 (163)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (2)2.7 (3)6.9 (8)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (26)3.3 (3)4.7 (3)29 (18)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.6 (14)3.5 (4)4.7 (3)9.0 (14)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 60 (149)8.3 (11)21 (19)30800/10

Δ HVref
f23, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
28
1e-2
369
1e-3
3845
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.2)5.2 (7)8.7 (6)4.1 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (0.9)4.4 (4)2.9 (1.0)313 (566)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)3.8 (3)22 (19)23 (11)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)5.9 (10)15 (11)10 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)4.6 (5)5.1 (2)11 (20)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)2.5 (2)814 (1017)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)4.8 (5)4.6 (5)13 (23)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)4.0 (4)11 (21)39 (45)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)2.3 (1)2.4 (1)23 (41)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)5.2 (5)6.2 (4)2.0 (0.4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.65 (0.4)3.5 (3)3.0 (2)1.6 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)14 (28)748 (714)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.80 (0.8)3.1 (2)3.2 (3)17 (20)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)5.1 (7)3.1 (2)5.7 (8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)3.6 (2)2.9 (1)3.7 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.85 (0.9)5.7 (7)5.9 (4)30830/10

Δ HVref
f24, 3-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
926
1e-2
8211
1e-3
2.1e5
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (9)2.9 (4)6.3 (10)2.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (9)0.65 (0.9)37 (82)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (6)10 (18)12 (11)2.5 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (12)3.2 (5)5.1 (5)1.1 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.95 (2)1.6 (2)10 (19)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)0.38 (0.6)146 (82)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)21 (49)18 (28)4.1 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.51 (0.8)1.1 (2)8.3 (13)6.4 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (4)0.49 (0.6)38 (39)5.8 (8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (4)1.8 (3)11 (18)6.3 (6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.79 (1)0.77 (1)57 (100)6.3 (11)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.95 (2)22 (25)15 (18)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (4)0.67 (1)3.2 (4)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (5)0.71 (1)1.6 (2)1.4 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)0.94 (1)2.4 (3)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (5)1.5 (2)1.7 (1)30810/10

Δ HVref
f25, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
520
1e-2
6596
1e-3
1.6e5
#succ
4/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)2.4 (4)2.4 (2)1.2 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)0.77 (1)20 (23)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)6.0 (11)13 (14)5.6 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (1)5.2 (11)5.7 (5)0.91 (0.4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)1.5 (2)1.2 (0.9)7.4 (10)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (7)0.43 (0.5)106 (205)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (8)0.81 (0.9)7.0 (14)8.0 (8)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (10)0.76 (1.0)5.7 (12)18 (17)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (28)0.62 (0.8)50 (80)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)1.8 (3)1.1 (0.8)3.2 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.6 (12)1.1 (2)5.9 (9)17 (17)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)7.7 (17)21 (34)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 8.1 (18)0.50 (0.8)1.7 (2)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (19)0.93 (1)1.2 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)0.78 (0.8)1.4 (2)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (40)1.7 (2)1.4 (1)30820/10

Δ HVref
f26, 3-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
836
1e-2
2117
1e-3
3012
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (7)3.5 (6)3.7 (5)29 (52)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (8)0.85 (1)36 (71)67 (50)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (11)9.5 (19)22 (37)41 (69)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)10 (18)9.3 (16)14 (15)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)1.8 (3)17 (38)44 (100)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (4)40 (90)61 (142)233 (423)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)1.00 (2)36 (71)30 (100)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (8)41 (91)61 (177)67 (75)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (3)0.51 (0.9)61 (71)43 (50)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.0 (10)1.8 (3)1.6 (2)27 (51)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (7)0.91 (2)36 (106)43 (125)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.8 (17)2.6 (5)6.5 (8)7.6 (15)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.1 (10)0.50 (0.8)2.0 (4)4.9 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (11)0.80 (1)2.2 (8)3.7 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (10)0.49 (0.7)2.0 (4)4.8 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)1.2 (2)1.1 (2)1.7 (2)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
588
1e-2
3297
1e-3
23418
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)0.76 (1)1.9 (1)0.72 (0.4)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)0.49 (0.6)137 (114)115 (93)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)1.1 (2)7.6 (8)4.3 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)1.5 (2)3.4 (3)1.8 (1.0)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)1.1 (1)1.0 (0.6)5.8 (10)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)128 (255)364 (409)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (1)0.98 (1)3.6 (7)11 (13)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.72 (0.6)0.40 (0.4)62 (47)31 (42)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (4)0.33 (0.3)91 (273)30 (32)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (1)0.83 (1)1.1 (0.8)3.6 (6)7/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (1)0.41 (0.4)23 (46)8.7 (13)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)13 (39)38 (37)12 (14)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.72 (0.6)1.8 (3)11 (29)12 (13)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (3)0.74 (1)3.1 (5)2.2 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.48 (0.4)2.2 (3)1.6 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)1.3 (1)1.9 (3)30430/10

Δ HVref
f28, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
55
1e-2
215
1e-3
1830
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)4.6 (7)8.7 (9)5.3 (2)8/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (6)2.2 (2)2.6 (2)19 (41)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (4)5.2 (7)28 (33)26 (19)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (7)5.8 (9)18 (18)13 (7)9/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (3)3.9 (5)5.7 (4)2.4 (1)4/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (6)1.3 (0.6)1.7 (1)656 (738)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (3)3.4 (3)4.6 (4)24 (47)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)3.2 (3)7.3 (13)101 (246)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.6 (7)2.4 (3)2.2 (1)82 (138)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.4 (13)4.3 (6)7.5 (7)3.3 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.1 (9)2.4 (2)4.2 (3)42 (82)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (6)5.4 (5)10 (12)28 (25)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (3)1.8 (1)2.5 (3)14 (22)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (10)3.1 (4)3.6 (2)11 (21)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (7)3.2 (3)3.8 (2)4.2 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (5)5.1 (8)6.7 (4)3.9 (4)0/10

Δ HVref
f29, 3-D
1e0
1
1e-1
74
1e-2
2499
1e-3
7053
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (16)15 (17)4.7 (2)5.2 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.9 (15)5.1 (4)0.87 (0.3)171 (138)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (16)21 (29)21 (13)31 (7)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)19 (25)10 (5)12 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (4)11 (7)2.1 (0.8)2.9 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)2.7 (1)280 (210)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)6.0 (5)24 (41)422 (191)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (6)5.7 (3)8.7 (13)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (2)4.0 (4)58 (182)388 (510)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (6)7.5 (6)2.6 (0.9)18 (21)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (1)2.8 (2)1.7 (2)48 (45)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (3)18 (16)33 (49)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (2)3.6 (4)12 (28)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (6)6.4 (4)8.4 (9)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)6.0 (2)6.6 (10)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (5)12 (7)12 (11)30800/10

Δ HVref
f30, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
46
1e-2
339
1e-3
2110
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (10)11 (18)15 (12)8.0 (4)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)5.3 (7)3.1 (2)214 (178)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (7)54 (125)59 (85)45 (30)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)25 (52)32 (36)18 (11)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 15 (37)11 (20)6.7 (6)3.3 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (16)2.4 (3)223 (443)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.6 (21)6.2 (10)4.2 (3)5.4 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)5.9 (7)2.9 (2)19 (38)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (8)2.9 (4)4.2 (6)23 (79)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (24)10 (18)8.9 (8)3.8 (2)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.3 (10)4.4 (6)4.0 (3)3.6 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (41)28 (57)113 (231)140 (96)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (10)3.2 (3)2.4 (2)26 (50)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)6.6 (7)3.7 (2)6.7 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)6.7 (7)3.8 (3)4.5 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)13 (17)11 (9)14 (10)0/10

Δ HVref
f31, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
660
1e-2
8169
1e-3
1.8e5
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)3.9 (5)2.0 (1)2.7 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)0.94 (1)55 (92)15 (19)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)11 (18)9.0 (8)1.4 (1.0)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)6.3 (8)4.8 (3)0.55 (0.3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)2.2 (3)10 (18)15 (11)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)0.44 (0.4)55 (46)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.1 (1.0)18 (24)4.5 (8)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)0.99 (1.0)27 (22)4.7 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)0.56 (0.5)66 (46)15 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.95 (1)2.1 (3)18 (37)2.6 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)1.1 (1)47 (105)15 (18)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)6.7 (25)9.3 (9)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (3)2.1 (3)4.4 (6)1.6 (2)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.8 (3)4.3 (7)1.6 (1.0)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.1 (0.9)3.4 (6)0.78 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)1.6 (1)1.7 (1)30830/10

Δ HVref
f32, 3-D
1e0
12
1e-1
946
1e-2
8968
1e-3
1.1e5
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (9)3.6 (4)2.6 (2)2.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)36 (159)34 (67)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)12 (21)21 (21)8.7 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)7.7 (10)6.8 (5)1.7 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (16)1.9 (2)4.9 (9)12 (7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)0.51 (0.4)301 (167)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (8)0.87 (0.9)8.3 (12)12 (12)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (14)0.67 (0.6)11 (17)26 (33)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (3)3.2 (7)53 (59)26 (18)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (8)2.0 (2)1.8 (2)4.9 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (3)1.2 (1)18 (33)13 (17)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (8)7.3 (10)31 (28)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)1.0 (2)3.3 (3)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (13)0.89 (0.8)3.1 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)0.92 (1)2.8 (2)2.7 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.7 (12)1.6 (1)3.2 (5)30860/10

Δ HVref
f33, 3-D
1e0
11
1e-1
553
1e-2
2134
1e-3
3462
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)6.4 (10)38 (106)59 (130)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (6)1.5 (3)61 (71)87 (87)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)33 (69)38 (59)54 (70)4/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (6)14 (23)15 (24)32 (70)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (6)3.9 (8)61 (141)38 (131)3/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (6)136 (271)94 (211)87 (152)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (6)1.5 (3)37 (70)62 (87)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (5)34 (85)61 (177)87 (152)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)1.5 (3)55 (70)58 (65)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.8 (10)3.8 (6)43 (106)59 (130)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (5)1.6 (2)61 (176)58 (109)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (15)8.9 (19)10 (14)9.2 (11)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.8 (6)0.63 (1)5.4 (18)8.8 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (11)1.6 (3)4.0 (14)9.0 (13)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)2.1 (4)5.5 (10)6.2 (18)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.7 (16)2.3 (3)1.4 (2)1.8 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f34, 3-D
1e0
22
1e-1
674
1e-2
3168
1e-3
14422
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)2.8 (5)2.6 (2)3.7 (11)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)50 (112)95 (189)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)4.7 (9)10 (14)8.2 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (8)4.6 (9)4.6 (6)3.3 (2)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (3)1.6 (2)1.2 (0.6)14 (31)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (3)0.32 (0.3)852 (758)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.66 (0.9)1.3 (2)14 (30)16 (26)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)50 (223)42 (166)35 (32)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (3)50 (111)110 (230)84 (78)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (5)1.9 (3)1.4 (1)14 (36)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)0.77 (1.0)11 (24)21 (26)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (6)6.9 (13)24 (46)20 (26)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.5 (3)5.4 (23)12 (17)10 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)0.91 (1)4.1 (7)2.1 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)1.3 (2)4.8 (7)3.9 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (14)1.4 (2)1.3 (0.8)30780/10

Δ HVref
f35, 3-D
1e0
1
1e-1
69
1e-2
1370
1e-3
14850
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (0.5)15 (12)7.4 (2)2.3 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)6.0 (3)1.8 (0.8)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (2)19 (23)36 (21)14 (4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (0.5)20 (21)17 (8)5.3 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)8.6 (5)3.3 (1)2.0 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (0.5)2.8 (2)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)7.7 (4)38 (67)52 (96)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)5.4 (3)58 (111)48 (35)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (2)5.4 (3)175 (166)53 (74)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (5)6.8 (3)5.2 (3)7.2 (9)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)6.9 (5)55 (105)21 (29)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)7.7 (3)9.1 (11)20 (10)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (0.2)2.8 (2)20 (24)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)8.2 (4)12 (18)20 (23)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.6 (9)7.7 (3)12 (28)20 (22)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)15 (7)30800/10

Δ HVref
f36, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
63
1e-2
690
1e-3
7454
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 17 (40)17 (27)21 (20)4.6 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (12)5.4 (4)2.8 (0.7)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (31)49 (94)62 (56)40 (23)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)27 (45)42 (43)14 (10)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.2 (18)12 (13)6.2 (2)2.4 (1.0)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)3.2 (2)3914 (4022)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (39)7.9 (7)59 (138)24 (31)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (32)7.6 (5)5.8 (8)53 (62)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 21 (52)5.4 (6)5.7 (5)43 (31)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (9)12 (17)7.7 (3)2.4 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.8 (13)6.7 (9)3.2 (0.9)3.1 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (51)18 (25)42 (39)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.3 (12)2.7 (2)5.2 (4)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (42)8.3 (7)6.2 (7)20 (25)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (46)6.8 (4)4.5 (3)19 (26)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (7)16 (15)14 (12)30790/10

Δ HVref
f37, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
730
1e-2
12388
1e-3
1.8e5
#succ
4/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (1)3.7 (4)1.7 (0.7)15 (18)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)1.0 (0.8)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)7.5 (8)10 (5)5.5 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)5.3 (6)4.1 (2)1.4 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)2.0 (2)11 (12)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)46 (103)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)1.3 (1)9.0 (17)3e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (8)0.96 (0.7)22 (14)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (1)1.8 (3)31 (42)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (1)2.5 (3)3.7 (7)4.5 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)1.4 (1)10 (18)7.8 (8)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (0.5)2.0 (2)11 (32)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.65 (0.4)0.78 (1.0)11 (7)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.1 (0.9)2.9 (5)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.3 (1)2.9 (3)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)1.9 (1)2.5 (2)30890/10

Δ HVref
f38, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
639
1e-2
15065
1e-3
4.5e5
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)4.0 (5)6.5 (10)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)1.5 (1)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.65 (0.4)10 (18)19 (19)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)6.6 (9)7.7 (8)6.4 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)2.6 (3)21 (15)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)202 (235)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)1.5 (1)12 (13)3e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (0.8)0.97 (0.9)21 (26)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)1.7 (3)180 (234)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)2.1 (3)2.6 (4)0.56 (0.5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.55 (0.1)1.1 (1)7.1 (10)6.3 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (0.5)10 (21)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (1)0.95 (1)5.1 (6)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.95 (1)1.4 (2)1.7 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.65 (0.4)1.0 (0.6)1.9 (1)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)2.0 (1)30660/10

Δ HVref
f39, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
271
1e-2
1604
1e-3
32411
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (10)5.6 (9)8.0 (5)2.3 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)124 (278)22 (94)37 (21)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)41 (93)41 (45)9.1 (6)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)17 (37)17 (14)3.3 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (8)4.8 (8)23 (47)2.8 (5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (5)124 (277)187 (327)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (10)2.0 (3)3.7 (6)22 (42)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)64 (158)48 (94)10 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (7)1.1 (1)23 (50)10 (8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (7)3.7 (6)3.5 (2)4.2 (6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.5 (13)2.1 (3)2.6 (3)9.0 (13)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)2.5 (2)16 (24)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.5 (6)1.2 (1)10 (24)8.9 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (5)3.2 (5)4.3 (6)2.7 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (18)1.6 (2)2.9 (5)2.6 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)4.2 (3)9.4 (6)30830/10

Δ HVref
f40, 3-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
899
1e-2
8116
1e-3
31550
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.68 (0.8)2.1 (2)17 (37)15 (17)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)1.1 (0.9)87 (148)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)3.6 (3)9.4 (4)13 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)3.8 (3)4.2 (1)4.6 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)1.6 (1)17 (28)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)401 (584)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)1.1 (0.7)1.7 (1)28 (44)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.85 (0.8)0.82 (0.5)36 (42)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)18 (43)20 (29)89 (62)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)1.5 (2)2.2 (4)1.4 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.80 (1.0)1.0 (0.6)2.6 (5)5.8 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)10 (17)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (3)10 (17)9.4 (11)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.83 (0.4)2.8 (3)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.73 (0.8)0.85 (0.6)1.1 (1)4.6 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.9 (1)3.8 (1)30770/10

Δ HVref
f41, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
55
1e-2
456
1e-3
4400
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)14 (21)15 (9)4.7 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)3.9 (4)2.9 (1)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)29 (56)58 (63)27 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)17 (30)31 (26)11 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.2 (19)8.8 (11)6.5 (4)2.2 (0.7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)3.0 (2)5923 (5428)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)5.6 (6)3.9 (2)5.8 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)5.2 (4)2.8 (2)14 (20)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (5)4.0 (4)2.9 (2)13 (21)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (4)11 (19)8.9 (5)2.1 (0.5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)6.1 (9)3.8 (2)1.7 (0.6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)9.0 (8)10 (12)30 (57)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.1 (8)2.8 (2)2.9 (1)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)5.0 (4)3.8 (2)5.5 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)5.6 (5)3.5 (2)4.5 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)13 (14)9.1 (9)30820/10

Δ HVref
f42, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
981
1e-2
9715
1e-3
2.0e5
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)2.7 (4)49 (39)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (10)0.66 (0.7)124 (100)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 16 (38)6.8 (11)27 (34)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (8)4.1 (6)27 (16)3e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 10 (23)1.2 (1)73 (170)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)34 (77)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (18)0.76 (0.8)15 (33)3e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)0.78 (1.0)18 (24)15 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (9)1.1 (2)5.7 (8)4.5 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (8)1.7 (3)2.3 (4)14 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.5 (10)1.00 (1)6.2 (9)4.7 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)0.98 (1)2.4 (2)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.2 (9)0.72 (1)4.9 (4)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.65 (0.4)0.67 (0.7)3.8 (6)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.0 (21)0.74 (0.7)3.4 (3)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)1.3 (1)30790/10

Δ HVref
f43, 3-D
1e0
11
1e-1
971
1e-2
8225
1e-3
2.6e5
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (1)1.8 (2)2.7 (2)4.9 (7)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.43 (0.8)0.61 (0.5)86 (91)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.38 (0.7)4.2 (6)13 (12)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.79 (2)3.5 (5)5.9 (3)1.3 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)1.2 (1)5.5 (10)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.87 (2)35 (78)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.68 (1)0.82 (0.6)13 (18)5.1 (8)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.35 (0.6)0.52 (0.3)15 (19)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (3)0.48 (0.5)2.5 (2)3.5 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (5)1.3 (2)1.8 (2)0.70 (0.5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)0.68 (0.6)1.9 (2)1.3 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.36 (0.5)0.99 (0.8)3.3 (4)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.44 (0.8)0.55 (0.7)4.9 (5)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.33 (0.6)0.77 (0.4)2.3 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.87 (2)0.58 (0.4)2.2 (3)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.27 (0.4)1.3 (0.8)3.7 (4)30500/10

Δ HVref
f44, 3-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
519
1e-2
1675
1e-3
5358
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 6.1 (9)6.8 (13)48 (90)17 (28)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (11)65 (145)45 (90)25 (43)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 31 (73)32 (73)38 (64)31 (49)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)13 (27)16 (27)21 (45)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (7)2.7 (4)46 (179)15 (28)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (8)65 (145)77 (224)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (13)1.4 (2)2.0 (3)3.7 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.7 (15)2.1 (4)45 (90)17 (30)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (5)0.69 (0.9)21 (47)11 (22)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.1 (20)3.5 (6)2.6 (3)1.7 (1)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (8)1.5 (2)1.1 (1)7.1 (14)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (7)1.5 (2)5.1 (7)26 (32)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.6 (6)0.76 (2)1.3 (2)5.1 (7)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.2 (16)1.2 (2)2.5 (5)3.7 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (11)1.2 (2)3.0 (6)3.2 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (44)2.9 (3)2.7 (2)2.7 (4)0/10

Δ HVref
f45, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
280
1e-2
1904
1e-3
21523
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.73 (0.5)2.1 (2)3.9 (2)2.5 (4)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)0.98 (0.5)40 (79)126 (220)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)2.3 (3)11 (7)5.4 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)2.1 (3)6.9 (4)2.3 (0.4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)1.3 (1)19 (40)10 (28)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)0.66 (0.4)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)1.5 (2)5.3 (8)3.8 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.93 (0.8)1.3 (1)47 (206)18 (28)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (3)0.93 (1)40 (118)18 (33)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.83 (0.7)0.98 (0.8)1.9 (0.9)2.0 (4)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (2)0.83 (0.7)22 (48)10 (17)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)2.1 (2)18 (20)13 (8)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.73 (0.6)13 (28)65 (91)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)1.2 (1)3.8 (7)2.1 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)1.1 (1)1.1 (0.7)1.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (1)2.0 (2)4.8 (4)30820/10

