Overview page

Table showing the ERT in number of evaluations

Last dimension | Dimension = 2 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (3)20 (6)27 (5)32 (10)41 (5)53 (11)65 (7)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)15 (4)19 (4)15/15
16-30coby 14 (4)19 (5)26 (9)36 (6)41 (9)59 (10)65 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)17 (4)17 (4)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 13 (3)13 (4)14 (4)15 (10)15 (10)15 (10)15 (10)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (1)14 (4)17 (2)15/15
16-30coby 13 (3)14 (4)14 (4)16 (10)16 (10)16 (10)16 (10)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)17 (4)18 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 14 (4)14 (4)14 (4)14 (4)14 (4)14 (4)14 (4)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)15 (4)17 (4)15/15
16-30coby 11 (1)14 (4)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)14 (4)17 (4)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 12 (3)13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)13 (6)13 (6)13 (6)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)14 (4)18 (0)15/15
16-30coby 13 (4)16 (7)16 (7)17 (11)17 (11)17 (11)17 (11)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)15 (4)18 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 13 (5)15 (7)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)18 (8)18 (8)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)14 (4)17 (2)15/15
16-30coby 11 (1)13 (5)13 (5)13 (5)13 (5)13 (5)13 (5)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)14 (4)18 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 13 (5)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)18 (14)19 (16)20 (16)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)14 (4)18 (0)15/15
16-30coby 12 (4)14 (6)15 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)13 (4)18 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (4)18 (5)21 (7)25 (9)38 (16)104 (85)145 (149)15/15
1-15slsqp 29 (12)38 (20)51 (30)65 (38)81 (44)125 (116)149 (128)15/15
16-30coby 15 (4)18 (4)23 (7)28 (9)49 (39)1434 (2008)1475 (2018)15/15
16-30slsqp 29 (12)35 (15)46 (15)58 (15)76 (25)118 (49)211 (174)15/15

Δ fopt
f8, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (7)25 (8)32 (7)39 (9)46 (9)56 (14)62 (16)15/15
1-15slsqp 29 (10)39 (8)52 (15)68 (17)83 (28)244 (358)488 (942)15/15
16-30coby 22 (8)26 (11)32 (8)39 (11)43 (10)53 (11)61 (11)15/15
16-30slsqp 30 (12)38 (12)50 (20)68 (28)80 (28)114 (56)322 (282)15/15

Δ fopt
f9, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (11)29 (8)35 (11)41 (13)49 (10)68 (16)72 (19)15/15
1-15slsqp 32 (14)42 (15)56 (18)66 (14)75 (18)120 (44)298 (360)15/15
16-30coby 20 (7)30 (11)37 (11)45 (16)54 (21)71 (19)83 (26)15/15
16-30slsqp 31 (12)43 (14)58 (18)71 (14)82 (20)190 (206)267 (204)15/15

Δ fopt
f10, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (6)26 (10)36 (12)43 (13)52 (11)69 (19)78 (21)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (8)35 (12)45 (12)58 (18)70 (15)88 (18)214 (168)15/15
16-30coby 22 (4)28 (7)36 (11)44 (11)49 (13)69 (10)75 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 35 (18)42 (14)52 (15)66 (15)75 (26)145 (158)223 (202)15/15

Δ fopt
f11, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (6)28 (7)37 (9)42 (11)52 (11)69 (15)74 (21)15/15
1-15slsqp 31 (12)42 (14)53 (18)71 (18)87 (20)137 (94)249 (160)15/15
16-30coby 22 (6)29 (9)38 (10)46 (9)54 (16)72 (23)84 (31)15/15
16-30slsqp 30 (14)40 (20)53 (16)64 (16)81 (23)112 (72)228 (249)15/15

Δ fopt
f12, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (7)32 (14)37 (14)47 (17)56 (22)71 (27)78 (31)15/15
1-15slsqp 30 (10)40 (14)48 (18)58 (22)75 (28)95 (28)149 (104)15/15
16-30coby 21 (5)28 (9)35 (5)42 (4)50 (7)67 (10)73 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 37 (10)45 (7)53 (12)66 (16)77 (24)131 (126)333 (385)15/15

Δ fopt
f13, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (0)21 (16)90 (111)15/15
16-30coby 12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)12 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (0)13 (4)45 (67)93 (108)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)13 (4)18 (5)53 (86)15/15
16-30coby 13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)13 (3)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)21 (23)25 (20)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15 (8)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)19 (7)23 (20)15/15
16-30coby 13 (3)15 (5)15 (5)16 (9)17 (9)17 (9)17 (9)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)12 (4)21 (7)94 (121)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)27 (20)61 (61)15/15
16-30coby 14 (5)14 (5)15 (9)15 (9)15 (9)15 (9)15 (9)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)15 (5)96 (206)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (5)15 (5)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)24 (30)98 (74)15/15
16-30coby 15 (3)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)16 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)19 (5)65 (94)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 12 (3)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)27 (34)104 (111)15/15
16-30coby 13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)13 (4)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)15 (4)88 (88)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 19 (10)27 (12)42 (13)49 (15)1804 (2022)3.4e4 (3e4)1e40/15
1-15slsqp 42 (34)59 (52)76 (81)92 (130)108 (176)4975 (1e4)1.6e4 (1e4)10/15
16-30coby 18 (7)34 (14)47 (10)59 (7)1943 (4011)2.4e4 (3e4)9.4e4 (1e5)2/15
16-30slsqp 34 (14)48 (22)62 (37)72 (50)167 (143)3825 (3534)1.6e4 (2e4)8/15

Δ fopt
f20, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (6)166 (29)176 (77)190 (138)201 (187)315 (651)372 (1006)15/15
1-15slsqp 39 (20)54 (41)106 (56)164 (72)208 (113)390 (393)988 (1222)15/15
16-30coby 21 (6)34 (7)55 (10)73 (8)86 (7)126 (11)141 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 36 (10)53 (28)66 (36)83 (43)112 (61)330 (492)538 (668)15/15

Δ fopt
f21, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (8)30 (9)39 (10)45 (9)55 (13)68 (14)80 (17)15/15
1-15slsqp 43 (18)55 (14)68 (20)89 (39)121 (67)369 (438)624 (726)15/15
16-30coby 22 (5)27 (6)34 (8)45 (9)53 (9)70 (13)75 (13)15/15
16-30slsqp 36 (14)53 (18)63 (17)85 (28)100 (38)249 (260)324 (304)15/15

Δ fopt
f22, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (5)31 (11)35 (15)42 (12)51 (8)69 (19)78 (18)15/15
1-15slsqp 39 (9)48 (18)66 (20)82 (34)153 (192)304 (260)455 (357)15/15
16-30coby 22 (6)33 (7)38 (8)47 (10)53 (10)73 (16)82 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 39 (14)56 (18)65 (30)91 (44)121 (98)408 (402)1208 (1154)15/15

Δ fopt
f23, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (5)28 (6)36 (6)41 (10)50 (11)67 (16)73 (19)15/15
1-15slsqp 39 (20)48 (18)67 (30)87 (31)106 (39)171 (106)219 (100)15/15
16-30coby 21 (6)28 (9)35 (10)46 (9)53 (9)67 (13)73 (16)15/15
16-30slsqp 39 (16)52 (12)63 (22)85 (30)126 (88)224 (180)384 (690)15/15

Δ fopt
f24, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (10)31 (10)36 (10)43 (14)49 (9)68 (12)80 (19)15/15
1-15slsqp 39 (18)55 (13)64 (18)77 (22)91 (25)177 (134)523 (750)15/15
16-30coby 24 (6)32 (9)39 (9)44 (11)51 (14)67 (9)77 (18)15/15
16-30slsqp 44 (14)52 (12)66 (22)91 (48)104 (60)275 (270)394 (423)15/15

Δ fopt
f25, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (13)30 (12)39 (15)53 (12)866 (1012)1.2e4 (9013)3.6e4 (3e4)5/15
1-15slsqp 33 (14)41 (10)49 (14)55 (17)57 (14)2490 (4096)9588 (9846)11/15
16-30coby 22 (13)35 (16)46 (18)54 (17)1133 (1014)1.5e4 (1e4)5.4e4 (5e4)3/15
16-30slsqp 30 (14)44 (17)50 (26)145 (30)229 (620)5038 (4704)1.2e4 (2e4)11/15

Δ fopt
f26, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 41 (6)62 (6)78 (7)105 (10)125 (9)346 (716)356 (758)15/15
1-15slsqp 34 (16)49 (22)69 (27)79 (30)103 (72)437 (600)804 (674)15/15
16-30coby 25 (6)1078 (919)1374 (1004)1553 (1890)1575 (2012)1589 (2012)1594 (2012)14/15
16-30slsqp 35 (14)56 (33)165 (96)190 (110)867 (140)1175 (1024)1787 (1656)15/15

Δ fopt
f27, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 22 (9)27 (7)35 (8)42 (14)49 (13)64 (17)72 (16)15/15
1-15slsqp 42 (18)56 (30)72 (32)112 (99)131 (92)253 (169)743 (630)15/15
16-30coby 23 (9)32 (7)38 (11)45 (14)53 (21)72 (22)80 (21)15/15
16-30slsqp 38 (10)50 (12)66 (20)81 (25)113 (81)282 (353)316 (348)15/15

Δ fopt
f28, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 24 (8)30 (9)38 (10)46 (7)52 (7)68 (12)76 (15)15/15
1-15slsqp 49 (43)63 (56)73 (53)90 (46)114 (60)384 (303)615 (906)15/15
16-30coby 24 (6)29 (7)36 (8)42 (6)49 (9)68 (13)74 (17)15/15
16-30slsqp 38 (15)51 (26)66 (32)77 (20)95 (25)261 (264)351 (376)15/15

Δ fopt
f29, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (3)31 (6)38 (7)45 (8)55 (13)69 (9)76 (13)15/15
1-15slsqp 43 (14)57 (20)70 (24)93 (24)131 (115)453 (371)730 (624)15/15
16-30coby 26 (7)32 (6)37 (10)44 (9)53 (11)67 (13)76 (13)15/15
16-30slsqp 43 (18)58 (20)71 (26)89 (26)109 (64)253 (180)610 (836)15/15

Δ fopt
f30, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 22 (5)29 (9)35 (4)43 (3)47 (5)63 (6)71 (12)15/15
1-15slsqp 37 (10)51 (20)65 (22)83 (22)98 (32)173 (108)406 (332)15/15
16-30coby 23 (8)31 (11)39 (8)47 (12)56 (10)71 (17)77 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 40 (20)55 (23)69 (31)85 (41)98 (42)200 (202)316 (207)15/15

Δ fopt
f31, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (10)17 (10)20 (12)156 (13)427 (13)1639 (4014)1647 (4018)15/15
1-15slsqp 15 (7)16 (7)16 (7)17 (7)18 (7)672 (24)686 (56)14/15
16-30coby 14 (7)18 (8)22 (13)23 (15)29 (18)703 (1014)980 (2006)15/15
16-30slsqp 15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)15 (7)18 (7)37 (34)40 (40)15/15

Δ fopt
f32, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 19 (8)27 (11)34 (11)39 (16)42 (19)48 (22)50 (26)15/15
1-15slsqp 16 (10)18 (14)21 (21)21 (21)23 (21)26 (20)27 (18)15/15
16-30coby 18 (5)24 (9)29 (12)32 (15)35 (16)42 (21)44 (26)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (10)18 (10)20 (10)20 (10)22 (10)24 (7)25 (10)15/15

Δ fopt
f33, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 24 (12)28 (15)33 (16)37 (21)45 (26)56 (32)61 (35)15/15
1-15slsqp 19 (14)21 (14)23 (21)23 (21)25 (21)27 (18)28 (18)15/15
16-30coby 22 (7)31 (17)38 (23)43 (26)45 (26)52 (33)57 (33)15/15
16-30slsqp 22 (10)25 (10)25 (10)25 (10)25 (10)27 (7)31 (14)15/15

Δ fopt
f34, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (9)24 (12)27 (15)33 (20)34 (23)40 (27)42 (34)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (7)20 (14)20 (14)23 (14)23 (14)25 (14)26 (10)15/15
16-30coby 18 (7)21 (10)27 (15)33 (18)37 (20)46 (32)49 (32)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (10)18 (10)20 (10)20 (10)21 (10)24 (12)25 (10)15/15

Δ fopt
f35, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 18 (8)22 (14)24 (16)26 (18)29 (24)31 (26)33 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 19 (10)20 (14)21 (14)22 (18)22 (18)25 (14)28 (14)15/15
16-30coby 20 (8)26 (14)33 (20)37 (23)42 (28)50 (33)53 (38)15/15
16-30slsqp 16 (10)18 (10)19 (10)20 (10)21 (10)22 (10)28 (10)15/15

Δ fopt
f36, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (6)26 (7)33 (12)37 (20)46 (22)52 (29)56 (34)15/15
1-15slsqp 19 (10)21 (10)22 (10)23 (10)24 (14)27 (14)28 (15)15/15
16-30coby 24 (12)29 (14)38 (10)41 (10)45 (16)52 (23)57 (23)15/15
16-30slsqp 22 (10)25 (10)26 (10)26 (10)28 (16)31 (14)31 (14)15/15

Δ fopt
f37, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (6)29 (7)31 (7)33 (11)35 (9)39 (9)42 (9)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)13 (4)21 (17)15/15
16-30coby 26 (7)29 (7)31 (9)34 (9)35 (9)38 (9)40 (9)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)13 (0)19 (18)45 (67)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 22 (10)24 (11)25 (14)25 (14)25 (14)25 (14)25 (14)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)19 (7)56 (50)15/15
16-30coby 21 (10)24 (12)25 (16)26 (16)26 (16)26 (16)26 (16)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)21 (16)40 (36)15/15

Δ fopt
f39, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (12)24 (13)24 (14)24 (14)25 (15)25 (15)25 (15)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)16 (4)32 (32)15/15
16-30coby 18 (7)18 (7)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)17 (4)35 (26)15/15

Δ fopt
f40, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 22 (13)24 (13)24 (17)27 (17)27 (17)27 (17)27 (17)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)23 (20)78 (118)15/15
16-30coby 23 (15)25 (15)25 (18)25 (18)25 (18)25 (18)25 (18)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)18 (5)36 (17)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (11)23 (11)23 (11)23 (11)23 (11)23 (11)23 (11)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)17 (7)43 (47)15/15
16-30coby 26 (14)28 (16)29 (16)31 (22)32 (22)33 (34)33 (34)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)17 (4)19 (4)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 19 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)20 (10)15/15
1-15slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)19 (7)54 (51)15/15
16-30coby 20 (11)22 (14)23 (17)23 (17)23 (17)23 (17)23 (17)15/15
16-30slsqp 11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)11 (0)20 (7)36 (31)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 453 (686)662 (693)671 (692)682 (697)692 (700)722 (699)968 (1092)15/15
1-15slsqp 1107 (1024)1427 (894)1438 (903)1456 (910)1478 (920)1535 (848)1637 (862)15/15
16-30coby 267 (272)518 (659)526 (660)535 (658)547 (659)704 (784)721 (782)15/15
16-30slsqp 1943 (3530)2484 (3530)2493 (3534)2503 (3548)2527 (3536)2611 (3456)2651 (3480)15/15

Δ fopt
f44, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 76 (92)82 (90)92 (92)98 (90)104 (90)115 (92)119 (92)15/15
1-15slsqp 1347 (1932)1363 (1936)1375 (1936)1385 (1938)1400 (1928)1434 (1930)1441 (1930)15/15
16-30coby 202 (267)212 (260)221 (260)226 (255)231 (253)262 (266)275 (264)15/15
16-30slsqp 1618 (2918)1627 (2522)1641 (2477)1654 (3660)1671 (2432)1693 (2540)1776 (2440)14/15