Δ HVref
f46, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
1937
1e-2
26783
1e-3
3.2e5
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)2.1 (2)2.5 (3)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)0.65 (0.6)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)8.5 (11)6.7 (2)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)4.7 (6)2.9 (0.6)1.2 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)1.1 (0.8)27 (20)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (6)0.32 (0.2)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (10)0.80 (0.7)6.6 (16)3e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)0.70 (0.7)21 (24)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (5)28 (63)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)1.6 (1)15 (21)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (4)0.77 (0.3)3e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)0.93 (0.7)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.4 (7)1.1 (1)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (14)0.88 (0.9)11 (7)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)0.79 (0.7)11 (17)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (5)1.3 (1.0)30740/10

Δ HVref
f47, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
1404
1e-2
32368
1e-3
4.9e5
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)2.7 (4)5.5 (5)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)0.85 (0.9)84 (104)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)9.1 (15)8.7 (7)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)4.7 (7)4.0 (3)3e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)1.5 (2)22 (28)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)54 (160)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.87 (0.9)2.3 (2)3e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (5)0.56 (0.5)25 (26)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (4)3.1 (7)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (4)1.1 (2)1.6 (3)1.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (6)0.87 (0.8)9.1 (11)3e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)5.4 (10)9.1 (7)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (22)1.0 (2)4.2 (3)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (11)0.90 (1)4.1 (3)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)0.92 (1)2.6 (2)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (7)1.3 (1)30840/10

Δ HVref
f48, 3-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
483
1e-2
24290
1e-3
1.7e5
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)13 (26)13 (13)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (6)157 (312)111 (99)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (11)32 (66)5.9 (4)4.2 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)14 (24)7.7 (10)3.3 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (8)3.1 (4)19 (28)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)156 (621)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (5)2.0 (2)10 (14)7.8 (4)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)2.5 (5)8.1 (14)8.1 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (4)0.87 (1.0)52 (39)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (4)3.2 (5)5.6 (9)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.9 (9)2.2 (3)30 (22)3e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (13)3.9 (6)5.3 (7)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.7 (6)4.5 (11)1.0 (0.8)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (9)1.8 (2)1.2 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)1.6 (2)3.4 (5)1.7 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)3.3 (3)30840/10

Δ HVref
f49, 3-D
1e0
11
1e-1
1489
1e-2
12838
1e-3
1.3e5
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (8)2.8 (2)7.5 (12)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (5)0.91 (0.6)211 (129)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)8.0 (10)12 (3)3e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)6.2 (6)7.1 (7)3e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)1.5 (1)36 (93)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (9)87 (202)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)1.0 (0.8)11 (18)11 (7)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)0.72 (0.5)8.2 (13)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)1.9 (3)29 (65)20 (30)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)1.7 (2)0.68 (0.3)20 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (6)0.83 (0.7)13 (19)5.9 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (10)0.80 (0.9)3.4 (1)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (5)2.8 (6)6.2 (13)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)0.88 (0.7)3.1 (3)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)1.00 (1)3.4 (4)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)1.4 (1)30740/10

Δ HVref
f50, 3-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
1434
1e-2
28762
1e-3
5.5e5
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)3.3 (4)3.6 (6)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (11)1.1 (1)24 (34)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (13)12 (15)7.9 (7)5.4 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (9)6.9 (8)4.2 (6)1.2 (0.7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)1.7 (2)11 (8)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (4)140 (157)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)1.0 (1)3.1 (4)5.3 (7)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)0.67 (0.6)13 (16)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)0.83 (1)3.0 (4)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1)2.1 (2)1.9 (3)0.90 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)0.89 (0.8)1.2 (1)1.1 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)1.1 (1)2.8 (5)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (2)0.65 (0.8)2.7 (4)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (1)0.91 (1)1.4 (1)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (4)0.79 (0.7)1.4 (2)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)1.5 (1)1.0 (1)30800/10

Δ HVref
f51, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
922
1e-2
8936
1e-3
1.4e5
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)4.1 (8)5.6 (10)2.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)37 (82)8.8 (17)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.4 (13)11 (24)14 (15)10 (11)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 7.5 (14)7.4 (16)8.3 (28)1.2 (0.9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (8)1.7 (3)4.7 (9)19 (22)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (7)36 (163)134 (118)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (14)0.69 (1)5.2 (10)6.0 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (7)37 (82)8.9 (25)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)4.0 (9)36 (82)3e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (9)1.3 (3)0.87 (0.6)1.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)0.76 (1)4.9 (10)6.0 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)1.1 (1)5.1 (4)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.2 (10)2.0 (5)2.8 (6)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (7)0.54 (0.9)1.1 (3)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)0.57 (0.8)1.2 (1)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)0.94 (1)1.6 (2)30850/10

Δ HVref
f52, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
845
1e-2
14105
1e-3
1.4e5
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (2)3.0 (3)3.7 (6)3e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)1.2 (1)192 (165)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (10)6.1 (10)8.0 (8)6.8 (10)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (6)5.1 (7)3.3 (3)4.2 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (5)1.6 (2)10 (11)3e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (14)237 (444)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (6)1.0 (0.9)5.4 (8)20 (18)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (7)0.83 (0.6)11 (11)20 (39)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (7)0.55 (0.4)1.9 (2)2.7 (6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.9 (9)1.5 (2)2.8 (5)0.76 (1.0)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (3)0.77 (0.7)1.4 (3)0.76 (0.6)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (6)2.0 (3)3.9 (3)3e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.0 (6)0.80 (0.8)4.1 (5)3e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (2)0.88 (0.6)1.5 (2)3e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (5)0.80 (0.8)1.1 (1)3e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)2.1 (2)1.0 (0.8)30860/10

Δ HVref
f53, 3-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
6.0
1e-2
32
1e-3
240
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)3.3 (3)5.3 (4)10 (4)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)5.8 (7)4.4 (2)3.1 (0.8)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)5.6 (7)5.9 (3)26 (11)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)4.0 (6)8.9 (6)15 (7)8/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)3.6 (5)6.2 (5)5.2 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (12)4.0 (5)2.9 (1)1251 (2813)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)3.1 (4)5.5 (4)3.5 (1)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)4.3 (7)6.0 (4)2.4 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)3.7 (4)2.2 (1)2.4 (0.6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)4.6 (6)6.5 (4)6.9 (4)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (9)5.1 (9)3.8 (2)4.3 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)5.7 (7)8.8 (2)4.6 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.0 (10)4.6 (6)3.2 (2)1.4 (0.9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (5)2.1 (2)7.2 (6)2.9 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (12)10 (14)7.2 (3)3.6 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)7.1 (14)12 (10)5.7 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 3-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
193
1e-2
2668
1e-3
17832
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (14)1.9 (2)2.5 (2)2.8 (5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (2)1.2 (0.9)29 (113)67 (63)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (4)2.3 (3)4.0 (5)5.8 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (1)2.7 (5)4.3 (3)2.5 (1)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (4)1.6 (2)13 (57)17 (17)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (8)0.98 (1)1012 (1743)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (5)2.1 (2)2.8 (5)3.2 (10)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (6)1.6 (2)27 (46)28 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (7)7.5 (18)101 (168)67 (76)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.9 (8)1.5 (1)1.0 (0.8)4.5 (8)5/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.2 (9)1.7 (3)13 (29)4.4 (17)2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (1)18 (40)18 (49)7.1 (11)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (3)20 (45)14 (17)4.5 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (10)1.3 (1)0.88 (0.8)0.60 (0.8)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (3)1.8 (2)2.1 (4)1.4 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (2)3.1 (3)1.8 (1)1.7 (0.9)0/10

Δ HVref
f55, 3-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
564
1e-2
2563
1e-3
94621
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 12 (26)2.8 (2)3.9 (1)0.60 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (14)1.5 (1)274 (468)3e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 21 (49)4.4 (6)15 (10)1.5 (0.4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (7)4.2 (5)7.8 (4)0.94 (0.9)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.1 (12)1.6 (2)52 (117)4.9 (9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)532 (665)3e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (4)1.7 (1)4.1 (5)1.1 (1)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (14)1.2 (1)16 (36)3.6 (6)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.1 (8)71 (153)93 (117)8.4 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (6)2.2 (2)1.8 (0.7)0.89 (2)3/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (2)60 (134)51 (59)7.4 (5)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (20)2.0 (2)13 (15)0.64 (0.8)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 14 (30)17 (27)30 (58)3.2 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)1.1 (0.6)2.2 (3)0.46 (0.2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (33)0.98 (0.9)13 (21)0.87 (0.9)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.4 (15)2.4 (2)12 (6)30720/10

Previous dimension | Dimension = 5 | Next dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 5-D
1e0
1
1e-1
75
1e-2
584
1e-3
3660
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (0.5)20 (12)20 (4)8.7 (0.8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (18)6.8 (4)4.0 (0.6)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)44 (50)112 (36)53 (7)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (2)33 (23)49 (13)21 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)13 (9)8.5 (2)4.6 (0.8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.9 (15)3.3 (2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)7.9 (3)4.4 (0.6)15 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (0.8)7.3 (2)3.8 (0.9)45 (37)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.8 (12)5.4 (3)6.2 (2)21 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (6)11 (10)12 (2)4.0 (0.2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.1 (8)10 (7)4.9 (0.7)5.7 (0.7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)11 (6)5.5 (1)9.3 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.8 (10)3.4 (2)6.0 (2)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)8.8 (3)5.2 (1)67 (103)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)7.2 (4)4.5 (1)133 (161)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)17 (6)27 (20)50510/10

Δ HVref
f2, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
105
1e-2
601
1e-3
3715
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (11)34 (46)22 (13)8.7 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.1 (9)6.0 (6)3.9 (2)1213 (1480)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (6)117 (202)143 (109)59 (23)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (8)64 (110)55 (37)22 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 15 (35)14 (16)8.8 (5)3.7 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (27)3.2 (3)1943 (3536)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (12)6.5 (4)3.2 (0.8)3.2 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.3 (13)5.4 (3)2.8 (1)28 (71)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (13)3.9 (4)97 (212)52 (73)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (22)17 (20)11 (4)3.7 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.6 (9)7.1 (7)4.7 (1)4.9 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (5)159 (363)225 (146)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.5 (7)2.4 (1)2.7 (1)12 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.0 (21)6.1 (4)3.7 (1)4.3 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (5)6.0 (3)3.2 (0.7)2.3 (0.9)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)12 (8)9.4 (7)50480/10

Δ HVref
f3, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
115
1e-2
665
1e-3
5170
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)21 (25)20 (10)6.5 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.57 (0.5)4.7 (4)3.3 (1)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (7)74 (142)121 (90)43 (17)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (8)40 (59)50 (31)16 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)12 (12)8.1 (4)27 (48)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (8)2.2 (2)3009 (2820)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)6.1 (4)4.4 (3)34 (75)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.60 (0.6)487 (1089)86 (189)56 (160)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (10)3.5 (3)5.7 (7)29 (42)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (6)11 (15)10 (3)2.8 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)8.3 (6)4.4 (1)4.7 (5)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)14 (14)137 (89)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.5 (2)2.9 (2)3.8 (4)92 (121)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)7.4 (4)4.9 (4)14 (22)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.60 (0.6)5.9 (5)4.1 (3)13 (13)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (5)12 (7)13 (10)50520/10

Δ HVref
f4, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
109
1e-2
571
1e-3
2669
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)15 (10)20 (6)11 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (17)4.8 (3)3.4 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (8)46 (73)122 (57)74 (15)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)26 (38)49 (20)27 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)8.5 (5)8.3 (2)4.5 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (12)2.0 (1)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)5.8 (2)4.0 (0.7)5.6 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (16)4.5 (2)3.1 (0.8)522 (478)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (11)3.2 (3)3.3 (2)41 (58)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)10 (11)12 (3)5.0 (0.7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.8 (21)7.5 (6)4.6 (1)4.8 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (61)13 (8)39 (34)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (1)1.8 (1.0)2.8 (2)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)5.0 (3)4.6 (2)16 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)5.2 (3)3.8 (1)5.1 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)11 (7)28 (51)50460/10

Δ HVref
f5, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
120
1e-2
1277
1e-3
21889
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)27 (13)17 (2)3.4 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.70 (0.5)6.1 (2)2.8 (0.7)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)71 (43)145 (37)42 (24)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)48 (24)50 (14)9.2 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.65 (0.4)12 (7)6.7 (2)1.8 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)3.1 (1)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.65 (0.4)7.2 (2)11 (8)66 (51)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.65 (0.4)6.1 (2)4.1 (0.9)20 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)4.9 (1)16 (21)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)16 (12)7.4 (1)3.7 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.65 (0.4)10 (3)21 (44)21 (36)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)12 (4)21 (16)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.3 (7)4.4 (3)11 (12)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.95 (1)7.9 (3)7.7 (6)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)7.6 (2)5.5 (3)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)15 (7)50460/10

Δ HVref
f6, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
73
1e-2
688
1e-3
3976
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (8)34 (30)20 (8)8.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (1)8.5 (5)3.4 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (11)117 (152)131 (66)57 (13)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)62 (74)52 (22)21 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)17 (17)8.2 (3)4.4 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (11)4.3 (3)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (9)10 (6)5.1 (2)16 (11)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.77 (1)7.8 (4)31 (67)332 (474)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.8 (9)6.4 (3)5.6 (4)73 (71)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (28)27 (28)11 (4)3.7 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)12 (9)4.4 (1)7.2 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (2)11 (5)7.2 (5)29 (28)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.93 (1)3.8 (2)5.5 (3)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (2)10 (5)5.0 (2)125 (101)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)9.2 (5)4.3 (1)35 (22)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)20 (12)50480/10

Δ HVref
f7, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
2763
1e-2
1.2e5
1e-3
3.5e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)3.3 (4)6.6 (4)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.65 (0.4)0.73 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)14 (16)12 (9)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)7.6 (10)5.3 (6)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (11)1.3 (1)36 (33)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)45 (136)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (9)1.00 (1)11 (12)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)2.0 (4)39 (48)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.90 (1)1.0 (2)18 (16)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (2)1.7 (1)5.2 (6)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)0.69 (0.4)2.8 (3)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)0.97 (0.8)3.9 (5)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.85 (0.9)0.76 (1)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)0.84 (0.8)3.8 (3)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)0.81 (0.9)4.0 (4)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)1.4 (1)50480/10

Δ HVref
f8, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
2167
1e-2
1.6e5
1e-3
2.1e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 19 (43)4.7 (3)1.9 (3)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (14)0.94 (0.5)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 16 (36)20 (15)7.3 (8)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (6)10 (7)1.5 (1)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 10 (20)2.1 (1)13 (19)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)154 (173)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (45)0.85 (0.5)6.5 (5)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (6)0.79 (0.6)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (26)0.97 (2)16 (15)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)2.6 (1)1.3 (2)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (27)1.1 (0.4)1.7 (2)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)2.6 (5)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.5 (4)1.3 (2)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (6)0.94 (0.6)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (8)0.87 (0.4)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (12)1.4 (0.5)50590/10

Δ HVref
f9, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
96
1e-2
521
1e-3
1986
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.9 (19)18 (21)22 (8)14 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)4.9 (5)3.5 (0.9)381 (504)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.9)37 (54)127 (77)94 (21)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (10)28 (39)53 (24)35 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (8)10 (10)8.8 (3)5.6 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (15)2.9 (2)961 (1200)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (12)5.9 (3)3.5 (0.8)3.9 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.9 (17)4.0 (2)2.5 (0.9)6.7 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (9)3.6 (4)3.1 (2)14 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (34)14 (22)12 (5)6.3 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (9)7.3 (6)5.0 (1)4.3 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (6)14 (5)18 (16)250 (360)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.5 (11)2.0 (0.8)1.9 (1.0)24 (28)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)6.4 (3)3.9 (1)7.6 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (6)6.1 (3)3.5 (1)4.7 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)14 (7)8.1 (3)50460/10

Δ HVref
f10, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
323
1e-2
9839
1e-3
52107
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 16 (31)13 (7)2.2 (0.7)11 (10)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.9 (10)3.9 (2)22 (38)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (8)44 (38)14 (3)6.8 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)25 (15)5.5 (1)3.4 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 10 (20)7.3 (3)0.80 (0.1)23 (31)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (12)174 (774)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)4.2 (2)12 (25)18 (14)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (12)3.1 (1)63 (86)91 (79)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (5)1.7 (0.7)34 (57)88 (82)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (32)8.4 (6)0.96 (0.2)4.4 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.8 (17)4.3 (2)0.38 (0.1)10 (13)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (28)4.9 (2)4.2 (7)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)1.5 (1)9.1 (11)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (16)4.0 (2)2.2 (3)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (6)4.0 (3)5.8 (12)9.2 (10)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (28)7.1 (2)50500/10

Δ HVref
f11, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
56
1e-2
436
1e-3
9189
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)10 (22)12 (22)3.1 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)4.0 (8)2.9 (4)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (6)12 (28)50 (115)13 (19)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (3)16 (37)24 (51)6.0 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)6.8 (16)5.8 (10)15 (27)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)2.3 (5)288 (574)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (9)3.8 (7)2.5 (2)1.9 (2)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (5)2.6 (4)2.2 (2)1.1 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)1.8 (3)4.4 (9)11 (34)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)5.4 (12)4.3 (7)1.5 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)2.9 (6)2.1 (3)1.0 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (5)3.7 (7)3.6 (3)2.0 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (4)2.3 (3)2.8 (3)2.9 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (2)3.0 (5)2.6 (3)1.8 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)3.5 (6)2.7 (3)1.8 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (5)8.0 (15)4.5 (5)50560/10

Δ HVref
f12, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
44
1e-2
641
1e-3
3991
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (1)29 (64)11 (20)4.6 (7)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)8.5 (13)2.1 (3)54 (63)4/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (3)47 (99)72 (152)33 (51)3/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (1)72 (173)28 (55)11 (17)7/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)20 (38)5.0 (8)16 (34)5/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (5)4.3 (6)87 (196)54 (63)1/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)11 (13)95 (210)55 (157)4/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)20 (41)217 (430)127 (376)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (4)5.6 (9)87 (196)32 (63)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (11)16 (29)4.6 (7)7.3 (16)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.5 (8)7.5 (14)2.0 (3)32 (64)5/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)140 (296)39 (105)13 (28)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.7 (9)4.9 (5)29 (39)8.5 (31)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.96 (1)10 (16)13 (24)6.7 (8)1/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (5)10 (16)14 (27)6.1 (13)4/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (1)21 (28)5.9 (9)1.5 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f13, 5-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
60
1e-2
560
1e-3
5582
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (12)15 (20)11 (12)3.6 (3)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (7)6.1 (6)2.1 (2)10 (45)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (15)35 (67)52 (71)24 (23)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)27 (47)20 (26)10 (8)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (9)13 (18)5.3 (5)1.4 (1)5/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (6)3.4 (4)0.98 (0.8)135 (246)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (22)5.7 (5)1.9 (1)0.74 (0.6)5/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (10)5.4 (5)2.7 (4)23 (68)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (3)4.1 (4)101 (225)12 (26)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.6 (14)5.5 (7)5.4 (4)1.5 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (9)6.5 (10)102 (224)11 (24)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)8.3 (7)20 (38)7.7 (12)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.5 (8)2.1 (2)0.82 (0.7)0.45 (0.6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.3 (19)5.7 (7)2.0 (2)1.7 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.0 (17)5.9 (7)1.8 (1)0.78 (0.7)3/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (31)12 (11)3.8 (3)1.2 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f14, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
247
1e-2
1713
1e-3
12801
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.54 (0.4)27 (15)17 (5)5.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)5.2 (2)2.6 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)101 (89)126 (28)50 (61)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)49 (39)46 (7)13 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)13 (5)6.5 (1)8.0 (11)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (2)2.1 (0.7)1168 (2554)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (3)7.9 (5)447 (584)360 (596)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)5.3 (5)686 (1534)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.72 (0.8)228 (507)311 (232)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.60 (0.5)16 (10)202 (220)108 (109)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (1)231 (507)310 (317)171 (137)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)199 (533)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.94 (1)3.0 (5)33 (75)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)6.7 (5)39 (31)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)5.4 (3)35 (29)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.76 (0.8)11 (17)50500/10

Δ HVref
f15, 5-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
74
1e-2
677
1e-3
6559
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (21)59 (74)24 (15)5.8 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (19)12 (12)4.1 (2)116 (134)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.0 (18)107 (129)165 (134)43 (21)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 14 (31)100 (161)60 (40)16 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.2 (19)29 (37)10 (6)2.4 (0.8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (26)5.0 (4)740 (739)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)10 (9)5.2 (4)6.1 (7)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.9 (21)6.2 (4)100 (399)145 (80)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (28)5.8 (8)88 (189)333 (582)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 17 (40)30 (36)11 (5)2.7 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.9 (17)13 (12)5.0 (2)18 (50)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (39)476 (525)672 (722)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.6 (6)5.2 (5)6.7 (10)69 (109)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (49)10 (8)5.9 (5)16 (27)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)7.1 (7)3.7 (2)3.5 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (39)21 (20)23 (21)50480/10

Δ HVref
f16, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
2810
1e-2
2.0e5
1e-3
4.2e6
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.63 (0.5)2.5 (3)0.27 (0.2)0.50 (0.6)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)0.60 (0.6)5.8 (9)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (5)12 (16)1.8 (1.0)1.2 (0.7)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (1)5.2 (6)0.65 (0.3)0.34 (0.2)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)1.5 (2)1.1 (2)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (12)0.27 (0.2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (6)1.3 (2)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.81 (1)10 (13)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)178 (267)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (3)1.6 (1)6.0 (4)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (6)0.58 (0.6)22 (22)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)19 (25)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (3)1.1 (2)0.65 (0.3)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)2.7 (6)2.2 (4)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)2.6 (5)2.2 (3)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)0.99 (1)50510/10

Δ HVref
f17, 5-D
1e0
29
1e-1
2935
1e-2
48624
1e-3
2.4e6
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 51 (127)3.3 (5)2.2 (3)0.34 (0.2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (20)0.79 (1)24 (31)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 218 (544)20 (37)8.2 (6)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 59 (146)8.1 (14)2.9 (2)0.31 (0.6)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (22)1.6 (2)4.8 (5)0.83 (1.0)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (10)43 (85)24 (26)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (11)8.0 (19)41 (57)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (8)16 (40)45 (76)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)44 (85)96 (51)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (30)1.7 (3)25 (59)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.1 (17)0.73 (0.9)41 (39)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (9)40 (60)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.0 (2)3.6 (6)4.6 (6)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (9)1.4 (3)4.4 (6)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (7)0.76 (1)4.2 (5)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (14)1.1 (2)50540/10

Δ HVref
f18, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
56
1e-2
557
1e-3
6912
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (8)5.6 (10)7.6 (9)4.7 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 12 (24)3.0 (4)2.1 (2)109 (127)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (4)9.1 (19)32 (57)28 (21)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)4.1 (7)16 (26)11 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.6 (5)5.0 (9)3.8 (4)1.9 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.2 (12)2.4 (3)0.89 (0.5)651 (434)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (5)3.6 (5)1.8 (0.8)1.1 (0.9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (5)2.7 (3)1.7 (1)33 (73)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.2 (10)2.5 (3)1.3 (1)5.8 (8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.0 (18)3.2 (4)3.6 (4)1.2 (0.4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.9 (15)2.9 (4)2.1 (2)1.2 (1)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (6)4.5 (6)8.3 (6)14 (25)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.6 (6)1.5 (1)0.89 (0.6)3.7 (6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (6)3.4 (5)2.0 (1)1.1 (0.9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (6)3.3 (4)1.7 (1)0.91 (0.6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (7)7.1 (9)3.2 (1)7.1 (6)0/10

Δ HVref
f19, 5-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
1292
1e-2
6164
1e-3
88464
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (10)2.5 (3)2.4 (1)0.39 (0.2)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)1.0 (1.0)122 (203)51 (47)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (9)6.1 (7)13 (7)2.5 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (17)4.1 (6)5.5 (3)0.92 (0.4)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (7)1.8 (2)10 (20)2.6 (6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)43 (97)730 (1136)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.6 (12)4.2 (9)40 (41)9.3 (10)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)44 (97)127 (192)53 (116)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (3)0.39 (0.1)190 (223)23 (24)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)1.4 (1)10 (21)0.77 (1)4/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (3)0.71 (0.5)55 (122)8.5 (14)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.3 (16)22 (19)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (3)0.25 (0.2)11 (16)2.5 (3)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)4.9 (10)4.9 (6)0.98 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (9)2.9 (6)4.2 (5)0.52 (0.7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (18)1.6 (1)1.4 (0.8)50500/10

Δ HVref
f20, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
70
1e-2
1162
1e-3
5724
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 33 (80)26 (35)11 (8)6.5 (4)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.7 (12)7.3 (7)1.8 (1)204 (153)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (20)78 (121)69 (67)46 (29)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 16 (38)50 (64)28 (24)18 (11)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 20 (50)18 (18)4.6 (3)25 (44)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.4 (12)3.8 (3)431 (646)350 (699)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (37)11 (8)50 (109)16 (26)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (15)8.2 (10)109 (216)39 (44)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (8)4.9 (5)50 (111)27 (70)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (35)17 (26)5.2 (3)3.7 (5)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.8 (17)12 (11)50 (216)12 (23)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (73)26 (41)13 (33)8.4 (15)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.5 (14)4.4 (4)7.6 (25)35 (46)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (27)8.1 (9)7.3 (13)8.9 (11)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (20)8.5 (7)6.8 (12)8.1 (9)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 27 (66)16 (13)4.9 (6)4.1 (3)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
86
1e-2
3249
1e-3
9924
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (7)21 (27)3.5 (3)3.3 (2)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 13 (21)5.9 (6)0.67 (0.7)76 (50)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (11)61 (85)24 (25)22 (16)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (13)36 (46)10 (11)8.4 (6)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (11)10 (14)1.8 (2)7.9 (15)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (5)2.5 (2)154 (154)76 (139)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (8)6.7 (7)18 (39)7.2 (14)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (7)650 (1457)18 (77)78 (115)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (6)4.0 (4)18 (39)8.7 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.7 (15)14 (19)1.5 (1)1.1 (0.7)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (7)8.4 (10)18 (39)7.0 (14)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (15)14 (20)3.6 (6)9.0 (10)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.8 (10)2.6 (3)2.2 (4)12 (19)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (7)8.4 (10)2.5 (8)4.2 (5)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (6)7.8 (10)2.4 (4)1.9 (3)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (37)17 (35)1.4 (1)1.1 (0.8)0/10

Δ HVref
f22, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
97
1e-2
1168
1e-3
12608
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 16 (38)43 (47)22 (8)5.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)8.5 (6)3.5 (1)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 9.4 (22)165 (311)150 (69)41 (32)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 15 (36)92 (127)56 (21)14 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)18 (22)7.7 (2)14 (20)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (25)4.1 (3)3857 (2783)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)11 (7)91 (290)78 (56)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.7 (13)581 (1292)115 (215)96 (50)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (23)5.9 (4)125 (216)380 (307)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (24)21 (25)13 (14)14 (16)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.87 (1)12 (8)17 (30)23 (28)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.9 (18)96 (96)411 (322)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.3 (10)5.6 (6)34 (76)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (33)11 (8)15 (17)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (20)13 (10)17 (24)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 31 (76)20 (12)50500/10

Δ HVref
f23, 5-D
1e0
1
1e-1
59
1e-2
618
1e-3
4410
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)21 (23)21 (10)7.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)8.0 (6)4.0 (2)266 (227)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)49 (69)124 (88)52 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)41 (49)51 (32)19 (5)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (0.2)14 (16)8.5 (4)16 (29)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)4.4 (3)1889 (3439)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (2)9.1 (10)4.9 (3)23 (34)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (0.5)6.7 (6)5.6 (5)76 (99)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (0.5)5.5 (5)35 (73)98 (94)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (3)15 (25)10 (4)3.7 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (5)8.6 (11)4.2 (2)11 (16)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (0.5)475 (685)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (1)3.9 (5)7.6 (7)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)9.3 (7)4.8 (2)23 (61)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)8.9 (8)5.3 (2)13 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)18 (15)24 (25)50520/10

Δ HVref
f24, 5-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
2347
1e-2
1.8e5
1e-3
4.1e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)4.0 (3)0.36 (0.1)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)0.85 (0.5)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.86 (1)19 (21)2.3 (0.2)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)10 (8)0.88 (0.1)0.54 (0.6)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (17)2.2 (2)4.4 (7)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (2)0.40 (0.2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.76 (1)1.3 (1)27 (51)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)24 (54)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.6 (5)76 (213)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)2.1 (1)27 (22)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1)1.1 (0.5)26 (36)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)27 (33)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.94 (1)1.4 (2)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (7)0.91 (0.4)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)1.4 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.96 (2)1.8 (1)50520/10

Δ HVref
f25, 5-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
3143
1e-2
1.2e5
1e-3
2.5e6
#succ
3/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 14 (35)2.8 (3)0.99 (2)0.36 (0.3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (13)0.62 (0.5)9.4 (19)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (10)15 (20)6.3 (5)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (12)6.9 (7)1.4 (0.9)0.33 (0.5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 12 (30)1.3 (1)2.8 (5)1.8 (0.8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (8)18 (40)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (6)18 (40)11 (11)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (8)19 (41)11 (14)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (4)71 (80)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.81 (2)1.5 (1)3.3 (6)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (8)0.70 (0.6)36 (20)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (15)39 (68)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (2)2.7 (5)1.8 (1)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (10)0.62 (0.5)3.7 (4)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (4)1.0 (1)1.7 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.4 (13)1.4 (2)50460/10

Δ HVref
f26, 5-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
59
1e-2
2182
1e-3
13673
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)21 (20)5.6 (8)5.9 (10)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (18)7.6 (7)26 (58)37 (37)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 15 (25)46 (64)30 (53)19 (18)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.4 (10)40 (50)13 (20)10 (13)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (11)17 (17)2.3 (3)4.9 (10)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.9 (9)3.7 (3)26 (115)85 (155)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.9 (10)11 (9)0.78 (0.8)4.5 (10)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (20)12 (18)58 (172)13 (18)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.9 (13)4.7 (5)27 (59)10 (18)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (22)13 (17)2.0 (2)10 (19)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.4 (11)8.4 (9)26 (58)4.4 (9)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (22)14 (15)3.9 (7)3.1 (3)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.3 (11)3.0 (2)0.56 (1)1.5 (6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (23)8.0 (6)3.2 (6)1.4 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.4 (12)7.3 (6)0.67 (0.6)1.1 (2)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (37)20 (11)1.6 (1)1.1 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 5-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
2631
1e-2
21971
1e-3
44576
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 27 (64)1.2 (1)0.83 (0.5)5.5 (11)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 15 (35)0.41 (0.2)23 (46)45 (45)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (11)6.3 (8)5.1 (3)5.9 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)2.8 (3)2.0 (1)2.1 (0.9)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 21 (51)0.72 (0.5)2.9 (6)11 (11)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (19)21 (48)91 (131)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 23 (53)0.59 (0.4)7.8 (11)9.2 (12)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (27)21 (48)23 (34)49 (55)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (7)0.27 (0.1)55 (109)45 (101)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (36)0.97 (0.7)0.36 (0.2)3.1 (8)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (33)0.42 (0.3)10 (17)17 (28)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)8.8 (15)9.3 (11)5.3 (5)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 14 (32)0.19 (0.1)9.1 (6)4.6 (4)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (9)0.45 (0.5)3.6 (4)4.8 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (23)0.61 (0.6)2.6 (2)4.7 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (34)0.70 (0.4)1.1 (1)50560/10

Δ HVref
f28, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
20
1e-2
145
1e-3
1230
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (17)36 (60)35 (26)16 (4)8/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 10 (24)10 (4)7.5 (3)2.9 (1)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (16)36 (49)154 (137)112 (49)2/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 22 (53)45 (77)62 (55)41 (16)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.65 (0.4)19 (18)17 (8)6.4 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (13)7.2 (4)3.8 (1)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)16 (16)8.3 (2)6.4 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)18 (10)7.5 (3)459 (780)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.0 (16)11 (8)5.2 (2)129 (206)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)18 (15)25 (12)7.4 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.0 (19)14 (13)11 (3)6.8 (8)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (11)26 (23)13 (6)36 (55)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.0 (6)8.2 (5)4.4 (3)54 (26)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)16 (8)8.6 (4)16 (22)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.7 (18)18 (15)8.6 (3)4.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (14)31 (28)16 (6)50450/10

Δ HVref
f29, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
114
1e-2
1413
1e-3
13660
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 41 (102)54 (46)18 (6)5.8 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (14)11 (6)2.8 (0.9)331 (284)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (32)223 (328)147 (62)54 (55)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)93 (92)52 (18)14 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 14 (35)21 (18)6.9 (2)2.3 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (10)3.9 (2)1417 (1769)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (14)12 (8)99 (183)160 (229)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)11 (7)49 (95)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.1 (11)6.1 (3)97 (179)349 (476)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)33 (24)36 (70)55 (60)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)15 (9)54 (112)69 (107)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (47)61 (41)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.7 (8)5.6 (5)21 (28)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.7 (13)11 (6)15 (25)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)14 (9)20 (21)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.0 (22)23 (11)50520/10

Δ HVref
f30, 5-D
1e0
1
1e-1
33
1e-2
366
1e-3
2294
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)41 (66)34 (14)13 (3)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)14 (15)5.4 (2)329 (164)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)142 (274)213 (142)97 (22)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.7 (12)67 (95)84 (52)35 (8)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 19 (44)31 (38)14 (6)5.3 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 9.1 (20)7.3 (5)344 (684)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (13)17 (16)6.8 (3)8.5 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (0.8)16 (14)5.7 (3)421 (480)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.3 (16)11 (8)10 (17)87 (122)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (0.5)37 (46)17 (7)6.3 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (27)14 (17)6.0 (2)6.3 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (5)162 (235)1253 (1745)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 8.6 (19)6.8 (5)4.5 (4)67 (46)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (60)15 (13)6.6 (3)18 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (11)14 (12)5.8 (3)7.7 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (7)38 (22)23 (39)50470/10

Δ HVref
f31, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
2166
1e-2
50028
1e-3
3.2e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (14)4.2 (4)1.1 (0.4)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.0 (15)0.97 (0.6)90 (137)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 10 (19)20 (21)7.4 (2)1.5 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (9)10 (10)2.7 (1)0.44 (0.4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (16)1.8 (2)15 (15)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (12)26 (58)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (23)1.7 (3)27 (34)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)1.2 (2)45 (75)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (7)77 (117)91 (70)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.8 (11)2.2 (2)90 (115)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (7)1.1 (0.8)93 (132)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (16)22 (24)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.4 (16)2.1 (4)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.7 (15)1.0 (1)9.2 (12)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)0.80 (0.6)9.1 (18)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (55)1.4 (1)50540/10

Δ HVref
f32, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
2131
1e-2
1.1e5
1e-3
2.4e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (12)2.7 (3)0.53 (0.3)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.5 (18)0.55 (0.4)10 (11)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (27)12 (15)3.7 (2)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (19)6.6 (7)1.2 (0.6)0.63 (0.5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 13 (31)1.4 (1)2.1 (6)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (9)0.26 (0.2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.8 (11)0.57 (0.4)11 (18)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (12)1.3 (2)19 (26)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (8)101 (235)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)1.4 (1)7.0 (11)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (7)0.74 (0.5)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (43)29 (39)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.9 (19)1.1 (2)4.0 (4)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (7)0.84 (0.8)1.9 (2)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)0.57 (0.3)1.9 (3)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)0.99 (0.7)50500/10

Δ HVref
f33, 5-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
627
1e-2
1214
1e-3
3730
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)90 (200)50 (108)20 (37)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 11 (20)89 (200)47 (311)34 (67)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 43 (100)54 (133)65 (134)46 (60)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 31 (74)25 (60)53 (121)28 (41)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 12 (21)89 (200)48 (105)17 (35)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)89 (200)46 (103)134 (268)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (31)1.5 (3)47 (104)16 (35)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (25)89 (200)104 (206)34 (67)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.1 (15)89 (200)103 (309)34 (101)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 22 (47)89 (200)48 (105)17 (34)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 19 (31)1.6 (3)104 (206)34 (101)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (29)10 (20)11 (21)4.3 (10)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.8 (11)9.2 (20)11 (21)3.8 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (27)1.4 (3)11 (21)4.0 (7)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (30)1.7 (3)4.8 (10)2.5 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 44 (62)2.2 (3)2.0 (2)1.9 (0.7)0/10

Δ HVref
f34, 5-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
1376
1e-2
15575
1e-3
54195
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)2.2 (2)1.1 (0.4)3.0 (7)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (4)0.58 (0.3)8.2 (16)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)8.5 (10)6.6 (2)4.6 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)4.1 (3)2.9 (1.0)1.6 (0.4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)1.4 (1)0.45 (0.2)4.2 (5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (3)41 (91)289 (449)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)0.78 (0.4)22 (16)14 (19)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)0.59 (0.3)32 (32)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)0.44 (0.1)81 (117)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1.0)1.4 (1)0.51 (0.1)6.4 (5)2/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)0.68 (0.5)32 (104)83 (81)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)5.1 (8)30 (25)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.92 (2)10 (37)29 (41)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.54 (0.6)0.61 (0.3)7.7 (7)9.0 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.76 (0.9)0.72 (0.4)5.7 (8)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.92 (1)1.2 (0.5)3.2 (2)50460/10

Δ HVref
f35, 5-D
1e0
1
1e-1
141
1e-2
2268
1e-3
51388
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (7)28 (22)10 (3)1.7 (0.5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (2)6.6 (3)2.6 (2)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (4)95 (115)75 (28)12 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (1)48 (39)28 (10)3.4 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)14 (10)4.1 (0.8)2.6 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (0.5)2.9 (2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)7.6 (3)47 (82)93 (102)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (10)6.7 (4)60 (111)16 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (6)4.4 (2)340 (220)96 (105)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.9 (7)22 (17)35 (66)14 (21)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (1)9.2 (7)118 (236)25 (24)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (10)10 (5)15 (19)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.3 (3)3.4 (2)38 (41)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)8.3 (4)21 (35)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)7.2 (5)20 (39)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (10)14 (7)50530/10

Δ HVref
f36, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
204
1e-2
4640
1e-3
41237
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (9)32 (18)8.3 (4)3.0 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)5.3 (2)1.1 (0.5)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)115 (98)77 (38)118 (91)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)59 (36)31 (19)10 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)14 (7)2.8 (1.0)1.2 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)2.1 (0.5)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)6.1 (2)54 (58)116 (188)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)5.2 (3)119 (190)110 (133)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)3.1 (1)51 (84)116 (82)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)17 (11)4.9 (5)5.4 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.3 (20)8.2 (3)19 (35)10 (30)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)8.9 (7)23 (23)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.80 (0.8)3.0 (1)30 (29)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)6.4 (3)16 (15)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)6.1 (3)8.4 (8)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)10 (4)50520/10

Δ HVref
f37, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
3956
1e-2
1.5e5
1e-3
2.5e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (1)3.2 (2)2.0 (4)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.2)0.62 (0.4)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)19 (15)3.2 (1)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)8.0 (5)1.0 (0.2)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.70 (0.5)1.3 (0.8)31 (33)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.8 (8)54 (127)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)0.83 (0.6)31 (33)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)0.80 (0.8)31 (27)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (4)54 (127)31 (31)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)1.6 (0.9)6.2 (9)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)0.64 (0.3)31 (15)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)2.3 (3)3.2 (4)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.55 (0.1)0.91 (1)3.4 (3)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)0.79 (0.7)3.2 (2)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)1.0 (0.8)3.1 (5)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)1.7 (1)50480/10

Δ HVref
f38, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
4366
1e-2
2.7e5
1e-3
5.4e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (1)4.6 (3)17 (14)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)29 (57)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)26 (15)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (7)12 (6)3.0 (2)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 14 (34)2.1 (1)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (10)115 (200)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)1.1 (0.7)17 (11)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1.9 (3)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)11 (19)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)1.8 (0.8)1.9 (3)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)0.68 (0.3)5.1 (8)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)28 (27)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.4 (17)3.2 (5)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)2.0 (3)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)1.0 (0.9)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (13)3.5 (5)50460/10