Δ fopt
f45, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 213 (377)221 (383)226 (380)233 (378)241 (381)256 (383)262 (382)15/15
1-15slsqp 495 (674)508 (668)518 (670)528 (664)538 (670)557 (673)567 (682)15/15
16-30coby 112 (118)119 (124)127 (122)132 (122)138 (126)155 (124)160 (130)15/15
16-30slsqp 681 (939)696 (933)704 (933)712 (944)725 (941)741 (946)753 (956)15/15

Δ fopt
f46, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 138 (266)145 (268)153 (265)159 (267)165 (269)179 (267)185 (274)15/15
1-15slsqp 693 (866)707 (867)719 (862)737 (864)749 (861)771 (896)779 (894)15/15
16-30coby 73 (102)80 (104)85 (106)93 (108)101 (104)121 (114)128 (112)15/15
16-30slsqp 638 (944)650 (948)660 (948)672 (932)681 (936)699 (949)740 (949)15/15

Δ fopt
f47, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 219 (610)227 (612)234 (618)241 (614)250 (620)266 (618)274 (620)15/15
1-15slsqp 461 (540)471 (547)478 (550)494 (540)502 (544)522 (540)824 (544)15/15
16-30coby 51 (7)56 (8)65 (9)69 (10)75 (12)89 (16)98 (13)15/15
16-30slsqp 634 (988)643 (988)652 (984)661 (998)671 (990)689 (987)693 (984)15/15

Δ fopt
f48, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 54 (11)61 (17)69 (13)73 (14)80 (14)95 (16)102 (18)15/15
1-15slsqp 341 (216)358 (219)372 (222)379 (226)387 (216)405 (219)449 (367)15/15
16-30coby 43 (11)48 (14)55 (13)61 (14)70 (14)80 (22)89 (29)15/15
16-30slsqp 496 (386)504 (387)520 (380)528 (383)544 (378)559 (376)576 (378)15/15

Δ fopt
f49, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 701 (973)769 (973)779 (969)790 (971)803 (964)1009 (981)1762 (2282)15/15
1-15slsqp 1970 (2164)2002 (2158)2013 (2164)2032 (2160)2048 (2152)2297 (2179)2336 (2160)15/15
16-30coby 683 (491)2193 (5454)2203 (5452)2214 (5462)2226 (5458)2254 (5456)2749 (5464)15/15
16-30slsqp 2985 (6122)5129 (6878)5141 (6058)5168 (9180)5193 (6896)5251 (5970)5278 (6205)13/15

Δ fopt
f50, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 228 (346)254 (344)266 (348)288 (342)316 (344)428 (509)494 (576)15/15
1-15slsqp 1341 (1518)1351 (1508)1361 (1512)1372 (1512)1385 (1512)1400 (1528)1436 (1550)15/15
16-30coby 770 (1164)778 (1170)784 (1172)790 (1178)796 (1172)808 (1178)813 (1172)15/15
16-30slsqp 1791 (3032)1809 (3040)1824 (3046)1832 (3043)1848 (3048)1905 (3052)1983 (3064)15/15

Δ fopt
f51, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 108 (92)115 (92)121 (94)127 (94)135 (94)149 (98)154 (98)15/15
1-15slsqp 415 (835)428 (834)439 (838)448 (834)463 (826)491 (824)541 (842)15/15
16-30coby 193 (208)198 (212)204 (212)230 (218)239 (220)255 (222)260 (218)15/15
16-30slsqp 614 (652)623 (652)637 (671)649 (668)659 (664)681 (652)686 (652)15/15

Δ fopt
f52, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 106 (180)111 (180)119 (182)123 (182)128 (180)141 (178)148 (182)15/15
1-15slsqp 464 (479)478 (490)489 (480)502 (480)512 (476)528 (481)543 (484)15/15
16-30coby 37 (7)43 (8)49 (5)56 (10)64 (12)76 (14)83 (21)15/15
16-30slsqp 658 (528)670 (526)682 (520)692 (522)701 (526)793 (546)827 (536)15/15

Δ fopt
f53, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 339 (570)345 (572)355 (570)359 (570)365 (568)379 (574)387 (568)15/15
1-15slsqp 1158 (1997)1170 (1997)1182 (2002)1194 (1990)1204 (1983)1230 (1991)1239 (1983)15/15
16-30coby 344 (728)350 (730)357 (732)362 (736)370 (730)385 (730)394 (732)15/15
16-30slsqp 521 (646)531 (656)542 (652)555 (666)569 (667)591 (676)606 (698)15/15

Δ fopt
f54, 2-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 70 (100)92 (100)99 (96)105 (102)116 (106)130 (108)136 (106)15/15
1-15slsqp 552 (1062)559 (1076)566 (1079)584 (1076)598 (1076)621 (1060)650 (1064)15/15
16-30coby 65 (92)70 (96)78 (98)83 (98)93 (98)110 (92)116 (94)15/15
16-30slsqp 382 (376)396 (378)412 (386)416 (382)424 (386)452 (398)492 (393)15/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 3 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (9)29 (12)39 (10)51 (12)67 (11)89 (14)100 (15)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)17 (4)25 (10)15/15
16-30coby 21 (8)30 (9)42 (11)53 (15)67 (12)90 (19)102 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)18 (4)21 (9)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 17 (5)23 (8)36 (6)47 (12)56 (12)76 (11)84 (17)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)19 (4)20 (4)15/15
16-30coby 17 (8)20 (9)24 (12)40 (17)47 (12)65 (18)80 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (4)21 (4)23 (4)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (3)17 (7)17 (7)17 (7)17 (7)17 (7)17 (7)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)20 (4)21 (2)15/15
16-30coby 15 (4)20 (10)23 (15)24 (15)25 (15)27 (15)27 (15)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)17 (4)21 (3)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 16 (4)18 (8)22 (13)25 (23)26 (23)27 (23)27 (23)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)18 (4)22 (0)15/15
16-30coby 17 (6)20 (7)21 (14)26 (16)27 (23)27 (23)27 (23)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)17 (4)21 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (5)16 (8)16 (8)17 (8)17 (8)17 (8)17 (8)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)18 (4)22 (0)15/15
16-30coby 14 (3)17 (10)20 (18)21 (20)21 (20)21 (20)21 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)19 (4)21 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (4)19 (8)21 (14)21 (14)21 (16)21 (16)21 (16)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)18 (4)22 (0)15/15
16-30coby 16 (6)19 (12)21 (13)23 (16)24 (16)26 (23)26 (23)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (4)19 (4)22 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (7)29 (8)42 (15)59 (17)1564 (2535)2.9e4 (3e4)4.5e4 (4e4)5/15
1-15slsqp 37 (16)50 (24)59 (20)84 (48)113 (50)413 (252)1028 (2314)15/15
16-30coby 19 (6)32 (11)252 (549)542 (1004)1274 (2018)2.4e4 (3e4)9.0e4 (1e5)3/15
16-30slsqp 35 (16)50 (24)62 (18)79 (30)117 (48)405 (354)844 (754)15/15

Δ fopt
f8, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 29 (20)186 (58)990 (2028)4792 (7411)1.1e4 (1e4)3.1e4 (3e4)1.3e5 (2e5)2/15
1-15slsqp 52 (57)137 (94)829 (1304)1579 (3506)3058 (3755)1.1e4 (8798)3.0e4 (4e4)7/15
16-30coby 28 (16)49 (24)691 (1026)8088 (1e4)1.4e4 (1e4)5.1e4 (6e4)1.0e5 (1e5)3/15
16-30slsqp 61 (38)112 (96)1104 (2288)2158 (3362)3739 (4446)2.8e4 (4e4)6.3e4 (7e4)3/15

Δ fopt
f9, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 118 (22)219 (22)328 (22)338 (22)352 (29)408 (33)437 (31)15/15
1-15slsqp 42 (18)53 (18)72 (29)87 (29)100 (39)197 (122)476 (390)15/15
16-30coby 33 (8)42 (12)55 (20)67 (26)88 (23)114 (29)123 (33)15/15
16-30slsqp 41 (14)55 (16)68 (21)81 (26)98 (22)199 (122)537 (449)15/15

Δ fopt
f10, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 32 (6)43 (16)59 (36)67 (34)77 (37)106 (51)131 (48)15/15
1-15slsqp 37 (19)57 (24)70 (29)81 (24)102 (44)264 (244)526 (608)15/15
16-30coby 51 (9)157 (292)361 (326)378 (328)388 (328)414 (331)424 (331)15/15
16-30slsqp 43 (19)64 (22)77 (22)99 (36)120 (43)337 (462)999 (1557)15/15

Δ fopt
f11, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (8)42 (10)49 (10)70 (21)144 (27)230 (29)244 (42)15/15
1-15slsqp 44 (24)64 (24)76 (24)90 (24)119 (44)355 (394)713 (874)15/15
16-30coby 31 (10)41 (13)51 (16)67 (13)77 (18)101 (21)111 (24)15/15
16-30slsqp 37 (14)49 (18)63 (20)76 (19)88 (29)403 (409)698 (618)15/15

Δ fopt
f12, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 30 (11)37 (8)48 (10)57 (12)69 (12)90 (13)99 (18)15/15
1-15slsqp 36 (14)50 (22)57 (19)72 (22)90 (32)181 (152)387 (340)15/15
16-30coby 32 (10)41 (14)49 (18)60 (20)73 (16)107 (20)118 (21)15/15
16-30slsqp 48 (18)59 (22)70 (28)81 (24)103 (27)309 (111)621 (1173)15/15

Δ fopt
f13, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 14 (3)15 (3)15 (3)15 (3)15 (3)15 (3)15 (3)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)28 (32)86 (94)15/15
16-30coby 13 (2)13 (2)13 (2)13 (2)13 (2)13 (2)13 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)16 (4)42 (34)82 (82)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 14 (2)14 (2)14 (2)14 (2)14 (2)14 (2)14 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)20 (9)40 (38)15/15
16-30coby 14 (2)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)14 (3)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)33 (38)66 (80)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 16 (6)16 (6)16 (6)16 (6)16 (6)16 (6)16 (6)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)33 (24)63 (82)15/15
16-30coby 16 (6)19 (12)20 (16)21 (17)21 (17)21 (17)21 (17)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)30 (24)60 (74)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 18 (7)18 (7)18 (7)18 (7)18 (7)18 (7)18 (7)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)38 (37)60 (83)15/15
16-30coby 15 (2)17 (7)17 (7)19 (13)19 (13)19 (13)19 (13)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (4)28 (24)68 (83)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 15 (6)17 (12)17 (12)17 (12)17 (12)17 (12)17 (12)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)21 (9)23 (4)15/15
16-30coby 20 (12)23 (15)24 (19)28 (22)29 (28)31 (34)31 (34)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (1)24 (6)55 (72)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 17 (6)19 (9)20 (14)21 (14)21 (14)21 (14)21 (14)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)31 (25)70 (66)15/15
16-30coby 14 (4)17 (7)19 (14)20 (14)20 (14)20 (14)20 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)23 (9)60 (68)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (15)114 (78)3217 (3008)6787 (7954)2.5e4 (2e4)2e40/15
1-15slsqp 67 (31)119 (78)574 (834)1393 (1789)4783 (5141)2.9e4 (2e4)8.1e4 (9e4)3/15
16-30coby 25 (13)413 (442)3208 (4028)8922 (9246)3.6e4 (6e4)2e40/15
16-30slsqp 42 (26)76 (40)162 (153)858 (380)2483 (6013)2.4e4 (3e4)6.8e4 (8e4)4/15

Δ fopt
f20, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (16)237 (209)2020 (3026)1.2e4 (1e4)3.0e4 (4e4)1.4e5 (7e4)2e40/15
1-15slsqp 55 (20)197 (215)1537 (1349)4812 (8486)1.4e4 (1e4)5.6e4 (6e4)1e40/15
16-30coby 31 (12)92 (53)3046 (5034)5336 (7018)2.5e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (2e5)2.5e5 (3e5)1/15
16-30slsqp 56 (20)78 (52)630 (1004)1815 (2172)6609 (8523)5.9e4 (6e4)1.2e5 (1e5)2/15

Δ fopt
f21, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (11)40 (12)53 (10)64 (16)76 (17)108 (20)118 (24)15/15
1-15slsqp 52 (14)77 (37)130 (80)161 (158)215 (186)288 (262)1037 (973)15/15
16-30coby 31 (10)42 (15)52 (22)104 (24)187 (30)234 (36)251 (48)15/15
16-30slsqp 50 (22)67 (20)88 (52)127 (50)219 (116)482 (283)854 (554)15/15

Δ fopt
f22, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 33 (11)42 (12)51 (13)66 (14)77 (13)378 (39)388 (44)15/15
1-15slsqp 55 (9)74 (16)89 (19)155 (51)191 (108)609 (860)1043 (1105)15/15
16-30coby 29 (10)35 (10)53 (15)82 (12)97 (22)125 (22)139 (30)15/15
16-30slsqp 54 (21)73 (22)96 (33)123 (52)186 (129)577 (872)1995 (3024)15/15

Δ fopt
f23, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (11)41 (10)51 (10)59 (12)92 (15)140 (42)163 (50)15/15
1-15slsqp 50 (14)69 (22)81 (26)108 (64)122 (76)199 (111)570 (686)15/15
16-30coby 31 (6)43 (11)60 (25)79 (25)95 (22)121 (20)135 (36)15/15
16-30slsqp 52 (19)74 (24)89 (34)116 (68)141 (60)464 (692)2442 (3627)15/15

Δ fopt
f24, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 30 (10)40 (12)55 (11)63 (16)84 (22)104 (22)118 (33)15/15
1-15slsqp 64 (18)76 (26)118 (46)155 (96)248 (148)1611 (1218)2851 (3036)14/15
16-30coby 35 (9)45 (8)57 (15)69 (17)86 (24)127 (57)147 (65)15/15
16-30slsqp 72 (48)83 (46)117 (66)146 (78)211 (266)818 (876)2528 (3470)15/15

Δ fopt
f25, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 25 (14)40 (14)50 (13)63 (20)3434 (6038)2.6e5 (3e5)2e40/15
1-15slsqp 47 (32)63 (43)90 (67)123 (128)155 (194)1.5e4 (1e4)2.5e5 (2e5)1/15
16-30coby 21 (11)38 (14)51 (10)64 (17)5306 (5018)2.6e5 (3e5)2e40/15
16-30slsqp 42 (18)61 (14)69 (16)83 (26)94 (26)1.1e4 (1e4)7.7e4 (5e4)3/15

Δ fopt
f26, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 35 (14)54 (16)66 (28)79 (23)2230 (5030)1.7e4 (2e4)1.9e4 (2e4)10/15
1-15slsqp 52 (31)75 (53)99 (97)120 (148)140 (202)4505 (5074)9886 (9788)14/15
16-30coby 30 (14)53 (19)70 (12)84 (19)1566 (3022)1.4e4 (1e4)3.4e4 (3e4)7/15
16-30slsqp 52 (22)70 (16)82 (30)89 (34)214 (68)1526 (1954)1.1e4 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f27, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 32 (13)50 (27)61 (32)73 (40)87 (47)108 (53)117 (63)15/15
1-15slsqp 53 (26)72 (16)88 (32)107 (43)155 (57)528 (796)1069 (1616)15/15
16-30coby 33 (14)43 (13)52 (18)66 (21)76 (22)100 (19)117 (34)15/15
16-30slsqp 60 (22)81 (40)115 (48)151 (122)281 (266)802 (1212)2131 (2791)15/15

Δ fopt
f28, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (7)43 (13)55 (16)68 (15)78 (18)101 (29)116 (32)15/15
1-15slsqp 53 (24)74 (29)97 (52)143 (80)178 (76)349 (314)668 (777)15/15
16-30coby 30 (8)41 (9)52 (11)97 (30)160 (29)237 (46)381 (1008)15/15
16-30slsqp 76 (38)94 (40)107 (42)131 (65)175 (149)377 (286)882 (920)15/15

Δ fopt
f29, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 35 (14)48 (22)61 (24)80 (25)119 (31)183 (34)213 (32)15/15
1-15slsqp 56 (24)80 (36)102 (32)117 (32)201 (209)909 (1448)2088 (3226)15/15
16-30coby 32 (6)44 (11)108 (16)334 (24)353 (34)498 (46)530 (70)15/15
16-30slsqp 54 (19)70 (18)84 (29)103 (32)168 (62)353 (469)1098 (1434)15/15

Δ fopt
f30, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (11)44 (11)54 (14)62 (14)72 (19)100 (19)112 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 64 (20)80 (26)97 (30)143 (36)186 (216)310 (229)844 (817)15/15
16-30coby 32 (7)39 (9)51 (10)68 (14)79 (12)129 (30)151 (44)15/15
16-30slsqp 62 (19)76 (16)94 (26)129 (82)182 (83)1418 (823)2655 (3919)15/15

Δ fopt
f31, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 33 (10)45 (13)54 (14)65 (16)475 (1016)1.9e4 (2e4)8.0e4 (7e4)3/15
1-15slsqp 45 (32)49 (36)55 (41)680 (192)804 (724)2508 (1540)5350 (1e4)15/15
16-30coby 33 (12)41 (9)50 (12)63 (14)1548 (3027)1.6e4 (2e4)2.9e4 (3e4)8/15
16-30slsqp 39 (22)49 (31)54 (36)63 (40)584 (192)1295 (709)2357 (5346)15/15

Δ fopt
f32, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (13)43 (14)63 (14)79 (22)102 (14)195 (148)450 (363)15/15
1-15slsqp 39 (11)45 (10)54 (16)64 (20)72 (20)313 (94)322 (98)15/15
16-30coby 38 (11)59 (22)98 (36)111 (30)123 (28)450 (199)510 (201)15/15
16-30slsqp 33 (20)38 (26)56 (36)71 (36)89 (38)137 (96)180 (172)15/15

Δ fopt
f33, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 33 (10)45 (15)54 (10)58 (13)65 (16)80 (22)86 (23)15/15
1-15slsqp 26 (14)29 (14)30 (18)31 (18)32 (18)76 (74)220 (318)15/15
16-30coby 36 (13)45 (14)54 (21)62 (18)67 (17)85 (14)95 (17)15/15
16-30slsqp 30 (14)34 (14)35 (14)35 (9)50 (14)90 (86)234 (233)15/15

Δ fopt
f34, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 29 (8)38 (12)48 (16)57 (18)69 (23)85 (31)92 (29)15/15
1-15slsqp 23 (9)29 (14)30 (18)30 (18)32 (18)38 (14)63 (47)15/15
16-30coby 32 (8)44 (12)53 (13)64 (15)73 (24)96 (19)104 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 28 (14)30 (18)31 (18)33 (18)35 (14)72 (54)136 (205)15/15

Δ fopt
f35, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 35 (10)41 (11)50 (13)60 (13)68 (18)83 (22)91 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 28 (14)32 (18)33 (18)35 (18)37 (20)59 (53)134 (110)15/15
16-30coby 32 (5)39 (11)51 (16)56 (13)65 (15)81 (18)89 (26)15/15
16-30slsqp 21 (9)27 (14)29 (14)29 (14)31 (14)42 (18)110 (131)15/15

Δ fopt
f36, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 35 (9)45 (9)50 (15)62 (9)71 (19)87 (21)93 (20)15/15
1-15slsqp 29 (14)32 (14)33 (14)35 (18)36 (18)63 (34)118 (120)15/15
16-30coby 34 (10)42 (13)51 (11)58 (13)70 (16)90 (24)98 (27)15/15
16-30slsqp 33 (18)36 (18)37 (18)38 (14)38 (14)63 (80)256 (371)15/15

Δ fopt
f37, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 39 (17)46 (16)55 (17)61 (22)69 (23)92 (45)151 (146)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (6)17 (6)27 (20)37 (24)15/15
16-30coby 36 (13)52 (19)63 (16)71 (15)78 (18)149 (65)1300 (216)14/15
16-30slsqp 14 (0)14 (0)15 (6)18 (10)22 (11)35 (26)61 (30)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 35 (10)42 (10)44 (11)48 (17)52 (18)64 (26)71 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (6)17 (6)39 (53)66 (68)15/15
16-30coby 33 (6)37 (10)41 (11)47 (15)55 (16)73 (22)80 (32)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)14 (0)15 (6)18 (11)20 (12)32 (26)53 (41)15/15

Δ fopt
f39, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (13)29 (15)31 (19)31 (19)31 (19)31 (19)31 (19)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)15 (4)28 (20)44 (28)15/15
16-30coby 26 (10)27 (11)27 (11)28 (11)28 (11)28 (11)28 (11)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)16 (4)27 (24)47 (57)15/15

Δ fopt
f40, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (14)29 (12)31 (13)32 (16)32 (16)32 (16)32 (16)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)37 (24)57 (32)15/15
16-30coby 25 (12)29 (14)29 (14)29 (14)29 (14)29 (14)29 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)26 (24)40 (24)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 24 (6)27 (10)28 (10)28 (10)28 (10)28 (10)28 (10)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (4)26 (9)45 (50)15/15
16-30coby 31 (11)35 (13)36 (13)39 (21)39 (21)43 (25)43 (25)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)28 (8)39 (35)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (12)26 (17)27 (18)28 (18)31 (27)32 (35)34 (35)15/15
1-15slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)14 (0)20 (6)41 (40)15/15
16-30coby 24 (12)26 (13)27 (13)30 (19)32 (27)32 (27)32 (27)15/15
16-30slsqp 13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)13 (0)25 (14)73 (58)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 6666 (8518)9494 (8464)9508 (1e4)9526 (9856)9559 (1e4)1.4e4 (1e4)2.8e4 (2e4)8/15
1-15slsqp 8508 (8786)9831 (8816)9849 (8786)9882 (8770)9954 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)12/15
16-30coby 6565 (8666)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)2.2e4 (2e4)2.8e4 (1e4)8/15
16-30slsqp 6968 (9912)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.5e4 (1e4)9/15

Δ fopt
f44, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 508 (537)522 (534)537 (527)553 (533)567 (526)1794 (1290)2048 (1280)15/15
1-15slsqp 9139 (1e4)9161 (1e4)9179 (1e4)9232 (8872)9290 (1e4)1.1e4 (9490)1.3e4 (1e4)10/15
16-30coby 1430 (2095)1448 (2099)1465 (2084)1483 (2099)1504 (2089)1945 (2729)3054 (3510)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.0e4 (8762)1.0e4 (8772)1.0e4 (8574)1.0e4 (8768)1.0e4 (8596)1.1e4 (8030)1.2e4 (8846)12/15

Δ fopt
f45, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 246 (456)258 (450)269 (455)298 (468)325 (470)373 (478)400 (513)15/15
1-15slsqp 1871 (1882)1888 (1892)1911 (1897)1930 (1893)1945 (1898)1966 (1876)2744 (5538)15/15
16-30coby 174 (232)185 (232)219 (306)228 (312)242 (318)263 (324)277 (324)15/15
16-30slsqp 2185 (2068)2201 (2060)2217 (2060)2236 (2065)2251 (2060)3003 (4037)3367 (4037)14/15

Δ fopt
f46, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 277 (342)289 (340)300 (342)310 (342)322 (338)344 (338)355 (340)15/15
1-15slsqp 1348 (1270)1366 (1268)1386 (1276)1403 (1268)1428 (1288)2955 (4080)3985 (4022)15/15
16-30coby 313 (270)320 (266)330 (272)340 (270)351 (272)378 (268)389 (268)15/15
16-30slsqp 3489 (6498)3503 (6521)3523 (6509)3542 (6500)4363 (7226)4395 (7230)4458 (7576)15/15

Δ fopt
f47, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 96 (168)107 (162)118 (160)133 (172)151 (164)177 (168)186 (172)15/15
1-15slsqp 1225 (1118)1234 (1122)1251 (1118)1272 (1118)1295 (1113)1360 (1052)1686 (1724)15/15
16-30coby 74 (152)86 (152)97 (156)119 (150)202 (154)308 (164)317 (168)15/15
16-30slsqp 1055 (1022)1072 (1017)1086 (1020)1102 (1021)1128 (1021)1198 (1035)2018 (3203)15/15

Δ fopt
f48, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 101 (148)114 (148)144 (146)182 (249)204 (284)265 (288)284 (284)15/15
1-15slsqp 823 (946)850 (979)860 (984)881 (990)894 (984)1035 (1278)1653 (1406)15/15
16-30coby 196 (272)205 (276)215 (280)225 (274)236 (280)256 (272)267 (266)15/15
16-30slsqp 1396 (1592)1412 (1604)1423 (1627)1441 (1615)1461 (1596)1553 (1625)1585 (1602)15/15

Δ fopt
f49, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 6058 (5239)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (7783)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.8e4 (1e4)4.8e4 (3e4)5/15
1-15slsqp 1.2e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (3e4)1.9e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (2e4)1.9e4 (2e4)1.9e4 (2e4)1.9e4 (3e4)8/15
16-30coby 5244 (4592)7493 (7950)7507 (7964)7521 (7962)7546 (7952)1.0e4 (9194)3.1e4 (2e4)8/15
16-30slsqp 2.4e4 (4e4)3.2e4 (3e4)3.2e4 (3e4)3.2e4 (2e4)3.2e4 (4e4)3.2e4 (3e4)3.2e4 (3e4)5/15

Δ fopt
f50, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2481 (3584)2494 (3576)2509 (3579)2525 (3564)2555 (3571)3282 (3450)4662 (4194)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (9314)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (9417)1.6e4 (1e4)1.6e4 (1e4)9/15
16-30coby 1223 (1066)1239 (1069)1253 (1070)1278 (1083)1294 (1089)1383 (1085)2910 (3768)15/15
16-30slsqp 9878 (9114)9910 (9026)9957 (9020)9986 (7534)1.0e4 (5830)1.4e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (3e4)8/15

Δ fopt
f51, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 155 (186)165 (190)174 (194)183 (190)194 (188)382 (295)580 (1150)15/15
1-15slsqp 2151 (2788)2166 (2808)2180 (2794)2215 (2799)2230 (2790)2691 (2746)2874 (2718)15/15
16-30coby 308 (549)319 (543)326 (546)334 (546)345 (546)368 (551)378 (556)15/15
16-30slsqp 2790 (3720)2809 (3746)2831 (3736)2846 (3739)2867 (3739)2906 (3656)3315 (4040)15/15

Δ fopt
f52, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 324 (298)336 (298)351 (302)364 (298)435 (482)546 (1048)562 (1054)15/15
1-15slsqp 1281 (1238)1299 (1236)1317 (1224)1334 (1215)1349 (1228)1383 (1224)1557 (1220)15/15
16-30coby 197 (306)207 (302)221 (298)233 (298)241 (296)262 (294)272 (300)15/15
16-30slsqp 2892 (5180)2911 (5312)2930 (5772)2956 (4234)2966 (4970)3261 (5286)3931 (4316)14/15

Δ fopt
f53, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 256 (376)265 (379)275 (384)288 (386)300 (381)326 (381)342 (384)15/15
1-15slsqp 772 (1100)785 (1104)806 (1100)824 (1096)844 (1104)870 (1110)1453 (1316)15/15
16-30coby 207 (236)215 (242)222 (238)238 (240)254 (242)284 (294)297 (300)15/15
16-30slsqp 657 (468)671 (463)690 (450)704 (465)720 (456)903 (1593)1252 (1972)15/15

Δ fopt
f54, 3-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 177 (292)189 (292)198 (294)205 (290)222 (294)242 (296)255 (302)15/15
1-15slsqp 816 (942)832 (934)840 (944)860 (948)881 (960)1100 (1480)1464 (2182)15/15
16-30coby 127 (195)156 (244)256 (238)273 (234)286 (240)305 (234)321 (240)15/15
16-30slsqp 848 (896)867 (887)882 (887)905 (892)933 (874)1108 (996)1180 (998)15/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 5 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (15)57 (15)78 (20)98 (16)120 (18)162 (19)183 (23)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)19 (6)27 (14)33 (14)15/15
16-30coby 37 (15)56 (12)78 (18)100 (19)120 (20)159 (19)178 (26)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (1)26 (6)34 (12)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 32 (11)51 (13)69 (15)86 (19)105 (15)142 (17)160 (24)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)29 (6)37 (8)15/15
16-30coby 32 (12)52 (15)76 (12)92 (20)115 (19)150 (32)174 (31)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)26 (6)39 (8)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 20 (6)24 (10)24 (10)24 (10)24 (10)24 (10)24 (10)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)21 (6)29 (4)29 (0)15/15
16-30coby 24 (10)29 (13)29 (13)29 (13)29 (13)29 (13)29 (13)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)28 (6)30 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (6)27 (20)28 (22)29 (26)29 (26)29 (26)29 (26)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)19 (6)29 (4)30 (0)15/15
16-30coby 20 (5)27 (12)31 (11)31 (11)31 (11)31 (11)31 (11)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (2)27 (6)30 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 23 (6)25 (12)30 (19)30 (19)31 (23)34 (23)34 (23)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)27 (6)30 (0)15/15
16-30coby 22 (8)24 (9)24 (9)26 (14)27 (14)27 (14)27 (14)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (2)27 (6)30 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (6)22 (7)30 (20)31 (20)32 (30)33 (30)33 (30)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)28 (6)30 (0)15/15
16-30coby 20 (7)24 (11)26 (16)27 (19)30 (22)33 (37)35 (43)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)27 (6)30 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (15)213 (474)2490 (2018)2.2e4 (2e4)1.4e5 (2e5)4.3e5 (3e5)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 78 (22)106 (43)154 (68)272 (230)439 (254)1350 (1237)1.4e4 (2e4)12/15
16-30coby 41 (17)464 (1016)3527 (4016)3.1e4 (4e4)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 70 (20)103 (38)155 (46)230 (136)456 (450)2043 (2857)9770 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f8, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 56 (31)490 (1016)4191 (6046)6.5e4 (1e5)2.5e5 (2e5)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 455 (268)2678 (5553)7385 (1e4)2.1e4 (2e4)5.8e4 (9e4)1.1e5 (9e4)4.6e5 (5e5)1/15
16-30coby 54 (27)1550 (2024)7036 (9022)8.5e4 (8e4)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 396 (526)1561 (2554)4537 (6209)2.5e4 (3e4)1.9e5 (8e4)2e40/15

Δ fopt
f9, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 184 (26)335 (1010)349 (1006)363 (1008)379 (1002)925 (2018)939 (2018)15/15
1-15slsqp 59 (27)78 (32)100 (28)137 (29)189 (108)1086 (1174)2616 (2930)15/15
16-30coby 46 (16)68 (18)618 (14)1883 (27)1990 (635)2515 (3073)3569 (1e4)14/15
16-30slsqp 64 (28)92 (29)119 (36)143 (40)189 (80)905 (1569)2167 (2722)15/15

Δ fopt
f10, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 51 (21)83 (31)245 (190)298 (413)367 (815)1100 (2016)1116 (2006)15/15
1-15slsqp 62 (20)81 (20)107 (20)126 (28)174 (64)1135 (1066)2998 (4700)15/15
16-30coby 181 (24)737 (1010)768 (1014)1007 (1018)1057 (1016)1093 (1028)1112 (1018)15/15
16-30slsqp 62 (20)90 (42)117 (34)166 (93)190 (128)917 (896)1769 (2723)15/15