Δ HVref
f39, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
215
1e-2
1160
1e-3
47472
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (11)19 (10)22 (8)1.9 (0.8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.4 (10)4.5 (2)3.3 (0.8)25 (47)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)79 (80)176 (66)13 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)41 (38)61 (22)4.1 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)9.4 (5)8.7 (3)0.77 (0.4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)1.9 (0.9)1007 (1078)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)4.6 (3)197 (550)96 (121)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)3.8 (1)290 (324)46 (46)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.85 (0.9)4.3 (4)168 (218)44 (68)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)12 (9)87 (126)10 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (6)5.7 (4)115 (217)18 (29)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)11 (6)114 (70)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.85 (0.9)1.7 (1)23 (22)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)5.7 (5)41 (32)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)5.2 (3)22 (25)10 (11)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)8.1 (2)50480/10

Δ HVref
f40, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
998
1e-2
34442
1e-3
2.0e5
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (4)9.3 (3)2.6 (4)11 (16)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (7)1.5 (0.3)131 (181)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)41 (15)7.5 (2)6.2 (7)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (11)19 (7)2.8 (0.6)2.3 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)3.9 (1)10 (11)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)335 (501)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (3)3.3 (3)12 (12)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)1.7 (1)16 (33)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (6)57 (126)131 (91)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (2)4.6 (0.9)0.41 (0.1)1.4 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (5)2.0 (0.6)6.6 (7)11 (12)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)13 (20)14 (13)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (1)6.8 (26)6.4 (8)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)7.5 (13)3.9 (1)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (8)2.5 (2)1.1 (0.9)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (3)3.1 (0.7)50540/10

Δ HVref
f41, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
48
1e-2
708
1e-3
6343
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)53 (61)20 (11)5.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (20)13 (11)3.6 (2)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (12)188 (314)134 (96)39 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)134 (177)54 (32)15 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 23 (55)27 (30)8.2 (4)2.9 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)6.2 (5)6357 (7239)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (46)16 (15)6.2 (3)11 (10)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.7 (11)13 (11)102 (215)146 (185)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.4 (17)8.8 (9)8.6 (10)215 (355)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.3 (12)41 (45)11 (5)2.3 (0.7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.0 (10)17 (18)4.1 (2)4.4 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (11)25 (22)8.5 (4)78 (101)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 11 (23)6.7 (7)8.7 (9)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)16 (17)5.8 (4)39 (31)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (13)14 (12)5.3 (2)11 (14)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (19)27 (23)69 (73)50540/10

Δ HVref
f42, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
2525
1e-2
3.4e5
1e-3
4.3e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (8)26 (53)13 (17)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 30 (74)0.91 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (19)23 (33)14 (25)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)32 (61)14 (8)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (13)24 (51)13 (17)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)22 (50)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (58)1.3 (1)13 (29)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 26 (64)24 (102)13 (16)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.7 (13)6.4 (13)2.2 (0.9)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.0 (16)2.2 (2)2.9 (3)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.0 (14)1.0 (0.8)1.9 (2)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (73)1.2 (2)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (24)2.3 (5)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.1 (21)1.3 (2)1.4 (1)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (8)1.2 (1)1.4 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 28 (69)1.6 (2)50480/10

Δ HVref
f43, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
2468
1e-2
1.5e5
1e-3
3.8e6
#succ
2/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)3.1 (3)1.8 (3)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)0.63 (0.5)14 (23)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (11)15 (19)4.3 (5)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (5)6.3 (8)1.1 (0.7)0.60 (0.6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)1.3 (1)3.5 (5)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)0.27 (0.2)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (5)0.63 (0.6)8.3 (10)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.8 (9)0.62 (0.5)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (5)1.4 (3)7.1 (9)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.1 (15)1.4 (1)1.4 (2)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (8)0.64 (0.6)2.6 (2)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)1.4 (2)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.8 (4)3.0 (5)3.3 (3)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)0.55 (0.5)1.0 (0.7)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.61 (0.6)1.5 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (27)0.97 (0.8)50520/10

Δ HVref
f44, 5-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
86
1e-2
513
1e-3
1853
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 23 (56)34 (50)28 (16)17 (5)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 12 (27)7.0 (6)4.2 (2)71 (203)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 40 (99)96 (194)177 (123)124 (50)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 64 (158)59 (101)70 (43)44 (14)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.6 (21)15 (17)11 (5)6.7 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (8)3.2 (3)245 (488)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (30)8.0 (7)4.5 (2)11 (13)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)6.9 (6)3.6 (2)64 (130)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.5 (20)5.1 (5)6.1 (6)160 (254)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 21 (51)20 (28)13 (8)7.7 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 27 (67)8.1 (11)5.1 (3)9.4 (11)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)12 (11)53 (53)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.5 (13)3.0 (3)2.3 (2)51 (55)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (30)7.7 (6)4.8 (2)17 (14)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)7.4 (5)4.5 (2)7.1 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 26 (63)16 (13)14 (19)50520/10

Δ HVref
f45, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
816
1e-2
5730
1e-3
53653
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)5.8 (3)14 (23)23 (17)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.6 (20)1.6 (0.6)132 (218)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (20)17 (16)29 (8)10 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.4 (14)9.3 (7)22 (25)12 (24)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.0 (18)3.0 (2)60 (88)85 (63)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (5)69 (153)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)1.6 (0.6)28 (44)17 (21)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (18)13 (29)136 (175)88 (126)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (6)16 (38)100 (71)91 (58)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.9 (15)3.2 (2)1.6 (0.5)2.8 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (5)1.7 (0.5)12 (26)15 (12)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (12)8.9 (16)37 (53)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.90 (1)1.5 (2)7.8 (9)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.8)1.9 (0.9)8.1 (12)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)1.8 (0.7)4.4 (8)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.9 (19)2.7 (1)50540/10

Δ HVref
f46, 5-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
11925
1e-2
4.9e5
1e-3
5.6e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (6)2.3 (1)2.7 (2)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (11)5.0 (11)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (9)12 (10)5.0 (4)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (16)5.3 (4)1.2 (0.5)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (14)0.89 (0.6)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.7 (7)63 (105)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (5)0.61 (0.4)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (7)4.4 (10)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (25)377 (356)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (6)5.4 (11)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.1 (17)11 (31)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (20)2.3 (2)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 14 (24)3.7 (4)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (7)1.8 (2)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.6 (11)1.9 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (8)1.3 (3)50450/10

Δ HVref
f47, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
4172
1e-2
2.7e5
1e-3
4.4e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)4.6 (3)7.7 (18)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (11)0.80 (0.5)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)22 (23)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)11 (11)8.3 (9)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.67 (0.8)2.2 (2)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (8)120 (210)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.97 (2)1.2 (1)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)1.5 (2)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (32)11 (18)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.73 (0.9)1.6 (1)8.9 (9)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (2)0.70 (0.4)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)10 (31)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.4 (5)7.2 (8)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (11)1.1 (0.9)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.67 (0.8)1.4 (2)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)1.4 (0.9)50430/10

Δ HVref
f48, 5-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
2160
1e-2
1.1e5
1e-3
2.1e6
#succ
2/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (20)6.7 (9)2.3 (5)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (6)1.1 (1)39 (79)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)27 (41)4.8 (3)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (14)12 (17)3.0 (3)1.1 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (9)2.3 (3)6.7 (14)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (6)0.39 (0.4)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (13)26 (58)13 (16)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (15)26 (58)39 (21)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (3)58 (174)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.7 (14)1.9 (2)39 (47)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.2 (13)9.5 (22)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (29)6.6 (12)4.3 (8)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (4)6.4 (17)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (11)3.4 (12)2.0 (1)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (10)2.2 (4)1.9 (1)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)1.6 (2)50540/10

Δ HVref
f49, 5-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
3737
1e-2
2.0e5
1e-3
1.3e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (24)18 (36)10 (12)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)15 (34)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 14 (35)18 (20)7.8 (7)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.3 (12)7.8 (9)4.5 (6)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (18)16 (34)22 (24)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (6)134 (435)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (6)0.87 (0.7)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (10)6.2 (14)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (6)16 (35)24 (16)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)1.5 (0.9)4.5 (3)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (7)1.5 (3)2.9 (4)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (20)6.0 (7)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)10 (15)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (9)2.3 (4)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.6 (10)2.2 (4)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (30)1.4 (2)50540/10

Δ HVref
f50, 5-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
3913
1e-2
2.2e5
1e-3
2.6e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.93 (2)3.7 (4)1.4 (1)5e50/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)0.82 (0.9)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.37 (0.3)21 (26)4.0 (4)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (15)9.3 (11)1.1 (0.8)5e50/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (14)1.9 (2)5.3 (7)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (11)14 (32)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)0.95 (1)6.4 (11)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (1)19 (41)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)1.2 (2)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)1.4 (1)1.0 (1)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.1 (11)0.64 (0.5)2.1 (1)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (4)2.3 (4)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.3 (12)1.4 (2)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (7)0.89 (1.0)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)0.64 (0.6)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.6 (11)1.2 (0.8)50540/10

Δ HVref
f51, 5-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
1251
1e-2
32465
1e-3
2.5e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (7)5.4 (7)1.7 (0.8)0.86 (2)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)1.1 (1)23 (23)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.9 (11)26 (41)18 (20)5e50/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (7)12 (17)4.4 (2)0.91 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)2.4 (2)7.2 (16)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (3)0.53 (0.6)62 (123)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (8)1.6 (2)13 (26)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (5)1.2 (2)38 (39)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)50 (111)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (6)3.0 (4)3.7 (5)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)1.2 (1)26 (52)5e50/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.9 (22)15 (31)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.3 (10)8.4 (17)4.7 (4)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)1.3 (2)2.8 (3)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (5)2.2 (4)3.0 (3)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)1.9 (2)50480/10

Δ HVref
f52, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
3027
1e-2
1.4e5
1e-3
2.1e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)2.6 (2)1.2 (2)2.2 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (15)19 (42)31 (55)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (3)12 (13)2.6 (2)2.3 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (3)6.0 (5)1.00 (0.7)1.1 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 9.2 (20)1.5 (1.0)5.3 (10)5e50/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (12)71 (124)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)0.65 (0.4)15 (30)5e50/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (6)22 (48)34 (21)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.7 (11)1.5 (3)3.5 (6)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (6)1.5 (1)0.42 (0.3)1.0 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.3 (14)0.59 (0.4)0.62 (0.8)2.2 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)1.2 (1)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.9 (10)6.7 (12)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (12)0.73 (0.6)5e40/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)0.47 (0.2)3.2 (4)5e40/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (5)1.2 (0.9)50480/10

Δ HVref
f53, 5-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
13
1e-2
42
1e-3
1443
#succ
2/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 9.1 (21)12 (14)29 (32)42 (89)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 12 (28)11 (9)10 (6)39 (87)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 28 (68)14 (19)62 (90)40 (75)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 13 (32)17 (18)26 (18)16 (28)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (14)18 (18)20 (14)40 (87)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.3 (10)6.8 (5)6.2 (6)87 (173)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)9.3 (10)16 (11)39 (87)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (42)12 (12)12 (4)7.7 (18)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)5.7 (7)8.2 (7)39 (173)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.9 (16)14 (13)21 (23)41 (88)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 25 (62)14 (22)11 (12)39 (174)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (74)21 (28)19 (11)1.5 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.2 (9)6.2 (5)4.6 (3)4.2 (18)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)13 (12)12 (7)2.1 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)12 (10)13 (6)1.6 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (49)25 (31)29 (13)1.8 (1)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 5-D
1e0
98
1e-1
1514
1e-2
12856
1e-3
45502
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (5)1.8 (3)1.2 (0.4)0.72 (0.2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.12 (0.2)0.59 (0.4)26 (19)44 (30)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (5)5.0 (9)8.0 (3)5.3 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (6)3.4 (5)3.2 (1)1.8 (0.5)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (5)1.0 (0.7)4.8 (10)11 (25)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.33 (0.8)0.25 (0.1)350 (554)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (1)0.74 (0.4)40 (88)17 (47)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (2)0.51 (0.3)40 (117)5e50/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.47 (1)0.24 (0.2)91 (331)44 (36)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.2 (5)0.94 (1)0.61 (0.2)7.6 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (4)0.46 (0.4)10 (39)26 (27)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.87 (2)8.3 (13)5e40/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.75 (2)8.5 (25)35 (50)10 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (3)0.64 (0.6)3.4 (7)4.7 (10)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 57 (128)4.2 (9)6.4 (6)10 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)1.2 (0.8)3.9 (4)50560/10

Δ HVref
f55, 5-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
1415
1e-2
18086
1e-3
51245
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)5.2 (3)1.2 (0.4)7.4 (10)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (15)40 (89)111 (145)5e50/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (8)17 (15)7.5 (2)5.7 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)8.7 (5)3.1 (0.5)3.3 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (6)2.0 (0.6)7.4 (62)88 (127)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)152 (265)5e50/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)3.2 (4)19 (28)16 (17)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (16)8.9 (19)50 (69)90 (163)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (3)43 (94)112 (104)88 (88)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (1)1.6 (1)0.51 (0.1)10 (12)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (7)1.2 (0.5)42 (41)88 (51)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.57 (0.4)1.5 (0.7)25 (28)9.2 (17)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.87 (1)36 (62)5e40/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)1.1 (0.8)11 (22)9.2 (9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.7 (20)2.2 (3)5.0 (7)9.0 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (7)2.0 (0.4)50480/10

Previous dimension | Dimension = 10 | Next dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
93
1e-2
886
1e-3
5534
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)95 (25)35 (3)13 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)16 (3)5.5 (0.4)★21e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)526 (189)269 (29)86 (4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)221 (71)96 (9)33 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)42 (10)14 (0.9)140 (188)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.0 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (3)7.9 (0.8)255 (699)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)13 (3)12 (4)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)10 (2)35 (10)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)67 (18)18 (2)13 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)27 (6)13 (4)26 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)24 (4)9.2 (2)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)8.0 (3)25 (10)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (4)15 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)17 (4)10 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)29 (4)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f2, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
98
1e-2
880
1e-3
6397
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)75 (27)34 (5)11 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.2)13 (3)4.8 (0.6)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)449 (247)263 (43)86 (17)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (1)181 (77)92 (12)30 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)34 (9)13 (2)4.2 (0.5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.2)5.8 (2)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)13 (4)5.7 (1)5.9 (4)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (1)11 (4)3.9 (0.6)669 (782)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.60 (0.2)9.5 (4)1.0e4 (1e4)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.70 (0.5)44 (18)17 (3)29 (41)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.55 (0.1)17 (5)13 (10)424 (614)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)1694 (1809)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.75 (0.6)8.0 (7)20 (25)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)15 (4)10 (7)73 (102)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)12 (4)5.1 (1)4.2 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)24 (8)27 (20)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f3, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
114
1e-2
1001
1e-3
6064
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 25 (52)97 (45)32 (6)12 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)15 (5)4.6 (0.8)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 18 (33)580 (347)257 (50)85 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (13)232 (117)92 (17)31 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 38 (93)39 (15)12 (2)24 (85)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 46 (92)6.3 (2)2333 (2248)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (32)13 (6)5.8 (2)52 (70)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)11 (5)6.1 (4)450 (786)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (19)8.6 (2)30 (36)789 (660)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.1 (12)54 (18)16 (2)11 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.3 (11)21 (8)11 (8)20 (15)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (8)958 (1976)427 (425)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (21)7.4 (4)13 (13)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (20)13 (5)8.2 (5)51 (26)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)12 (4)6.3 (3)41 (45)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 23 (56)23 (6)31 (31)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f4, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
118
1e-2
1013
1e-3
6250
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)101 (31)33 (8)29 (42)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)14 (5)4.4 (0.7)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)604 (297)266 (56)100 (48)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)252 (130)92 (19)42 (35)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)40 (14)12 (2)22 (121)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)5.6 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)13 (3)5.3 (1.0)47 (70)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)11 (4)149 (288)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)8.8 (3)19 (10)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)50 (16)16 (2)13 (7)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)20 (6)6.2 (1)64 (123)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)58 (48)461 (321)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)5.1 (2)5.4 (3)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)14 (6)8.9 (3)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)13 (5)6.0 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (6)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f5, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
176
1e-2
1805
1e-3
20009
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)95 (29)29 (3)7.4 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)13 (3)4.3 (0.4)★21e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)667 (270)264 (44)163 (100)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)268 (105)88 (15)20 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)36 (9)10 (2)3.4 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4.7 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)12 (3)18 (17)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)10 (3)15 (13)135 (182)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)8.4 (2)248 (267)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)45 (14)12 (2)21 (27)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)18 (4)10 (6)71 (106)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (4)50 (37)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)7.3 (3)29 (12)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)13 (4)25 (22)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)13 (4)16 (12)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (5)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f6, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
120
1e-2
1280
1e-3
8850
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 18 (43)103 (61)30 (6)9.2 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.4 (16)15 (7)4.3 (1)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (28)706 (517)238 (54)68 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 14 (32)274 (194)84 (17)25 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 26 (61)41 (20)11 (2)5.6 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (22)6.9 (3)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (34)16 (6)6.9 (2)74 (88)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (23)13 (7)249 (410)1102 (1526)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (27)8.6 (3)301 (395)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (35)55 (32)13 (3)6.2 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.9 (17)24 (11)7.5 (5)65 (61)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (24)21 (15)12 (10)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (17)8.5 (7)17 (13)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.7 (14)16 (9)12 (5)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (27)14 (6)6.5 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (7)25 (9)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f7, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
11174
1e-2
6.9e5
1e-3
3.7e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 44 (108)14 (24)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (18)0.59 (0.4)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (30)50 (51)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)14 (12)14 (14)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 17 (41)11 (23)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (21)60 (112)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.7 (18)1.5 (2)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.4 (10)18 (34)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.9 (21)3.2 (6)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)1.4 (0.8)14 (16)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.9 (16)1.7 (3)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (53)4.5 (9)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.3 (10)10 (11)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (29)2.3 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (29)1.8 (3)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.1 (19)1.7 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f8, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
7518
1e-2
1.4e6
1e-3
2.0e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 11 (20)5.6 (2)2.8 (3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 11 (23)0.95 (0.4)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 24 (54)42 (18)6.9 (9)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (12)15 (6)1.0 (0.9)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 27 (58)2.2 (0.9)2.8 (4)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (20)89 (233)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (45)2.3 (3)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)69 (69)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (32)29 (54)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 18 (40)2.0 (0.6)6.8 (6)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (15)3.1 (6)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)16 (18)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (2)54 (96)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (32)3.3 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (28)2.7 (4)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (57)3.9 (4)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f9, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
116
1e-2
906
1e-3
3733
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)88 (29)32 (3)16 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)13 (3)4.5 (0.4)628 (804)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)500 (275)255 (28)123 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)207 (71)89 (7)43 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)32 (9)12 (1)5.9 (0.4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)5.1 (1.0)2578 (1932)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)12 (2)4.9 (0.8)7.0 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)9.1 (3)5.2 (4)178 (136)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)7.1 (2)22 (21)159 (100)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)50 (7)16 (0.9)11 (5)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)19 (5)6.2 (0.8)14 (7)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)29 (13)184 (415)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)5.6 (2)3.5 (2)263 (248)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)12 (3)5.8 (2)22 (21)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)11 (3)5.3 (1)11 (10)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (3)51 (119)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f10, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
3855
1e-2
90606
1e-3
1.5e6
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 40 (98)6.5 (1)26 (19)6.1 (5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (16)0.91 (0.2)99 (80)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 14 (34)46 (7)7.1 (4)6.5 (4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)18 (4)7.3 (7)6.2 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 13 (32)2.3 (0.7)17 (19)6.1 (8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.2 (14)111 (130)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 33 (82)1.2 (0.6)99 (146)6.2 (7)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)66 (130)44 (107)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 21 (52)174 (389)100 (141)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 22 (54)2.8 (0.4)13 (16)1.6 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.9 (21)1.1 (0.2)44 (47)6.2 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 29 (70)7.8 (13)4.6 (3)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 13 (31)8.7 (14)10 (6)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)4.6 (8)3.0 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.5 (20)2.8 (5)4.6 (7)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 31 (76)3.1 (5)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f11, 10-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
138
1e-2
1132
1e-3
31641
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (26)29 (70)25 (27)5.3 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)6.9 (14)103 (223)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 32 (79)184 (456)144 (213)25 (16)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 17 (42)78 (190)61 (76)11 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.5 (18)13 (29)12 (12)129 (111)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (8)2.7 (4)7952 (6625)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (26)3.7 (5)2.7 (2)5.0 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.86 (2)2.7 (4)2.1 (1)2.9 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.94 (2)1.7 (3)7.2 (13)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.2 (10)7.4 (15)7.0 (8)2.6 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (6)2.8 (5)3.8 (5)11 (19)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (28)4.8 (7)4.0 (2)1.8 (1)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.2 (8)2.1 (2)4.1 (3)14 (24)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (11)2.8 (4)2.8 (2)2.4 (2)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (5)2.8 (4)2.4 (2)3.0 (3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (17)5.7 (8)4.6 (4)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f12, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
59
1e-2
447
1e-3
4680
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)31 (37)42 (47)16 (6)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)11 (11)6.2 (4)1.8 (0.9)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)127 (200)215 (286)126 (68)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (9)49 (97)97 (105)46 (19)3/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (8)21 (26)16 (16)5.4 (3)2/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (18)5.7 (6)2.2 (2)54 (107)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)10 (7)17 (36)143 (428)1/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)7.1 (7)251 (561)323 (376)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1)6.7 (5)9.5 (19)51 (93)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)23 (28)13 (9)7.1 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (6)11 (11)5.5 (3)39 (84)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)18 (22)34 (61)23 (43)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (4)4.8 (4)27 (113)15 (21)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.5 (10)10 (10)13 (27)15 (32)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (2)10 (8)9.0 (15)15 (38)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)17 (16)8.6 (9)2.6 (2)0/10