Δ fopt
f11, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 47 (13)56 (15)68 (22)90 (16)379 (26)682 (2012)813 (2030)15/15
1-15slsqp 64 (20)91 (29)111 (27)143 (36)165 (44)515 (534)2822 (5047)15/15
16-30coby 63 (14)196 (17)212 (14)230 (20)245 (20)286 (28)308 (53)15/15
16-30slsqp 61 (20)86 (27)101 (29)150 (62)178 (76)470 (499)1165 (1330)15/15

Δ fopt
f12, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 46 (17)65 (12)75 (15)92 (11)102 (12)129 (21)149 (18)15/15
1-15slsqp 67 (34)85 (34)112 (39)130 (27)150 (44)338 (216)901 (604)15/15
16-30coby 48 (20)63 (16)79 (17)93 (24)107 (20)137 (22)155 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 66 (26)80 (34)109 (40)130 (60)161 (76)422 (582)1404 (1728)15/15

Δ fopt
f13, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)46 (38)61 (53)15/15
16-30coby 17 (1)17 (1)17 (2)17 (2)17 (2)17 (2)17 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)22 (6)45 (45)71 (116)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)17 (1)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)31 (16)61 (38)15/15
16-30coby 18 (2)18 (2)18 (2)18 (2)18 (2)18 (2)18 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)31 (23)82 (64)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 19 (5)20 (5)20 (5)21 (7)21 (7)21 (7)21 (7)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)19 (6)31 (10)52 (38)15/15
16-30coby 21 (4)25 (12)25 (12)25 (12)25 (12)25 (12)25 (12)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (0)22 (6)42 (30)76 (74)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 21 (7)23 (7)24 (7)26 (18)26 (18)26 (18)26 (18)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)28 (5)86 (76)15/15
16-30coby 20 (5)21 (8)21 (8)21 (8)21 (8)21 (8)21 (8)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)21 (6)47 (40)112 (147)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 22 (6)28 (17)29 (17)29 (20)29 (20)29 (20)29 (20)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (0)47 (44)81 (62)15/15
16-30coby 22 (7)29 (12)33 (21)36 (23)37 (25)45 (45)47 (50)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)46 (40)76 (55)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 19 (3)22 (15)27 (17)27 (17)32 (29)34 (31)34 (31)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)18 (0)48 (28)145 (160)15/15
16-30coby 20 (7)23 (12)23 (12)27 (24)27 (24)31 (39)33 (47)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)34 (20)121 (181)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 146 (58)2546 (2526)1.0e4 (2e4)6.2e4 (6e4)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 148 (74)291 (84)1202 (1508)3789 (3601)2.6e4 (3e4)2e40/15
16-30coby 38 (19)335 (457)8655 (8911)4.5e4 (4e4)5.6e5 (7e5)4e40/15
16-30slsqp 253 (220)425 (420)3048 (4408)9647 (1e4)3.3e4 (3e4)2e40/15

Δ fopt
f20, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 49 (30)1463 (4012)8575 (8866)5.4e4 (2e4)4.8e5 (3e5)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 384 (584)2920 (3230)1.4e4 (2e4)5.4e4 (4e4)2.5e5 (2e5)4e40/15
16-30coby 335 (28)3011 (4006)1.8e4 (2e4)1.3e5 (2e5)4e40/15
16-30slsqp 472 (213)1956 (2589)7570 (7118)2.2e4 (2e4)8.8e4 (1e5)2e40/15

Δ fopt
f21, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 111 (35)329 (1016)345 (1006)366 (1016)379 (1012)889 (1392)1133 (3055)15/15
1-15slsqp 93 (48)163 (180)318 (312)390 (357)904 (358)2415 (1982)5501 (1e4)13/15
16-30coby 52 (21)335 (24)352 (24)371 (26)385 (27)417 (55)432 (49)15/15
16-30slsqp 188 (184)248 (211)496 (537)592 (537)620 (530)1242 (1922)6829 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f22, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 132 (90)612 (996)859 (1016)1042 (1008)1232 (1024)1899 (3035)1955 (3043)15/15
1-15slsqp 89 (43)123 (25)152 (34)192 (64)263 (170)873 (1270)4720 (7902)14/15
16-30coby 44 (11)77 (25)200 (242)286 (359)454 (1014)566 (1008)611 (1018)15/15
16-30slsqp 88 (34)126 (31)170 (98)212 (103)301 (286)371 (308)2277 (1926)15/15

Δ fopt
f23, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 64 (16)156 (14)1019 (15)1301 (20)1382 (318)1617 (1010)1645 (1016)15/15
1-15slsqp 98 (28)127 (43)147 (38)177 (97)205 (96)1825 (1476)2653 (3145)14/15
16-30coby 52 (13)65 (13)80 (21)95 (18)111 (15)144 (14)162 (19)15/15
16-30slsqp 104 (20)127 (41)160 (55)182 (41)207 (38)719 (770)1831 (2490)15/15

Δ fopt
f24, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 51 (11)62 (11)76 (16)93 (12)109 (11)137 (24)156 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 104 (28)124 (31)170 (79)191 (86)233 (108)1505 (2130)4502 (6886)15/15
16-30coby 53 (9)66 (20)99 (14)220 (16)251 (18)276 (25)296 (24)15/15
16-30slsqp 104 (22)128 (44)164 (37)213 (80)294 (216)3517 (1843)7768 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f25, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (13)52 (24)76 (20)96 (16)2.3e4 (2e4)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 49 (39)61 (39)71 (48)77 (48)181 (372)2.1e5 (1e5)2e40/15
16-30coby 32 (16)57 (24)80 (15)99 (15)1.3e4 (1e4)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 75 (72)112 (72)142 (96)197 (232)364 (398)1.3e5 (1e5)2e40/15

Δ fopt
f26, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 61 (21)83 (23)101 (21)124 (20)1.1e4 (2e4)4.7e5 (4e5)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 76 (36)104 (82)242 (90)258 (166)507 (248)6.8e4 (3e4)2e40/15
16-30coby 50 (19)71 (13)92 (18)110 (18)1.0e4 (1e4)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 77 (44)108 (80)145 (136)178 (241)488 (1186)1.3e5 (1e5)3.9e5 (7e5)1/15

Δ fopt
f27, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 59 (23)1813 (3024)2361 (3029)2902 (3015)2916 (3024)2953 (3042)2972 (3038)14/15
1-15slsqp 114 (64)371 (514)574 (507)708 (507)1335 (1781)3608 (4954)7556 (9172)15/15
16-30coby 229 (306)738 (1050)785 (1314)833 (1560)1008 (2020)1083 (2012)1145 (2024)15/15
16-30slsqp 120 (49)211 (184)305 (214)429 (286)451 (286)3896 (4362)1.1e4 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f28, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 184 (22)207 (48)474 (998)633 (1018)787 (1016)1154 (2008)1245 (2026)15/15
1-15slsqp 90 (45)127 (50)158 (50)188 (78)286 (234)1472 (1660)5635 (1e4)15/15
16-30coby 47 (14)68 (12)78 (17)100 (20)112 (23)201 (68)312 (298)15/15
16-30slsqp 99 (41)135 (68)190 (148)240 (141)296 (148)836 (1487)2570 (3515)15/15

Δ fopt
f29, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 54 (12)70 (19)86 (20)102 (23)204 (24)360 (39)432 (31)15/15
1-15slsqp 92 (20)118 (28)169 (44)265 (196)343 (262)2000 (1246)6461 (1e4)15/15
16-30coby 48 (10)65 (14)80 (14)96 (20)252 (42)1620 (1022)1657 (1012)15/15
16-30slsqp 98 (28)120 (26)154 (18)185 (41)247 (96)846 (1268)4534 (4522)14/15

Δ fopt
f30, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 42 (12)63 (14)78 (17)94 (18)115 (23)147 (33)158 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 97 (28)132 (36)171 (52)211 (52)355 (366)2453 (6387)4621 (6894)13/15
16-30coby 53 (14)69 (16)79 (14)97 (17)117 (17)147 (21)164 (25)15/15
16-30slsqp 103 (34)138 (38)165 (30)254 (69)349 (219)1573 (2362)8223 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f31, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 61 (13)81 (18)102 (16)127 (17)551 (1012)1.5e4 (2e4)3.6e4 (3e4)10/15
1-15slsqp 104 (64)114 (71)116 (71)127 (80)1022 (1414)6489 (2e4)3.9e4 (6e4)8/15
16-30coby 60 (21)83 (17)110 (22)126 (22)280 (46)8689 (1e4)2.4e4 (3e4)12/15
16-30slsqp 112 (70)127 (82)131 (82)168 (89)1660 (2786)4656 (6988)1.9e4 (3e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f32, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 63 (18)164 (203)334 (572)2668 (4936)6170 (2e4)1.4e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (5e4)10/15
1-15slsqp 113 (31)135 (43)151 (57)337 (78)477 (180)2664 (837)3008 (874)15/15
16-30coby 63 (16)95 (25)136 (43)229 (98)408 (363)2777 (1720)1.0e4 (1e4)13/15
16-30slsqp 97 (66)104 (66)122 (73)148 (70)213 (180)423 (544)1038 (1695)15/15

Δ fopt
f33, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 56 (16)70 (17)88 (24)99 (28)113 (23)135 (18)143 (25)15/15
1-15slsqp 44 (28)52 (28)53 (28)54 (28)54 (28)249 (488)1084 (1286)15/15
16-30coby 57 (12)69 (16)89 (28)105 (28)119 (24)145 (42)156 (40)15/15
16-30slsqp 42 (13)49 (20)51 (20)53 (13)59 (22)226 (380)859 (1396)15/15

Δ fopt
f34, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 46 (14)61 (17)78 (10)84 (23)104 (17)131 (30)142 (25)15/15
1-15slsqp 38 (13)47 (6)49 (6)49 (6)51 (6)320 (431)1912 (3070)15/15
16-30coby 50 (15)72 (15)87 (27)103 (26)113 (32)141 (41)149 (42)15/15
16-30slsqp 42 (13)51 (6)52 (6)53 (6)61 (14)457 (854)1248 (1888)15/15

Δ fopt
f35, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 48 (21)63 (13)76 (20)91 (19)103 (14)125 (30)135 (24)15/15
1-15slsqp 41 (20)50 (20)52 (13)53 (13)58 (15)340 (674)1297 (1869)15/15
16-30coby 47 (11)64 (16)77 (11)87 (13)100 (13)124 (23)137 (23)15/15
16-30slsqp 36 (20)43 (20)49 (26)51 (26)52 (20)114 (153)716 (1300)15/15

Δ fopt
f36, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 51 (14)65 (6)78 (14)91 (9)101 (11)118 (22)136 (25)15/15
1-15slsqp 45 (13)52 (6)52 (6)53 (6)65 (6)383 (396)2267 (2874)15/15
16-30coby 57 (17)68 (12)77 (14)89 (8)101 (16)124 (21)138 (21)15/15
16-30slsqp 43 (13)51 (6)54 (6)55 (13)74 (13)374 (444)1575 (1333)15/15

Δ fopt
f37, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 60 (23)96 (33)155 (31)2879 (30)2962 (77)1.3e4 (2e4)1.5e5 (2e5)3/15
1-15slsqp 35 (20)46 (20)52 (20)56 (22)66 (29)100 (42)114 (42)15/15
16-30coby 53 (10)88 (24)170 (54)2206 (85)3920 (325)1.8e4 (2e4)8.1e4 (6e4)5/15
16-30slsqp 30 (14)46 (27)53 (31)62 (31)80 (42)119 (56)134 (51)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 57 (13)84 (25)128 (70)188 (175)452 (561)1.7e4 (2e4)3.4e4 (4e4)8/15
1-15slsqp 40 (16)71 (38)87 (54)104 (66)125 (62)185 (90)231 (108)15/15
16-30coby 55 (18)78 (21)123 (44)197 (105)445 (143)6646 (2e4)2.6e4 (4e4)12/15
16-30slsqp 32 (15)45 (22)58 (30)71 (50)89 (58)132 (68)192 (158)15/15

Δ fopt
f39, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 41 (11)47 (20)53 (19)58 (24)60 (27)60 (27)60 (27)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)32 (12)65 (45)15/15
16-30coby 44 (19)49 (20)52 (20)53 (20)53 (20)53 (20)53 (20)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)20 (6)32 (12)90 (117)15/15

Δ fopt
f40, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 45 (11)48 (14)56 (21)59 (30)59 (30)62 (30)62 (30)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)23 (6)29 (6)55 (62)15/15
16-30coby 40 (14)45 (17)55 (31)57 (34)60 (42)65 (44)65 (44)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)19 (6)37 (28)68 (56)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 29 (10)35 (20)38 (24)44 (37)47 (38)52 (53)52 (53)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)19 (6)68 (118)79 (112)15/15
16-30coby 37 (7)46 (16)48 (18)48 (18)50 (23)51 (23)53 (23)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)36 (30)79 (76)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 31 (8)40 (19)47 (30)52 (33)58 (34)63 (49)63 (49)15/15
1-15slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)46 (53)94 (124)15/15
16-30coby 31 (15)35 (19)42 (25)44 (26)48 (33)56 (48)56 (48)15/15
16-30slsqp 17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)17 (0)39 (10)77 (91)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 7.0e4 (6e4)8.3e4 (8e4)8.4e4 (9e4)8.4e4 (1e5)8.4e4 (1e5)4.3e5 (5e5)3e40/15
1-15slsqp 8.3e4 (8e4)1.1e5 (7e4)1.1e5 (1e5)1.1e5 (2e5)1.1e5 (9e4)1.7e5 (2e5)1.7e5 (3e5)2/15
16-30coby 5.8e4 (5e4)1.1e5 (1e5)1.1e5 (9e4)1.1e5 (1e5)1.1e5 (7e4)1.1e5 (8e4)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 1.1e5 (1e5)3.4e5 (4e5)3.4e5 (3e5)3.4e5 (4e5)3.4e5 (3e5)3.4e5 (3e5)3.4e5 (3e5)1/15

Δ fopt
f44, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 4.1e4 (4e4)4.1e4 (4e4)4.1e4 (3e4)4.1e4 (4e4)5.1e4 (5e4)4e40/15
1-15slsqp 1.2e5 (7e4)1.2e5 (9e4)1.2e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (2e5)1.9e5 (2e5)3.9e5 (3e5)3.9e5 (4e5)1/15
16-30coby 3.1e4 (3e4)3.1e4 (3e4)3.1e4 (4e4)3.3e4 (2e4)4.2e4 (4e4)2e40/15
16-30slsqp 8.3e4 (6e4)8.3e4 (1e5)8.3e4 (1e5)8.3e4 (7e4)8.4e4 (8e4)1.7e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)2/15

Δ fopt
f45, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1710 (3166)1734 (3185)1768 (3193)1840 (3201)2209 (3196)2717 (3191)2749 (3187)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (3e4)2.0e4 (2e4)13/15
16-30coby 2167 (5218)2187 (5213)2211 (5224)2501 (5230)3842 (5309)4487 (5305)4501 (5303)15/15
16-30slsqp 2.6e4 (4e4)2.6e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (4e4)2.6e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (5e4)2.6e4 (4e4)3.8e4 (4e4)7/15

Δ fopt
f46, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 230 (448)251 (440)269 (456)282 (448)302 (458)469 (566)485 (576)15/15
1-15slsqp 2.4e4 (3e4)2.4e4 (4e4)2.4e4 (5e4)2.4e4 (2e4)2.4e4 (2e4)2.4e4 (4e4)2.6e4 (3e4)11/15
16-30coby 624 (715)644 (727)676 (717)964 (1233)1060 (1222)1144 (1245)1164 (1241)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.8e4 (3e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)2.2e4 (2e4)10/15