Δ HVref
f13, 10-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
32
1e-2
220
1e-3
3827
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 20 (48)101 (172)73 (51)16 (7)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 17 (42)19 (24)12 (7)2.1 (1)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)490 (1055)445 (494)138 (75)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.83 (1)221 (405)192 (156)53 (29)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 36 (88)55 (74)34 (29)5.8 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (27)11 (12)4.8 (3)611 (392)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (21)22 (19)9.3 (3)70 (121)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3)15 (12)10 (4)352 (605)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.7 (14)13 (12)5.4 (2)703 (1229)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)61 (73)33 (12)25 (52)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.6 (13)24 (27)13 (7)296 (387)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (23)32 (28)29 (19)54 (35)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.8 (4)6.8 (5)3.6 (2)5.3 (9)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)18 (16)10 (5)8.4 (12)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (14)14 (13)7.6 (4)7.4 (18)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)33 (30)16 (6)26 (45)0/10

Δ HVref
f14, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
351
1e-2
3352
1e-3
76555
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (6)67 (32)19 (4)2.3 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.7 (18)9.0 (3)2.7 (0.5)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)469 (226)165 (35)129 (134)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (4)178 (86)57 (12)5.7 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)26 (12)7.0 (2)4.3 (7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (12)3.3 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (13)8.5 (3)57 (94)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (5)6.5 (3)93 (234)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (5)324 (718)2743 (1790)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.6 (13)29 (11)126 (232)60 (44)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.5 (12)11 (3)153 (200)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (17)1413 (1212)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.6 (11)3.6 (2)14 (15)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)11 (6)24 (24)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (2)7.9 (3)19 (21)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)19 (24)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f15, 10-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
102
1e-2
1082
1e-3
10556
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (8)94 (93)37 (11)8.4 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (11)18 (9)5.1 (1)143 (142)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)444 (552)286 (102)102 (106)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.4 (7)184 (197)99 (34)25 (10)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)39 (33)13 (4)3.1 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (9)7.3 (6)926 (924)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)11 (8)13 (20)10 (9)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)12 (12)77 (180)854 (924)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (5)7.6 (6)2272 (4473)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.1 (4)43 (41)14 (5)58 (49)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)19 (11)239 (467)862 (663)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (29)1047 (1055)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.3 (8)5.2 (5)11 (19)92 (192)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)14 (13)12 (11)44 (26)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)10 (8)5.7 (4)5.2 (5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.5 (20)25 (22)27 (16)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f16, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
16889
1e-2
7.3e5
1e-3
2.2e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)1.9 (2)1.1 (1)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (22)0.30 (0.3)12 (13)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)15 (20)2.5 (2)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 7.1 (17)4.9 (6)1.0 (1)0.44 (0.7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)0.82 (0.8)3.3 (3)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (8)0.12 (0.1)12 (12)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (6)15 (44)13 (22)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)15 (44)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (9)104 (127)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)2.6 (5)12 (10)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.1 (20)26 (59)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)53 (73)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.7 (16)2.8 (5)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.6 (18)1.8 (6)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.8 (19)1.1 (2)1.3 (1)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (6)0.50 (0.5)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f17, 10-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
7097
1e-2
2.5e5
1e-3
4.0e6
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 12 (27)3.8 (3)0.50 (0.1)1.1 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 9.2 (18)0.57 (0.4)4.2 (7)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (19)29 (25)7.2 (7)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 10 (20)10 (9)1.3 (0.3)1.1 (1)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 23 (49)1.5 (1)1.2 (2)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 30 (53)0.21 (0.1)37 (38)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (14)2.1 (4)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (14)61 (106)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.8 (11)97 (115)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (7)1.4 (1)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (16)0.57 (0.4)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (11)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (3)15 (19)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.1 (19)1.0 (2)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.1 (17)3.9 (14)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.3 (6)0.99 (1)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f18, 10-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
75
1e-2
650
1e-3
8969
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.89 (2)40 (53)35 (20)8.6 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)14 (11)5.3 (3)1004 (1143)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.41 (0.5)60 (78)211 (135)72 (26)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)73 (104)87 (50)26 (11)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.77 (1)26 (26)13 (5)3.8 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)5.6 (4)173 (385)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)9.4 (5)3.7 (0.7)1.8 (1)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.59 (0.8)6.3 (2)3.5 (2)87 (103)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)6.5 (4)2.8 (1)36 (42)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)18 (21)11 (3)30 (84)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)8.1 (7)4.1 (0.8)39 (85)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.56 (0.9)24 (16)22 (16)48 (37)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.31 (0.4)3.6 (2)1.8 (0.8)17 (37)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)10 (5)3.8 (1)2.9 (1)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)7.1 (3)3.3 (0.8)1.3 (0.4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.44 (0.6)15 (10)5.9 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f19, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
6872
1e-2
58336
1e-3
2.7e6
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)2.3 (0.8)0.77 (0.4)0.19 (0.3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.70 (0.9)0.36 (0.1)26 (30)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)18 (4)5.5 (1.0)0.29 (0.2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (1)6.1 (2)2.0 (0.5)0.14 (0.1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)1.0 (0.3)4.6 (9)3.4 (8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)37 (146)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)0.56 (0.3)27 (32)3.4 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)37 (73)69 (103)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.82 (1)39 (109)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.47 (0.5)0.96 (0.1)12 (30)1.5 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.85 (1)0.46 (0.2)69 (90)3.4 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.78 (1)43 (50)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (3)3.8 (7)15 (11)0.34 (1)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)0.87 (1)16 (22)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.57 (0.7)1.9 (4)4.7 (5)0.37 (0.3)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.78 (1)0.59 (0.2)1.7 (0.7)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f20, 10-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
84
1e-2
640
1e-3
4014
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 19 (44)58 (77)30 (37)39 (71)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.1 (14)11 (10)4.0 (5)108 (187)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 8.8 (16)242 (390)198 (297)109 (130)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 25 (57)136 (194)72 (103)59 (144)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 15 (31)24 (26)10 (12)38 (78)3/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (8)4.5 (4)392 (1172)107 (125)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (16)13 (9)4.4 (4)12 (18)3/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (13)10 (8)4.0 (4)258 (374)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.0 (17)7.3 (5)7.1 (13)124 (187)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.7 (11)32 (34)12 (10)4.5 (5)1/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (31)19 (15)5.0 (4)3.7 (6)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (21)16 (11)7.4 (9)20 (13)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 9.2 (19)6.3 (4)12 (25)17 (56)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (10)10 (8)4.2 (5)17 (19)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.6 (11)9.4 (8)4.4 (5)13 (13)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.6 (14)21 (13)7.9 (9)3.0 (5)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
105
1e-2
826
1e-3
24204
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 35 (83)64 (62)30 (20)8.8 (15)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 14 (24)12 (9)4.5 (2)42 (41)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 55 (136)339 (449)227 (177)27 (39)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 41 (101)147 (175)86 (61)11 (11)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 16 (37)28 (24)11 (7)6.5 (12)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (23)4.4 (3)304 (605)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (49)12 (7)4.5 (3)7.9 (16)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 23 (58)8.6 (5)48 (111)178 (279)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 26 (64)8.0 (5)17 (36)44 (93)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 24 (57)36 (35)14 (7)6.0 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (24)17 (10)6.3 (5)12 (22)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 31 (75)19 (9)11 (10)6.0 (9)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.1 (12)3.9 (4)8.1 (16)7.0 (5)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (44)12 (8)6.6 (7)7.0 (6)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (10)11 (7)4.7 (3)2.8 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (44)21 (13)7.6 (9)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f22, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
286
1e-2
2633
1e-3
22507
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 24 (55)66 (31)23 (6)8.2 (7)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 49 (119)10 (3)99 (475)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)495 (280)184 (47)83 (47)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 17 (39)179 (102)66 (20)22 (17)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 75 (186)25 (9)8.4 (2)4.6 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (18)3.4 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (35)11 (4)118 (192)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)8.4 (3)81 (153)96 (86)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 22 (54)27 (34)190 (234)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (3)31 (9)74 (107)84 (51)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 18 (44)19 (20)65 (131)209 (467)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 76 (190)150 (114)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 8.1 (17)5.0 (2)42 (34)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (7)15 (13)37 (62)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)10 (3)27 (26)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 58 (140)27 (30)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f23, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
115
1e-2
943
1e-3
5370
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (7)80 (80)37 (12)13 (3)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (1)16 (9)5.4 (2)1678 (2980)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)410 (573)300 (99)104 (18)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)191 (211)104 (32)37 (7)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 9.3 (21)30 (27)14 (4)5.1 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (9)5.9 (3)2476 (2386)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (4)11 (7)6.6 (3)22 (31)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (20)12 (10)11 (15)304 (372)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (24)8.0 (6)337 (545)1835 (1024)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (2)33 (34)15 (5)12 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (1)17 (12)18 (31)48 (62)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (13)464 (739)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.9 (2)5.5 (4)11 (18)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (1)11 (9)12 (12)58 (56)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)11 (9)7.4 (4)26 (47)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)19 (12)24 (27)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f24, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
12987
1e-2
4.8e5
1e-3
2.6e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (4)3.0 (3)3.4 (3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 9.1 (22)0.45 (0.4)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.9 (14)18 (17)6.7 (7)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)7.2 (6)0.91 (0.3)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)1.1 (0.8)8.4 (10)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 18 (43)0.17 (0.1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)2.4 (4)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)20 (58)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 24 (58)180 (212)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)0.97 (0.4)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)33 (39)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.6 (10)12 (6)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (60)2.2 (3)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (8)2.4 (8)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (12)1.1 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f25, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
7857
1e-2
8.9e5
1e-3
1.5e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)3.1 (2)0.45 (0.8)0.62 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (0.9)0.53 (0.4)4.5 (4)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.65 (0.4)22 (19)3.4 (4)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)8.6 (7)0.71 (0.7)0.64 (0.9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (0.9)1.3 (1.0)1.7 (2)0.64 (0.7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (9)0.24 (0.2)4.5 (4)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (5)0.76 (0.7)10 (3)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)56 (162)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)337 (509)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.0 (4)1.2 (0.8)4.5 (6)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.75 (0.6)16 (39)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)51 (67)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.2 (4)21 (16)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.95 (1)3.8 (7)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)6.7 (10)1.1 (1)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)1.00 (0.9)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f26, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
85
1e-2
381
1e-3
1644
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)44 (41)43 (33)40 (43)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (17)8.6 (6)6.2 (3)71 (152)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (13)140 (192)283 (222)262 (157)1/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)72 (83)111 (94)86 (49)2/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (7)18 (15)17 (8)15 (19)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)4.5 (2)2.6 (0.9)262 (457)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.73 (1)9.1 (6)5.7 (2)4.5 (5)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (17)7.6 (3)5.2 (3)12 (24)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.3 (10)6.2 (3)3.2 (1)6.9 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (34)27 (29)21 (10)10 (4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 29 (73)16 (12)8.4 (3)4.6 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (48)14 (11)9.2 (5)7.2 (8)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.2 (15)4.5 (3)2.8 (2)9.2 (18)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (39)10 (5)5.8 (3)6.6 (11)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (29)8.5 (4)4.8 (3)4.2 (5)1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 28 (70)18 (7)8.4 (3)4.6 (3)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
12590
1e-2
78458
1e-3
3.5e6
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.0 (16)1.8 (0.6)3.9 (6)1.2 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 20 (49)0.24 (0.1)51 (25)2.6 (3)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (7)12 (6)5.3 (1)0.39 (0.4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.6 (8)4.5 (2)2.0 (0.7)0.21 (0.3)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (7)0.57 (0.3)19 (19)2.6 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (10)8.9 (20)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (7)0.33 (0.2)15 (30)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)0.23 (0.1)116 (134)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (7)56 (103)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (7)0.70 (0.2)4.3 (13)2.6 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.9 (14)0.32 (0.1)52 (77)2.6 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)19 (38)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.3 (4)3.7 (12)12 (10)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.9 (11)0.28 (0.1)12 (12)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (7)0.51 (0.5)3.9 (3)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)0.54 (0.3)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f28, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
24
1e-2
358
1e-3
5622
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 34 (84)185 (128)59 (16)9.2 (2)7/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 15 (37)41 (20)9.0 (2)1.7 (0.6)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (13)718 (509)422 (154)75 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 80 (198)344 (329)160 (47)26 (4)6/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 30 (74)81 (48)22 (5)3.3 (0.5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)17 (7)3.9 (2)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (40)47 (20)9.2 (3)33 (55)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (36)38 (15)42 (70)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 20 (48)27 (12)9.1 (9)1678 (1112)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 21 (51)128 (106)28 (7)28 (55)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 17 (42)63 (36)11 (3)730 (534)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (50)62 (26)13 (5)38 (33)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.6 (5)17 (7)5.0 (2)170 (169)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (55)42 (19)11 (6)173 (343)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (37)41 (19)8.8 (3)7.2 (7)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 37 (92)81 (27)14 (3)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f29, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
108
1e-2
7772
1e-3
40372
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 4.7 (10)205 (59)8.0 (2)4.4 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (9)29 (5)1.0 (0.2)★21e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)1592 (561)66 (13)59 (87)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)587 (154)22 (4)10 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)76 (15)2.7 (0.5)4.7 (7)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)11 (3)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)35 (19)38 (65)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)24 (11)121 (91)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (10)72 (106)73 (74)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)102 (25)41 (98)44 (87)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.2 (17)52 (43)41 (65)245 (254)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (48)236 (172)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (2)19 (10)12 (17)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)61 (65)12 (19)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)37 (25)7.7 (8)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (54)121 (83)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f30, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
109
1e-2
968
1e-3
5577
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)96 (47)38 (7)13 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (12)17 (6)5.1 (1)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)524 (397)310 (63)111 (17)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 23 (56)237 (145)108 (17)37 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 56 (136)40 (21)14 (2)5.1 (1.0)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 20 (46)5.9 (2)4134 (5424)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 32 (78)14 (4)7.0 (2)23 (22)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.9 (20)13 (7)22 (30)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.0 (20)11 (9)90 (99)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 38 (91)48 (18)15 (3)17 (15)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 16 (36)19 (7)12 (9)104 (117)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (5)571 (1028)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 11 (24)7.3 (7)11 (15)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)15 (7)11 (8)179 (314)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (36)14 (9)7.1 (3)78 (153)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 54 (133)24 (8)51 (97)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f31, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
12618
1e-2
5.8e5
1e-3
9.2e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 64 (160)3.5 (3)4.2 (2)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.5 (15)0.46 (0.3)6.9 (6)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.55 (0.1)24 (25)5.5 (8)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 20 (49)9.1 (8)0.95 (1)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 18 (44)1.2 (0.9)7.0 (12)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (17)0.20 (0.1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (16)12 (22)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (51)53 (60)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.2 (12)185 (337)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 27 (65)5.5 (12)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (34)53 (60)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 54 (134)32 (24)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 8.8 (21)19 (37)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (43)2.4 (3)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (55)3.5 (4)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 50 (124)3.3 (5)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f32, 10-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
6372
1e-2
3.3e5
1e-3
8.4e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 59 (137)5.1 (3)1.7 (5)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 17 (32)0.74 (0.4)28 (38)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 18 (41)38 (26)15 (14)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 32 (77)14 (8)1.4 (0.7)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 19 (47)1.8 (1)7.3 (17)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 10 (19)0.35 (0.2)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.3 (20)1.1 (0.7)29 (16)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (12)183 (424)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.6 (14)236 (471)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 15 (26)2.0 (1)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 19 (48)54 (79)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 26 (49)141 (130)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.5 (8)18 (25)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (28)5.3 (12)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (30)3.8 (6)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 23 (54)2.4 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f33, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
17
1e-2
154
1e-3
1507
#succ
6/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 98 (243)232 (146)103 (65)42 (25)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 19 (46)52 (28)15 (6)5.5 (4)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 9.1 (22)991 (1277)779 (642)443 (367)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 82 (205)513 (366)303 (183)118 (60)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 64 (160)103 (59)41 (24)18 (16)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 21 (51)22 (10)5.9 (2)2656 (2986)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 34 (85)63 (27)16 (5)28 (56)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 37 (93)47 (26)13 (3)628 (752)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 19 (48)31 (17)8.1 (3)311 (504)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 52 (129)201 (176)57 (21)22 (25)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 48 (120)85 (41)21 (8)8.4 (9)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 48 (118)79 (29)18 (9)16 (38)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 11 (26)19 (10)5.0 (3)7.8 (8)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 40 (99)53 (36)16 (10)15 (20)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 29 (72)47 (22)15 (6)7.1 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 74 (184)99 (38)26 (12)21 (15)0/10