Δ fopt
f47, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 555 (937)574 (937)720 (998)735 (998)750 (1002)783 (1008)802 (1012)15/15
1-15slsqp 9407 (2e4)9437 (2e4)9467 (1e4)9490 (3e4)9514 (2e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.7e4 (3e4)12/15
16-30coby 457 (818)474 (820)488 (822)501 (816)523 (844)584 (866)664 (905)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.6e4 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f48, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 147 (260)160 (256)172 (260)184 (256)202 (254)230 (258)240 (252)15/15
1-15slsqp 2124 (3181)2149 (3174)2168 (3174)2190 (3181)2211 (3156)2979 (4848)4140 (6182)15/15
16-30coby 306 (462)318 (458)332 (464)349 (452)363 (458)393 (466)405 (458)15/15
16-30slsqp 2187 (2318)2210 (2315)2243 (2316)2266 (2302)2300 (2302)2414 (2548)4429 (5756)15/15

Δ fopt
f49, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.0e5 (1e5)4.2e5 (3e5)4.2e5 (5e5)4.2e5 (5e5)4.2e5 (6e5)2e40/15
1-15slsqp 3.3e5 (5e5)3.3e5 (3e5)3.3e5 (4e5)3.3e5 (5e5)3.3e5 (3e5)3.3e5 (4e5)3.3e5 (4e5)1/15
16-30coby 1.1e5 (1e5)1.1e5 (5e4)1.1e5 (1e5)1.1e5 (2e5)1.1e5 (2e5)3e40/15
16-30slsqp 7.4e4 (1e5)9.9e4 (8e4)9.9e4 (9e4)9.9e4 (9e4)9.9e4 (2e5)1.5e5 (3e5)1.5e5 (1e5)2/15

Δ fopt
f50, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5.0e4 (4e4)5.0e4 (6e4)5.0e4 (3e4)5.0e4 (5e4)6.4e4 (9e4)4.7e5 (6e5)2e40/15
1-15slsqp 1.2e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (4e4)1.2e5 (9e4)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)2e40/15
16-30coby 6.6e4 (4e4)6.6e4 (8e4)6.6e4 (5e4)6.6e4 (1e5)6.6e4 (5e4)2.3e5 (3e5)2e40/15
16-30slsqp 7.7e4 (1e5)7.7e4 (8e4)7.7e4 (8e4)7.7e4 (9e4)1.1e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)2e40/15

Δ fopt
f51, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1113 (2226)1214 (2242)1352 (2258)1488 (2534)2186 (2522)2210 (2506)2228 (2518)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.5e4 (2e4)1.5e4 (2e4)1.5e4 (2e4)1.5e4 (2e4)1.5e4 (1e4)1.7e4 (3e4)2.1e4 (2e4)10/15
16-30coby 2315 (2153)2344 (2185)2424 (2186)2818 (2291)3049 (3828)4926 (4446)4942 (4448)14/15
16-30slsqp 2.0e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (2e4)2.2e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (2e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f52, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1148 (2034)1165 (2032)1180 (2038)1192 (2020)1212 (2022)1241 (2030)1263 (2028)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.0e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)14/15
16-30coby 1426 (1757)1454 (1758)1558 (1756)1694 (1750)2151 (2644)2533 (3242)2638 (3240)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.2e4 (9290)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.2e4 (1e4)1.7e4 (2e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f53, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 441 (813)455 (822)548 (835)681 (840)706 (829)732 (828)753 (832)15/15
1-15slsqp 5487 (5232)5519 (5248)5542 (5242)5570 (5264)5597 (5264)6315 (5248)1.1e4 (2e4)14/15
16-30coby 1184 (1840)1201 (1841)1216 (1846)1233 (1845)1252 (1844)1280 (1841)1292 (1842)15/15
16-30slsqp 8534 (2e4)8565 (1e4)8595 (8892)8620 (9284)9528 (1e4)9727 (1e4)1.3e4 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f54, 5-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 467 (484)482 (486)499 (484)508 (474)528 (486)550 (486)565 (484)15/15
1-15slsqp 2447 (2078)2465 (2087)2498 (2072)2534 (2060)2557 (2050)2731 (2056)3946 (2896)15/15
16-30coby 415 (478)434 (470)604 (1008)663 (1012)735 (1012)763 (1018)780 (1018)15/15
16-30slsqp 860 (865)889 (878)913 (870)930 (864)949 (870)1420 (1812)3309 (6534)15/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 10 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 85 (15)137 (20)186 (23)239 (26)294 (33)391 (40)446 (34)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)32 (12)43 (24)58 (24)15/15
16-30coby 81 (19)133 (16)182 (19)229 (21)278 (32)375 (24)430 (35)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)30 (12)47 (23)65 (22)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 77 (13)133 (21)177 (23)224 (31)277 (42)371 (42)422 (53)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)30 (12)44 (23)65 (20)15/15
16-30coby 81 (20)132 (22)174 (21)221 (29)260 (25)362 (32)407 (42)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (12)51 (23)74 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 74 (18)113 (24)152 (27)195 (29)237 (25)322 (53)359 (59)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (12)56 (12)71 (12)15/15
16-30coby 69 (20)117 (34)155 (38)198 (33)241 (45)353 (46)394 (53)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)33 (12)52 (22)67 (12)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 42 (15)55 (31)61 (39)65 (39)83 (43)83 (43)83 (43)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)31 (12)50 (0)50 (0)15/15
16-30coby 55 (22)70 (30)78 (36)87 (42)87 (42)87 (42)87 (42)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)33 (12)49 (0)50 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 38 (10)49 (23)50 (23)59 (42)60 (44)64 (54)64 (54)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (12)50 (0)50 (0)15/15
16-30coby 40 (12)46 (22)54 (32)60 (48)63 (53)66 (70)66 (70)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)33 (12)50 (0)50 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 39 (21)57 (29)68 (25)80 (46)88 (53)96 (63)96 (63)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (4)48 (0)50 (0)15/15
16-30coby 37 (12)41 (23)49 (33)60 (51)71 (60)84 (76)88 (88)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (12)50 (0)50 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 279 (267)5677 (6768)1.7e5 (2e5)6e40/15
1-15slsqp 177 (60)255 (72)374 (208)663 (482)946 (1054)6.8e4 (1e5)3.5e5 (5e5)2/15
16-30coby 98 (33)3942 (4182)1.1e5 (1e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 182 (64)269 (122)383 (246)635 (392)1342 (1710)5.1e4 (6e4)7.4e5 (5e5)1/15

Δ fopt
f8, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1099 (3060)1.6e4 (3e4)8.3e5 (5e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 1126 (1614)1.1e4 (2e4)4.8e4 (5e4)1.5e5 (3e5)9.2e5 (7e5)5e40/15
16-30coby 221 (332)1.1e4 (1e4)2.7e5 (2e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 950 (1126)1.1e4 (2e4)5.6e4 (1e5)2.0e5 (2e5)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f9, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2728 (3992)3.4e4 (6e4)1.9e5 (2e5)8.5e5 (1e6)8.5e5 (9e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 2537 (1820)2.3e4 (3e4)7.2e4 (6e4)5.1e5 (5e5)7e40/15
16-30coby 2002 (2979)2.0e4 (3e4)2.2e5 (3e5)7e40/15
16-30slsqp 2730 (3496)1.7e4 (3e4)5.9e4 (4e4)2.4e5 (2e5)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f10, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 411 (152)796 (1034)1988 (2022)2081 (2024)2117 (2028)9179 (1e4)9922 (1e4)15/15
1-15slsqp 566 (1332)622 (1345)1180 (2662)1620 (2808)1902 (2788)4342 (5889)4.2e4 (4e4)11/15
16-30coby 704 (1024)2304 (5088)6086 (5098)6391 (5090)6418 (5108)6484 (5102)6925 (5124)14/15
16-30slsqp 805 (988)1276 (2634)1524 (2634)1613 (2638)1781 (2650)1.4e4 (2e4)5.8e4 (6e4)10/15

Δ fopt
f11, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 97 (21)124 (23)153 (20)181 (20)204 (21)257 (19)284 (21)15/15
1-15slsqp 145 (48)197 (50)238 (60)275 (70)350 (86)1627 (1920)1.2e4 (2e4)14/15
16-30coby 90 (29)252 (25)282 (36)302 (29)345 (51)531 (1010)614 (1008)15/15
16-30slsqp 139 (47)186 (49)231 (86)270 (74)311 (103)1915 (2050)8976 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f12, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 100 (27)125 (22)151 (35)176 (18)205 (25)258 (20)282 (29)15/15
1-15slsqp 132 (23)185 (24)228 (34)270 (60)375 (102)2138 (2620)1.9e4 (3e4)12/15
16-30coby 102 (23)125 (17)151 (20)175 (28)205 (25)256 (22)320 (174)15/15
16-30slsqp 156 (36)192 (58)227 (48)305 (109)377 (144)3549 (6622)2.3e4 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f13, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 26 (1)26 (1)26 (1)26 (1)26 (1)26 (1)26 (1)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)83 (84)158 (159)15/15
16-30coby 27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)62 (37)87 (26)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 27 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)44 (14)226 (238)15/15
16-30coby 27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)27 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (0)49 (37)150 (160)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)37 (26)104 (42)246 (281)15/15
16-30coby 28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)28 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)33 (12)102 (76)310 (268)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (14)40 (24)44 (27)47 (27)51 (30)51 (30)51 (30)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)32 (12)170 (234)453 (442)15/15
16-30coby 36 (21)43 (38)51 (41)61 (77)63 (84)67 (84)67 (84)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)38 (12)158 (178)340 (416)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 34 (11)42 (23)50 (34)59 (55)65 (59)79 (83)81 (83)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)34 (12)113 (80)315 (230)15/15
16-30coby 37 (13)44 (26)51 (34)52 (38)56 (44)61 (63)61 (63)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)37 (12)109 (124)249 (220)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 36 (11)51 (32)51 (32)65 (47)67 (47)73 (64)73 (64)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)30 (12)71 (44)281 (360)15/15
16-30coby 37 (11)51 (30)61 (39)67 (41)77 (61)99 (83)105 (98)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (0)116 (136)244 (244)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 133 (82)8236 (1e4)1.1e5 (2e5)6e40/15
1-15slsqp 401 (160)2157 (4003)1.7e4 (4e4)1.8e5 (2e5)6e40/15
16-30coby 112 (38)4335 (5286)1.4e5 (1e5)8e40/15
16-30slsqp 456 (174)1733 (2264)1.9e4 (2e4)2.0e5 (2e5)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f20, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 598 (1272)1.4e4 (3e4)5.1e5 (5e5)7e40/15
1-15slsqp 950 (1599)1.2e4 (2e4)3.1e4 (3e4)4.5e5 (4e5)5e40/15
16-30coby 372 (64)1.8e4 (3e4)2.2e5 (3e5)6e40/15
16-30slsqp 740 (230)2915 (2454)5.8e4 (4e4)7e40/15

Δ fopt
f21, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5942 (1016)2.8e4 (3e4)2.1e5 (2e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 2708 (2082)2.2e4 (3e4)5.1e5 (2e5)1.0e6 (7e5)6e40/15
16-30coby 2260 (4012)2.8e4 (3e4)8.8e5 (9e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 2716 (3472)2.4e4 (5e4)2.3e5 (2e5)7e40/15

Δ fopt
f22, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 498 (1028)806 (2010)1099 (1992)1130 (2004)1156 (2008)1237 (2018)2314 (4098)15/15
1-15slsqp 773 (943)1248 (1683)2326 (2694)2409 (2692)2568 (2646)2.2e4 (3e4)7.1e4 (1e5)6/15
16-30coby 1606 (2036)1831 (2024)3658 (2028)4227 (2024)4259 (2022)4451 (2040)4818 (3563)15/15
16-30slsqp 376 (314)436 (303)523 (316)656 (548)688 (534)6999 (8419)5.0e4 (6e4)10/15

Δ fopt
f23, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 92 (27)126 (19)157 (24)181 (21)204 (34)272 (32)293 (35)15/15
1-15slsqp 229 (123)274 (88)353 (164)420 (188)493 (172)5126 (8784)2.7e4 (3e4)12/15
16-30coby 104 (24)126 (32)154 (32)186 (30)216 (23)270 (31)386 (36)15/15
16-30slsqp 216 (71)289 (130)364 (132)406 (154)506 (130)4814 (2724)8049 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f24, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 104 (11)122 (19)153 (16)179 (19)205 (23)255 (18)297 (22)15/15
1-15slsqp 184 (34)222 (14)287 (46)348 (72)403 (84)8052 (2e4)2.3e4 (3e4)12/15
16-30coby 104 (18)133 (14)158 (17)182 (16)204 (24)255 (20)278 (21)15/15
16-30slsqp 208 (51)266 (78)341 (112)402 (110)614 (532)1.4e4 (3e4)3.0e4 (3e4)11/15

Δ fopt
f25, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 46 (25)89 (32)130 (50)163 (40)4.7e5 (6e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 91 (47)123 (88)140 (88)196 (88)558 (1252)7.2e5 (7e5)5e40/15
16-30coby 54 (32)91 (44)128 (29)175 (28)1.4e5 (1e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 118 (98)163 (75)200 (75)222 (98)574 (1341)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f26, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 121 (37)165 (57)200 (62)235 (52)2.9e5 (5e5)6e40/15
1-15slsqp 357 (180)421 (188)471 (250)500 (362)787 (512)6.8e5 (7e5)5e40/15
16-30coby 78 (40)125 (28)165 (25)198 (41)8.1e4 (1e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 245 (324)285 (338)292 (338)480 (585)995 (2207)7.2e5 (1e6)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f27, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 796 (581)1669 (3152)4513 (4469)4884 (4654)5.9e4 (5e4)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 255 (302)352 (360)455 (461)520 (474)1153 (2182)5e40/15
16-30coby 285 (94)1319 (2092)2472 (3840)4012 (5010)2.1e4 (3e4)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 368 (242)447 (388)495 (647)508 (658)608 (740)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f28, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1072 (3042)2454 (4030)9184 (1e4)1.7e4 (3e4)1.7e4 (3e4)1.7e4 (3e4)2.3e4 (5e4)14/15
1-15slsqp 240 (118)719 (593)1294 (2388)3614 (7774)1.5e4 (3e4)3.6e4 (5e4)9.2e4 (9e4)7/15
16-30coby 488 (419)3240 (4094)1.1e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.6e4 (3e4)1.6e4 (3e4)1.6e4 (3e4)15/15
16-30slsqp 350 (155)1145 (1377)2107 (1970)2334 (1958)3562 (6425)1.2e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (4e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f29, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 638 (1012)672 (1008)698 (1016)850 (1022)881 (1050)940 (1052)963 (1050)15/15
1-15slsqp 185 (52)242 (66)355 (135)469 (224)547 (336)5709 (5620)3.5e4 (3e4)10/15
16-30coby 108 (31)1876 (23)1894 (26)1925 (23)1960 (82)2152 (1024)2184 (1022)15/15
16-30slsqp 183 (24)408 (40)480 (143)528 (154)570 (143)3699 (3792)1.7e4 (2e4)13/15

Δ fopt
f30, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 101 (24)124 (23)151 (25)173 (38)196 (37)260 (19)284 (19)15/15
1-15slsqp 198 (70)269 (78)319 (88)434 (145)589 (478)9147 (3e4)2.0e4 (3e4)11/15
16-30coby 99 (22)123 (27)149 (18)178 (24)206 (25)260 (15)383 (180)15/15
16-30slsqp 248 (123)329 (136)377 (136)435 (136)488 (166)4548 (8098)1.2e4 (2e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f31, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 130 (19)179 (25)225 (14)280 (22)608 (1010)7241 (9032)3.3e4 (4e4)15/15
1-15slsqp 333 (66)368 (78)384 (90)409 (66)811 (772)1.3e4 (2e4)8.2e4 (7e4)8/15
16-30coby 131 (33)182 (33)232 (26)284 (29)474 (46)2.0e4 (2e4)4.1e4 (5e4)15/15
16-30slsqp 322 (103)354 (68)389 (54)422 (76)635 (492)1.7e4 (3e4)6.2e4 (6e4)8/15

Δ fopt
f32, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 223 (139)432 (264)746 (538)2803 (3099)8845 (1e4)1.9e5 (2e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 558 (212)943 (210)1393 (294)2002 (3742)5320 (5420)2.1e4 (3e4)4.8e4 (8e4)11/15
16-30coby 142 (24)266 (144)617 (720)2400 (5816)1.2e4 (3e4)1.2e5 (2e5)4.1e5 (4e5)2/15
16-30slsqp 330 (75)364 (48)433 (84)554 (202)662 (460)4706 (5962)4.5e4 (5e4)11/15

Δ fopt
f33, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 163 (43)233 (52)309 (63)450 (137)1240 (760)2.1e4 (4e4)6.9e4 (9e4)9/15
1-15slsqp 242 (50)270 (51)304 (51)321 (51)365 (62)6138 (7721)4.3e5 (3e5)1/15
16-30coby 159 (31)214 (42)284 (42)407 (191)799 (541)1.0e4 (1e4)3.5e4 (5e4)13/15
16-30slsqp 246 (49)274 (49)305 (49)349 (60)466 (416)4952 (4795)9.8e4 (9e4)5/15

Δ fopt
f34, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 106 (26)134 (27)165 (40)190 (46)213 (64)261 (72)270 (63)15/15
1-15slsqp 80 (36)94 (25)98 (36)98 (36)114 (38)2043 (2946)7703 (8879)14/15
16-30coby 106 (33)136 (43)150 (42)186 (40)199 (41)244 (55)268 (44)15/15
16-30slsqp 96 (49)110 (49)115 (49)126 (72)167 (72)3293 (1998)1.1e4 (3e4)12/15

Δ fopt
f35, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 92 (20)125 (17)146 (17)165 (18)190 (26)236 (26)245 (30)15/15
1-15slsqp 68 (23)82 (12)87 (12)87 (12)92 (14)1691 (1852)8285 (6750)14/15
16-30coby 97 (19)123 (19)146 (27)169 (30)193 (15)229 (36)260 (32)15/15
16-30slsqp 75 (34)88 (23)93 (23)96 (24)123 (36)2326 (3486)1.0e4 (1e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f36, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 109 (14)122 (15)151 (16)163 (17)188 (30)226 (32)262 (31)15/15
1-15slsqp 81 (12)90 (12)90 (12)91 (12)132 (143)2374 (3411)2.7e4 (2e4)8/15
16-30coby 105 (22)126 (24)152 (20)169 (21)187 (22)223 (34)246 (31)15/15
16-30slsqp 76 (12)79 (12)82 (12)84 (12)92 (23)3643 (4222)2.9e4 (1e4)7/15

Δ fopt
f37, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 112 (18)197 (43)655 (633)2.1e4 (3e4)1.6e5 (1e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 118 (66)178 (40)238 (56)272 (73)306 (73)423 (78)457 (78)15/15
16-30coby 108 (17)201 (46)529 (428)1.4e4 (3e4)7.3e4 (1e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 97 (53)161 (94)206 (114)240 (125)277 (136)384 (150)432 (194)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 106 (23)190 (36)443 (190)5853 (594)4.6e4 (4e4)6e40/15
1-15slsqp 168 (105)278 (116)351 (112)400 (147)454 (170)658 (198)857 (382)15/15
16-30coby 108 (25)208 (57)443 (266)4386 (2782)2.1e4 (3e4)6e40/15
16-30slsqp 132 (94)210 (118)282 (114)325 (112)369 (124)529 (158)2698 (740)15/15

Δ fopt
f39, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 108 (22)184 (55)347 (193)861 (792)7668 (1e4)3.8e4 (7e4)1.4e5 (1e5)5/15
1-15slsqp 127 (126)213 (162)265 (182)313 (167)352 (178)483 (168)556 (191)15/15
16-30coby 110 (34)183 (42)418 (366)1441 (1770)1.4e4 (3e4)4.7e4 (7e4)9.5e4 (1e5)8/15
16-30slsqp 128 (103)217 (128)276 (138)313 (160)375 (172)524 (226)595 (192)15/15

Δ fopt
f40, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 103 (41)142 (62)194 (120)247 (206)284 (260)302 (262)302 (262)15/15
1-15slsqp 64 (88)82 (123)95 (147)103 (160)120 (171)127 (160)165 (184)15/15
16-30coby 94 (34)133 (58)189 (96)253 (136)273 (203)285 (235)288 (260)15/15
16-30slsqp 42 (27)57 (51)70 (88)78 (88)91 (112)113 (100)195 (252)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 64 (21)72 (22)76 (43)79 (43)79 (43)79 (43)79 (43)15/15
1-15slsqp 29 (0)29 (0)29 (0)29 (0)38 (12)73 (54)121 (150)15/15
16-30coby 77 (21)82 (23)90 (32)105 (53)107 (53)110 (53)110 (53)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)35 (12)63 (12)104 (119)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 50 (7)61 (23)61 (23)65 (23)70 (54)74 (54)79 (87)15/15
1-15slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)29 (2)86 (89)130 (104)15/15
16-30coby 53 (18)63 (31)67 (31)73 (48)81 (71)83 (76)83 (76)15/15
16-30slsqp 27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)27 (0)35 (12)71 (54)228 (361)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5e40/15
1-15slsqp 5e40/15
16-30coby 6e40/15
16-30slsqp 5e40/15

Δ fopt
f44, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5e40/15
1-15slsqp 5e40/15
16-30coby 6e40/15
16-30slsqp 5e40/15

Δ fopt
f45, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.1e5 (2e5)1.1e5 (2e5)1.3e5 (1e5)2.5e5 (3e5)3.7e5 (3e5)5e40/15
1-15slsqp 5e40/15
16-30coby 8.4e5 (8e5)8.4e5 (7e5)8.4e5 (7e5)5e40/15
16-30slsqp 9.6e5 (1e6)9.6e5 (9e5)6e40/15

Δ fopt
f46, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.0e4 (3e4)2.0e4 (3e4)2.1e4 (3e4)2.3e4 (3e4)2.3e4 (3e4)2.3e4 (3e4)2.3e4 (3e4)15/15
1-15slsqp 5e40/15
16-30coby 1.9e4 (2e4)1.9e4 (2e4)2.0e4 (2e4)2.0e4 (2e4)2.1e4 (2e4)3.2e4 (3e4)3.2e4 (4e4)13/15
16-30slsqp 9.9e5 (2e6)9.9e5 (2e6)9.9e5 (9e5)9.9e5 (1e6)9.9e5 (1e6)9.9e5 (2e6)9.9e5 (1e6)1/15

Δ fopt
f47, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 3789 (4542)3829 (4548)3867 (4532)3956 (4534)4041 (4542)4089 (4534)4117 (4514)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.8e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (3e5)2.3e5 (2e5)4.6e5 (5e5)2/15
16-30coby 4814 (4936)4845 (4938)4876 (4926)4900 (4926)4935 (4926)4981 (4926)5010 (4910)15/15
16-30slsqp 9.2e4 (1e5)9.2e4 (9e4)9.2e4 (1e5)9.2e4 (7e4)9.2e4 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)2.1e5 (4e5)4/15

Δ fopt
f48, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 365 (540)397 (546)423 (532)446 (540)467 (550)518 (536)611 (542)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.3e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (2e4)4.1e4 (3e4)13/15
16-30coby 244 (36)280 (27)301 (23)328 (24)350 (23)403 (35)452 (170)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (1e4)3.6e4 (4e4)14/15

Δ fopt
f49, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 7e40/15
1-15slsqp 7e40/15
16-30coby 6e40/15
16-30slsqp 5e40/15

Δ fopt
f50, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5e40/15
1-15slsqp 6e40/15
16-30coby 6e40/15
16-30slsqp 5e40/15

Δ fopt
f51, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5e40/15
1-15slsqp 6e40/15
16-30coby 5e40/15
16-30slsqp 5e40/15

Δ fopt
f52, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.5e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (3e5)3.1e5 (4e5)3.1e5 (6e5)3/15
1-15slsqp 8.9e5 (9e5)8.9e5 (9e5)8.9e5 (2e6)8.9e5 (9e5)8.9e5 (7e5)8.9e5 (4e5)8.9e5 (1e6)1/15
16-30coby 9.3e4 (1e5)9.3e4 (1e5)1.1e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (1e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1.6e5 (9e4)5/15
16-30slsqp 9.0e5 (9e5)9.0e5 (7e5)9.0e5 (8e5)9.0e5 (1e6)9.0e5 (1e6)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f53, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.5e4 (2e4)2.5e4 (5e4)2.6e4 (5e4)2.6e4 (3e4)2.6e4 (4e4)2.6e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (5e4)14/15
1-15slsqp 1.3e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (9e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (8e4)1.3e5 (2e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (2e5)5/15
16-30coby 3.1e4 (4e4)3.1e4 (4e4)3.1e4 (4e4)3.1e4 (6e4)3.1e4 (4e4)3.1e4 (4e4)3.2e4 (4e4)13/15
16-30slsqp 1.3e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (3e5)1.3e5 (7e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1.3e5 (2e5)1.3e5 (1e5)1.8e5 (2e5)5/15

Δ fopt
f54, 10-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2001 (2732)2024 (2754)2058 (2751)2074 (2752)2100 (2757)2156 (2755)2763 (2750)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (3e4)3.6e4 (4e4)14/15
16-30coby 1026 (998)1046 (1014)1079 (1002)1100 (1014)1131 (1020)1180 (1014)1204 (1002)15/15
16-30slsqp 1.1e4 (2e4)1.1e4 (2e4)1.1e4 (2e4)1.1e4 (2e4)1.1e4 (2e4)1.5e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (3e4)14/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 20 | Next dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 210 (53)335 (32)473 (50)582 (36)693 (50)956 (104)1071 (78)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)53 (22)109 (44)122 (38)15/15
16-30coby 206 (42)326 (46)466 (33)594 (61)705 (55)973 (49)1079 (61)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (2)97 (44)123 (42)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 228 (25)339 (50)470 (50)595 (45)713 (48)977 (88)1089 (68)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)115 (40)134 (1)15/15
16-30coby 234 (57)353 (39)493 (49)628 (101)746 (86)1016 (69)1133 (70)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)48 (0)120 (22)134 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 200 (39)321 (44)442 (58)553 (49)665 (75)902 (67)1020 (83)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)56 (22)127 (22)134 (1)15/15
16-30coby 210 (41)330 (50)459 (73)546 (76)650 (89)860 (94)979 (124)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)56 (22)117 (22)134 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 209 (28)327 (48)461 (396)994 (1483)1062 (1472)2154 (2470)2317 (2468)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)68 (22)108 (22)133 (1)15/15
16-30coby 155 (47)247 (38)444 (362)641 (372)845 (462)2067 (2288)2377 (2530)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)53 (22)108 (22)131 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 95 (28)149 (41)168 (58)188 (87)191 (101)200 (120)200 (120)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)73 (22)90 (0)90 (0)15/15
16-30coby 89 (18)101 (34)159 (50)176 (79)195 (125)204 (167)212 (167)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)76 (22)90 (0)90 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 63 (22)71 (25)99 (68)121 (92)128 (102)159 (151)168 (152)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)90 (0)90 (0)15/15
16-30coby 64 (21)91 (60)107 (61)282 (103)320 (120)370 (160)384 (182)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)57 (22)90 (0)90 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 688 (671)1.9e5 (3e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 588 (160)799 (272)1317 (340)2231 (1143)4514 (6234)1.7e6 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30coby 826 (1056)7.9e4 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 647 (252)878 (427)1687 (1381)2681 (2647)8546 (1e4)7.1e5 (5e5)1.5e6 (1e6)1/15

Δ fopt
f8, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 7897 (5304)6.1e5 (1e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1.9e4 (4e4)8.3e4 (9e4)3.9e5 (3e5)1.8e6 (3e6)1e50/15
16-30coby 7465 (1e4)8.9e5 (2e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 8014 (1e4)9.8e4 (1e5)3.9e5 (6e5)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f9, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 5498 (1e4)1.6e6 (2e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2.3e4 (3e4)1.6e5 (2e5)7.8e5 (9e5)1e50/15
16-30coby 9498 (2e4)9.1e5 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2.7e4 (5e4)1.3e5 (8e4)1.9e6 (2e6)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f10, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 9819 (5064)7.0e4 (7e4)7.7e5 (9e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1.4e4 (2e4)5.8e4 (9e4)1.2e5 (1e5)1.7e5 (1e5)5.6e5 (4e5)1e50/15
16-30coby 1.4e4 (1e4)9.6e4 (1e5)4.6e5 (8e5)1.5e6 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1.9e4 (2e4)6.2e4 (1e5)2.0e5 (2e5)7.4e5 (1e6)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f11, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 237 (48)274 (59)330 (76)388 (51)435 (52)548 (47)593 (62)15/15
1-15slsqp 622 (409)719 (408)807 (348)921 (406)1831 (826)2.5e4 (4e4)7.8e4 (7e4)10/15
16-30coby 218 (58)268 (77)331 (50)382 (60)427 (35)529 (41)579 (55)15/15
16-30slsqp 748 (498)1178 (2238)1304 (2216)1444 (2225)1599 (2222)1.6e4 (3e4)2.2e5 (2e5)5/15

Δ fopt
f12, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 191 (52)246 (42)300 (41)356 (24)401 (28)511 (46)634 (326)15/15
1-15slsqp 306 (64)416 (108)489 (68)565 (86)696 (112)9607 (2e4)8.3e4 (9e4)11/15
16-30coby 205 (42)253 (27)309 (48)367 (41)415 (29)504 (37)753 (41)15/15
16-30slsqp 310 (88)420 (66)487 (88)569 (131)883 (216)1.1e4 (1e4)1.6e5 (1e5)6/15

Δ fopt
f13, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 45 (4)46 (0)46 (0)46 (0)46 (0)46 (0)46 (0)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)249 (262)644 (903)15/15
16-30coby 47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)57 (22)175 (154)302 (246)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 46 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)114 (120)349 (226)15/15
16-30coby 47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)47 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)138 (106)413 (292)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 47 (1)48 (2)48 (2)48 (2)48 (2)48 (2)48 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)155 (100)356 (239)15/15
16-30coby 47 (2)48 (2)49 (3)49 (3)49 (3)49 (3)49 (3)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)53 (22)159 (112)362 (268)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 51 (2)51 (2)51 (2)51 (3)51 (3)51 (3)51 (3)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)73 (32)389 (242)1202 (1292)15/15
16-30coby 51 (1)52 (2)52 (2)52 (2)52 (2)52 (2)52 (2)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)76 (22)319 (242)1112 (997)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 57 (20)72 (41)83 (61)102 (89)105 (89)122 (142)125 (142)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)53 (22)74 (28)524 (494)726 (536)15/15
16-30coby 93 (18)148 (270)233 (316)260 (350)273 (350)306 (422)308 (432)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)70 (27)400 (562)900 (998)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 77 (42)143 (63)187 (298)232 (348)253 (378)344 (408)383 (408)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)85 (43)372 (441)423 (420)15/15
16-30coby 70 (29)89 (58)143 (78)148 (100)163 (123)208 (268)219 (268)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)50 (0)56 (22)259 (284)401 (346)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 723 (263)6.2e4 (6e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1348 (372)6450 (9270)1.2e5 (2e5)1.8e6 (9e5)1e50/15
16-30coby 373 (316)4.7e4 (6e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1094 (300)5196 (6209)1.5e5 (1e5)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f20, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 3308 (4028)3.5e5 (4e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 3573 (1631)6.6e4 (1e5)6.5e5 (5e5)1e50/15
16-30coby 3015 (4172)4.1e5 (5e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 4623 (7960)3.7e4 (5e4)4.9e5 (2e5)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f21, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.1e4 (4e4)9.6e5 (2e6)2e50/15
1-15slsqp 9220 (1e4)1.8e5 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30coby 1.0e4 (2e4)3.6e5 (8e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 4710 (5124)2.0e5 (3e5)2.1e6 (3e6)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f22, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.3e4 (4e4)1.9e5 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1.8e4 (2e4)1.7e5 (2e5)1.9e6 (2e6)1e50/15
16-30coby 2.5e4 (5e4)1.3e5 (2e5)1.7e6 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1.6e4 (2e4)1.8e5 (2e5)9.4e5 (1e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f23, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 684 (1068)733 (1080)897 (1076)949 (1066)1016 (1184)1235 (1994)1293 (1996)15/15
1-15slsqp 1184 (1230)1268 (1230)1392 (1186)1521 (1178)3390 (2536)6.5e4 (1e5)1.8e5 (2e5)6/15
16-30coby 1880 (4048)2050 (4038)2100 (4033)2158 (4066)3227 (5008)3321 (5026)3377 (5014)15/15
16-30slsqp 905 (680)1109 (805)1266 (782)2207 (1566)3538 (6584)2.3e4 (4e4)7.6e4 (1e5)11/15