Δ HVref
f34, 10-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
3602
1e-2
54082
1e-3
9.0e5
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.9 (6)5.2 (2)2.9 (5)0.84 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.7 (21)0.74 (0.2)28 (32)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.2 (10)37 (13)6.5 (1)0.84 (0.4)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)13 (5)4.2 (5)0.39 (0.4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 13 (32)2.0 (0.6)4.9 (9)4.5 (6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (8)31 (70)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.6 (15)0.98 (0.5)14 (18)4.5 (4)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.8 (19)54 (119)74 (79)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (5)2.3 (5)44 (33)10 (12)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (5)2.2 (0.3)4.9 (14)0.51 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.3 (9)0.85 (0.2)28 (74)4.6 (8)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)21 (23)18 (9)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.8 (9)12 (21)4.7 (6)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (16)1.1 (0.9)7.5 (12)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.6 (13)3.8 (7)4.5 (3)1.0 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.3 (13)1.7 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f35, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
126
1e-2
2595
1e-3
25274
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)117 (27)19 (2)6.1 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)17 (4)3472 (3276)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)733 (227)156 (17)44 (20)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)288 (86)54 (5)14 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)44 (10)6.8 (0.5)65 (50)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.4 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (4)17 (8)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)15 (4)8.0 (4)36 (80)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)15 (7)3701 (2408)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)66 (15)24 (11)62 (99)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)23 (4)61 (43)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)23 (6)6.7 (1)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)10 (3)41 (53)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)19 (5)15 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (3)13 (3)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)30 (6)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f36, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
327
1e-2
3312
1e-3
33699
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 48 (118)85 (17)21 (4)7.0 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 22 (52)9.0 (2)2.7 (0.2)★21e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 9.1 (20)719 (207)197 (52)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (7)231 (45)63 (12)20 (16)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (2)28 (7)7.1 (1)2.6 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (20)3.4 (0.9)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)10 (1)33 (32)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (4)8.5 (3)128 (152)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (2)4.9 (2)2755 (1812)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.0 (12)30 (6)8.1 (2)42 (23)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.7 (14)12 (2)69 (102)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (13)25 (24)142 (146)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (1)5.5 (3)132 (179)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)17 (15)38 (33)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (57)11 (7)23 (23)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (20)18 (7)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f37, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
10070
1e-2
4.9e5
1e-3
1.7e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (0.8)4.2 (3)18 (26)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (12)25 (50)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)33 (20)20 (8)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (4)11 (7)8.9 (9)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 10 (22)1.6 (1)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.8 (14)100 (149)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (5)1.2 (1)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.3 (6)12 (25)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)48 (50)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.5 (1)1.5 (0.7)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (2)0.76 (0.4)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (4)3.4 (6)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (0.2)8.0 (10)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (7)2.2 (4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (8)1.5 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (7)2.2 (3)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f38, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
11650
1e-2
1.1e6
1e-3
2.3e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (4)5.6 (2)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.5 (12)38 (86)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (14)45 (14)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 10 (25)15 (6)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)12 (23)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 14 (33)344 (236)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (3)1.4 (1)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.0 (21)35 (85)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (6)133 (47)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 29 (70)1.6 (0.4)8.8 (11)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (26)2.5 (4)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.3 (12)36 (60)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (22)14 (16)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)4.0 (5)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)3.2 (4)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (50)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f39, 10-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
355
1e-2
3656
1e-3
19977
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.9 (19)62 (25)16 (4)7.6 (4)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 3.3 (8)7.9 (2)2.0 (0.3)203 (212)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (10)437 (174)136 (33)66 (27)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (4)160 (73)47 (10)19 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (5)22 (8)5.7 (1)3.5 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (3)3.0 (0.9)1095 (821)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (4)10 (6)47 (93)103 (100)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)7.3 (3)10 (13)65 (58)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.99 (2)4.8 (2)151 (144)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (3)28 (10)19 (26)40 (129)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.59 (1)11 (3)56 (88)47 (51)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.3 (15)13 (5)47 (49)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.80 (2)3.6 (2)21 (28)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.83 (2)10 (5)19 (28)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.0 (12)13 (17)12 (12)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (4)21 (17)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f40, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
4399
1e-2
1.0e5
1e-3
1.0e6
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)5.8 (0.7)1.8 (3)1.8 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.88 (0.1)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)44 (6)5.1 (0.7)1.9 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)16 (2)1.8 (0.3)1.3 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.3 (0.3)15 (17)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)228 (455)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.3 (0.7)7.7 (8)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)28 (62)16 (27)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)166 (398)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2.6 (0.3)0.78 (1)1.5 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.98 (0.3)40 (64)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)27 (71)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)11 (11)4.8 (2)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)7.3 (11)4.3 (5)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.3 (0.7)1.9 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.1 (3)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f41, 10-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
206
1e-2
1600
1e-3
11425
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 18 (38)68 (51)26 (7)7.3 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 12 (23)10 (4)3.6 (0.8)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 18 (36)441 (400)204 (55)54 (9)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)172 (142)71 (18)19 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 24 (52)26 (15)10 (2)4.2 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.5 (7)4.2 (1)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (47)9.4 (6)6.9 (2)109 (139)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)8.8 (6)332 (328)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (26)5.5 (3)1079 (1962)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 28 (56)32 (21)11 (3)4.3 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (22)13 (7)4.4 (1)170 (207)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (55)13 (7)7.4 (2)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.5 (8)4.7 (3)25 (31)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.8 (16)10 (6)16 (7)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.9 (17)8.7 (6)7.3 (4)82 (105)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (47)16 (9)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f42, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
18170
1e-2
6.4e5
1e-3
1.3e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.6 (3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)14 (41)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)24 (28)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)13 (19)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.9 (28)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)14 (28)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.8 (11)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)8.5 (19)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2.0 (2)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.70 (0.4)15 (9)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.67 (1)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (2)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)6.2 (7)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.9 (5)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.3 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (1)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f43, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
5180
1e-2
3.2e5
1e-3
7.3e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 57 (142)4.1 (3)1.1 (2)1.3 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 11 (27)0.67 (0.6)12 (17)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.5 (18)27 (27)4.3 (3)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)11 (11)1.1 (0.6)0.63 (0.7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (14)1.7 (2)2.2 (4)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (17)0.34 (0.4)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)0.92 (1)28 (30)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)49 (97)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.2 (12)6.8 (10)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 26 (64)1.8 (1)7.4 (20)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.9 (14)0.68 (0.5)13 (10)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (7)10 (11)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.4 (2)9.5 (15)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (24)0.94 (1)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.3 (22)1.3 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (5)1.3 (1)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f44, 10-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
125
1e-2
834
1e-3
3534
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 30 (75)85 (74)42 (16)19 (5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 29 (73)14 (8)5.6 (1)287 (709)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 96 (239)524 (772)339 (126)155 (34)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 94 (235)211 (230)118 (43)54 (13)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 77 (192)32 (30)15 (5)7.1 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.1 (20)5.5 (2)802 (1799)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (55)12 (8)6.0 (2)9.1 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (37)8.7 (6)5.9 (4)304 (329)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (29)6.4 (3)38 (45)482 (456)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 28 (70)42 (36)18 (6)16 (10)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (28)16 (11)8.2 (5)49 (26)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (48)30 (19)307 (210)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.6 (11)4.2 (3)3.7 (2)279 (255)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 20 (50)12 (6)9.0 (6)58 (46)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (42)10 (7)7.5 (3)10 (4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 53 (132)20 (12)36 (25)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f45, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
4900
1e-2
73882
1e-3
7.4e5
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4.9 (1)15 (14)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.68 (0.2)122 (85)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)36 (9)15 (11)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)16 (3)16 (7)13 (10)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.9 (0.4)21 (27)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)136 (357)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.92 (0.6)58 (54)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)24 (52)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2.5 (6)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.7 (0.4)9.3 (7)5.5 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.77 (0.2)122 (91)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.0 (0.6)13 (18)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)1.00 (0.5)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.4 (6)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.9 (5)13 (17)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.7 (1)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f46, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
29415
1e-2
1.5e6
1e-3
5.8e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)2.3 (1)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)0.37 (0.2)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)17 (9)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)6.2 (3)1.9 (1)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.7 (18)0.83 (0.4)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.87 (1)51 (77)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)5.4 (11)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (6)35 (43)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.77 (0.9)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 18 (42)0.65 (0.2)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (3)80 (110)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)8.9 (10)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.63 (0.7)31 (66)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)4.0 (10)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)3.1 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)3.3 (4)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f47, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
20669
1e-2
1.1e6
1e-3
3.5e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 54 (135)3.2 (2)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 24 (58)5.8 (24)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 10 (24)27 (15)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 13 (30)8.3 (4)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)1.1 (0.6)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 6.1 (14)21 (24)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)7.6 (15)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (30)120 (229)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)55 (80)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.6 (5)2.8 (5)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.2 (22)9.2 (31)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.7 (20)20 (16)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.3 (17)44 (60)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (32)2.4 (3)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)3.0 (3)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (8)4.7 (3)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f48, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
5403
1e-2
3.8e5
1e-3
9.5e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)5.0 (6)1.4 (3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 14 (34)0.73 (0.8)6.2 (14)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (3)36 (42)3.7 (3)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)14 (19)1.2 (1.0)0.99 (0.9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)1.9 (2)4.1 (9)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.5 (10)0.32 (0.3)24 (10)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)1.5 (3)11 (10)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)21 (47)24 (21)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (7)80 (93)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.60 (0.2)1.7 (2)24 (33)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)21 (47)24 (31)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (4)8.8 (9)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.0 (4)8.1 (9)2.4 (2)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)3.5 (7)2.4 (2)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)7.4 (14)2.4 (4)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (6)1.3 (2)0.26 (0.2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f49, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
25717
1e-2
2.4e6
1e-3
1.5e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 11 (27)1.8 (1)3.8 (4)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 13 (31)4.6 (10)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 29 (72)13 (9)2.0 (4)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (14)5.0 (4)3.9 (5)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 9.0 (22)0.67 (0.4)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (20)58 (97)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)2.6 (6)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.8 (14)22 (38)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (27)2.1 (2)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.6 (21)0.66 (0.4)1.8 (3)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.5 (21)0.52 (0.8)2.0 (2)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)3.6 (2)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.8 (14)16 (25)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)1.3 (2)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (16)2.4 (4)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)1.9 (1)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f50, 10-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
15119
1e-2
9.2e5
1e-3
1.2e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 75 (185)4.1 (2)4.5 (3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 28 (66)0.65 (0.3)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (15)30 (12)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (12)11 (5)1.8 (2)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 38 (94)1.6 (0.7)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (25)99 (198)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.90 (1)4.0 (7)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (31)266 (183)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (27)25 (19)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 18 (43)1.2 (0.3)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 24 (58)4.7 (8)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.2 (22)29 (51)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 42 (101)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (32)8.4 (8)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.8 (15)11 (17)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (40)6.4 (5)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f51, 10-D
1e0
1
1e-1
3839
1e-2
3.9e5
1e-3
8.7e6
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (4)4.8 (4)0.31 (0.2)0.48 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (12)0.75 (0.5)2.6 (4)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (8)36 (30)4.3 (4)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.7 (4)14 (11)0.84 (0.4)0.24 (0.3)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)2.0 (1)1.2 (2)1.0 (0.6)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.0 (18)0.28 (0.2)23 (52)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)1.2 (2)11 (15)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (6)36 (143)23 (57)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.4 (8)122 (261)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (4)2.2 (2)11 (9)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.4 (4)0.87 (0.7)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 28 (68)40 (124)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.1 (10)27 (33)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (22)1.4 (2)1.2 (2)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (28)1.00 (1)2.4 (2)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)1.2 (1.0)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f52, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
82946
1e-2
2.8e6
1e-3
1.4e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (1)0.74 (0.3)1e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (3)3.1 (6)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)5.4 (2)3.5 (5)1e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)2.0 (1.0)1.6 (2)1e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)0.30 (0.1)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.1 (15)48 (39)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (3)3.8 (6)1e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.6 (5)15 (18)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (2)4.7 (5)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)0.26 (0.1)1.5 (1)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.3 (7)0.44 (0.8)3.3 (5)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)2.1 (5)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.7 (3)5.0 (5)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (3)1.2 (0.9)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)1.6 (1)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f53, 10-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
26
1e-2
117
1e-3
2163
#succ
2/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 78 (193)83 (60)81 (19)14 (7)2/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 21 (51)25 (12)13 (5)1.8 (0.8)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 39 (95)241 (245)352 (89)95 (61)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 16 (39)152 (83)180 (65)37 (20)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 32 (78)45 (30)32 (8)4.9 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.9 (21)10 (4)5.0 (2)116 (231)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (50)34 (20)14 (2)1.4 (0.5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)20 (7)8.6 (2)1.1 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.7 (8)18 (9)7.4 (3)0.75 (0.4)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 26 (63)50 (43)46 (10)4.9 (1)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 16 (39)44 (20)19 (3)1.9 (0.5)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 48 (118)38 (17)17 (5)1.9 (0.8)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.2 (14)8.8 (4)4.0 (2)0.70 (0.6)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (37)25 (13)13 (4)1.3 (0.7)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)22 (9)11 (4)1.1 (0.4)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 34 (83)55 (14)24 (3)2.2 (0.7)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 10-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
8747
1e-2
58898
1e-3
9.5e5
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 36 (88)2.3 (0.4)2.8 (4)1.7 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 23 (54)0.45 (0.3)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 20 (49)18 (5)6.5 (1)0.96 (0.5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 81 (202)6.1 (2)3.2 (3)0.70 (0.8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (20)0.89 (0.1)26 (42)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.6 (20)76 (229)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.5 (13)0.46 (0.2)28 (41)4.4 (6)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (25)29 (57)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.5 (23)37 (101)153 (153)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 14 (35)0.97 (0.2)17 (51)2.5 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.6 (18)13 (29)153 (255)1e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 31 (76)15 (14)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (24)8.5 (7)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (5)0.42 (0.2)6.9 (9)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (41)0.47 (0.5)7.0 (6)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (60)0.64 (0.2)1e40/10

Δ HVref
f55, 10-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
22439
1e-2
1.0e6
1e-3
3.0e6
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (4)1.4 (0.4)0.72 (1)1.4 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (9)45 (45)1e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)11 (3)0.77 (0.5)0.62 (0.3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (3)4.0 (1)0.83 (0.8)0.90 (1)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (18)5.5 (11)3.9 (5)1e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)67 (56)1e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.6 (20)20 (23)3.9 (6)3.1 (4)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)30 (45)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (6)1e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)5.5 (11)1.5 (3)0.83 (0.8)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.5 (13)12 (45)2.5 (3)3.0 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)7.0 (10)0.43 (0.3)1e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.2 (7)11 (16)1e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)5.0 (9)0.42 (0.4)1e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (6)4.7 (9)1e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (8)1.4 (3)1e40/10

Previous dimension | Dimension = 20 | Next dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
157
1e-2
1468
1e-3
8244
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)189 (19)48 (2)17 (0.4)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)25 (2)6.9 (0.4)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1541 (171)392 (16)125 (3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)533 (43)135 (4)48 (0.9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)67 (7)18 (0.6)72 (182)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)10 (0.8)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (2)12 (1)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)26 (11)205 (214)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)21 (5)565 (116)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)100 (13)24 (1.0)90 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)36 (4)87 (54)449 (613)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)31 (4)15 (4)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)14 (3)116 (60)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)26 (6)43 (12)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (3)21 (4)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)34 (3)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f2, 20-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
163
1e-2
2170
1e-3
21153
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (5)237 (79)42 (9)9.2 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 67 (167)30 (11)5.2 (1)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.6 (19)1887 (776)373 (101)141 (128)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.0 (4)651 (227)122 (29)28 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 150 (374)80 (24)14 (3)3.4 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 22 (54)10 (3)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (5)18 (4)6.6 (4)8.0 (5)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)16 (6)283 (789)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.9 (4)14 (3)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 12 (30)90 (19)17 (3)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.5 (13)32 (7)8921 (9447)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.4 (8)8.9 (4)104 (65)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)19 (5)16 (9)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.1 (15)18 (6)5.6 (1)4.1 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (33)26 (4)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f3, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
216
1e-2
2384
1e-3
11104
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)163 (40)32 (4)14 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)21 (5)4.3 (0.5)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1292 (342)271 (31)107 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)458 (99)92 (11)38 (5)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)57 (11)12 (2)26 (48)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.5 (1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)15 (3)5.7 (1)763 (675)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (8)104 (215)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)21 (17)825 (1263)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)71 (11)16 (4)34 (29)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)26 (5)50 (31)133 (103)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3890 (4624)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)9.2 (3)40 (41)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)19 (10)29 (21)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)15 (4)8.8 (5)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)24 (5)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f4, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
172
1e-2
1682
1e-3
10200
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)210 (29)45 (3)14 (0.5)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)26 (3)5.8 (0.3)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1732 (232)398 (34)118 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)602 (68)132 (9)40 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)72 (11)16 (0.7)5.1 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)8.8 (1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)20 (3)8.1 (2)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (7)1833 (2410)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)17 (7)141 (68)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)91 (10)23 (5)34 (14)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)33 (4)32 (14)190 (298)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)921 (1172)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)11 (6)22 (13)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (5)25 (12)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)20 (5)11 (2)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)30 (4)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f5, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
190
1e-2
3207
1e-3
32860
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)245 (45)35 (3)7.9 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)29 (4)4.7 (0.4)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2298 (464)328 (38)150 (153)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)779 (175)105 (12)23 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)86 (16)12 (1)3.5 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)11 (1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)27 (10)23 (10)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)28 (16)38 (35)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)41 (19)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)101 (15)18 (7)72 (56)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)38 (6)96 (42)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)35 (6)55 (35)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)24 (11)622 (842)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)45 (34)74 (63)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)39 (27)46 (30)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)89 (63)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f6, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
236
1e-2
2134
1e-3
16568
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)150 (35)39 (4)10 (0.7)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.0 (12)19 (4)4.9 (0.7)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (5)1310 (293)342 (29)81 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.7 (8)435 (81)113 (10)28 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 3.1 (7)52 (7)13 (1.0)4.0 (0.5)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 4.8 (11)6.6 (1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.9 (9)15 (3)11 (4)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)16 (8)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.1 (17)12 (6)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (7)64 (13)16 (2)77 (35)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (11)23 (6)206 (169)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (4)19 (6)27 (21)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.7 (8)9.0 (3)86 (109)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)17 (3)41 (23)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)17 (7)16 (9)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (36)22 (4)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f7, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
24981
1e-2
6.8e5
1e-3
3.8e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)3.7 (2)27 (27)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.48 (0.3)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)32 (23)29 (45)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)11 (7)13 (16)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.3 (0.9)27 (28)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)9.1 (20)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.0 (3)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)7.0 (12)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)73 (84)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.1 (0.4)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.2 (2)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.3 (2)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)8.5 (16)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.5 (6)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.4 (3)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.5 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f8, 20-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
16448
1e-2
2.4e6
1e-3
2.8e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 162 (405)6.0 (3)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 49 (123)0.86 (0.4)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 44 (108)50 (21)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 625 (1561)17 (8)8.2 (6)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 129 (322)2.2 (1)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 15 (36)52 (61)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (20)36 (61)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)487 (517)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (26)492 (515)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 81 (201)4.3 (6)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (7)25 (60)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (60)55 (88)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 11 (26)49 (37)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (17)12 (19)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (3)9.1 (22)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 23 (58)2.6 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f9, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
144
1e-2
1468
1e-3
5944
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)248 (24)49 (3)22 (1)8/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)31 (3)6.2 (0.3)512 (507)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2040 (232)428 (28)181 (11)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)689 (86)144 (9)62 (3)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)87 (12)17 (0.8)7.6 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)11 (2)5452 (9877)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (2)5.9 (0.7)13 (8)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)17 (4)457 (1023)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)16 (3)126 (55)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)105 (11)22 (0.9)36 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)37 (7)31 (20)84 (38)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)53 (8)581 (375)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)10 (4)4.6 (2)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (4)14 (6)103 (81)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)20 (4)7.7 (2)68 (54)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)32 (4)135 (167)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f10, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
6124
1e-2
2.0e5
1e-3
2.4e5
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)9.2 (1)1.7 (3)20 (29)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.1 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)82 (10)6.1 (5)26 (12)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)26 (3)2.7 (5)15 (27)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)3.2 (0.4)4.4 (7)74 (100)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)37 (82)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)83 (245)10 (10)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)83 (163)24 (52)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)142 (327)93 (144)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)3.8 (0.6)4.8 (10)22 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.5 (0.5)11 (20)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)11 (17)1.2 (2)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)35 (74)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)6.6 (11)1.6 (2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)6.9 (10)1.9 (0.8)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (17)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f11, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
246
1e-2
3177
1e-3
1.1e5
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)89 (93)48 (21)16 (16)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 2.4 (5)19 (13)956 (944)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3.2 (7)338 (563)345 (157)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (11)184 (250)131 (55)35 (44)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.53 (0.5)38 (29)22 (10)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.87 (1)7.8 (5)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.83 (1)5.1 (3)2.5 (0.7)55 (33)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (5)3.5 (2)2.7 (1)85 (68)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (4)2.7 (2)137 (241)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.9 (6)14 (12)8.1 (8)13 (13)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.83 (1)5.8 (4)8.8 (10)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)7.1 (4)3.1 (0.8)2.1 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (3)2.6 (1)6.7 (4)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.4 (20)4.6 (3)3.7 (2)19 (16)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.6 (16)4.3 (3)2.2 (0.7)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (61)7.9 (5)8.0 (12)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f12, 20-D
1e0
11
1e-1
131
1e-2
1483
1e-3
11435
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.98 (2)161 (118)76 (24)24 (8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.0 (16)26 (16)8.7 (2)2.7 (1)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)1121 (1002)874 (861)854 (490)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)431 (326)222 (65)74 (22)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 4.0 (7)61 (46)25 (9)8.6 (4)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 7.8 (13)10 (5)2.9 (1)118 (88)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)13 (4)3.1 (0.9)58 (88)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (2)9.5 (3)135 (326)1582 (3236)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.6 (3)10 (4)11 (15)215 (359)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.87 (1)48 (20)13 (5)65 (122)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.67 (1)19 (6)12 (17)83 (100)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (2)29 (15)6.9 (3)15 (9)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (5)7.2 (3)2.7 (1)8.8 (18)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.84 (1)11 (4)4.0 (2)12 (20)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.71 (1)10 (3)3.8 (2)10 (10)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.8)21 (4)5.1 (2)5.5 (8)0/10

Δ HVref
f13, 20-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
139
1e-2
1087
1e-3
17899
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 318 (795)197 (104)70 (19)13 (4)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 40 (94)26 (10)8.5 (3)114 (168)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 14 (35)1499 (871)682 (223)203 (195)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 650 (1623)539 (254)214 (64)37 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 76 (190)69 (31)26 (7)4.2 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 15 (37)9.3 (4)1229 (2300)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (27)14 (5)5.3 (2)27 (52)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (1)9.2 (4)17 (25)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.9 (18)10 (3)43 (45)1111 (1062)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 45 (111)60 (27)20 (4)136 (60)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 16 (39)24 (9)20 (21)332 (369)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (73)38 (31)26 (25)50 (53)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.3 (7)4.9 (2)3.1 (2)7.2 (10)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (28)12 (6)6.3 (3)10 (9)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.4 (18)11 (4)5.0 (1)6.8 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (37)19 (8)12 (19)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f14, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
349
1e-2
6102
1e-3
63789
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.63 (0.8)180 (56)23 (4)14 (16)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 4.6 (11)22 (7)4.0 (2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1488 (468)202 (35)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.63 (0.8)527 (153)69 (12)13 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)62 (16)8.1 (2)17 (25)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)7.8 (3)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (2)23 (8)65 (99)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.77 (1)17 (7)251 (178)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.93 (2)2700 (4452)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.63 (0.8)66 (14)117 (157)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.2 (2)75 (100)323 (608)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.47 (0.3)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (3)9.5 (3)38 (19)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.43 (0.2)29 (16)97 (67)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)28 (16)31 (30)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.40 (0.2)55 (36)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f15, 20-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
210
1e-2
2099
1e-3
25094
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 6.0 (15)224 (104)53 (14)8.7 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 88 (219)31 (14)6.7 (2)720 (638)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (29)1799 (959)453 (120)119 (63)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.88 (2)592 (373)151 (40)26 (8)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 55 (138)83 (41)18 (4)3.4 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.3 (20)12 (6)2226 (2621)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (32)15 (8)13 (6)30 (44)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.7 (9)14 (8)435 (715)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.5 (16)2391 (4764)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.8 (14)52 (18)37 (52)381 (365)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 6.7 (16)21 (8)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.2 (18)9493 (7146)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.6 (4)7.2 (4)46 (74)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (15)13 (7)24 (9)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.4 (13)15 (12)11 (5)16 (11)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (10)19 (8)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f16, 20-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
32242
1e-2
1.0e6
1e-3
1.9e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (2)3.5 (2)2.4 (5)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.2 (2)0.46 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (4)26 (14)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)9.3 (5)2.3 (2)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.92 (1)1.3 (0.7)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 28 (49)0.16 (0.1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.5 (7)2.2 (3)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (1)27 (78)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (5)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (3)7.9 (17)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.8 (9)263 (426)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.0 (2)30 (26)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)2.4 (4)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.77 (1)5.9 (7)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (2)1.7 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f17, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
33890
1e-2
9.3e5
1e-3
2.7e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.4 (2)1.7 (2)0.69 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.32 (0.2)8.7 (11)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)19 (15)6.7 (7)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.8 (5)1.7 (3)0.71 (0.6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.84 (0.6)2.3 (4)0.68 (1.0)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.7 (15)19 (33)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)27 (30)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)89 (59)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)236 (384)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)40 (45)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)138 (103)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)24 (63)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)24 (19)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)6.1 (12)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)8.9 (9)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.78 (1)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f18, 20-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
141
1e-2
1507
1e-3
17541
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 22 (51)221 (97)54 (18)17 (9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 8.2 (20)30 (11)6.7 (2)458 (342)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.5 (2)1655 (1074)499 (191)547 (513)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.8 (4)598 (322)163 (62)62 (51)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)82 (33)19 (6)33 (57)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 14 (33)11 (3)1993 (2986)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (2)13 (3)3.3 (0.4)3.1 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)9.0 (3)6.2 (6)1114 (1881)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.1 (6)8.8 (3)22 (34)319 (332)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.8 (4)52 (24)12 (3)70 (75)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.7 (6)22 (5)5.8 (2)300 (271)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)60 (35)32 (19)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.5 (3)5.5 (2)2.1 (0.8)53 (41)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (8)12 (5)3.8 (0.8)4.6 (3)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)11 (2)3.3 (0.8)2.5 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)20 (6)6.2 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f19, 20-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
18889
1e-2
2.4e5
1e-3
5.1e6
#succ
6/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (4)3.3 (1)1.5 (2)3.6 (8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (3)0.61 (0.5)33 (25)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 6.7 (16)27 (7)4.6 (0.9)0.93 (1.0)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 3.0 (7)10 (2)1.6 (0.5)0.39 (0.2)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 128 (320)1.3 (0.4)5.8 (10)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 37 (90)71 (132)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.3 (22)48 (80)35 (47)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (9)27 (53)21 (32)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.9 (10)954 (1615)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)6.9 (14)20 (27)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.4 (8)159 (185)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (2)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.2 (7)7.4 (16)7.5 (14)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (5)11 (13)2.3 (5)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (14)3.4 (8)3.5 (4)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.29 (0.2)4.7 (8)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f20, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
136
1e-2
1870
1e-3
8641
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.57 (0.6)125 (77)30 (24)26 (36)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.47 (0.3)20 (13)3.8 (3)60 (116)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.87 (1)916 (807)235 (214)166 (125)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.37 (0.1)360 (284)84 (78)83 (112)5/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.63 (0.8)53 (35)11 (10)12 (20)1/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 0.43 (0.2)7.5 (3)120 (269)100 (116)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (17)17 (8)14 (25)543 (637)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.9 (6)14 (7)144 (311)927 (1099)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 13 (32)11 (4)21 (48)278 (294)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.3 (5)70 (25)10 (4)8.2 (11)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)27 (11)6.0 (7)88 (116)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (3)26 (11)32 (110)95 (93)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.73 (1)10 (5)49 (55)94 (64)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (16)15 (6)26 (70)95 (93)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)16 (7)17 (30)57 (92)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (31)26 (10)9.2 (7)11 (9)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 20-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
331
1e-2
1753
1e-3
9785
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 39 (96)76 (30)39 (12)22 (16)3/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 16 (40)10 (3)4.7 (2)310 (512)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 140 (348)586 (304)327 (109)162 (78)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 133 (332)216 (91)113 (36)54 (31)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 65 (162)28 (11)13 (4)10 (10)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 15 (38)3.6 (1)491 (856)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (61)7.5 (3)4.9 (3)61 (94)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (41)5.8 (3)317 (866)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 23 (58)5.3 (3)107 (211)1965 (2555)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 29 (72)33 (14)14 (4)71 (121)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 40 (99)13 (5)13 (15)255 (393)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 31 (77)13 (8)17 (21)61 (74)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 16 (39)4.0 (2)21 (40)201 (148)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (54)7.0 (4)14 (22)96 (146)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 19 (46)6.9 (3)6.7 (6)39 (31)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)11 (4)13 (9)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f22, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
313
1e-2
4469
1e-3
23797
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)160 (31)26 (2)11 (4)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)22 (4)1795 (6825)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1366 (306)222 (28)86 (24)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)476 (107)77 (9)27 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)60 (11)10 (2)43 (85)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.8 (1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (8)64 (120)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (6)76 (131)380 (877)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)121 (119)4233 (2797)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)68 (11)58 (53)119 (119)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)37 (23)180 (254)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2696 (3836)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)14 (6)204 (281)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)36 (23)61 (51)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)29 (16)31 (26)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)99 (83)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f23, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
332
1e-2
2660
1e-3
16975
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (3)130 (23)37 (4)13 (8)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.47 (0.3)18 (2)89 (189)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 15 (38)1079 (208)311 (38)88 (13)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (13)368 (86)107 (14)32 (7)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.63 (0.8)46 (11)13 (2)34 (59)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1.7 (4)6.3 (2)6769 (6015)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (4)11 (4)12 (11)193 (178)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.1 (7)11 (7)301 (940)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.0 (7)873 (1936)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.7 (3)39 (8)27 (36)67 (52)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.4 (3)16 (6)435 (530)1162 (1060)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (31)1740 (1578)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.5 (6)8.0 (7)67 (57)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.3 (12)10 (6)27 (24)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)10 (5)13 (8)115 (242)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (7)18 (11)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f24, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
61504
1e-2
8.1e5
1e-3
6.5e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 963 (2404)1.4 (0.9)23 (23)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 107 (266)0.22 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.7 (17)11 (8)24 (34)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1102 (2754)3.9 (3)1.6 (1)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 316 (788)0.54 (0.4)22 (23)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 53 (131)3.7 (8)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 44 (107)3.9 (8)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 29 (70)22 (33)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 60 (147)293 (358)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 59 (145)5.6 (12)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 20 (46)293 (171)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 828 (2067)29 (46)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 16 (39)13 (30)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 9.4 (21)3.8 (5)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.2 (18)1.4 (2)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.1 (3)1.5 (0.9)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f25, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
34160
1e-2
9.2e5
1e-3
1.2e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.7 (2)1.2 (1)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.22 (0.2)5.1 (9)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)14 (13)4.6 (4)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4.9 (4)1.4 (1)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.64 (0.5)3.3 (4)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.11 (0.1)5.1 (8)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)8.7 (21)20 (30)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)59 (117)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)101 (115)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.64 (0.6)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)62 (136)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)14 (12)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)4.3 (12)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.8 (3)2.0 (2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.8 (6)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.55 (0.5)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f26, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
136
1e-2
1117
1e-3
4425
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 615 (1536)195 (75)56 (24)88 (139)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 71 (176)25 (8)6.4 (2)118 (226)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 3470 (8675)1415 (672)503 (277)365 (282)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1416 (3538)524 (232)163 (74)150 (161)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 227 (566)70 (22)19 (8)64 (122)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 32 (78)8.7 (2)201 (449)679 (452)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 54 (135)18 (7)5.6 (3)55 (232)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 26 (65)12 (6)11 (17)696 (566)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 37 (91)11 (4)42 (73)126 (217)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 180 (450)73 (30)19 (7)11 (9)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 110 (274)28 (13)10 (9)19 (28)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 122 (305)33 (17)16 (11)22 (25)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (25)6.4 (4)6.6 (11)49 (80)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 35 (87)16 (8)6.9 (5)21 (40)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 40 (98)15 (9)5.3 (4)13 (22)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 38 (93)24 (11)8.4 (12)8.9 (6)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
60235
1e-2
1.3e6
1e-3
6.4e6
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (3)4.8 (9)2.4 (4)1.3 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 304 (756)8.4 (17)6.2 (9)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 59 (145)10 (3)1.3 (1)1.5 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 22 (52)3.3 (1)0.69 (0.7)1.3 (2)1/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 565 (1410)4.1 (8)3.6 (4)2.8 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 73 (180)33 (42)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (42)8.5 (25)6.2 (4)2.9 (3)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 30 (72)50 (50)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 5.6 (12)134 (398)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.1 (20)8.7 (17)2.6 (4)2.9 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 11 (24)9.5 (17)6.5 (6)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 36 (87)31 (37)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 8.4 (18)7.9 (5)1.4 (1)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (2)3.8 (4)1.5 (2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.2 (3)2.5 (3)1.4 (1)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (5)1.4 (1)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f28, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
62
1e-2
539
1e-3
6898
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)387 (77)102 (8)17 (2)5/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)51 (9)13 (1)37 (74)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2954 (605)880 (121)151 (17)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1036 (194)298 (38)51 (6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)143 (28)36 (4)6.2 (1)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)20 (6)419 (930)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)41 (8)15 (6)33 (42)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)34 (12)2041 (4068)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)27 (7)126 (77)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)185 (32)45 (4)314 (313)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)66 (13)34 (36)1340 (1015)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)51 (14)25 (10)88 (73)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)15 (4)11 (4)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)39 (9)38 (21)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)34 (12)18 (9)28 (25)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)60 (13)61 (93)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f29, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
359
1e-2
3841
1e-3
30739
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)154 (23)31 (3)7.2 (0.9)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)19 (3)4.0 (0.4)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1319 (136)273 (22)88 (68)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)446 (45)91 (6)21 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)54 (6)11 (0.7)3.0 (0.3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.5 (0.7)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (8)24 (12)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)19 (7)373 (698)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)62 (45)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)64 (9)48 (26)205 (195)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)35 (24)83 (70)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)343 (407)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)12 (5)170 (328)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)37 (20)122 (92)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)31 (14)41 (28)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f30, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
220
1e-2
1777
1e-3
10156
#succ
9/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 7.4 (16)158 (55)47 (7)15 (1)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 51 (126)20 (7)5.7 (1)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 9.4 (21)1358 (495)413 (61)132 (14)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1.9 (2)473 (164)137 (20)43 (4)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 15 (34)59 (17)16 (2)5.6 (0.9)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 49 (121)7.0 (2)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.3 (3)15 (6)11 (4)200 (257)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 21 (51)15 (8)1327 (1980)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.6 (9)29 (43)1041 (766)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.1 (18)57 (20)20 (5)109 (115)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.0 (8)21 (9)171 (175)1893 (1625)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (4)1770 (1727)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (0.2)9.0 (5)15 (12)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (13)15 (9)29 (18)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)17 (14)16 (9)191 (133)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.8 (20)21 (9)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f31, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
27722
1e-2
8.6e5
1e-3
3.0e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 92 (229)3.9 (2)21 (21)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 75 (186)0.56 (0.3)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 142 (353)33 (18)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 270 (673)11 (6)4.8 (6)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 103 (256)1.4 (0.7)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 34 (84)0.21 (0.1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.5 (18)24 (61)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (8)169 (325)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 23 (57)322 (885)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 93 (231)32 (36)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 41 (102)650 (956)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 46 (115)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 6.6 (16)67 (78)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (44)5.3 (7)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (25)8.4 (11)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 60 (150)6.7 (8)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f32, 20-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
32985
1e-2
1.1e6
1e-3
2.6e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 289 (718)2.5 (1)1.1 (2)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 101 (194)0.34 (0.2)16 (16)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 960 (2396)21 (9)8.9 (8)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 249 (618)7.3 (3)1.3 (1)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 159 (372)0.89 (0.4)2.8 (2)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 37 (73)6.9 (15)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 36 (78)17 (61)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (34)243 (440)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 24 (53)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 92 (218)61 (91)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 36 (84)142 (273)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 25 (47)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 14 (33)14 (29)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 18 (36)14 (18)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (32)9.3 (23)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 37 (89)1.6 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f33, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
33
1e-2
278
1e-3
3348
#succ
6/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)662 (180)184 (42)47 (25)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)87 (21)22 (4)5.8 (3)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)5109 (866)1576 (472)362 (124)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1778 (373)535 (141)139 (75)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)234 (53)62 (16)15 (8)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)33 (8)7.9 (2)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)66 (13)18 (1)18 (29)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)47 (16)21 (10)2477 (4616)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)38 (8)13 (4)1166 (597)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)272 (72)69 (10)27 (39)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)103 (22)25 (4)132 (201)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)87 (24)26 (9)15 (32)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)21 (6)7.1 (2)41 (48)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)54 (14)20 (3)26 (22)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)54 (13)18 (4)16 (19)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)95 (21)29 (8)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f34, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
45588
1e-2
1.9e5
1e-3
2.3e5
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 477 (1192)1.2 (0.3)5.2 (11)36 (78)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 81 (201)0.15 (0.0)25 (21)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1292 (3228)11 (3)5.4 (2)20 (11)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1264 (3158)3.6 (0.9)3.9 (5)16 (17)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 272 (679)0.44 (0.1)7.3 (11)79 (52)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 20 (49)29 (22)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 41 (103)0.22 (0.1)17 (21)82 (83)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 34 (83)19 (22)96 (137)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 43 (106)32 (33)99 (132)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 95 (238)0.48 (0.1)13 (12)41 (52)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 62 (155)20 (33)45 (48)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 213 (532)42 (48)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 10 (24)6.7 (9)10 (15)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 35 (87)2.1 (4)2.9 (2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (59)3.3 (2)3.0 (6)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 51 (126)2.0 (1)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f35, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
338
1e-2
4782
1e-3
41429
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)127 (20)22 (2)5.2 (0.6)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)17 (2)3770 (4810)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1090 (214)191 (20)47 (15)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)371 (62)65 (6)15 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)45 (7)7.7 (0.6)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.3 (0.5)★22e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (4)36 (18)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)19 (7)23 (13)34 (40)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)102 (72)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)60 (10)88 (89)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)26 (5)528 (265)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)22 (5)19 (8)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)12 (3)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)23 (11)133 (119)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)20 (5)49 (41)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)59 (47)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f36, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
454
1e-2
4824
1e-3
48159
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)142 (30)30 (4)6.8 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)14 (2)3.5 (0.3)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1308 (225)282 (37)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)421 (74)90 (13)28 (31)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)46 (7)10 (0.8)3.1 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)5.0 (0.6)★22e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (7)36 (32)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)23 (11)1128 (1508)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)214 (498)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)48 (7)61 (110)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)19 (3)1765 (3006)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)27 (26)191 (176)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)11 (4)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)33 (18)405 (394)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)25 (11)34 (15)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)433 (275)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f37, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
10528
1e-2
5.2e5
1e-3
3.5e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)10 (5)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.3 (0.8)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)82 (40)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)29 (13)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)3.6 (2)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)285 (475)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.0 (5)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)30 (58)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)117 (304)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)3.3 (1)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)191 (238)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (27)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)17 (27)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)10 (11)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.9 (4)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)18 (34)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f38, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
36705
1e-2
3.9e6
1e-3
2.2e8
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.0 (2)5.3 (3)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 6.3 (15)82 (109)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.90 (1)38 (10)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.50 (0.4)14 (3)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.7)7.7 (14)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 13 (31)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.93 (2)16 (28)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.67 (0.8)219 (300)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.3 (2)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.47 (0.3)1.6 (0.7)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.53 (0.5)64 (101)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.43 (0.2)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 0.43 (0.2)23 (52)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.47 (0.3)6.5 (8)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)11 (10)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (0.9)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f39, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
457
1e-2
3876
1e-3
25958
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)113 (15)30 (3)8.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)13 (2)3.7 (0.4)★22e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)961 (173)265 (40)89 (43)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)325 (56)88 (10)24 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)39 (6)10 (1)4.3 (3)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4.9 (0.7)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)14 (5)72 (133)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)16 (10)133 (218)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)73 (78)4942 (7482)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)48 (11)99 (143)115 (219)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)24 (18)123 (158)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)27 (15)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)7.2 (4)28 (21)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)23 (17)59 (33)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)20 (14)26 (20)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)122 (166)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f40, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
26134
1e-2
2.1e5
1e-3
2.6e6
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.3 (0.4)7.0 (22)1.9 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)8.8 (19)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)20 (3)8.0 (6)2.5 (2)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.9 (1)5.9 (5)1.5 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.86 (0.1)15 (17)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)179 (191)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.6 (3)26 (19)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.48 (0.4)40 (38)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)57 (101)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.0 (0.2)13 (21)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2.0 (4)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)6.0 (4)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)5.9 (16)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.4 (4)9.4 (9)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.0 (0.9)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.2 (3)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f41, 20-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
245
1e-2
2389
1e-3
15818
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 42 (104)144 (47)37 (5)10 (1)1/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 62 (154)19 (5)4.8 (0.7)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 7.3 (17)1199 (480)315 (44)82 (8)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.5 (5)419 (156)106 (13)29 (3)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 99 (246)54 (18)13 (2)4.5 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 12 (30)7.7 (1.0)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.0 (9)14 (6)16 (8)351 (377)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (38)22 (31)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 9.1 (21)21 (34)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 31 (76)49 (19)14 (2)1198 (1106)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.8 (18)20 (10)955 (895)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (41)21 (8)22 (11)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 12 (30)10 (7)103 (114)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (36)14 (10)41 (18)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 29 (72)14 (11)15 (7)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (29)20 (12)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f42, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
34578
1e-2
2.9e6
1e-3
2.3e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)3.3 (2)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.38 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)30 (19)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)10 (7)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.4 (15)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)6.6 (15)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.2 (1)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)26 (73)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)11 (14)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.70 (0.3)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.0 (2)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.6 (3)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)14 (14)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.7 (2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.2 (3)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.2 (1.0)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f43, 20-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
55957
1e-2
2.3e6
1e-3
3.9e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.3 (2)1.4 (0.5)2.1 (3)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 21 (51)0.19 (0.1)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 2.1 (4)12 (4)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.8 (6)4.0 (1)0.81 (0.6)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)0.51 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 20 (50)0.10 (0.1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)5.0 (19)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)144 (152)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 0.90 (1)89 (65)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.4 (10)0.90 (0.9)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.2 (7)23 (32)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (7)15 (11)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 2.6 (5)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)4.1 (10)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (3)6.0 (5)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)1.0 (1.0)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f44, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
168
1e-2
1485
1e-3
6584
#succ
10/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 31 (75)200 (72)52 (12)21 (4)4/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 65 (151)27 (10)6.4 (2)135 (380)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 34 (82)1629 (957)457 (99)176 (31)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 83 (204)558 (278)151 (38)60 (12)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 205 (511)75 (21)18 (5)7.4 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 53 (122)9.4 (3)900 (1347)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (53)19 (11)10 (7)47 (172)0/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 24 (59)17 (13)19 (20)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 40 (99)36 (69)2516 (1947)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 56 (136)69 (36)25 (18)84 (96)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 48 (118)28 (14)205 (274)535 (395)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 29 (71)175 (618)1239 (1246)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 3.6 (8)7.0 (5)10 (13)279 (220)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (39)20 (13)22 (25)141 (140)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.5 (20)17 (12)11 (8)21 (19)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 63 (157)25 (13)63 (47)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f45, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
49797
1e-2
2.4e6
1e-3
5.2e6
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (0.2)1.3 (0.5)0.88 (0.8)3.5 (2)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 7.2 (16)17 (20)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (0.2)11 (3)1.1 (0.7)3.8 (5)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 2.2 (3)4.0 (0.8)0.74 (1)3.6 (9)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.6 (2)0.46 (0.2)3.3 (4)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 3.9 (7)27 (40)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.8 (4)5.0 (11)3.4 (3)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)6.6 (14)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.7 (9)13 (30)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 4.1 (8)4.9 (10)1.3 (1)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (4)17 (30)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)1.3 (3)0.37 (0.3)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.3 (0.8)2.0 (4)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.7 (2)0.81 (1)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (0.2)0.97 (1)0.76 (0.9)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.4 (1)1.8 (1)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f46, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
55141
1e-2
1.0e6
1e-3
1.1e8
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.8 (1)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.34 (0.1)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)22 (9)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.5 (3)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.0 (0.4)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)9.2 (18)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)6.4 (10)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)332 (336)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)16 (45)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)10 (20)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)10 (9)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f47, 20-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
54618
1e-2
2.2e6
1e-3
5.2e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.60 (0.2)3.3 (1)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)0.40 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 0.95 (1)36 (27)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.80 (0.8)10 (4)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 0.85 (0.9)1.1 (0.4)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 5.6 (13)25 (18)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (4)8.5 (13)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)330 (577)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.8 (6)330 (394)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 2.5 (5)42 (74)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (2)330 (293)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.55 (0.1)33 (49)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1.1 (2)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.75 (0.6)33 (42)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (1)33 (32)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.65 (0.4)3.4 (4)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f48, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
22301
1e-2
3.5e5
1e-3
3.3e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)3.6 (2)23 (52)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.50 (0.2)51 (63)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)28 (16)55 (82)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)10 (6)3.8 (2)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.3 (0.8)51 (32)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.20 (0.1)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.7 (3)53 (16)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)60 (45)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)807 (830)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.1 (0.5)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)90 (202)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)81 (63)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)15 (13)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (1)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.2 (3)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.8 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f49, 20-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
1.6e5
1e-2
1.1e7
1e-3
7.1e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1.1 (1)0.84 (0.4)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 5.2 (12)5.4 (12)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 9.4 (22)6.8 (3)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 0.75 (0.6)2.5 (1)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1.4 (2)1.7 (3)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 8.4 (20)49 (21)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (5)6.1 (12)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.2 (9)29 (31)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 8.9 (21)11 (7)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 3.5 (8)1.3 (1)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1.1 (1)1.7 (3)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (26)3.5 (4)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 7.0 (16)5.3 (10)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (30)5.1 (6)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.2 (7)3.2 (4)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (25)1.2 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f50, 20-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
22169
1e-2
1.3e6
1e-3
2.0e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 0.67 (0.8)4.8 (2)6.7 (12)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 0.87 (1)0.68 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 4.1 (9)38 (12)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 5.8 (14)13 (5)2.4 (4)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 2.3 (5)1.7 (0.6)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 11 (26)11 (25)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (1)4.4 (5)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.5 (15)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 10 (23)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.3 (17)26 (113)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 7.6 (18)93 (99)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 5.0 (12)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.87 (1)43 (45)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)84 (56)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.4 (8)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f51, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
8574
1e-2
9.9e5
1e-3
2.2e7
#succ
0/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)7.4 (3)0.28 (0.1)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.97 (0.4)18 (25)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)59 (24)6.5 (7)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)21 (8)0.79 (0.2)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)2.7 (1)1.5 (3)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.38 (0.2)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)43 (210)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)554 (590)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)2100 (758)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)29 (60)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)261 (642)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)210 (198)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)17 (41)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)25 (76)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.9 (3)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f52, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
82166
1e-2
4.9e6
1e-3
2.4e7
#succ
1/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.5 (0.7)2e60/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)11 (24)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)12 (5)4.1 (5)2e60/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4.1 (2)3.8 (6)2e60/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.55 (0.3)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)97 (116)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)12 (18)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)106 (89)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)31 (32)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)0.80 (1)3.7 (4)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)4.2 (8)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)10 (9)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)10 (10)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.9 (6)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.2 (4)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (2)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f53, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
28
1e-2
159
1e-3
1952
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)649 (139)250 (28)46 (8)6/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)89 (23)32 (2)5.2 (0.9)0/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)4019 (1996)1985 (214)437 (94)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1685 (627)691 (59)139 (31)4/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)247 (64)87 (9)15 (2)0/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)36 (8)11 (1)1026 (3074)0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)61 (19)23 (3)3.7 (1.0)2/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)39 (16)20 (6)393 (515)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)37 (17)17 (8)21 (30)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)234 (101)94 (5)13 (2)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)91 (30)33 (3)5.8 (3)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)68 (20)29 (5)5.3 (2)0/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)22 (6)11 (4)16 (27)0/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)46 (19)22 (6)5.8 (4)0/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)51 (17)22 (4)3.9 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)87 (22)33 (4)7.3 (4)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 20-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
6049
1e-2
1.6e5
1e-3
2.5e6
#succ
8/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 293 (732)8.5 (1)5.9 (6)2.0 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 69 (172)1.1 (0.2)110 (268)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1195 (2987)73 (10)5.4 (0.7)0.74 (0.3)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 522 (1305)25 (3)1.9 (0.3)0.58 (0.6)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 72 (181)3.2 (0.5)8.4 (21)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 27 (67)83 (165)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 22 (55)38 (83)18 (46)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 12 (30)143 (166)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 16 (39)46 (97)55 (91)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 59 (146)3.3 (0.5)7.0 (13)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 29 (71)1.3 (0.2)118 (177)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 66 (164)44 (44)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 4.9 (12)9.1 (17)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 17 (42)5.0 (9)5.2 (7)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 15 (37)10 (17)11 (17)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 40 (99)2.6 (3)2e40/10