Δ fopt
f24, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 215 (36)263 (40)316 (46)359 (31)417 (18)510 (51)724 (340)15/15
1-15slsqp 444 (105)556 (144)655 (132)766 (184)1108 (1072)1.8e4 (4e4)1.1e5 (2e5)8/15
16-30coby 213 (43)265 (43)303 (40)371 (41)416 (28)527 (22)676 (314)15/15
16-30slsqp 444 (139)544 (122)660 (134)766 (180)1168 (992)2.9e4 (4e4)1.7e5 (2e5)5/15

Δ fopt
f25, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 96 (49)144 (80)266 (43)736 (74)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 177 (108)206 (108)247 (87)261 (87)404 (459)1e50/15
16-30coby 59 (42)127 (81)236 (89)2350 (3068)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 146 (90)253 (164)290 (200)382 (317)583 (718)1.6e6 (1e6)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f26, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 324 (62)415 (100)472 (74)979 (2040)1.8e6 (2e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 288 (92)381 (180)442 (180)558 (180)1.7e4 (5e4)1e50/15
16-30coby 170 (77)245 (51)314 (58)783 (1098)5.4e5 (9e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 304 (226)415 (366)582 (770)607 (791)3111 (1722)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f27, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 515 (1006)2134 (5028)2896 (5056)4088 (5084)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 537 (726)665 (749)720 (749)806 (728)5017 (1654)1e50/15
16-30coby 813 (2020)1835 (2048)2517 (3431)5622 (5986)1.8e6 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 469 (342)631 (488)656 (510)673 (488)1110 (1194)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f28, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2266 (2678)3.6e4 (5e4)5.8e4 (1e5)8.3e4 (8e4)1.2e5 (2e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1163 (1154)3936 (4314)4524 (7012)4608 (6990)8693 (9301)1.5e6 (2e6)1e50/15
16-30coby 2866 (4006)1.2e4 (3e4)4.8e4 (5e4)6.1e4 (9e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 677 (557)1008 (858)4026 (1e4)4897 (1e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f29, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 665 (1030)1664 (3083)1732 (3061)2304 (3079)2351 (3052)2451 (3077)2515 (3071)15/15
1-15slsqp 756 (768)1064 (1744)1206 (1813)1444 (2292)2816 (4273)4.2e4 (6e4)9.9e4 (2e5)8/15
16-30coby 1655 (3071)2133 (3039)1.2e4 (5022)1.3e4 (5034)1.3e4 (5066)1.3e4 (5060)1.4e4 (5056)14/15
16-30slsqp 1783 (2634)2933 (4055)4237 (7690)1.1e4 (1e4)1.1e4 (1e4)4.0e4 (9e4)1.6e5 (3e5)7/15

Δ fopt
f30, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 209 (45)272 (39)315 (20)359 (29)418 (32)517 (42)590 (33)15/15
1-15slsqp 452 (133)585 (182)714 (205)845 (204)1247 (836)1.2e4 (1e4)5.5e4 (7e4)10/15
16-30coby 210 (31)263 (26)304 (40)363 (33)411 (33)514 (28)840 (924)15/15
16-30slsqp 458 (131)573 (158)693 (234)932 (344)1600 (826)4.4e4 (5e4)1.0e5 (9e4)7/15

Δ fopt
f31, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 331 (56)455 (71)579 (58)681 (63)827 (85)1.3e4 (1e4)5.2e4 (4e4)15/15
1-15slsqp 861 (323)1043 (212)1146 (252)1269 (184)3069 (3295)1.0e5 (1e5)3.2e5 (3e5)5/15
16-30coby 323 (64)447 (79)576 (67)691 (70)857 (82)6952 (5970)3.8e4 (4e4)15/15
16-30slsqp 835 (370)994 (231)1129 (252)1458 (853)4522 (4960)1.0e5 (9e4)2.4e5 (3e5)5/15

Δ fopt
f32, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 397 (203)1279 (1572)3998 (4482)2.0e4 (2e4)8.7e4 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1063 (275)1626 (524)1798 (342)2417 (2766)5863 (8496)6.6e4 (9e4)4.7e5 (8e5)3/15
16-30coby 329 (97)1165 (1250)6788 (8096)2.4e4 (4e4)6.7e4 (1e5)1.8e6 (3e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1/15
16-30slsqp 1301 (156)2012 (670)3121 (5102)3526 (5078)2.0e4 (6e4)2.1e5 (2e5)1.6e6 (1e6)1/15

Δ fopt
f33, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 423 (114)694 (279)1290 (648)1.0e4 (2e4)1.2e5 (9e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 978 (133)1094 (38)1167 (89)1225 (227)2113 (1952)2.0e5 (3e5)7.0e5 (3e5)2/15
16-30coby 410 (102)801 (485)1852 (1300)1.5e4 (3e4)7.9e4 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 991 (112)1089 (46)1186 (152)1239 (152)2228 (1013)1.8e5 (2e5)8.4e5 (8e5)2/15

Δ fopt
f34, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 344 (95)504 (109)626 (108)770 (162)954 (104)8155 (8272)3.5e4 (6e4)14/15
1-15slsqp 441 (110)484 (112)528 (114)668 (114)1460 (3202)1.5e5 (2e5)5e40/15
16-30coby 334 (61)437 (91)579 (73)747 (98)1117 (469)2.8e4 (3e4)3.7e4 (5e4)14/15
16-30slsqp 468 (112)526 (94)660 (135)683 (137)1687 (2058)1.7e5 (2e5)5e40/15

Δ fopt
f35, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 215 (43)260 (53)309 (56)358 (39)385 (32)476 (55)490 (59)15/15
1-15slsqp 142 (43)162 (43)168 (43)170 (43)309 (364)7280 (8141)4.7e4 (5e4)8/15
16-30coby 204 (30)252 (46)299 (49)348 (43)371 (33)466 (52)495 (50)15/15
16-30slsqp 150 (43)165 (22)168 (22)173 (22)837 (1082)1.0e4 (1e4)5.4e4 (2e4)8/15

Δ fopt
f36, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 215 (41)248 (33)299 (40)330 (41)385 (72)441 (48)521 (70)15/15
1-15slsqp 150 (22)167 (22)170 (22)262 (240)478 (464)1.7e4 (2e4)3.8e5 (6e5)1/15
16-30coby 205 (44)255 (26)282 (43)330 (34)366 (56)444 (42)537 (294)15/15
16-30slsqp 153 (22)156 (22)167 (22)171 (24)740 (886)2.1e4 (2e4)5.2e4 (6e4)6/15

Δ fopt
f37, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 277 (31)554 (62)2.1e4 (5e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 329 (188)535 (158)664 (182)754 (178)842 (156)1098 (196)1199 (236)15/15
16-30coby 286 (54)577 (72)2.1e4 (5e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 373 (136)574 (116)725 (177)817 (200)906 (240)1140 (294)1218 (270)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 275 (42)554 (104)4.7e4 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 568 (312)954 (292)1146 (363)1274 (307)1422 (350)1873 (508)2457 (958)15/15
16-30coby 285 (54)572 (138)2.4e4 (6e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 504 (212)847 (336)1051 (358)1179 (404)1307 (428)1721 (580)6161 (1e4)15/15

Δ fopt
f39, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 277 (55)577 (110)2.7e4 (5e4)5.6e5 (3e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 738 (266)1038 (176)1235 (265)1386 (178)1521 (221)2012 (376)2895 (808)15/15
16-30coby 278 (43)520 (66)2269 (1202)7.7e5 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 537 (384)949 (221)1111 (311)1221 (332)1360 (352)1871 (400)4761 (1109)15/15

Δ fopt
f40, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 246 (40)493 (96)1474 (1480)1.7e4 (1e4)5.5e4 (8e4)2.8e5 (2e5)9.6e5 (7e5)2/15
1-15slsqp 407 (272)658 (202)809 (266)893 (267)986 (226)1095 (261)1146 (242)15/15
16-30coby 238 (40)466 (107)979 (413)8510 (1e4)2.5e4 (5e4)2.7e5 (4e5)8.1e5 (6e5)2/15
16-30slsqp 332 (227)593 (181)763 (156)851 (176)920 (176)1049 (158)1092 (178)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 189 (74)323 (138)466 (234)542 (380)629 (480)651 (504)657 (504)15/15
1-15slsqp 68 (0)68 (0)77 (0)83 (22)100 (22)170 (228)211 (315)15/15
16-30coby 213 (51)366 (88)692 (311)802 (576)1027 (1486)1123 (1487)1126 (1487)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (114)116 (156)134 (200)140 (204)172 (222)180 (200)222 (200)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 77 (32)104 (52)118 (57)133 (106)133 (106)163 (160)175 (160)15/15
1-15slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)53 (22)196 (198)202 (220)15/15
16-30coby 76 (23)96 (47)120 (78)140 (85)142 (85)174 (164)174 (164)15/15
16-30slsqp 47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)47 (0)58 (22)97 (0)279 (369)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f44, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f45, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f46, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f47, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (2e5)1.8e5 (1e5)8/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (3e5)9/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f48, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 382 (44)437 (48)493 (51)536 (72)585 (73)685 (37)1130 (1012)15/15
1-15slsqp 1.4e5 (1e5)1.4e5 (3e5)1.4e5 (9e4)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)2.7e5 (2e5)9.7e5 (1e6)2/15
16-30coby 483 (1140)561 (1016)617 (1030)661 (1024)702 (1012)799 (1018)1118 (1028)15/15
16-30slsqp 7.5e4 (8e4)7.5e4 (8e4)7.5e4 (8e4)7.5e4 (8e4)7.5e4 (8e4)1.8e5 (2e5)2.7e5 (1e5)6/15

Δ fopt
f49, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f50, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f51, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f52, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f53, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 8.6e5 (8e5)8.6e5 (1e6)8.6e5 (1e6)8.6e5 (1e6)8.6e5 (6e5)8.6e5 (7e5)8.6e5 (9e5)2/15
1-15slsqp 1e50/15
16-30coby 6.3e5 (4e5)6.3e5 (1e6)6.3e5 (8e5)6.3e5 (5e5)6.3e5 (5e5)6.3e5 (6e5)6.3e5 (5e5)3/15
16-30slsqp 1e50/15

Δ fopt
f54, 20-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)1.6e4 (2e4)15/15
1-15slsqp 4.9e4 (7e4)5.0e4 (7e4)5.0e4 (7e4)5.0e4 (7e4)5.0e4 (7e4)1.1e5 (1e5)2.9e5 (2e5)6/15
16-30coby 1.1e4 (2e4)1.1e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)15/15
16-30slsqp 8.1e4 (1e5)8.1e4 (1e5)8.1e4 (1e5)8.1e4 (9e4)8.1e4 (1e5)1.3e5 (1e5)2.9e5 (4e5)6/15

Previous dimension | Dimension = 40 | First dimension

Δ fopt
f1, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 584 (100)898 (219)1172 (195)1503 (205)1803 (177)8.5e5 (1e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)93 (0)98 (42)240 (33)256 (1)15/15
16-30coby 567 (67)876 (87)1139 (93)1500 (114)1902 (128)4.3e5 (4e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)255 (1)255 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f2, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 603 (75)901 (139)1168 (107)1507 (128)1919 (192)1.3e5 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)93 (0)244 (0)255 (1)15/15
16-30coby 587 (127)900 (151)1178 (195)1510 (176)2050 (195)2.1e5 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (0)229 (78)255 (0)15/15

Δ fopt
f3, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 567 (115)840 (170)1101 (165)1435 (194)1740 (212)1.3e5 (2e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (42)255 (0)261 (0)15/15
16-30coby 592 (93)894 (117)1142 (195)1474 (255)2012 (1086)8.7e4 (8e4)7.9e5 (7e5)2/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)104 (42)250 (1)255 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f4, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 626 (92)1605 (2816)4545 (4568)1.1e4 (1e4)3.3e4 (4e4)9.4e4 (1e5)1.9e5 (2e5)7/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)154 (42)248 (1)254 (1)15/15
16-30coby 619 (726)1682 (1428)5507 (7872)1.9e4 (3e4)3.2e4 (5e4)1.3e5 (1e5)1.6e5 (2e5)8/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)126 (42)254 (1)254 (1)15/15

Δ fopt
f5, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 847 (1310)1499 (3116)2543 (3116)2668 (3176)2668 (3176)4182 (7767)4182 (7767)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)99 (42)159 (42)170 (0)1082 (780)15/15
16-30coby 512 (574)1522 (1915)2666 (3010)2761 (3010)3925 (4492)4007 (4492)4007 (4492)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (42)159 (42)170 (0)1571 (1502)15/15

Δ fopt
f6, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 126 (40)365 (574)621 (646)890 (788)890 (788)927 (910)927 (910)15/15
1-15slsqp 93 (0)93 (0)93 (0)93 (1)159 (42)195 (0)1165 (2802)15/15
16-30coby 141 (82)260 (125)260 (125)685 (1078)717 (1078)769 (1078)769 (1078)15/15
16-30slsqp 93 (0)93 (0)93 (0)98 (0)160 (42)201 (0)1547 (2468)15/15

Δ fopt
f7, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.1e4 (1e4)2e50/15
1-15slsqp 1847 (789)2582 (1398)4565 (2962)9944 (9352)1.7e5 (4e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 1.2e4 (1e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1850 (522)2730 (1404)4573 (2805)7468 (6798)1.0e5 (2e5)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f8, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.2e5 (1e5)7.8e5 (7e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1.1e5 (2e5)5.1e5 (8e5)1.6e6 (1e6)2e50/15
16-30coby 1.7e5 (3e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 7.9e4 (1e5)3.1e5 (5e5)1.6e6 (2e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f9, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 4.1e5 (6e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 4.9e5 (5e5)4.2e6 (2e6)3e50/15
16-30coby 1.9e5 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2.9e5 (4e5)3.5e6 (3e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f10, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 7.9e4 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 3.7e5 (4e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 9.8e4 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 3.7e5 (5e5)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f11, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1932 (2056)4350 (2112)4625 (2144)4740 (2124)4842 (2150)5040 (2144)5136 (2140)15/15
1-15slsqp 4546 (7271)5644 (8121)5882 (8440)6089 (8352)1.0e4 (9818)3.3e5 (4e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 2400 (2472)3605 (7124)3724 (7098)3837 (7112)3948 (7085)4145 (7100)4247 (7109)15/15
16-30slsqp 6026 (8196)1.2e4 (2e4)1.2e4 (2e4)1.3e4 (2e4)2.6e4 (4e4)4.6e5 (6e5)3.6e6 (5e6)1/15