Δ HVref
f55, 20-D
1e0
1
1e-1
8.4e5
1e-2
8.8e6
1e-3
8.8e6
#succ
7/10
COMO-100 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.37 (0.6)0.93 (1)2.1 (3)0/10
COMO-10 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.6 (4)2e60/10
COMO-1e3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.1 (0.7)0.37 (0.4)1.1 (1)0/10
COMO-316 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)0.54 (0.6)0.28 (0.1)0.99 (2)0/10
COMO-32 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)1.6 (3)2.1 (2)2e60/10
COMO-3 biobj dufosse toure 1 (0)21 (26)2e60/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.8 (5)2.1 (3)2e60/10
IBEA-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.8 (4)2.1 (1)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-10-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)21 (16)2e60/10
MO-CMA-ES-100-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)1.1 (2)0.92 (1)2.1 (3)0/10
MO-CMA-ES-32-autoref biobj Dufosse Toure 1 (0)9.5 (13)2e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (1)2e50/10
N-III-11-platypus biobj Brockhoff 1 (0)2.1 (1)2e50/10
N-III-111-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.32 (0.4)0.22 (0.2)2e50/10
NSGA-II-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.58 (0.8)2e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.23 (0.2)2e40/10

Previous dimension | Dimension = 40 | First dimension

Δ HVref
f1, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
6023
1e-2
9415
1e-3
3.4e5
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.2 (0.1)★25.0 (0.5)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.8 (0.3)8.3 (1)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.7 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f2, 40-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
8937
1e-2
36920
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (4)0.64 (0.1)0.75 (0.3)★22.5e6 (4e6) 1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 16 (40) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 14 (35)0.94 (0.3) 0/10

Δ HVref
f3, 40-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
9126
1e-2
14466
1e-3
1.8e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0)0.71 (0.1)2.4 (1)★24e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0)399 (460)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0)1.1 (0.3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f4, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
6096
1e-2
9522
1e-3
9.9e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.1 (0.1)★23.1 (0.5)★24e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.6 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f5, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
7059
1e-2
18327
1e-3
5.1e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.7 (0.3)20 (5)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.0 (0.4)14 (5)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f6, 40-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
7488
1e-2
13828
1e-3
2.1e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.36 (0.4)1.0 (0.2)5.0 (2)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.0 (15)2.0 (1)19 (9)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.84 (2)3.2 (2)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f7, 40-D
1e0
28
1e-1
26319
1e-2
4.7e6
1e-3
2.0e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.04 (0)18 (39)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.04 (0)5.2 (8)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.04 (0)2.3 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f8, 40-D
1e0
32
1e-1
23042
1e-2
1.7e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.99 (2)47 (174) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (3)157 (313) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.27 (0.6)3.6 (4) 0/10

Δ HVref
f9, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
6019
1e-2
8971
1e-3
27077
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.0 (0.2)2.2 (0.4)★2140 (215)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.7 (3)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.4 (0.2)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f10, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
1.0e6
1e-2
4.0e6
1e-3
1.7e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.45 (1.0)1.5 (2)2.1 (4)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.18 (0.4)0.30 (0.2)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f11, 40-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
9656
1e-2
4.4e6
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.0 (4)0.28 (0.1)3.6e-3 (8e-4)5.0e6 (7e6) 2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.57 (0.6)0.39 (0.1)0.00 (2e-3)1.6e5 (1e5) 5/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.1 (2)0.41 (0.1)0.09 (0.2) 0/10

Δ HVref
f12, 40-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
20487
1e-2
1.1e6
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.14 (0)0.16 (0.1)0.01 (0.0)4.9e5 (1e6) 3/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.14 (0)0.46 (0.2)0.04 (0.0)1.5e5 (2e5) 2/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.14 (0)0.23 (0.1)0.02 (0.0)1.9e5 (2e5) 0/10

Δ HVref
f13, 40-D
1e0
209
1e-1
8106
1e-2
17455
1e-3
1.7e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.48 (1)0.51 (0.1)1.0 (0.3)★26.8e-3 (0.0)7/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.80 (2)1.4 (0.4)6.0 (3)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.51 (1)0.65 (0.2)11 (10)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f14, 40-D
1e0
9.0
1e-1
15592
1e-2
2.9e5
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0)1.4 (0.8)0.79 (0.5) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.11 (0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f15, 40-D
1e0
45
1e-1
35010
1e-2
3.8e5
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.02 (0)0.17 (0.1)0.27 (0.2)3.6e6 (2e6) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.02 (0)51 (60) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.02 (0)0.23 (0.1) 0/10

Δ HVref
f16, 40-D
1e0
11
1e-1
2.8e6
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.2 (15)0.21 (0.5)  0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.7 (14)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.3 (3)0.01 (0.0)  0/10

Δ HVref
f17, 40-D
1e0
11
1e-1
4.8e5
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.86 (2)0.78 (2)  0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (6)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.5 (6)0.06 (0.0)  0/10

Δ HVref
f18, 40-D
1e0
95
1e-1
11697
1e-2
31016
1e-3
4.0e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (3)0.33 (0.1)0.42 (0.2)★23.6e-3 (4e-3)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.4 (6)1.8 (1)8.3 (8)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (4)0.41 (0.1)6.2 (9)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f19, 40-D
1e0
5.0
1e-1
4.0e6
1e-2
1.6e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.70 (1)0.43 (0.5)1.0 (0.8)1.6e7 (1e7) 2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.54 (0.8) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (3)0.09 (0.1) 0/10

Δ HVref
f20, 40-D
1e0
40
1e-1
8896
1e-2
2.4e5
1e-3
2.1e6
#succ
1/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.03 (0)0.49 (0.1)0.19 (0.3)7.8 (11)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.03 (0)0.70 (0.2)0.71 (2)0.84 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.03 (0)0.66 (0.2)0.18 (0.1)0.09 (0.2)0/10

Δ HVref
f21, 40-D
1e0
140
1e-1
9081
1e-2
18728
1e-3
7.5e5
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.0 (3)0.52 (0.1)0.91 (0.4)0.95 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.45 (1)0.88 (0.3)2.8 (2)5.2 (9)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.94 (2)0.65 (0.2)4.0 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f22, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
21394
1e-2
68583
1e-3
4.8e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.75 (0.2)★212 (34)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)19 (29)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f23, 40-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
54998
1e-2
97265
1e-3
3.3e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)0.10 (0.0)0.48 (0.2)3.0 (4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)0.13 (0.0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f24, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
1.9e6
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.04 (0.1)3.7e7 (7e7)  0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.06 (0.1)  0/10

Δ HVref
f25, 40-D
1e0
4.0
1e-1
6.1e6
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)0.22 (0.3)3.9e7 (5e7)  0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.25 (0)8.5e-3 (0.0)  0/10

Δ HVref
f26, 40-D
1e0
59
1e-1
13218
1e-2
22850
1e-3
1.3e5
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (4)0.36 (0.1)0.50 (0.2)0.29 (0.3)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.6 (4)0.81 (0.4)1.6 (1)1.8 (2)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (7)0.42 (0.1)0.79 (0.7)0.52 (0.6)0/10

Δ HVref
f27, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
2.0e6
1e-2
1.9e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.87 (2)0.85 (0.4)3.6e7 (3e7) 1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f28, 40-D
1e0
244
1e-1
7646
1e-2
59516
1e-3
7.7e5
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1e-3 (0)0.68 (0.1)0.31 (0.1)★20.50 (0.4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1e-3 (0)0.96 (0.1)0.53 (0.1)5.1 (6)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1e-3 (0)0.91 (0.2)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f29, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
8316
1e-2
30254
1e-3
6.7e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.2 (0.4)★28.2 (3)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f30, 40-D
1e0
98
1e-1
8154
1e-2
18983
1e-3
7.0e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.01 (0)0.93 (0.7)2.6 (1)2.5 (4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.01 (0)207 (278)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.01 (0)2.2 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f31, 40-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
55825
1e-2
9.6e6
1e-3
3.8e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.74 (2)17 (30)3.9 (4)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 6.9 (17)65 (47)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.20 (0.1)6.5 (4)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f32, 40-D
1e0
57
1e-1
28540
1e-2
1.6e7
1e-3
1.9e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.37 (0.9)152 (282)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (5)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (3)4.3 (3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f33, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
5510
1e-2
7194
1e-3
13709
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.77 (0.1)1.5 (0.4)3.8 (2)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.0 (0.2)2.2 (0.5)4.4 (1)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.96 (0.1)8.9 (9)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f34, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
1.7e6
1e-2
6.0e6
1e-3
3.7e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.9 (3)2.7 (2)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.22 (0.1)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f35, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
7777
1e-2
22384
1e-3
4.2e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.5 (0.2)★235 (15)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)2.1 (0.4)9.1 (2)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f36, 40-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
11368
1e-2
2.4e5
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0)2.0 (0.7)2.8 (1) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0)4.2 (5) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f37, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
49950
1e-2
6.8e6
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.5 (1)1.7 (4) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4.2 (8) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f38, 40-D
1e0
11
1e-1
67828
1e-2
3.7e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.8 (9)6.4 (9) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.0 (7) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.0 (17) 0/10

Δ HVref
f39, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
8397
1e-2
27400
1e-3
4.5e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.6 (0.5)4.4 (2)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.7 (2)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)21 (17)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f40, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
9235
1e-2
4.0e6
1e-3
1.0e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)115 (217)2.3 (2)3.6 (6)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)206 (351)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f41, 40-D
1e0
42
1e-1
29058
1e-2
77278
1e-3
1.1e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (7)0.33 (0.2)2.0 (2)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.9 (5)0.59 (0.3)2.3 (1)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 2.7 (7)1.1 (1)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f42, 40-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
1.7e6
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.17 (0)0.19 (0.4)2.0e7 (3e7)  0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.17 (0)0.12 (0.1)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.17 (0)0.02 (0.0)  0/10

Δ HVref
f43, 40-D
1e0
8.0
1e-1
41747
1e-2
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.2 (3)8.1 (19)1.7e7 (3e7) 3.6e7 (2e7) 1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.7 (11)16 (22)  0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 11 (28)1.4 (2)  0/10

Δ HVref
f44, 40-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
7836
1e-2
19356
1e-3
1.1e5
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.63 (1)0.61 (0.2)1.6 (0.6)★22.3 (2)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 10 (25)2.0 (1)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 13 (33)0.84 (0.3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f45, 40-D
1e0
3.0
1e-1
4.0e6
1e-2
9.4e6
1e-3
3.8e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.33 (0)0.78 (2)1.8 (2)4e60/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.33 (0)0.16 (0.1)0.40 (0.6)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.33 (0)0.10 (0.1)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f46, 40-D
1e0
2.0
1e-1
1.6e6
1e-2
3.8e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0)0.77 (1)0.45 (0.5)1.8e7 (2e7) 2/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.50 (0)0.07 (0.0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f47, 40-D
1e0
6.0
1e-1
1.2e5
1e-2
4.0e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 3.6 (9)6.9 (10) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (13) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.5 (3) 0/10

Δ HVref
f48, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
69919
1e-2
1.7e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.9 (3)2.2 (2) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.43 (0.3) 0/10

Δ HVref
f49, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
1.1e6
1e-2
7.3e6
1e-3
1.9e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.51 (1)5.1 (8)2.0 (4)0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.8 (2)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.38 (0.2)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f50, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
5.0e5
1e-2
3.7e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)3.1 (5) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f51, 40-D
1e0
10
1e-1
25050
1e-2
1.6e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 4.1 (10)22 (48)2.4 (3) 0/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 0.18 (0.2)144 (192) 0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 5.2 (13)1.1 (1.0) 0/10

Δ HVref
f52, 40-D
1e0
7.0
1e-1
1.0e6
1e-2
6.8e6
1e-3
1.9e7
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1.8 (4)0.50 (1)2.4 (1)1.9 (4)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 7.7 (19)1.6 (1)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 8.7 (21)0.18 (0.3)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f53, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
6336
1e-2
8127
1e-3
12091
#succ
2/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.61 (0.1)0.91 (0.1)★21.1 (0.3)7/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.67 (0.2)1.2 (0.1)1.9 (0.5)0/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.73 (0.1)1.4 (0.5)15 (13)0/10

Δ HVref
f54, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
1.0e6
1e-2
6.0e6
1e-3
9.9e6
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.46 (1.0)0.67 (1)0.65 (1)1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)4e50/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.18 (0.1)4e40/10

Δ HVref
f55, 40-D
1e0
1
1e-1
2.7e6
1e-2
1.6e7
1e-3
#succ
0/10
GDE3-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)1.6 (2)2.2 (3)3.6e7 (4e7) 1/10
MOEAD-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.17 (0.3)0.23 (0.2)3.6e6 (6e6) 1/10
SPEA2-platypus biobj Brockhoff Tusar 1 (0)0.04 (0.0)0.02 (0.0)3.8e5 (5e5) 1/10

Average runtime (aRT in number of function evaluations) divided by the respective best aRT measured during BBOB-2016 in different dimensions. This aRT ratio and, in braces as dispersion measure, the half difference between 10 and 90%-tile of bootstrapped run lengths appear for each algorithm and target, the corresponding reference aRT  in the first row. The different target ∆I-values are shown in the top row. #succ is the number of trials that reached the (final) target Iref+ 10−5. The median number of conducted function evaluations is additionally given in italics, if the target in the last column was never reached. Entries, succeeded by a star, are statistically significantly better (according to the rank-sum test) when compared to all other algorithms of the table, with p = 0.05 or p = 10−k when the number k following the star is larger than 1, with Bonferroni correction by the number of functions (55). A ↓ indicates the same tested against the best algorithm from BBOB 2016. Best results are printed in bold.
Data produced with COCO v2.3.1.31, hv-hashes inconsistent: ff0e71e8cd978373 and 9c62f617dadcb154 found!