Δ fopt
f12, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 554 (88)672 (100)771 (86)867 (98)965 (115)1144 (85)1638 (1310)15/15
1-15slsqp 764 (251)925 (190)1053 (318)1372 (566)5453 (7889)1.1e5 (1e5)7.8e5 (1e6)2/15
16-30coby 409 (74)529 (61)621 (66)726 (72)821 (72)1016 (72)1665 (676)15/15
16-30slsqp 682 (169)857 (220)1001 (251)1327 (404)5336 (6736)1.7e5 (2e5)1e50/15

Δ fopt
f13, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 81 (13)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (0)388 (303)598 (364)15/15
16-30coby 82 (15)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)86 (0)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)104 (42)320 (350)848 (808)15/15

Δ fopt
f14, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 87 (1)87 (1)87 (1)87 (1)87 (1)87 (1)87 (1)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (0)277 (272)677 (760)15/15
16-30coby 86 (1)86 (1)86 (1)86 (1)86 (1)86 (1)86 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (0)462 (358)1322 (1149)15/15

Δ fopt
f15, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 88 (2)88 (2)88 (2)88 (2)88 (2)88 (2)88 (2)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (42)506 (374)1581 (1262)15/15
16-30coby 89 (1)89 (1)89 (1)89 (1)89 (1)89 (1)89 (1)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)144 (168)456 (326)1261 (1174)15/15

Δ fopt
f16, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 94 (3)95 (4)95 (4)95 (4)95 (4)95 (4)95 (4)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)207 (210)1236 (1466)1763 (1664)15/15
16-30coby 93 (2)93 (3)94 (3)94 (3)94 (3)94 (3)94 (3)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)98 (42)225 (220)1561 (1286)3156 (4072)15/15

Δ fopt
f17, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 337 (628)659 (1144)1268 (1678)2258 (3232)3018 (3196)3419 (3889)3431 (3889)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)188 (42)1128 (1086)2957 (2568)15/15
16-30coby 461 (532)1116 (1597)1514 (1676)3118 (2820)3124 (2860)3751 (3332)3751 (3332)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)112 (0)236 (186)1157 (1444)3325 (2382)15/15

Δ fopt
f18, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 126 (41)126 (41)164 (153)305 (161)521 (1062)697 (1062)719 (1062)15/15
1-15slsqp 99 (44)99 (44)99 (44)99 (44)256 (228)801 (824)2251 (3396)15/15
16-30coby 121 (39)121 (39)296 (204)318 (208)371 (242)500 (401)542 (403)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)93 (0)173 (84)1046 (1360)2588 (2159)15/15

Δ fopt
f19, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.4e4 (4e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2955 (736)3.2e4 (2e4)3.5e6 (3e6)2e50/15
16-30coby 4743 (5172)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 3894 (2340)4.7e4 (5e4)3.2e6 (3e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f20, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.5e5 (2e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2.5e4 (8845)1.5e5 (1e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 2.0e5 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 7330 (4521)2.4e5 (3e5)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f21, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 3.9e5 (6e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 4.7e4 (7e4)3e50/15
16-30coby 3.1e5 (4e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 4.8e4 (1e5)1.5e6 (2e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f22, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.0e6 (4e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 5.6e5 (4e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 3.2e5 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 4.7e5 (1e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f23, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.6e4 (2e4)1.6e4 (2e4)1.7e4 (2e4)1.7e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)1.8e4 (2e4)14/15
1-15slsqp 1.0e4 (9739)1.0e4 (9700)1.1e4 (9658)1.9e4 (2e4)7.5e4 (9e4)1.1e6 (8e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 1.9e4 (4e4)2.7e4 (5e4)2.7e4 (7e4)2.7e4 (5e4)2.8e4 (5e4)2.8e4 (7e4)2.8e4 (6e4)14/15
16-30slsqp 8809 (1e4)1.6e4 (1e4)1.7e4 (1e4)1.9e4 (1e4)5.5e4 (7e4)1.2e6 (6e5)3e50/15

Δ fopt
f24, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 572 (78)657 (56)764 (111)855 (94)955 (70)1159 (73)1656 (1234)15/15
1-15slsqp 1009 (335)1222 (432)1441 (474)2587 (3244)8634 (1e4)1.5e5 (1e5)1.3e6 (1e6)1/15
16-30coby 426 (63)515 (75)585 (71)682 (51)788 (71)978 (77)1368 (604)15/15
16-30slsqp 839 (210)1031 (300)1168 (300)1433 (368)3485 (5152)7.3e4 (6e4)5.1e5 (7e5)3/15

Δ fopt
f25, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 146 (68)273 (167)432 (198)2.5e5 (3e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 242 (83)347 (166)442 (166)754 (780)2.9e4 (1086)2e50/15
16-30coby 161 (98)269 (134)440 (171)1.9e5 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 367 (256)666 (522)766 (588)946 (736)4316 (2480)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f26, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 353 (108)499 (85)644 (81)8.1e4 (9e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 869 (1092)1027 (1434)1088 (1434)1244 (1475)6.1e4 (2e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 276 (141)457 (122)627 (103)3.5e4 (5e4)1.7e6 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1255 (1434)1524 (1692)1811 (1651)2415 (4314)3.0e4 (7e4)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f27, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 926 (1068)1700 (1994)2043 (2290)1.0e5 (1e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 604 (380)703 (421)753 (421)885 (736)3.2e4 (1e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 2472 (2066)1.1e4 (4146)1.5e4 (3e4)5.7e4 (6e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 609 (346)737 (548)803 (589)853 (548)5.2e4 (1e5)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f28, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 7557 (1e4)8.4e4 (2e5)3.7e5 (4e5)8.2e5 (8e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2256 (2419)5173 (6932)5287 (6890)6215 (6848)1.9e5 (3e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 2.2e4 (5e4)8.6e4 (9e4)1.3e5 (2e5)1.5e5 (2e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1454 (1746)1640 (1832)1800 (1832)3914 (2100)7.6e4 (2e5)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f29, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2.3e4 (5e4)6.1e4 (1e5)6.2e4 (7e4)6.2e4 (9e4)6.3e4 (7e4)6.3e4 (7e4)6.3e4 (9e4)13/15
1-15slsqp 8919 (2e4)4.7e4 (1e5)5.1e4 (1e5)5.1e4 (2e5)6.3e4 (1e5)3.4e5 (5e5)1.7e6 (2e6)2/15
16-30coby 1.1e4 (2e4)6.8e4 (7e4)1.2e5 (3e5)1.2e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (1e5)1.2e5 (3e5)10/15
16-30slsqp 7818 (1e4)2.4e4 (2e4)5.0e4 (9e4)5.1e4 (9e4)5.5e4 (9e4)1.5e5 (1e5)3.6e5 (5e5)7/15

Δ fopt
f30, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 443 (56)528 (57)641 (58)715 (63)831 (49)1034 (76)1438 (626)15/15
1-15slsqp 1000 (322)1232 (282)1446 (324)2082 (1314)5475 (9456)5.9e4 (1e5)1.5e5 (3e5)7/15
16-30coby 440 (96)543 (86)639 (67)744 (65)836 (69)999 (65)1336 (77)15/15
16-30slsqp 1176 (476)1460 (540)1820 (644)2190 (1142)3922 (5458)7.6e4 (9e4)4.0e5 (4e5)4/15

Δ fopt
f31, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 892 (85)1182 (103)1421 (141)1704 (132)6047 (4013)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1972 (904)2398 (916)2904 (872)6155 (4742)3.9e4 (6e4)8.2e5 (1e6)2e50/15
16-30coby 825 (182)1103 (213)1399 (182)1670 (251)4897 (4096)9.9e5 (1e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1922 (1300)2324 (1342)2697 (1125)3886 (3802)2.4e4 (4e4)7.3e5 (1e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f32, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 792 (299)1963 (2126)1.1e4 (1e4)8.6e4 (7e4)9.0e5 (8e5)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2952 (1302)3887 (1372)6797 (3316)1.3e4 (1e4)5.0e4 (1e5)4.6e5 (4e5)7.4e5 (5e5)4/15
16-30coby 815 (160)2409 (3241)1.3e4 (1e4)1.2e5 (1e5)1.7e6 (3e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2610 (1006)9474 (1e4)1.2e4 (1e4)2.8e4 (4e4)9.3e4 (1e5)7.6e5 (4e5)4.2e6 (5e6)1/15

Δ fopt
f33, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 951 (254)5998 (2388)5.1e4 (7e4)8.9e5 (1e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 3089 (734)3842 (648)4270 (512)5982 (88)1.8e4 (2e4)2e50/15
16-30coby 1411 (1074)8065 (1e4)8.2e4 (9e4)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 3513 (742)4144 (682)4579 (270)5035 (478)5.6e4 (1e5)1.2e6 (1e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f34, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 836 (118)1111 (124)1579 (343)3758 (3005)6.5e4 (6e4)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1993 (251)2128 (90)2564 (169)5522 (4530)3.2e4 (6e4)1e50/15
16-30coby 856 (97)1112 (191)1735 (361)7245 (4988)1.2e5 (1e5)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2027 (172)2138 (164)2210 (166)4143 (1800)6.0e4 (7e4)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f35, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 530 (85)640 (94)699 (105)798 (128)865 (89)1045 (129)1113 (115)15/15
1-15slsqp 298 (42)320 (84)348 (84)603 (552)2645 (4753)6.5e4 (6e4)2.7e5 (5e5)4/15
16-30coby 521 (100)594 (165)673 (98)765 (130)844 (112)972 (105)1073 (180)15/15
16-30slsqp 292 (84)314 (84)320 (84)686 (1044)2424 (3428)5.4e4 (6e4)2.4e5 (3e5)4/15

Δ fopt
f36, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 396 (266)533 (71)591 (83)693 (101)766 (72)949 (125)1022 (93)15/15
1-15slsqp 298 (253)348 (168)421 (210)967 (1036)2896 (3055)1.1e5 (9e4)7.4e5 (1e6)1/15
16-30coby 410 (78)551 (69)596 (55)689 (120)760 (88)895 (141)982 (112)15/15
16-30slsqp 281 (42)309 (42)357 (127)641 (354)2925 (2954)7.5e4 (4e4)3.6e5 (4e5)2/15

Δ fopt
f37, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 688 (181)1565 (288)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1076 (426)1681 (300)2078 (427)2368 (430)2588 (380)3172 (500)3400 (458)15/15
16-30coby 732 (67)1732 (217)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1247 (382)1844 (338)2271 (507)2588 (466)2775 (507)3307 (548)3552 (464)15/15

Δ fopt
f38, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 733 (144)1634 (255)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1638 (646)2728 (938)3422 (1066)3779 (1064)4100 (1148)4999 (1438)8.0e4 (2e5)13/15
16-30coby 723 (113)1663 (201)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1335 (390)2371 (732)3047 (986)3387 (1025)3629 (1068)4485 (1277)8.2e4 (2e5)11/15

Δ fopt
f39, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 733 (127)2027 (260)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1648 (518)2790 (462)3392 (632)3709 (814)4048 (755)5009 (836)9.6e4 (2e5)11/15
16-30coby 737 (112)2394 (1090)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1707 (298)2947 (604)3542 (512)3859 (638)4196 (676)5256 (1093)7.0e4 (1e5)12/15

Δ fopt
f40, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 659 (73)1666 (250)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 1311 (772)2177 (425)2688 (426)3027 (510)3284 (592)3927 (550)4361 (673)15/15
16-30coby 677 (115)1745 (1014)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 1117 (732)2059 (429)2541 (593)2812 (548)3081 (594)3751 (673)4350 (929)15/15

Δ fopt
f41, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 509 (97)1167 (222)6.0e4 (9e4)3.1e5 (5e5)9.3e5 (1e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (3e6)1/15
1-15slsqp 618 (429)1057 (684)1347 (634)1527 (634)1582 (718)1633 (680)1638 (720)15/15
16-30coby 516 (95)1206 (208)1.6e4 (4e4)7.9e4 (7e4)1.8e5 (2e5)2.2e5 (2e5)3.4e5 (6e5)4/15
16-30slsqp 549 (513)1018 (767)1279 (937)1424 (1020)1491 (1020)1524 (1020)1656 (762)15/15

Δ fopt
f42, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 189 (30)196 (40)196 (40)227 (135)265 (144)377 (212)377 (212)15/15
1-15slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)131 (42)209 (42)560 (802)15/15
16-30coby 180 (67)219 (77)231 (102)231 (102)312 (212)387 (290)403 (374)15/15
16-30slsqp 87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)87 (0)148 (42)230 (42)444 (432)15/15

Δ fopt
f43, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f44, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f45, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f46, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f47, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 2e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f48, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 3124 (3054)3206 (3073)3327 (3080)3415 (3064)3522 (3071)3708 (3051)1.0e4 (3984)14/15
1-15slsqp 2.1e5 (4e5)2.1e5 (3e5)2.1e5 (5e5)2.2e5 (4e5)2.6e5 (6e5)2.8e6 (4e6)2e50/15
16-30coby 2366 (4310)2488 (4137)2622 (4121)2712 (4080)2823 (4061)3007 (4096)9092 (2e4)15/15
16-30slsqp 2.3e5 (4e5)2.3e5 (4e5)2.3e5 (2e5)2.3e5 (2e5)2.3e5 (2e5)1.1e6 (2e6)2e50/15

Δ fopt
f49, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f50, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f51, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f52, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1.8e6 (4e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1.8e6 (1e6)1.8e6 (2e6)1e50/15
1-15slsqp 3.4e6 (4e6)3.4e6 (5e6)3.4e6 (6e6)3.4e6 (3e6)2e50/15
16-30coby 1.9e6 (2e6)1.9e6 (2e6)1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f53, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 1e50/15
1-15slsqp 2e50/15
16-30coby 1e50/15
16-30slsqp 2e50/15

Δ fopt
f54, 40-D
1e1
 
1e0
 
1e-1
 
1e-2
 
1e-3
 
1e-5
 
1e-6
 
#succ
 
1-15coby 4.4e4 (8e4)4.4e4 (7e4)4.4e4 (8e4)4.4e4 (7e4)4.4e4 (7e4)4.5e4 (8e4)8.6e4 (9e4)12/15
1-15slsqp 1.7e5 (2e5)1.7e5 (2e5)1.7e5 (2e5)1.7e5 (2e5)1.7e5 (2e5)2e50/15
16-30coby 4.7e4 (5e4)4.7e4 (5e4)4.8e4 (8e4)4.8e4 (5e4)4.8e4 (8e4)4.8e4 (8e4)5.2e4 (5e4)13/15
16-30slsqp 1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (2e5)1.4e5 (3e5)1.4e5 (1e5)6.0e5 (1e6)1.4e6 (1e6)2/15

Expected runtime (ERT) to reach given targets, measured in number of function evaluations, in different dimensions. For each function, the ERT  and, in braces as dispersion measure, the half difference between 10 and 90%-tile of (bootstrapped) runtimes is shown for the different target ∆f-values as shown in the top row. #succ is the number of trials that reached the last target fopt+ 10−6. The median number of conducted function evaluations is additionally given in italics, if the target in the last column was never reached. Entries, succeeded by a star, are statistically significantly better (according to the rank-sum test) when compared to all other algorithms of the table, with p = 0.05 or p = 10−k when the number k following the star is larger than 1, with Bonferroni correction by the number of functions (48). A ↓ indicates the same tested against . Best results are printed in bold.